The Case Against Gamified Prop Trading
The trading industry stands at a crossroads. One road leads to more gamification, more extraction, more disillusionment. The other leads to professionalism, purpose, and shared upside.
In a recent op-ed for the Financial Times, BlackRock Chair and CEO Larry Fink called for the second draft of globalisation.
'The first step,' he said, is in 'helping more people become investors.'
Fink outlined how 'the Trump administration's tariffs are the symptom of a backlash to the era of what might be called 'globalism without guardrails.' Global GDP grew more since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 than in all recorded history before it. But the benefits weren't evenly shared. S&P 500 investors saw a return of more than 3,800 per cent. Rustbelt workers did not.'
He goes on to argue that 'at the heart of this new model are the capital markets: exchanges where people invest in stocks, bonds, infrastructure, everything. Why? Because markets are uniquely suited to transforming global growth into local wealth.'
I couldn't agree more. While Fink was primarily referring to people's ability to invest in markets long-term, it's equally important to make the case for the power of markets in the context of trading.
It has never been easier to provide people with a real understanding of stock markets and opportunities to harness their power. But it needs to be done properly. In the post-pandemic world, trading is popular and perilous.
From Reddit-fueled meme stocks to Instagram ads promising six-figure incomes in weeks, trading has become a cultural phenomenon. But beneath the glossy surface of fast payouts, slick dashboards, and instant accounts lies a more uncomfortable truth: in the new age of gamified proprietary trading, the trader is no longer the protagonist; they're the product.
This is the reality ushered in by platforms like Hola Prime and the explosion of 'funded trader programs.' What began as a promising movement to democratize market access has mutated into a profit-extraction engine dressed up in UX and buzzwords. If the GameStop saga exposed the dangers of payment for order flow, the current state of prop trading is a sequel where the script is even more cynical.
The premise of these new platforms is seductive: we'll give you capital to trade without risking your own money. Just pass a simple evaluation, click through a few disclaimers, and you're off to the races. Some now even offer instant accounts: skip the test, trade now, get paid in under an hour.
But here's the rub: the business model isn't about helping you succeed. It's about getting you through the door, extracting fees, and quietly setting conditions that ensure most participants fail.
The real revenue engine isn't trading profits, it's the fees traders pay for the privilege of chasing them.
Most funded trader platforms charge upfront fees for evaluations, with limited transparency and minimal incentive alignment. If you fail (as most do), the firm keeps your money. If you succeed, you're handed capital under highly artificial constraints: inflated spreads, punitive commissions, and execution speeds that are just slow enough to give the house the edge.
It's a system rigged for churn. The faster you burn out, the sooner the next aspiring trader can be onboarded and monetized. This isn't proprietary trading; it's proprietary entertainment, where every trader is both contestant and consumer.
Gamified dashboards, explosive payout headlines, are engineered to hook you like a Vegas slot machine. All wrapped in a language of empowerment that masks a deeply extractive core.
Take Hola Prime's headline-grabbing '1-Hour Payouts.' On paper, it's a breakthrough. In practice, it's table stakes masquerading as a revolution. Speedy payouts are nice, but they're a distraction from the real question: what are you actually building for traders?
Are you training them in institutional-grade discipline? Are you teaching risk management? Are you offering a career ladder or a casino floor?
Real proprietary trading firms do all of the above. They invest in their traders, not just their branding. They build loyalty through long-term alignment, not short-term gimmicks. At firms like Real Trading, when traders win, the firm wins. There's no fee treadmill, no asymmetry. The incentives are clear, and the traders are treated like the talent they are, not just throughput on a spreadsheet.
'Instant Accounts' skip the evaluation process entirely. That's not innovation, it's abdication. For serious traders, the evaluation is the beginning of the journey. It's where you demonstrate discipline, consistency, and judgment under pressure. It's where a firm learns who you are and whether it can entrust you with capital.
By removing it, you lower the barrier, but you also flatten the profession. What's left isn't trading; it's speculation, dressed up in startup lingo.
There is real talent in this new generation of retail traders, particularly in emerging markets. These are individuals hungry to learn, to grow, to become professionals. But instead of nurturing them, the current wave of gamified prop firms exploits them.
Imagine what could happen if this energy were redirected toward institutional discipline rather than dopamine-fueled churn. If platforms invested in career-building, not just customer acquisition.
Real proprietary trading should be a path, not a pit stop.
The markets have become faster, more automated, and more unequal. The edge now often lies with those who can deploy algorithms and AI at scale. But amid this high-frequency arms race, something fundamental is being lost: the human trader.
Human judgment. Emotional intelligence. Pattern recognition that no bot can replicate. These are the qualities that, when nurtured, complement, if not beat, the work of the machines; especially in moments of market chaos where instinct and experience trump code.
Real prop firms recognize this. They treat traders as long-term partners. They offer structured training, risk coaching, and capital scaling that mirrors performance. They don't hand you a lottery ticket; they hand you a roadmap.
The trading industry stands at a crossroads. One road leads to more gamification, more extraction, more disillusionment. The other leads to professionalism, purpose, and shared upside.
The question isn't whether fast payouts or sleek apps are bad. It's whether they come instead of meaningful development, or in support of it.
The next generation of traders deserves more than gimmicks. They deserve mentorship, meritocracy, and the tools to build a future, not just flip a trade.
Let's stop turning traders into products and start turning them into professionals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Exploring Three High Growth Tech Stocks In The US Market
In the last week, the United States market has been flat, yet it is up 9.9% over the past year with earnings projected to grow by 15% annually. In this context of steady growth and positive earnings forecasts, identifying high-growth tech stocks involves looking for companies that demonstrate strong innovation potential and robust financial health amidst these conditions. Name Revenue Growth Earnings Growth Growth Rating Super Micro Computer 26.38% 39.09% ★★★★★★ Mereo BioPharma Group 53.63% 66.57% ★★★★★★ Ardelyx 21.03% 60.42% ★★★★★★ TG Therapeutics 26.46% 38.75% ★★★★★★ AVITA Medical 27.36% 60.93% ★★★★★★ Blueprint Medicines 21.12% 60.77% ★★★★★★ Alnylam Pharmaceuticals 23.63% 60.71% ★★★★★★ Alkami Technology 20.53% 76.67% ★★★★★★ Ascendis Pharma 35.07% 59.92% ★★★★★★ Lumentum Holdings 22.99% 103.97% ★★★★★★ Click here to see the full list of 229 stocks from our US High Growth Tech and AI Stocks screener. Let's uncover some gems from our specialized screener. Simply Wall St Growth Rating: ★★★★☆☆ Overview: Tenable Holdings, Inc. offers cyber exposure management solutions across various global regions and has a market capitalization of approximately $4.01 billion. Operations: Tenable Holdings generates revenue primarily from its Security Software & Services segment, amounting to $923.20 million. The company operates across the Americas, Europe, the Middle East, Africa, the Asia Pacific, and Japan. Tenable Holdings, despite its current unprofitability, is strategically positioning itself for future profitability with significant leadership and product expansions. The company's recent appointment of experienced executives and the anticipated launch of an expanded Tenable One platform underscore a focused strategy on enhancing cybersecurity capabilities. Notably, Tenable's R&D expenditure has been robust, supporting its aggressive innovation trajectory. This commitment is reflected in its projected earnings growth of 61.1% annually and an ambitious revenue forecast aiming for $970 million to $980 million by year-end. Moreover, the repurchase of 1.6 million shares early this year highlights confidence in their strategic direction amidst a challenging competitive landscape. Click here to discover the nuances of Tenable Holdings with our detailed analytical health report. Gain insights into Tenable Holdings' past trends and performance with our Past report. Simply Wall St Growth Rating: ★★★★★☆ Overview: Corning Incorporated operates in the optical communications, display technologies, environmental technologies, specialty materials, and life sciences sectors both in the United States and globally, with a market cap of approximately $43.23 billion. Operations: The company generates revenue primarily from optical communications ($5.08 billion) and display technologies ($3.91 billion), with additional contributions from specialty materials, life sciences, and Hemlock and emerging growth businesses. Corning's strategic collaborations and technological advancements underscore its potential in high-growth sectors like AI and mobile technologies. Recently, Corning partnered with Broadcom to enhance data center capacities with its optical components for a pioneering ethernet switch, reflecting significant strides in AI infrastructure efficiency. Additionally, the introduction of Gorilla Glass Ceramic 21 in Samsung's latest smartphone exemplifies Corning's influence on mobile durability innovations. These efforts are supported by robust R&D investments totaling $404 million last year, aimed at refining technologies that meet evolving digital demands. With a projected annual earnings growth of 27.9% and revenue increases expected at 9.6% per year, Corning is positioning itself as a key player in essential tech domains despite some financial setbacks like a notable one-off loss impacting recent results. Take a closer look at Corning's potential here in our health report. Evaluate Corning's historical performance by accessing our past performance report. Simply Wall St Growth Rating: ★★★★★☆ Overview: MNTN, Inc. is a performance TV software company that offers advertising services in the United States with a market capitalization of approximately $1.53 billion. Operations: The company generates revenue primarily from its Internet Software & Services segment, amounting to $246.27 million. MNTN, recently public following a $187.2 million IPO, illustrates a dynamic shift in tech with its aggressive growth metrics and strategic legal structuring to bolster market presence. Despite current unprofitability, the company is on a trajectory with forecasted earnings growth at an impressive 74.5% annually, significantly outpacing the industry average. This performance is underpinned by substantial R&D investments aimed at pioneering innovations in software and AI technologies, ensuring MNTN remains competitive in a rapidly evolving sector. These efforts are complemented by recent regulatory updates and significant capital raised through equity offerings totaling nearly $700 million, positioning MNTN to capitalize on expanding market opportunities and enhance shareholder value. Click to explore a detailed breakdown of our findings in MNTN's health report. Review our historical performance report to gain insights into MNTN's's past performance. Explore the 229 names from our US High Growth Tech and AI Stocks screener here. Are these companies part of your investment strategy? Use Simply Wall St to consolidate your holdings into a portfolio and gain insights with our comprehensive analysis tools. Discover a world of investment opportunities with Simply Wall St's free app and access unparalleled stock analysis across all markets. Explore high-performing small cap companies that haven't yet garnered significant analyst attention. Fuel your portfolio with companies showing strong growth potential, backed by optimistic outlooks both from analysts and management. Find companies with promising cash flow potential yet trading below their fair value. This article by Simply Wall St is general in nature. We provide commentary based on historical data and analyst forecasts only using an unbiased methodology and our articles are not intended to be financial advice. It does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and does not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. We aim to bring you long-term focused analysis driven by fundamental data. Note that our analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material. Simply Wall St has no position in any stocks mentioned. Companies discussed in this article include TENB GLW and MNTN. Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
SoftBank Pitches $1 Trillion US AI Hub to TSMC, Trump Team
(Bloomberg) -- SoftBank Group Corp. founder Masayoshi Son is seeking to team up with Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co. to realize what could be his biggest bet yet — a trillion-dollar industrial complex in Arizona to build robots and artificial intelligence. Security Concerns Hit Some of the World's 'Most Livable Cities' JFK AirTrain Cuts Fares 50% This Summer to Lure Riders Off Roads One Architect's Quest to Save Mumbai's Heritage From Disappearing NYC Congestion Toll Cuts Manhattan Gridlock by 25%, RPA Reports Taser-Maker Axon Triggers a NIMBY Backlash in its Hometown Son envisions a version of the vast manufacturing hub of China's Shenzhen that would bring back high-tech manufacturing to the US, according to people familiar with the billionaire's thinking. The park may comprise production lines for AI-powered industrial robots, they said, asking not to be named as the plan remains private. SoftBank officials are keen to have the Taiwanese maker of Nvidia Corp.'s advanced AI chips play a prominent role in the project, although it's not clear what part Son sees for TSMC, which already plans to invest $165 billion in the US and has started mass production at its first Arizona factory. Nor is it clear that TSMC would be interested. A person familiar with the chipmaker's thinking said that SoftBank's project has no bearing on TSMC's plans in Phoenix. Shares of SoftBank jumped as much as 2.3% in Tokyo Friday. TSMC's stock price rose 1.9% in Taipei. Codenamed 'Project Crystal Land,' the Arizona complex represents the 67-year-old SoftBank chief's most ambitious attempt in a career that's spanned numerous bet-the-house bids, thousands-fold-returns and billions of dollars in losses. Son, who's often expressed disappointment in his own legacy, has repeatedly said he means to do everything he can to hurry AI development. SoftBank officials have spoken with federal and state government officials to discuss possible tax breaks for companies building factories or otherwise investing in the industrial park, including talks with US Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick, the people said. The Japanese billionaire is also personally sounding out interest among an array of tech companies, they said. The project has been floated to executives at South Korea's Samsung Electronics Co., they said. Representatives of SoftBank, TSMC and Samsung declined to comment. A Commerce Department spokesperson did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Son has pulled together a list of SoftBank Vision Fund portfolio companies that might take part in the Arizona manufacturing hub, the people said. SoftBank-backed startups working on robotics and automation technologies — such as Agile Robots SE — may set up production facilities at the industrial complex, they said. The plans are preliminary and feasibility hinges on support from the Trump administration and state officials. While the cost of the project as envisioned by Son may require as much as $1 trillion to execute — a sum previously reported by the Nikkei — the actual scale depends on interest from big technology companies. If successful, Son has floated building multiple cutting-edge industrial parks across the US. SoftBank is exploring the Arizona project as it also moves forward on plans to invest as much as $30 billion into OpenAI and plans a $6.5 billion acquisition of Ampere Computing LLC. It's also seeding money into the Stargate venture with OpenAI, Oracle Corp. and Abu Dhabi's MGX, seeking to ferry hundreds of billions of dollars into data centers and related infrastructure around the world. Those outlays come as SoftBank's cash stood at ¥3.4 trillion ($23 billion) at the end of March. The Tokyo-based company has since tapped its T-Mobile US Inc. stake, selling roughly a quarter of what it held in March to raise $4.8 billion this month. SoftBank also has net assets valued at ¥25.7 trillion, of which chip designer Arm Holdings Plc makes the single largest portion, allowing it to borrow billions more as needed. SoftBank's exploring project financing for Stargate data centers, a model that could be adapted to a big endeavor like Crystal Land. Common for large-scale infrastructure like oil or gas pipelines, the project finance template would allow the tech investor to raise funding on a project-by-project basis and require less money upfront. Son's restless search for growth has resulted in projects that proceed in fits and starts, making it difficult to gauge how committed he is to any one venture. The billionaire is often goaded by the desire to boost SoftBank's stock price and repay retail investors who've held onto the company's shares from before the dot-com boom and bust, people close to the SoftBank chief have said. Many investors have waited for decades for the stock to regain dot-com bubble levels — something it's flirted with only a few times since 2020. If Son's primary motivation is to clear the way for AI, it may be more cost-efficient to encourage partnerships that link manufacturing expertise with that of AI engineers and specialists in fields from medicine to robotics, and incubating smaller companies, according to Melissa Otto, head of research at Visible Alpha. But pouring cash into data centers may help lower the cost of developing AI applications and spur broader adoption, she said. 'He's a long-term thinker, and he takes risks,' Otto said. 'It's just too early to tell.' --With assistance from Debby Wu, Catherine Lucey, Yoolim Lee and Mayumi Negishi. (Updates with share price reaction in the fourth paragraph.) Ken Griffin on Trump, Harvard and Why Novice Investors Won't Beat the Pros Is Mark Cuban the Loudmouth Billionaire that Democrats Need for 2028? The US Has More Copper Than China But No Way to Refine All of It Can 'MAMUWT' Be to Musk What 'TACO' Is to Trump? How a Tiny Middleman Could Access Two-Factor Login Codes From Tech Giants ©2025 Bloomberg L.P. Sign in to access your portfolio
New York Times
39 minutes ago
- New York Times
Iran's Foreign Minister to Meet With European Counterparts Amid War Fears
Iran's foreign minister, Abbas Araghchi, was scheduled to meet with top diplomats from Britain, France and Germany on Friday in Geneva, in a last-ditch effort to avert a dangerous escalation in the weeklong conflict between Israel and Iran. With President Trump setting a new deadline of two weeks before he decides whether to join Israel's aerial campaign against military and nuclear sites in Iran, the European diplomats will deliver an urgent message to Mr. Araghchi that his government must make significant concessions in its nuclear program. Expectations for the meeting were restrained, given the wide gaps between Iran and the United States in their now-suspended negotiations. Yet Mr. Trump's reprieve, after a week in which he seemed to be marching inexorably toward war, buoyed hopes somewhat, suggesting that there was still time to act. 'Based on the fact that there's a substantial chance of negotiations that may or may not take place with Iran in the near future,' the president said in a statement on Thursday, 'I will make my decision whether or not to go within the next two weeks.' Mr. Trump denied reports that he had already authorized an attack on Iran but withheld final approval to see if Iran's leaders acceded to his demand that they abandon the country's nuclear program. Among the issues on the table in Geneva, officials from several countries said, are giving outside inspectors unfettered access to Iran's nuclear facilities, as well as cutting its stockpile of ballistic missiles, which it has fired against Israel in retaliation for Israeli strikes on military bases and nuclear installations. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
