Kristin Cavallari left stunned as her first boyfriend makes crass jibe about their sex life during their reunion

Kristin Cavallari has explained how her public reunion with her first love went sour.
One of the 38-year-old former MTV star's most famous romances was with her high school sweetheart, Stephen Colletti, but she was previously involved with a middle school boyfriend named Johnny.
Kristin explained on the latest episode of E!'s Honestly Cavallari: The Headline Tour, 'I'm going to be pulling up Johnny, my very first boyfriend from Chicago. I've talked about him a couple times on the podcast. We were as in love as you could be at the tender age of 13 and 14.'
While she had fond memories of their relationship, her childhood ex had a different perspective as he reduced their bond to sex.
Cavallari told the live audience, 'I would wake up in the morning and I would have poems on my window.'
But Johnny rebutted: 'You'd wake up next to me. That's the podcast version. To be clear, you would actually greet me in outfits just like [the one you're wearing now]. I saw you come out in this and it's hard.'
On Wednesday's episode she shared that Johnny was 'nervous' about appearing as a guest in front of a live audience, so she provided him with the questions she planned to ask him as a courtesy.
'For people who don't do this, it's f**king nerve-wracking,' the mom-of-three said. 'So, I even appreciate him getting up.'
And the blonde bombshell explained how she came up with the idea to feature her former beau on the tour.
'Johnny was actually coming to the Chicago show anyway,' she noted in a confessional in the episode. 'I was like, "Wait a minute, this could be really fun." We all know how it is to get over your first love — it's very difficult. And I do wonder if I've sort of, like, changed the narrative in my mind all these years. To have his perspective is gonna be awesome.'
Worse than downplaying the depth of their relationship, Johnny went on to accuse the star of hooking up with his friend.
'Before you left, you were sampling Barrington, [Illinois],' he added. 'You broke my heart, actually, because you hooked up with my best friend [Tommy].'
The former Laguna Beach cast member clapped back, 'I don't even remember Tommy. I hooked up with Tommy?!'
She went on to express her disappointment in a post-show interview, 'Johnny is a massive letdown. It honestly breaks my heart because for all of these years I have held my relationship with Johnny in this high regard. And then he got up on stage and he was a completely different person.'
Cavallari emphasized, 'He was the only person I gave the questions to beforehand because obviously he doesn't do this stuff.
'He knew exactly what I was going to say, so, to me, it just feels premeditated, like he wanted to come out there and tear me down. These memories that I've had with Johnny all of these years are now just completely ruined.'
Kristin continued to reel over the shocking, blindsided interaction the following day.
'You wanna trash me in front of my f**king audience?' she vented to best friend Justin Anderson. 'It's f**ked up! It's really f**ked up. I hate Johnny.'
Even more confusing, she said that Johnny followed up the tour appearance with a gushing text.
'You were amazing last night,' she read aloud. 'Thanks for such a fun escape from reality, definitely needed that. You're gonna absolutely crush the rest of your tour. No doubt about it.'
Another former flame, Talan Torriero, joined her on tour, along with other Laguna Beach classmates.
Unfortunately, she had a similar experience with Torriero.
The experiences prompted her to take a hard look at the patterns in the men she chooses romantically.
'I actually don't even care about looking like an idiot in front of the audience,' she confessed to Justin.
'This is a much bigger thing for me. It's the theme of my whole life. With Talan, it's like, "Okay, it's expected." Then Johnny, it was like, "Oh my god!" Like, no guy has ever taken accountability in my life, ever.'
Kristin was married to Jay Cutler from 2013 until their split in 2020. The divorce was finalized in June 2022.
They share sons Camden, 12, Jaxon, 11, and daughter Saylor, nine.
The Uncommon James founder has also been open about recently cutting ties with her 'narcissistic ' father.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

Justin Bieber's wife Hailey flies solo in NYC after ditching wedding ring amid fears for their marriage

shocked her fans on Friday when she was spotted out in New York City with a bare ring finger. But the 28-year-old wife of Justin Bieber gave mixed messages on Saturday when she was spotted again sporting her enormous diamond ring. The reversal comes after a reported blow-out fight between the couple on the previous Sunday — Father's Day — when Hailey allegedly called her husband a 'f***ing child.' After stirring up more fears for their marriage with her ring-free look in photos obtained by TMZ, Hailey instead showcased her summer style when her ring reappeared on her Saturday outing in the Big Apple. The brunette beauty — who recently unfollowed her perceived nemesis Selena Gomez on social media — looked fresh as a daisy while stepping out in the SoHo area. The Rhode Skin founder flaunted her long, toned limbs in a tight-fitting black sleeveless T-shirt and white-and-black polka dot leggings. She completed the look with black mule sandals and a black bag, accessorizing with only a pair of dark sunglasses, a gold watch and her large diamond wedding ring. The runway veteran's brunette hair was styled straight, and she wore natural-looking makeup. Despite her pristine appearance, fans have been concerned for the couple after Justin's Father's Day reportedly ended in a bitter showdown after he spent the day posting bizarre messages on Instagram. The singer, 31, failed to share any tribute to his wife or their nine-month-old son Jack Blues Bieber on the day, aside from seemingly referring to Hailey as a 'lil ho.' Instead he shared a barrage of bizarre pictures and messages on his social media, including private messages in which he admitted to being 'traumatized' before cutting out a friend for struggling to accept his 'anger.' According to an insider who spoke to The Sun, Hailey was 'beyond furious' and branded her husband a 'f***ing child' as she begged him to seek professional help rather than sharing rambling messages online. Justin also shared a personal statement referring to himself as 'broken' and spoke about how he struggles with anger, healing and self-worth. In one of the posts he showed off two Prada backpacks, a MacBook and a gold and diamond–covered Audemars Piguet watch, which may have been gifts from Hailey. Justin referenced Father's Day and wrote in one post, 'Happy daddies day to me u lil ho.' In response, Hailey took a savage swipe at her husband following his brutal remark towards her on Mother's Day in which he declared 'Mother's Day sucks a**.' Returning the remark, Hailey wrote: 'Father's Day sucks a**.' Back in May, the Peaches singer had a concerning outburst on Mother's Day when Hailey was celebrating the holiday as a mom for the first time. An insider told the Sun that this latest outburst, which comes months after Justin was pictured at a strip club, has rocked the couple. A source told the publication: 'The post really set her off — she told him it was one of the dumbest things he's ever done like 'feeding raw meat to a pack of lions who want to eat you alive.' The mother of one is apparently desperate for him to go to therapy for his issues, with the insider saying: 'She's been telling him for a while to get help — see a therapist, talk to someone who can help him manage his anger and mood swings. Hailey didn't want him to post that message' They added: 'She's fed up with his childish behaviour and the constant negativity he brings onto himself. She told him to stop being a 'f***ing child' and to finally start listening to the people who care about him.' During the day, Justin shared around 20 posts with the middle finger emoji as the caption, including several with his son. 'I'm a dad that's not to be f***ed with,' he wrote with a weary-eyed selfie on Sunday. He did share several selfies of himself seemingly celebrating the day as he shared a snap of him posing with a hibachi chef and a photo of Hailey sitting at a grand piano with Jack in his lap. Regardless of not posting a tribute, it appeared Hailey spent the day with the new dad as she reposted one of his snapshots of her and their son together but did not make any mention of Justin and did not wish him a happy Father's Day on social media. The conflict comes after a prominent LA-based divorce attorney exclusively shared with that Justin could end up with half of Hailey Bieber's payout for her billion-dollar cosmetics empire if they should divorce. However, she is not likely to gain much from the massive sale of his song catalog. Hailey has lately has been celebrating the third successful year of her beauty company. She and her co-founders recently sold the company to e.l.f. Beauty for $1 billion, although she remains the face of the company, and will serve as Chief Creative Officer and Head of Innovation. The singer posted this on Saturday. 'Why you so angry?' a fan asked. 'Go play with your child. You're a father now. Grow up, Justin.' Another suggested 'THERAPY!!!!!' Just one day after the announcement, Selena Gomez's cosmetics company Rare Beauty posted two snaps of its founder and simply captioned them with, 'Still here.' One of the images showed the Bad Liar songstress blowing a kiss towards the camera, while another featured her staring into the lens with a sultry look on her face. Many fans became convinced that Selena was subtly poking fun at Hailey's sale with the post, and they were not amused. Hailey's supporters quickly flooded the replies of the post with angry messages. 'It seems like Hailey is always on her mind. Pathetic,' one outraged user wrote. 'The way she's actually shady as hell,' added another. As a result, the two have now unfollowed each other on social media after trying to put an end to their alleged feud, created after Bieber married Gomez's ex-boyfriend, Justin Bieber, in 2018. The couple are now the parents of a nearly one-year-old son, Jack. Justin Bieber's recent series of cryptic and often angry online posts have caused some concern among his fans and lead to speculation that his nearly seven-year marriage is being strained. After posting a photo of himself next to four angry emojis on Saturday, followers once again reached out to the troubled singer. 'WE GOT YO BACK BROTHER,' wrote one fan. However, others seemed to be encouraging the Grammy winner to get a grip on himself. 'Why you so angry? Go play with your child. You're a father now. Grow up, Justin,' advised one fan. 'Explain why you feel sorry for a millionaire who created the world he is in? Grow up, get off drugs take control of your life you have a kid to raise. It's not about you anymore….,' wrote another. 'Anger is always the sister of deep sadness »… Hope you'll find a way to free yourself from it,' admonished a fan, while another suggested he go to 'THERAPY!!!!!'

Daily Mail​

an hour ago

• Daily Mail​

Stunning gymnast Suni Lee gives two-word response to taunt about OG Anunoby dating rumors

Gymnast Suni Lee gave a hysterical response on Saturday to a heckle referencing the rumors of a relationship between her and Knicks star OG Anunoby. The lighthearted suggestions of a romance between the pair began back in April, when Lee was spotted sitting courtside for a Knicks-Suns game in which Anunoby ultimately scored 32 points. Actress Anne Hathaway was also present at that game. From there, some Knicks fans became convinced that Lee (who attended several playoff games too) was something of a good luck charm for Anuboby, with his teammate Josh Hart even saying on his 'Roommates Show' podcast that the Knicks 'need' Lee and Hathaway at every playoff matchup. Lee was talking about her Knicks fandom this weekend at Fanatics Fest when a fan interrupted her by shouting out Anunoby's name. 'OG!', he yelled. Lee looked a bit stunned as she laughed the comment off, before telling the fan that the comment was 'out of pocket.' Fan: 'OG!' Suni Lee: 'Outta pocket.' 💀 (via @FiresideKnicks, @FanaticsFest) — Legion Hoops (@LegionHoops) June 21, 2025 And some fans were on the gold medalist's side as they reacted to the remark. 'She was so embarrassed,' one wrote on X. 'Why they gotta do that,' a second said. And a third joked: 'OG finna hit her up after this.' Lee and Anunoby posed for some pictures after the Knicks beat the Magic on December 3, though the fellow athletes have not actually been spotted outside of Madison Square Garden together. Nonetheless, Lee became a Knicks fan favorite as they had their best postseason run in 25 years and went to the Eastern Conference Finals. Unfortunately, the Knicks lost to the Pistons in the first round on April 21 when Lee was seen sitting on Celebrity Row. Anunoby had a modest 10 points and shot 0-4 from three in that game. The Knicks also lost with Lee in attendance in Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals vs. the Pacers, as Indiana pulled off a stunning comeback to win 138-135 in overtime. Anunoby performed better in that game, as he scored 16 points in the loss. While London-born Anunoby had an impressive year for the Knicks, Lee captured her second Olympic gold medal for Team USA last summer. After previously winning an all-around gold at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics, she claimed another in the team event in Paris

The Sun

2 hours ago

• The Sun

Weekly horoscope for June 22 – June 28: What the stars have in store for every zodiac sign revealed

OUR much-loved astrologer Meg sadly died in 2023 but her column will be kept alive by her friend and protégée Maggie Innes. Read on to see what's written in the stars for you today. ARIES MAR 21 - APR 20 12 With Mercury sharpening your creative thinking, you possess the ability to review numerous ideas and instantly identify the best one for you. While barriers may still emerge, they will now seem temporary and beatable. In love, it's tempting to keep planning a grand reveal, but your chart is ready for you to simply go for it. A family new moon favors fresh ways of bonding with someone whose name begins with "D." TAURUS APR 21 - MAY 21 12 Sticking to your convictions on a family issue may not be easy, but you can achieve it by consistently returning to the "why" rather than fretting over the "how." While you generally dislike conflict, healthy debate can be very healing for you this week. In terms of passion, the new moon helps loosen any shyness, allowing partners to relate on a new level of absolute honesty. If you're single, "The One" might get your name wrong at first. GEMINI MAY 22 - JUNE 21 12 Your chart grants you the energy to restart a cash calculation; play your part by applying your firmest focus and keeping negative voices out of your head. This is a week of communication ease, thanks to Mercury, as even words you assumed were lost in translation could begin to yield rewards. So, do be patient a little longer. Passion brings back a fantasy face. CANCER JUNE 22 - JULY 22 12 With Mars now established in your connections sector, you have the courage to contact anyone, even when unsure of the response. So, use this while it's hot. If you're in love, a personal new moon is your "try-anything" trump card—ask again, and a partner may have changed their mind. If you're single, no one is out of your league; remember that around someone whose name begins with "K." LEO JULY 23 - AUG 23 12 The logic and mental sparkle of Mercury are all yours for the next few weeks, so how will you use it? From writing effective reports to putting difficult feelings into words, you can persuade and promote in your own unique way. Your words could even feature on a stage or screen. A secret that is starting to bother you needs some attention; the new moon can help. VIRGO AUG 24 - SEPT 22 12 Your focus is on the friendship world, and who may need more from you at this time. This could be the least likely person to ask, yet your moon instinct is strong, so do listen to it. If you're in a relationship, Venus keeps a door open while you decide, but this may not be forever. If you're single, your dream date has so many travel stories to tell. Luck circles someone whose name begins with "F." LIBRA SEPT 23 - OCT 23 12 Choosing the right goal at the right time is your big decision this week, and the light of the new moon is your best guide. Even if an ambition isn't the biggest or most impressive, if it feels right, it is right. But you must promise yourself not to keep looking back—only forward. Love that asks more questions than it answers can be a challenge, but an irresistible one. SCORPIO OCT 24 - NOV 22 New destinations and a fresh sense of pushing boundaries make your chart dance this week—there's nothing you can't take on when you set your heart on it. But beware of using this strength to slip over some love-lines, perhaps linked to someone not completely free. A better option can be right there when you truly look. Mercury boosts quick-reaction time for prizes. SAGITTARIUS NOV 23 - DEC 21 12 As your learning ability increases almost overnight, this can be your moment to get back to a study or practical experience course. Previous blocks can be gone, and the road to your future feels wide open. You've also taken lessons on board in love, and even against the odds, you should be safe from repeating a recent mistake. So, do trust your heart again, totally. CAPRICORN DEC 22 - JAN 20 12 So many aspects of yourself may have puzzled you lately, but now Mercury brings some understanding, plus the ability to push forward again. You can deal with doubts and cope with uncertainty, setting a new standard for everyone else in your life. A moon of reconciliation gets two sides talking again, and a team can be back together. Love is lighter, with a two-way sense of fun. AQUARIUS JAN 21 - FEB 18 12 Sticking to a health track, even when it no longer feels like a great fit, is not the Aquarius answer. This week, you can read or hear about something that could be so much better, and you will recognize it straight away. If you're in love, Mercury adds forward-planning to Venus's security, and some big plans can be made. If you're single, a dull date can hide such a hot prospect. PISCES FEB 19 - MAR 20 12 With the heat of the sun and the insight of the new moon both lighting up your creative chart, ideas flow thick and fast, and at least one can be well underway by the weekend. The key is starting strong, even when the plan isn't quite perfect, as you have the initiative to alter it along the way. Passion links to voices, and the way you simply can't ignore one special one.