Ohio AG's office lays out argument in appeal that avoids fighting the six-week abortion ban
Photo by Getty Images.
The Ohio Attorney General's Office does not plan to fight a court ruling overturning the six-week abortion ban, but he wants an appellate court to roll back rulings that overturned other parts of the same law.
In a brief submitted to the First District Court of Appeals, Ohio's solicitor general, T. Elliot Gaiser, reiterated that the appeal before the court didn't have anything to do with attempting to roll back a Hamilton County judge's ruling that a ban on abortions at six weeks gestation, included in 2019's Senate Bill 23, was unconstitutional.
'The state has long conceded the obvious: The state's 'Heartbeat Ban' – which banned abortions after a fetal heartbeat is detected – was overridden by the new Abortion Amendment,' Gaiser wrote, referring to the 2023 constitutional amendment passed by 57% of Ohio voters to enshrine reproductive rights including abortion into the state document. 'Thus, the state is not defending that Heartbeat Ban. Nor is the state even trying, in this appeal, to defend the merits of any of the ancillary abortion regulations that were amended or enacted in the same bill as the Heartbeat Ban.'
Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas Judge Christian Jenkins cited the constitutional amendment as part of his October 2024 ruling, saying the Ohio Constitution now protects 'the right to pre-viability abortion,' and to 'give meaning to the voice of Ohio's voters, the Amendment must be given full effect, and laws such as those enacted by (Senate Bill) 23 must be enjoined.'
The state is appealing decisions it says came alongside the six-week abortion ban ruling, that were made by the judge without a request from the groups suing to see the abortion ban struck down.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The solicitor general claimed the trial court decision 'broke all the rules,' and the plaintiffs in the case 'filed a vague, unclear motion for judgment.'
Gaiser said the trial court should have asked whether the provisions of the law could 'stand alone' without the six-week abortion ban attached to them.
'Many provisions here plainly can, as they were law for years before S.B. 23 was enacted,' the brief stated.
Those provisions included what Gaiser called a 'Check and Tell' provision, a requirement that doctors check for fetal cardiac activity and offer to allow the pregnant individual to hear it.
The main reason supporters called the law the 'Heartbeat Act' was because they claimed a fetal heartbeat was present at six weeks of pregnancy. Scientist say fetal cardiac activity at that stage isn't a fully formed heart, but instead indicates cardiac tissue development.
Some of the provisions brought up in the brief have been temporarily paused by a different court case, one in Franklin County in August 2024. In that case, a judge in the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas pumped the brakes on a 24-hour waiting period required before an abortion and the provision requiring doctors to check fetal activity.
Judge David C. Young cited the constitutional amendment as reason to stop enforcement of the requirements in that case for now.
Gaiser said the Hamilton County court that took up the S.B. 23 case 'relied on the analysis' from the Franklin County case in issuing its decision, even though 'plaintiffs did not even identify the challenged statutes' in the initial lawsuit 'and did not offer any substantive challenge to them.'
Provisions such as definition sections, Ohio Department of Health reporting requirements, and others 'can all work on their own without a Heartbeat Ban,' according to the brief.
'True, some (of the other provisions) might not seem to achieve much – such as the express protection of contraception – but they also do not harm Plaintiffs by staying in place, and even if they merely state the General Assembly's intent as to contraception and the like, that is no small thing,' Gaiser wrote. 'One critical representative function of any legislature is to codify the moral judgments of the community, including moral approval – here, of contraceptives.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
North Korea fires rockets, as tensions with South Korea mount
North Korea fired more than 10 rounds of rockets into the Yellow Sea Thursday, just one day after South Korea held joint air drills with the US and Japan — in the latest sign of mounting tensions between the neighboring countries. The missiles were shot from Pyongyang's upgraded 240-millimeter multiple rocket launcher — believed to be capable of targeting South Korean population centers including the Seoul metropolitan area — which the hermit country unveiled last year. 'The projectiles, believed to be multiple launch rockets, flew tens of kilometers before falling into the Yellow Sea,'a South Korean military official told local media, adding South Korean and US intelligence are closely analyzing details. 3 North Korea has been launching rockets to flex its military muscle. via REUTERS On Wednesday, South Korea, the US and Japan held their first trilateral military air exercise of the Lee Jae Myung administration — the new leader elected earlier this month. Tensions on the Korean Peninsula have increased in recent months, following North Korean leader Kim Jong Un's alignment with Russian President Vladimir Putin — supplying weapons and as many as 15,000 troops to support Russia's war against Ukraine. South Korean officials are concerned that Pyongyang could receive economic aid in return and advanced military technology to further develop its weapons programs. Kim has also continued to accelerate the development of his nuclear and missile program. 3 Kim Jong Un has been calling on his country to ramp up military production in recent months. KCNA VIA KNS/AFP via Getty Images The reclusive leader has been visiting military industrial factories across the country, calling on them to ramp up production of shells in order to meet the demands of war in the 21st century. North Korea also successfully built two 5,000-ton naval destroyers this year, with Kim calling the new battleship 'convincing proof of the rapid transformation of our Navy.' 3 The rockets were fired near Pyongyang, North Korea's capital. AFP via Getty Images
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Deadly Russian assaults on Ukraine continue as date for new peace talks nears
At least one person was killed in Ukraine Friday night as Russia continued its unrelenting attacks, despite both parties reportedly inching closer to a new round of peace talks. A barrage of more than 20 Russian drones rained down on residential areas in the Ukrainian port city of Odesa and the northeastern city of Kharkiv overnight, according to officials. One civilian was killed and almost two dozen were injured, including two girls — 12 and 17-years-old — and three emergency workers. The strikes sparked fires that caused the partial collapse of a four-story apartment building and tore through the upper floors of a 23-story high-rise, leading to the evacuation of about 600 residents. Advertisement 4 Firefighters evacuated residents from a burning apartment building following Russia's massive air attack in Odesa. AP The Kremlin's attack also included 86 Iranian Shahed and decoy drones blasted across the country into Saturday, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said in a post on Telegram. 'Russia continues its tactics of targeted terror against our people,' Zelensky said in the post. Advertisement He called on Western countries to keep the pressure on Russia, including through sanctions. 'The sooner the sick people in the Kremlin lose the ability to finance the war, the more lives we can save in Ukraine,' Zelensky said. 4 Emergency responders worked at the site of an apartment building hit by a Russian drone strike in Odesa. via REUTERS In the 24 hours leading up to the nighttime attack, Russia bombarded its neighbor with hundreds more drones and cruise and ballistic missiles, according to Ukraine's air force. Advertisement The attacks followed an assault on Kyiv Tuesday that killed 28 and injured 142 others — marking the deadliest onslaught on the capital city this year. Meanwhile, the warring countries completed another round of prisoner exchanges on Friday, the second trade of POWs and soldiers' remains in two days, though neither side specified how many people were involved in the swap. 4 A kitchen in a high-rise apartment building was destroyed in a Russian drone attack in Odesa. AFP via Getty Images Zelensky said on X that most of his country's POWs had been held by Russia for more than two years, following their full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Advertisement The oldest of the released captives was 63 years old and another, a 45-year-old service member, was released on his birthday, Ukrainian negotiator Dmytro Lubinets said. Zelensky also charged Russian President Vladimir Putin with using the return of the dead to obscure the scale of its military losses from the public, the Kyiv Independent reported. 4 Residential buildings, businesses, civilian infrastructure and cars were wrecked in the overnight attacks, officials said. AFP via Getty Images At a press conference Friday, Zelensky said authorities confirmed that at least 20 of the bodies returned as Ukrainians were actually Russian soldiers. The two countries have carried out a series of swaps since renewing peace talks, which in Istanbul last month. The last negotiations were held on June 2 and though Kyiv has not spoken recently of them resuming, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Friday that the date for the next round is expected to be agreed upon this coming week. With Post wires
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
NY primary falling on hottest day of heat wave could be bad news for Cuomo
The heat wave could be good news for far lefties and bad news for ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo. The 102 degree scorcher expected for Tuesday's primaries is likely to help far lefties such as socialist NYC mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani while hurting Cuomo, the frontrunner to win the Democratic mayoral nomination who is appealing to more moderate voters, political pundits told The Post. 'It's very likely the heat will lower turnout on Tuesday — especially if the city is in a heat emergency — [and that] will be bad news for any campaign relying on Election Day turnout, which has previously been older and more moderate,' said Jon Paul Lupo, a longtime Democratic consultant and former top aide for ex-Mayor Bill de Blasio. 'But we're seeing historic levels of early vote — some voters are getting the message and voting early to avoid the heat.' Cuomo campaign spokesman Jason Elan insisted oppressive heat won't stop the former governor's supporters from showing up at the polls. The NYC primary falls on the hottest day of the upcoming four-day heat wave. Michael Nagle 'While we encourage people to vote early to beat the heat, we expect high turnout on Election Day because New Yorkers are excited to cast their ballots for Andrew Cuomo,' Elan said. Governor Kathy Hochul signed a bill Saturday allowing primary voters to be given refreshments as they wait on line to cast their ballots. 'Our democracy works best when every eligible voter has a chance to cast their ballot,' Hochul said. 'Providing water to voters waiting in line is a common-sense way to ensure New Yorkers have an easy, safe and secure experience in the voting booth. I'm committing to protecting the right to vote for all eligible New Yorkers.' Governor Kathy Hochul signed a bill allowing primary voters to be given refreshments as they wait on line. Getty Images The new bill repeals a law that prohibited voters from receiving food, water and other refreshments at polling sites. Hochul, however, urged New Yorkers to vote early and beat the heat. 'The No.1 cause of weather-related death is extreme heat, but preparation, communication and other precautions can save lives,' Hochul said in a statement. 'That is why we are deploying a whole of government approach to keep New Yorkers safe, working to protect our most vulnerable populations, and encouraging voters to take advantage of early voting ahead of the June 24 Primary Election Day.'
