Schoolboy attacked teacher like a 'ragdoll' and left her permanently disfigured

A teenager who attacked a teacher and said 'the stupid cow deserves it' has been spared prison.
Carol Shaw, who worked at St Paul's Academy in Dundee, was seriously injured after Keiran Matthew grabbed her and dumped her head-first on a concrete floor.
She was knocked unconscious after being thrown 'like a ragdoll' to the ground, and left lying in a pool of her own blood while Matthew played on his phone and put his feet up on another teacher's desk.
Matthew, who was 17 at the time of the attack but is now 18, walked free from court after his sentence fell within Scottish rules on avoiding short-term prison sentences for first offenders.
The attack happened after Matthew refused to get changed separately from other pupils for a PE class.
The measure had been agreed by Matthew, his foster mum and the school because of his previous aggression towards other pupils.
But on March 22 of last year he became 'agitated and heightened' over his separation from other pupils, so Ms Shaw was called in because she was deemed a 'safe' person for him and had successfully de-escalated volatile incidents.
Two other teachers and pupils were placed in a locked classroom away from Matthew, but Fiscal depute Laura Bruce told the court: 'The accused then realised they had gone to the ICT class and moved towards the door and said 'I'm f****** going in there too'.
'He tried to exit to the corridor where Ms Shaw had her back to him.
'She recalls him gripping her in a rugby-style grip with her arms pinned to her sides and the next thing she felt was the horrific impact of her head striking the floor.
'She was blinded by her own blood, which covered her face and top with a large amount of blood seen on the floor.
'Another teacher had witnessed the accused lift her completely off her feet, throwing her to the floor deliberately and landing head-first.
'Another said she appeared to be like a ragdoll flying through the air.
'The accused sat at a teacher's desk, with his feet on the desk and using his mobile phone.
'He told a teacher 'Sir, it wasn't an outburst of anger. She deserved it'.'
He later banged on the desk and said: 'The stupid cow deserved it.'
A colleague took Ms Shaw to hospital due to an expected 20-minute wait for an ambulance.
She suffered concussion, was unable to finish sentences, and was given 10 stitches, leaving her with a large Y-shaped scar on her head.
Plastic surgeon Dr Ketki Kaushal said the assault could have been life-threatening.
Matthew pled guilty to seizing the teacher's neck and body, throwing her to the floor, causing her to strike her head and be rendered unconscious.
He admitted the assault was to her severe injury, permanent disfigurement and the danger of her life.
Matthew, who has ADHD and an 'extremely low' IQ range between 47 and 59, said 'I am sorry' when he was cautioned and charged with the assault.
Solicitor Theo Finlay, defending, said: 'He has had longstanding issues managing his emotions. It is likely he was already in a heightened condition. He experiences nightmares and requires to be medicated.
'That is attributed to childhood abuse. He needs prompts to eat and struggles in noisy or busy environments. He was not being allowed into the changing room and had feelings of unfairness.
'He described becoming agitated. The teacher moved others away, which made him feel more agitated and singled out. At school he felt intensely disliked and frequently provoked by his peers.'
Sheriff Tim Niven-Smith said the assault merited 18 months in prison, but this was reduced for an early guilty plea.
The sentence then fell within Scottish sentencing rules on avoiding short sentences for first offenders, meaning Matthew was able to walk free from court.
He was placed under social work supervision for three years and ordered to attend courses including one for anger management.
Matthew was also placed on a Restriction of Liberty Order for 12 months between 9pm and 7am every night.
Sheriff Niven-Smith said: 'It is difficult to imagine a more serious assault, having regard to the consequences of your attack for Ms Shaw. More Trending
'It is not over-egging the pudding or exaggerating to say your attack has affected her life in every aspect.
'She is permanently disfigured. Photos show an extensive, significant scar on her head.
'Until her promotion, she was the safe person for you to seek sanctuary with if you felt overwhelmed. She has dedicated her life to vulnerable school children such as you.
'You have robbed her of her career as she has been unable to go back to school due to panic attacks, nightmares and night terrors as a result of this assault.'
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: Man calmly calls to report he shot dead his wife, stepson and mother-in-law
MORE: 'Painfully thin' toddler, 2, 'murdered by grandparents in house of misery'
MORE: Body found in search for British man Greg Monks who went missing on stag do in Portugal

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Glasgow Times

3 hours ago

• Glasgow Times

'Where have the 4,000 people from the Red Road flats gone?'

They dominated the skyline, standing tall over the north of the city, and blocked out what little sunlight there was for me to enjoy in the 1970s and 80s. They also provided homes for 4,000 people. A decade after their demolition, their absence is felt on homelessness lists almost as much as the ghost of their bulk is on the landscape. We were told the area would be regenerated, that life and community would spring back up in their place, and that what came next would be a vast improvement on what was there before. Instead, we have a pile of rubble, a wasteland that nobody seems to want to do anything about. In shifting the land, the local authority clearly thought it could wash its hands of the responsibility which comes with it. But ensuring every resident has a safe and secure home is the council's responsibility and, like so many other local authorities across the country, it has failed badly in its duty to do so. More than 8,500 homelessness applications were made to the council last year, a rise of a fifth from the previous year. That shows in statistical terms how much worse the problem is getting. Where have the 4,000 people from the Red Road flats gone? They can't be in Sighthill, a part of the city which has faced similar neglect after tower blocks were razed to the ground. There was money for a bridge across a motorway, but not accommodation to address a genuine human crisis right under our noses. People in this part of the city also see the irony of a £1 billion new prison being planned for the area. It seems no expense is being spared for the good people of Barlinnie, while everywhere else has to suffer. This should not be a complicated problem for the council, nor the Scottish Government – which has sole, devolved power over housing – to solve. When universities expand to take more students, they very quickly and efficiently throw up new bespoke accommodation, often in nice parts of the city with swish furnishings and en-suite bathrooms. For them, it's simple. If we want more people to be here, we simply need to build more places for them to live. Why can't that attitude be replicated for ordinary residents of the city? We have thousands of people who are homeless, which should tell planners and managers that we therefore need thousands more homes in which they can live. Sometimes layers of power and government can make things more complicated than they need to be. Even a primary school child would understand that, by removing homes for 4,000 people from the equation, those need to be put back in as a matter of urgency. Yet 10 years have passed and nothing seems to be happening at the Red Road site. We could have used that as an example of how to do things, how to use land and facilities well to create safe and sustainable new communities. Instead, we have an eyesore blighting the city, and serving as an unsightly reminder of how badly our council and government have failed the homeless people of Glasgow.

The National

3 hours ago

• The National

Ruth Watson: It's time for Scotland to eat well and dump the meal deal

In Asia, bento boxes are prepared with care, offering a selection of rice, protein, vegetables. Hawker stalls offer a range of freshly cooked meals, sometimes served on a banana leaf – recyclable tableware doesn't get better than that. In Europe, the 'gastronomic meal of the French' – a festive multi-course meal emphasising the art of eating and drinking well, bringing people together for special occasions – is now listed by Unesco as something which is part of the 'intangible cultural heritage of humanity'. And we have the meal deal. As a nation, we do need to think about what's going in our mouths. Only 22% adults in Scotland eat the recommended five or more portions of fruit and veg a day. Most only eat 3.3 portions of fruit and vegetables on a typical day. This figure has not changed much for 20 years, despite the 'five a day' messaging. As for fibre? Again, our ultra-processed modern diets are slowing things down. Fewer than 10% of adults in Scotland eat the recommended 30g of roughage in a day. READ MORE: LIVE: Palestine Action protests as group set to be proscribed Last year saw the launch of the Scottish Eatwell Guide. It aims to get people talking about the kind of food and drink they eat, as well as where it comes from. The guide points to oats, barley, and beremeal for local sources of wholegrain, which help keep you full for longer, as well as having cholesterol-busting components. Our taste for tatties is no bad thing either. Potatoes have a surprising amount of nutrients and keeping the skin on adds both to the fibre and the vitamins in our daily diet. As for proteins, venison from our hills has a remarkable nutrition profile, while Scotch Beef and Scotch Lamb are famous across the world for the quality of the meat on the plate, and our farmers are working hard to come up with local vegetarian protein options, including fava, or field, beans (pairs well with Chianti, apparently …). This cousin of the broad bean has been grown here since the Iron Age but fell out of favour once people could afford to eat meat more often, something which seems to be the case with many of our traditional foods. The team at the Gaia Foundation's Seed Sovereignty programme have found a broad bean called 'Scottish' which is available from a few seed suppliers in New Zealand, but from UK, or even European catalogues. These broad beans were brought to New Zealand in the 1860s by Scottish settlers and have been kept alive by keen farmers and gardeners since. The Seed Sovereignty Programme is working with a New Zealand seed company to repatriate the 'Scottish' broad bean back to Scotland. Edinburgh nutritionist Dr Laura Wyness was a Scottish Food Tourism Ambassador when she had her lightbulb moment. She told me: 'There are different versions of the UK Eatwell guide – there's the vegan version, there's the vegetarian version, the African Caribbean version and the South Asian version, and I thought, 'why is there not a Scottish version of the Eatwell Guide?', because we are quite distinct in the food that we have in Scotland and what we produce.' Wyness teamed up with Nutrition Scotland and worked with Scotland Food and Drink, while liaising with Food Standards Scotland, Public Health Scotland and the Scottish Government to make sure food messaging was both healthy and relatable. The idea seems to be working. 'The people who have been downloading it from the Nutrition Scotland website are mainly people working in educational settings such as teachers and community education workers,' Wyness said. 'We're now planning a study with Robert Gordon University that will look into how the Scottish Eatwell Guide is used as an educational tool in community settings.' She went on: 'I think a lot of people are interested in finding out more about where our food comes from and how it's produced because sustainability is at the forefront of people's minds. 'A lot of people want to eat more locally to support local communities and local businesses, so there's that kind of building awareness about local food and how it actually fits into a healthy, balanced diet. Scotland's National Chef, Gary Maclean, and some leading Scottish food brands are supporting the Scottish Eatwell Guide (if you have a Scottish food and drink business and would like to be involved, Wyness and the team at Nutrition Scotland would love to hear from you). Wyness hopes the Scottish Eatwell Guide can help us have different conversations about the food we eat and serve. 'I think the perception of the Scottish diet is that it is fairly unhealthy, you know, the pies and the tablet and things like that we're kind of quite well known for,' she said. 'People always talk about the Mediterranean diet being healthy, but actually the Scottish diet can be really healthy using what we have locally, such as the whole grains, and the root vegetables, salad, the berries, the game and seafood …' READ MORE: Private Scottish island with castle up for sale for £5.5m Wyness added: 'I got one response which really struck me. It was from someone who was giving us feedback on the Scottish Eatwell Guide. She said, 'It removes the worry that if I visit Scotland I won't be feeling well at the end of the trip after eating unhealthily, that, actually, I'll be feeling great after eating a healthy Scottish diet'.' That comment got me thinking about the power we all have to be ambassadors for Scotland, for our communities, for our own wellbeing. Agents of our own image, with pride in our food culture and heritage, and a wee bit healthier, too. Findings from the Scotland Visitor Survey 2023 showed that almost half of visitors (46%) took part in at least one food and drink activity during their trip last year, with nearly one-fifth of long-haul visitors now naming food and drink as the reason for choosing Scotland as a destination. A spokesperson for VisitScotland told me: 'More and more visitors are seeking out local produce when they're on holiday. It's a global trend driven by a desire for authentic travel and influenced by television and social media. It's the same for Scotland. 'UK visitors rate it as a top activity while half of visitors from our biggest international market, North America, say it's an important part of their visit. We know Scotland's food and drink is exceptional and it's through memorable tourism experiences that we can build our reputation on the global stage.' The humble field bean fell out of favour once people could afford to eat more meat. It often seems to be the case that we associate our traditional foods with the humdrum, or the humble. Generations which had known extreme poverty and hardship wanted to embrace plenty and not be reminded of the peasant fare our forebears relied upon. However, in losing our food traditions, we are losing part of ourselves. Modern, ready food is making us sicker and often costs way more. We don't need to spend hours in the kitchen to make good food. Perhaps it is time to eat well, Scotland, and dump the meal deal. Ruth Watson is the founder of the Keep Scotland the Brand campaign

Edinburgh Live

7 hours ago

• Edinburgh Live

Notorious Scottish child killer slammed by crime partner behind bars in verbal attack

Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info A Scottish notorious child killer has slammed her partner in crime in an outspoken attack. Rachel Trelfa has accused former civil partner Nyomi Fee of being a 'master manipulator', the Daily Record reports. The pair were convicted of murdering Trelfa's son Liam in 2014 who suffered fatal heart injuries similar to those found on road crash victims. Trelfa wrote: 'My ex, Nyomi Fee, abused me and is a master manipulator and lies through her teeth. She messed my head up big time.' Liam was badly neglected and spent the last few days of his life in agony from an untreated broken leg and fractured arm. At the couple's trial, Nyomi Fee was described as 'domineering' and it was claimed she was the 'main actor' in Liam's murder. Fee got a sentence of 24 years and Trelfa was given just six months less for her appalling part in allowing and contributing to the murder of her son. Trelfa's condemnation of her ex came in a character reference she wrote for her prison pal, killer Jayney Sutherley. Trelfa believes Fee manufactured accusations against Sutherley, who was cleared in court of waging a homophobic and transphobic vendetta against Fee and her trans lover Alex Stewart – who was known as Alan Baker when jailed for murder in 2013. Hairdresser Sutherley – who killed a man with scissors – had been accused of persecuting Fee and Stewart. Trelfa wrote about Fee: 'She messed my head up big time but Jayney has been there and supported me. 'I can say, hand on heart, that Jayney is not homophobic in any way or ever insulted me. She is a lovely person who will help anyone. She adds: 'I would just like to say I have a very nice friendship with Jayney. She has taken me for me and taken me under her wing. She is so supportive with me.' Trelfa says she is also in a relationship with another woman despite being behind bars. She said: 'I am gay and in a relationship with a woman. Janey has been there for me if I have any problems. 'We work together in the hairdresser's and she has taught me so much. I have a lot of time for her.' Rachel Trelfa and Nyomi Fee moved from Ryton, near Newcastle-upon-Tyne, to Fife in December 2011, after Trelfa left baby Liam's father. Their trial at the High Court in Livingston in 2016 heard how Fee tried to blame Liam's death on another child. Doctors found Liam had suffered a ruptured heart from a blow or blows to his body. They also discovered double fractures of his thigh bone and arm. In total they counted more than 30 injuries on his body. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community her eand get the latest news sent straight to your messages. The evil pair locked two other boys in a makeshift cage, part of which was kept under their mattress. Jayney's trial in May heard how she was accused of being transphobic, largely because she insisted on calling Stewart – who has full male biology – a man. Sheriff Millar found the charges not proven. It emerged the charge had prevented Sutherley from applying for parole for more than a year. Sutherley, now 51, stabbed 40-year-old Alistair MacFadyen through the heart at a flat in Fairway Avenue, Glenburn, Paisley, in June 2019. She was sentenced to six years and eight months after pleading guilty to culpable homicide. She was originally accused of murder. The Crown accepted the reduced plea on the basis of provocation. The victim had been out of prison for two days when he was stabbed. In 2013 Baker invited John Weir, 36, into his home in Bonhill, West Dunbartonshire, before stabbing him at least 16 times. He claimed self-defence but was convicted of murder. After identifying as a woman, the killer was transferred from a male prison to HMP Greenock, where they became involved in a relationship with Fee. The couple are believed to be engaged. The relationship has caused fury among other prisoners, who claim the couple have been given freedoms that others cannot enjoy. The Sutherley trial heard claims that the couple had sex in prison showers, were granted time alone in each other's cells and fumbled with each other in public areas in the jail.