Judge Dismisses Sean Combs Juror Over Inconsistent Statements
Follow all of our Sean Combs trial coverage
Sean Combs' sex trafficking and racketeering trial entered its sixth week Monday with the judge dismissing a juror whose credibility was contested after he gave inconsistent statements about where he lives.
More from Rolling Stone
Wife of Weezer Bassist Appears in Court, Wins Delay in LAPD Shooting Case
Kneecap's Mo Chara Granted Unconditional Bail at First Hearing on Terror Charge
Tyler Perry Sued for Alleged Sexual Assault, Battery by 'The Oval' Actor
The juror, a 41-year-old Black man who works for New York's Department of Corrections, initially said he lived in the Bronx. He later casually mentioned to court staff during trial that he had moved to New Jersey to live with his finacée and child. When the issue was brought to the court's attention, the man said the move to New Jersey 'may not be permanent' and that he still had a New York driver's license and received his mail in the Bronx.
On Friday, U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian said 'the record raised serious concerns as to the juror's candor and whether he shaded answers to get on and stay on the jury.' (According to CNN, the man said during jury selection that he was a fan of 1990s hip-hop but that he didn't know much about the case.)
'Even if this juror had an excuse or explanation for the inconsistencies in the record, that would be yet another set of shifting answers on basic questions about the juror's residence. This would only heighten the specter that the juror's trying to shade answers in an effort to remain on the jury,' Subramanian said Monday as he issued his final decision. 'In other words, there's nothing the juror could say at this point that would put the genie back in the bottle and repair the damage to his credibility.'
Combs sighed in court after the judge ruled. The reaction was noticeably muted compared to Friday, when he was visibly angry, vigorously shaking his head, and whispering to his legal team.
Combs' camp emphatically fought the juror's removal, calling him one of only two Black men on the jury. On Friday, Combs' attorney, Xavier Donaldson, said it would be a 'step backwards' to remove the man. In a letter to the court filed Sunday night, the defense team said Combs wanted a mistrial if the juror was excused. The lawyers said prosecutors used seven of their nine peremptory strikes to remove Black jurors from the prospective panel before the final jury was selected. They argued that removing the seated juror over his residency issue after five weeks of trial would be 'discriminatory.'
'The fairness of the trial depends in part on having jurors with backgrounds similar to Mr. Combs share their perspectives on the evidence with other jurors from diverse backgrounds during deliberations,' the 14-page letter, authored by Combs' attorney, Alexandra Shapiro, said. 'Removing this particular juror will deprive Mr. Combs of that important perspective and it is no answer to simply say that there are other Black jurors, or other males, on the jury.'
On Monday, Judge Subramanian said it would be 'improper' to consider the race of the juror while determining whether to excuse the man. The judge said he took the weekend to consider the issue and that he was comfortable with his decision, considering the alternate jurors were selected in a fair process agreed to by both sides.
The alternate juror who filled the excused juror's seat is a 57-year-old male who appears to be white and lives with his wife and children in Westchester County, according to NBC News. On Monday, the defense contested another juror, though Subramanian said there was no connection between that juror and the one already dismissed.
Combs, 55, was arrested in September and has pleaded not guilty to charges of sex trafficking, transportation to engage in prostitution and racketeering conspiracy. If convicted as charged, he could spend the rest of his life in prison.
Combs' lawyers deny the music mogul was the head of a criminal enterprise allegedly designed to fulfill his sexual desires and protect his reputation. Instead, they've described Combs as a 'swinger' who indulged his 'kinky' proclivities with his longtime girlfriends. Combs has acknowledged he kicked and dragged Casandra 'Cassie' Ventura in the hallway of the InterContinental hotel in 2016, but he denies he coerced her or another recent ex-girlfriend, 'Jane,' into sex trafficking.
Throughout the trial playing out in lower Manhattan, prosecutors have alleged Combs used force, fraud, or coercion to manipulate Ventura and Jane into drug-fueled, highly orchestrated sex marathons with male escorts that Combs directed and recorded. The encounters were known as 'freak-offs,' 'hotel nights,' and 'king nights,' according to testimony.
For the first time Monday, jurors were shown freak-off videos, which were admitted under seal and not shown to the gallery. The explicit videos were introduced using a summary chart that detailed 71 alleged instances where Combs booked hotel rooms for freak-offs with Ventura between August 2009 and June 2017. The chart contained names of the male escorts and corresponding travel information if they were flown in from out of state. Summary witness SDNY special agent DeLeassa Penland said the data was compiled through bank statements, hotel and flight records, text messages, and videotapes.
The videos were introduced in the context of confirming certain male escorts were in the hotel rooms for some of the alleged freak-offs with Ventura. Putting on headphones, many of the jurors watched a few moments of the 11-minute to 40-minute videos, with intent expressions and holding their chin in their hands.
Earlier in the day, Ananya Sankar, a paralegal specialist with the U.S. Attorney's Office, was called to the stand. Sankar walked jurors through a lengthy chart showing texts and communications between Combs' former chief of staff, Kristina Khorram, and other staffers or even Combs himself.
In the messages, extracted from seized devices, Khorram and others allegedly discussed prepping hotel rooms for freak-offs and dropping off supplies, including drugs and large sums of cash to pay male escorts. (Khorram has been described as a 'co-conspirator' but has not been called to testify.)
In one exchange shown to jurors, Combs' former assistant Ryan Lopez texted Khorram, 'LOL. Think I saw one of the cowboys today. You can spot them in the lobby like an escort.' Khorram texted back with four laughing face emojis, later asking, 'BTW, how long is he going to stay awake?' Prosecutors positioned the December 2019 exchange as clear evidence Khorram knew Combs used an escort service called 'Cowboys 4 Angels' to hire paid male sex workers for his freak-offs with Ventura and Jane.
'Hotel called, Paul coming up,' Khorram texted Combs in another exchange dated Nov. 14, 2021. (Jane previously told jurors that 'Paul' was an escort they used for 'hotel nights.') In a subsequent exchange on March 3, 2022, a travel assistant sent Khorram flight information for Paul.
Prosecutors also allege Khorram was aware of Combs' violence towards Ventura. In a text exchange dated May 2, 2017, Ventura described Combs attacking her. 'No one deserves being dragged by their hair,' Ventura wrote. 'I locked the door for my safety.' In April 2018, Ventura texted Khorram, 'I can't do the violent, scary, kick me out of my own house stuff anymore.'
Jurors also saw photos dated December 2023 that showed a text exchange from another device. The photos, which would have been snapped a month after Ventura filed her bombshell sex trafficking and rape lawsuit against Combs, depicted Jane telling Combs she felt 'extremely exploited, heartbroken and manipulated' by the music mogul.
Shortly after the photos were taken, Jane texted Khorram directly, jurors heard. 'He just threatened me about my sex tapes that he has of me on two phones. He said that he would expose me and send them to my child's father,' Jane wrote.
When Combs' defense lawyer Teny Geragos had her turn to question Sankar, she highlighted an exchange between Khorram and Jane from June 13, 2022. In one message, Jane sounds eager to travel and join Combs at a hotel. 'Pulling up to airport, yay,' she wrote. 'I'm excited to surprise him.'
In a subsequent message in the series, Jane suggested to Khorram that Combs' security should bring $5,000 to $10,000 in cash to the room, ostensibly to pay for a male escort. A centerpiece of Combs' defense is that Jane and Ventura repeatedly consented to the freak-offs and sometimes managed paying the escorts themselves.
In yet another exchange, longtime Combs spokeswoman Nathalie Moar texted Khorram on Aug. 18, 2016, informing her that TMZ was about to run a story about Combs allegedly snatching Ventura's phone and taking off running down a street in Beverly Hills. 'The only reason it's running is because of police report,' Moar allegedly texted Khorram in the messages shown to jurors. Moar said she was communicating with Ventura as well, claiming Ventura was 'worried' about the TMZ story and wanted to get an 'advance' copy. 'I told her that cannot happen,' Moar wrote, referring to Ventura.
After Khorram was named as a co-defendant in multiple civil lawsuits, she released a statement in March. 'For months, horrific accusations have been made about me in various lawsuits regarding my former boss,' she said. 'These false allegations of my involvement are causing irreparable and incalculable damage to my reputation and the emotional well-being of myself and my family. I have never condoned or aided and abetted the sexual assault of anyone. Nor have I ever drugged anyone. The idea that I could be accused of playing a role in – or even being a bystander to – the rape of anyone is beyond upsetting, disturbing, and unthinkable. That is not who I am and my heart goes out to all victims of sexual assault. I am confident that the allegations against me will be proven to be untrue.'
Before court ended for the day, jurors saw a text exchange between Combs and Ventura regarding an alleged freak-off with four male entertainers in Jan. 9, 2013. 'Would you want to celebrate Christmas and have a freak-off tonight or Friday?' Combs asked Ventura before sending another message saying he had her present.
After more than two dozen witnesses, the government said they will rest later this week. On Tuesday, they plan to call one of their final witnesses, Combs' former recent assistant Brendan Paul. The former Syracuse University basketball player was the lone person arrested during the simultaneous raids on Combs' homes in March 2024. As Combs was about to take off on a private plane bound for the Caribbean with his daughters and entourage, Miami police detained him and said they found cocaine traces and marijuana candy in Paul's baggage. His case was ultimately dismissed after he completed a drug diversion course.
In a sneak peek at how the defense plans to proceed, defense lawyers said Monday they plan to call Vashta Wilson, a former vice president of human resources for Combs, and Stephan Lind-Orjala, who's listed online as a facilities manager at Combs Enterprises, as witnesses.
Best of Rolling Stone
Sly and the Family Stone: 20 Essential Songs
The 50 Greatest Eminem Songs
All 274 of Taylor Swift's Songs, Ranked
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Buzz Feed
2 hours ago
- Buzz Feed
27 Torrid Items To Reinvent Your Style This Summer
A denim trucker jacket because every season deserves a tried and true staple that goes with literally everything. But, don't get it twisted. Every denim jacket isn't just a replica of another. This one features a trucker jacket silhouette and a distressed hem to set it apart from the others. Promising review: "I received this jacket in the mail yesterday and I like it. I feel like to could be styled with dresses, jeans and trousers depending on the look you are trying to achieve. IMO, the fit is true to size. Also, in my opinion, there is not a lot of stretch. I ordered a 2 and that's what i normally order in shirts, jackets and blazers. The sleeves hit right at the wrist. My favorite part of the jacket is the raw hem at the bottom. I will probably also purchase the darker denim. I would recommend." —Lovin All Things DenimPrice: $41.94 (originally $69.90; available in sizes M–6X and two colors) A sleeveless mini dress featuring pockets that reviewers can't stop raving about. They love the knit fabric and the smoothing effect the dress gives. They say it's great for every occasion because it can be dressed up or down. Bonus: It comes in many colors. Promising reviews: "Love the new colors! I can't help but buy these dresses! These dresses always fit and look good. Can't go wrong." —CJS8082"Comfortable Fit! Love how the flare lays around my belly area. I bought several more colors in this because I'm in love with these! Used this Black one with my Western Torrid Boots for a Mexican Festival 🥳 and got so many compliments 🥰🙌🏻❤️ All I had to do was accessorize it. The stretch and length were a blessing all night long 😍. Love Love Love This Style! Thank you, My Fabulous Torrid!!!!! ❤️🙌🏻" —LaPalomaDelValle95601Price: $20+ (originally $55.90; available in sizes M–6X and six colors) A corset tank with a knit fabric that holds you close for a somewhat bodycon effect. Did I mention the tie straps? If you've got an occasion on the books and are rummaging for something to wear, this corset tank combo will always stop the show. And that matching skirt you're eyeing, you can get it right here. Promising review: "Bought this in a two and I'm so happy I did! It's snug on the fit as you'd expect for a corset tank. It's stupid cute! I paired it with a skirt bought from Torrid years ago, and it looks amazing with it. This shirt looks amazing with everything I've tried it with so far, may end up buying it in more colors, I love it that much, the color I did buy was black." —I_love_milk_dudsPrice: $21.54 (originally $35.90; available in sizes M–6X and three colors) A triangle swim top, that's wire-free for your comfort, with matching high-waisted cheeky bottom, ready to ensure you stay photo-ready at the next pool party, even if you never take a dip. Promising reviews: "I bought this bikini top a month ago to help build my confidence in my physical. The color and the shape of the product work really well, and I'm so happy that I found the design pattern I absolutely love. I would totally recommend this product." —Anonymous"Big girl, big fun! Great fit for the summer sun. The waist and cup sizes are just the right fit. Gives support. Looks good wet or dry." —AnonymousPrice: $35.94 for the top (originally $59.90; available in sizes L–6X and three styles) and 20+ for the bottoms (originally $44.90; available in sizes M–6X and nine styles) A leopard sarong ideal for weekend getaways when multipurpose clothing reigns supreme. You can wear it as a skirt or a dress for a barely-there garment on the hottest of days. Promising review: "So, I purchased this in leopard print. And thought it was cute. I have never found a sarong that fits well. I got this and omg! It fits so well in both styles, the dress style and the sarong style. this will be my go-to this summer, I am so glad I bought it!" —theedarkcrystalPrice: $14.95 (originally $29.90; also available in two other colors) A button front overall set on upgrading your usual farmhouse chic attire. These overalls aren't rough like other denim; they're softer for added comfort. And, the haltered top adds a little sauciness that you don't get from traditional overalls. Promising reviews: "These are so dang cute and comfortable! I've never had a pair of overalls that weren't too short in the rise. These are terrific!" —QueenKarin"Total score. I love a good pair of bibs. The ties are awesome and the back is not like farmer bibs. I did get an 18 for more room. I get so many compliments every time I wear them. I am thinking about another pair for some patches." —Kris10starrPrice: $59.94 (originally $99.90; available in sizes 16–22) A drop cherry earring so ~sweet~ for your go-to summer 'fit... whether that's a dress and sandals, or a basic tank, high-rise shorts, and your fave slides. Price: $11.94 (originally $19.90) A V-neck tee in an assortment of 21 colors to be used at your discretion, all summer long. Perhaps you just want to lounge around in an ultra-soft tee. Or, maybe you want to twist it up into a crop top for more stylish flair. And if you want to wear one every day of the week, that's your business. Promising reviews: "Absolutely love the cowhide color! I got so many compliments. And the fit and feel of the shirt is awesome!" —angelmir"Finally, a t-shirt that fits well and looks great on. I actually went back to order another color!!!" —Smiling76Price: $10+ (originally $27.90; available in sizes M–6X and 21 colors) A sheer button-up shirt for those who need a few pieces to add to their workplace-appropriate collection. It can also serve as a thin jacket when the summer nights get cool and you want a little something on your arms. Price: $33.54 (originally $54.90; available in sizes M–6X) A ghosty summer earring, or shall we say *summerweenie* earring, for the spooky at heart who still love to play in the sun. Once you pop out these puppies, you'll know it's only a matter of months until you get to Halloween. Price: $11.94 (originally $19.90) A pair of cork-sole heels because the natural wood look makes it the perfect shoe to pair with your maxi dress, denim shorts, and skinny jeans. Yes! We've found our summer heel. Price: $39.54 (originally $65.90; available in sizes 6.5–13) A mesh maxi skirt with flowers galore that'll look great with your favorite combat boots (because yes, you're edgy year round). Price: $35.94 (originally $59.90; available in sizes M–6X) A smocked crop top and skirt set so you don't have to worry about matching pieces together. The halter top and skirt, complete with leg slit, would like to be your plus one for the beach bonfire this weeend. Promising review: "Get this! I stepped out my comfort zone and with full intention to return it once it came in from it on and LOVED it! Top and bottom is stretchy. Theres 1 slit. Could've added another one ot the one could've been higher. Going to add some wedges, accessories and maybe a Jean jacket if the weather isnt warm enough. I got a 1 bc I'm top heavy. It was perfect!" —TorriddivaJPrice: $20 (originally $99.90; available in sizes 2X–6X) A platform sandal in case you've been on the hunt for a shoe that can withstand hours on your feet with no problem. Promising review: "I bought these in green a month ago and loved them so much I ordered the other colors. They fit well, are not too bulky and are very comfortable. I bought my usual Torrid size and I had no problems." —AngelB05Price: $33.54 (originally $55.90; available in sizes 6–13 and three colors) A pair of high-rise pull-on shorts so your denim jorts can take the day off on warm days when you'd prefer to wear a lighter material. Price: $10 (originally $29.90; available in sizes M–6X and two colors) And! a matching collared top to turn those garments into a travel-friendly ensemble. Plus, if you think about it, you can never have enough loungewear. Promising review: "So soft and feels amazing. I bought this in blue and may *need* to get every color. I love how this feels and how I look in it. It's casual, yet could be worn to work. GREAT TOP!" —AH251Price: $59.90 (available in sizes M–6X and three colors) A halter midi dress in a ~hot~ pink color that's practically screaming at you to usher in the island vibes. Sure, we may not be able to go to the island, but we can always bring the island to us. The first step? Throwing on this dress! Promising review: "This dress is summer-ready fun. Love the neckline, and the fit across the bust is great because the smocking is so perfect. It's a sweet color!" —AzcynPrice: $35.99+ (originally $75.90; available in sizes M–6X and two colors) A pair of biker shorts because truthfully, you can never have enough, especially when they come in so many colors. Come summer festivities, you'll appreciate the stretchy material that'll give you the freedom to move when you attend your local free concert in the park. Promising review: "These bike shorts are the perfect length to wear with a T-shirt around the house! They are super soft and super stretchy, perfect for lounging in. And they have pockets!! I bought my usual size 2 and they are a perfect fit, but could possibly even go a size smaller since they have a great stretch." —MandyLue77Price: $15.54 (originally $25.90; available in sizes M–6X and nine colors) A cotton maxidress for a refreshing and breezy dress to wear when you have to ride your bike from the family country house down the road to the bus station so you can stop your childhood crush from leaving town because you haven't had the chance to tell them, "I've always loved you, too." Promising review: "Love love love this dress! It is flowy and not too cool or too warm for summer wear, even in air conditioning or high heat. Looks adorable and I could see wearing it out to honestly, I got it to be comfortable around home or on live calls for work and feel beautiful." —Angel KatPrice: $99.90 (available in sizes M–6X) A tie-front blouse pretty much the definition of work and play. Throw a cami or shell underneath for a 9-to-5 appropriate top, but once you clock out, ditch the cami and tube top for a gorgeous night-out look. Promising review: "I bought this with the matching wide-leg pants and it looks amazing together? I wear it with a tube top under it for more professional settings and without the tube top and with a purple bra for a [gorgeous] look! Go for it!" —CShampPrice: $27.54 (originally $45.90; available in sizes L–6X and two colors) A smoky pair of cat-eye sunglasses because your peepers are craving a retro pair of shades to dim some of the sun's shine this season. Price: $10.14 (originally $16.90; available in four colors) A crochet maxi cover-up made of a lightweight fabric that will gracefully drape over your body. It would be perfect to use as a cover-up for beach days, but it can also be worn over your bodycon dress or tank and jean combo for some added pizzazz. Promising review: "So freaking gorgeous! Even better in person. I wish it were a dress so I could wear it all the time, lol." —MandaMandaPrice: $20+ (originally $69.90; available sizes M–4X and two colors) A pair of high-rise relaxed denim trousers if you're ready to morph into a '90s R&B *it girl* at a time when baggy jeans and crop tops ruled the world. "Alexa, play 'I Wanna Be Down' by Brandy." Price: $79.90 (available in sizes 10–30 and three lengths) A pair of high-rise shorts in a gritty black because you're not going to turn down your all-black aesthetic simply because the sun decided to turn the heat up. Some reviewers suggest sizing up for a looser fit. Promising review: "These are comfy and fit perfectly. Love the coloring and the look. These will be my go-to shorts for all summer long." —Mandi2025Price: $33.54 (originally $55.90; available in sizes 10–16 and two colors) A casual skater dress when you're unsure what the day will hold and want to throw on something that won't be too dressy if the vibes are casual, but won't make you stand out if the vibes are more polished. We call this an anything dress. Promising review: "Can't wait for warm weather!!! These dresses are so cute and comfortable. It will be cute with little slip-on sneakers for a super casual dressed up a bit with sandals and some jewelry." —MELD68Price: $20+ (originally $55.90; available in sizes M–5X and five colors) A vibrant skort in a 'poppin yellow hue that'll have passerbys yelling, "MUSTAAAAAARD." And if you're wondering if this wonderful piece of athletic wear has a matching top: voila! Promising review: "I love this skort! It is comfortable, has nice flow (doesn't stick to you) and the shorts underneath mean I don't have to worry about flashing anyone." —JemjemjemPrice: $35.94 (originally $59.90; available sizes M–6X and two colors) A pair of white crochet sneakers reviewers love because they're super cozy but also super cute. When you can find a shoe that can do both, never let it go. Promising review: "This white lace is so cute! They match everything and are easy to pull on or off when on the go! Thank you, My Torrid! ❤️ I never have to sacrifice cuteness for comfort. 👍🏻" —LaPalomaDelValle2025Price: $23.94 (originally $39.90; available in sizes 6–13 and two widths)
CBS News
2 hours ago
- CBS News
LAPD detectives searching for hit-and-run driver that killed pedestrian at Sun Valley gas station
Los Angeles police detectives are searching for a hit-and-run driver who ran over and killed a man in the parking lot of a Sun Valley gas station earlier this week. They were dispatched to the gas station, located at the intersection of Lauren Canyon Boulevard and Roscoe Boulevard, at around 6 a.m., according to a press release from the LAPD. Police say that the victim, who has been identified as 43-year-old Erik Florer by the Los Angeles County Medical Examiner, was lying on the ground when he was run over by the suspect, who was driving a dark-colored Hummer EV SUV. After running over Florer, the driver stopped outside of the gas station's convenience store and picked up a passenger, only described as a male. The driver, also described as a male, then drove away from the station heading northbound on Pendleton Street, police said. As they continue their search for the suspect, police have shared video of the incident on their YouTube page. The video is very graphic. Anyone who knows more is asked to contact detectives at (818) 644-8119.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Los Angeles taxpayers to foot millions for 'peaceful' anti-ICE protests
The violent and destructive Los Angeles anti-ICE protests cost taxpayers $32 million, according to a report by the city budget chief. Controller Kenneth Mejia posted the figures on X, detailing what the money from local taxpayers will be funding. City taxpayers are on the hook for emergency services, cleanup and public property damage, all stemming from the protests that turned into riots, according to Mejia's post. More than $29 million, or 92% of the cost, is for the Los Angeles Police Department's response. Part of these funds will also cover the cost of the citywide tactical alerts. La Anti-ice Rioters Face New Charges As Violence Rages A little more than $1 million will go to the city's efforts to clean up the city and repair damage to public property, according to Mejia's post. The rest of the money will be distributed to various departments, such as the Los Angeles Fire Department, the city's street services, general services, tourism and others. Read On The Fox News App Mejia noted the funding did not factor in potential lawsuits that could arise from the unrest. Fbi Will Investigate 'Any Evidence Of A Criminal Conspiracy' In La Riots The protests, described as "peaceful" by Sen. Cory Booker, D-N.J., and the liberal media, saw demonstrators violently clash with the LAPD over multiple days, prompting President Donald Trump to deploy both the National Guard and active-duty military personnel. The protests have led to several arrests, including Grzegorz Vandenberg, 48. He was charged with buying fireworks with the intent to harm law enforcement and government officials during the protests, according to the Department of Justice. While at a store, federal authorities allege, he told employees he previously served in the military's special forces and claimed he could make pipe bombs before revealing he was planning to travel to Los Angeles to kill law enforcement officers and government officials in the anti-ICE riots. Federal Agents Thwart Man's Explosive Alleged Plot Against Officers During La Riots Los Angeles County Sheriff Robert G. Luna announced that nearly a dozen deputies were injured during the ongoing riots after protesters launched rocks, Molotov cocktails and "high-grade pyrotechnics" at them. Since June 7, the LAPD has made over 500 arrests related to protests, according to the LAPD. Mejia's office did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital's request for comment. Fox News' Christina Coleman, Julia Bonavita and Stepheny Price contributed to this article source: Los Angeles taxpayers to foot millions for 'peaceful' anti-ICE protests
