Workers' rights: Union members tend to become spectators while leaders take decisions
Employment equity – currently a bone of contention between the right and left of SA's political spectrum – 'has had a major effect'.
Cosatu members on their way to Johannesburg Stck Exchange in Sandton in Johannesburg, 7 October 2024, to hand memorandum as part of its National Day of Action against the economic crisis' in the country. COSATU allies, the South African Clothing and Textile Workers Union (Sactwu) and the South African Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers Union (Saccawu) participated in the strike. Picture: Nigel Sibanda/ The Citizen
As thousands of workers yesterday marked May Day, a labour expert says the Labour Relations Act (LRA) has affected working conditions.
This has been strengthened by labour federations Cosatu and Saftu being united in opposition to the value-added tax (VAT) hike and amendments to labour laws.
Prof Lucien van der Walt, of Rhodes University's economics and governance department, lauded the LRA as the first legislation in the country's history to provide all workers 'access to a formal industrial relations machinery.'
ALSO READ: Celebrating Workers' Day with no work? Unemployment forum boycotts the day
This, said Van der Walt, included protected strikes and other measures from which unions benefited.
'Until the late 1970s, such legislation excluded black African workers, who were confined to a separate, labour-repressive system,' he said.
'The changes in the 1980s facilitated massive union growth, with Cosatu membership growing from 450 000 in 1985 to well over two million in the 2000s.'
'Downsize'
However, Van der Walt said the downside of the LRA was that 'it – like its predecessor, the Industrial Conciliation Act – is based around time-consuming and bureaucratic processes'.
'For workers to have a protected strike, other avenues provided to resolve the issues must be exhausted,' he said.
ALSO READ: Govt increases minimum wage – here's how much domestic workers should earn from 1 March
'Unions get entangled in lengthy and complicated procedures. This affects how unions work, with members left out.
'Rather than driving and controlling, members tend to become spectators, with organisers and leaders focusing on the legal system, rather than on worker mobilisation and education.
'Organisers and leaders also get more power through their know-how and often make decisions without direction from members.
ALSO READ: Numsa demands wage increase, night shift allowance for motor industry workers
'So, over time, the LRA has fostered a much more top-down, passive approach to trade unionism,' he added.
Employment equity
Employment equity (EE) – currently a bone of contention between the right and left of SA's political spectrum – 'has had a major effect'.
'The SA workforce was historically highly shaped by race and sex. Essentially, white workers dominated many skilled and better-paying jobs, including government,' said Van der Walt.
'Women of all races were locked out of many occupations.
'EE measures have shifted this situation, most notably in government, which is by far the biggest single employer.
ALSO READ: Municipal workers place duty above pay as overtime cap hurts residents
'There have also been changes in the private sector. There has been enormous pressure to have what has been deemed a more representative workforce. 'But EE has had little effect on people living with disabilities.'
Van der Walt said EE limitations included:
Measures expressed in law and policy, not intended to act as a simple quota system reserving jobs by race or sex; and
Fostering racial tensions among workers through conflicts over jobs and promotions.
'The reality that EE is simply unable to address broader problems of widespread low-wage work, job insecurity and unemployment,' he said.
'Conflicts over EE would be less serious if there were more jobs and better jobs. There would be less competition for a small number of skilled, well-paid jobs and less stress for people who lost jobs.
'But EE, by its nature, is focused on the redistribution of fairly small numbers of well-paid and skilled jobs.'
'Anti-worker labour laws'
In his May Day message, Saftu secretary-general Zwelinzima Vavi said workers across the labour movement were 'united in opposition to the VAT increase and anti-worker labour laws'.
'Comrades, we meet at a moment of profound danger, with the working class under siege. Brutal austerity is ripping apart our communities. Corporate profiteering is driving hunger and homelessness,' said Vavi.
'The bosses and their government are not stopping at VAT. They are unleashing a direct assault on worker rights through vicious labour law amendments and a draft code of good practice on dismissal.
'These are not technical changes, but are rather a blatant declaration of war on the working class. Saftu calls for mass resistance against these betrayals,' he added.
Cosatu said it remained opposed to proposed amendments to labour law, which followed extensive engagements between labour and business at the National Economic Development and Labour Council, with similar public hearings held in parliament.
According to Cosatu national spokesperson, Matthew Parks, changes to the law included 'adapting employment equity targets to take into account regional demographic diversity and to adopt more focused targets for sectors falling woefully behind employment equity'.
NOW READ: Massive Transnet strike could bring logistics sector to its knees
– brians@citizen.co.za
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
15 hours ago
- IOL News
Civil society calls for decent jobs for the marginalised working class at G20 build-up event
Tanya van Meelis who serves as the Head of the Policy Unit and Labour Market Policy Coordinator at Cosatu, addressed delegates to the C20 South Africa launch at The Capital on the Park in Sandton on Sunday. South Africa's controversial National Dialogue must not be dominated by conservative and divisive voices. These are the words of Levy Singh, Youth 20 (Y20) South Africa Sherpa during his address at the first day of the three-day C20 South Africa launch held at The Capital on the Park in Sandton on Sunday. When South Africa hosts the G20 summit later this year, it will be the first time the gathering takes place on African soil. The country recently officially assumed leadership of the Y20 — the G20's dedicated platform for youth engagement — at a high-profile event recently held at the historic Rand Club in Johannesburg. "As civil society, we have to be bold and defend our core quality principles. As the Y20 We are committed to working with all the working groups. We also need to continue to deepen our unity and aligning over the next 23 weeks. South Africa will be handing over the G20 Summit to the US, and there is no certainty that our working groups will be sustained beyond this year under Donald Trump's regime. However, we must continue to be robust and rigorous and put forward our progress agenda."
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Clarity sought on alleged R700m cost of National Dialogue
The Presidency's plan to hold a major National Dialogue in August is being criticised for its potential cost, lack of oversight, and uncertain agenda. The proposed National Dialogue has the potential to be another watershed moment for South Africa, as the Convention for a Democratic SA was in the early '90s. Picture: Gallo Images/Die Burger There are concerns about the lack of transparency around President Cyril Ramaphosa's proposed National Dialogue that is meant to take place in a few weeks. Ramaphosa said the country will hold the first leg on 15 August, with the second leg expected to take place next year. Local talks will be held before then. The purpose of this convention is to discuss South Africa's problems and find solutions to them. However, it has been met with anger following an announcement that it could cost more than R700 million. Unions and political parties call for accountability The government has stated that there is no definite figure yet. Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) spokesperson Matthew Parks said he is concerned about the abuse of state funds used for the National Dialogue. 'We can talk about figures like R10 million or R20 million, but R700 million is just ridiculous. 'Government can find ways of ensuring this is done in a manner that is more affordable. We just objected to a VAT hike, it would not make sense for us to agree to this,' he said. Conflicting statements over the proposed budget Parks said Cosatu had engaged with the Presidency and was reassured there is no final figure for how much the dialogue will cost. The amount of R700 million was first estimated by Nkosinathi Biko, executive trustee of the Steve Biko Foundation. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa announces 'Eminent Persons Group' to guide national dialogue – These are the people appointed 'Nothing has been tabled to parliament and Cabinet, so this is random ramblings from some officials and people from foundations,' said Parks. Questions about coordination and purpose Rise Mzansi spokesperson Mabine Seabe said: 'The touted R700 million price tag appears excessive, which is why Rise Mzansi will be engaging with President Cyril Ramaphosa on this matter and timelines both in the buildup to and after the National Dialogue. 'We will use our parliamentary oversight authority to ensure that every rand and cent is accounted for.' ActionSA parliamentary leader Athol Trollip said parliamentarians have not been given intricate details of how the National Dialogue will be coordinated. Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya told SAfm this week: 'There isn't a budget, there isn't a number or a cost that the government has committed to. 'All we have is what has been communicated as a proposal that the foundations have put forward. 'Government is going to be the fiscal custodian of the process and it has not yet engaged in formulating a budget. So the debate about R700 million is completely misplaced and unnecessary.' Dialogue 'must be ambitious' Dr Philani Mthembu from the Institute for Global Dialogue said the dialogue, if done correctly, can be an important tool in addressing problematic legislation and policies. ALSO READ: 'Bring all to dialogue': Experts insist national dialogue must be people-driven 'If this dialogue is compared to the Convention for a Democratic South Africa, then it needs to be ambitious in what it is trying to achieve. 'For instance, we must ask if this will open up the debate on reviewing the constitution, what elements of the constitution are working and which need to be revised. 'This dialogue could discuss issues such as electoral reform and whether we are ready for new systems that will hold those in power to account. 'It has to be ambitious, otherwise if we just discuss issues such as national cohesion and service delivery, we already know these challenges. Discussing the deep issues will have more impact.' A noble idea? Advocate Sipho Mantula, a researcher at Thabo Mbeki African School of Public & International Affairs, said the idea of a national convention is a noble one. 'Conventions are normally called when there is a national crisis or key issues that affect the country, from governance to the rule of law to the socio-cultural and economic conditions.' Mantula said all state organs and institutions should assist in ensuring the success of the National Dialogue and no-one should be left behind. 'It should begin with local conventions and then provincial conventions that ultimately lead to the National Dialogue,' he said. NOW READ: 'A meaningless publicity stunt by a limping president': EFF slams Ramaphosa's national dialogue call
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Bellville business owner fined R96,000 for failing to submit tax returns
The Bellville Magistrate's Court has fined a business owner R96 000 for failing to submit various tax returns over several years. "Mayet was the sole member of A and Y Wholesale Retail Enterprise CC, which traded as a wholesale retail enterprise trading under the name and style of Plastipak. The Bellville Magistrate's Court has fined a businessman for failure to submit income tax returns, Value Added Tax (VAT) returns, and Pay as You Earn (PAYE) returns. "The company was registered for Income Tax, VAT, PAYE (EMP 201) and PAYE (EMP 501). "Mayet was the representative VAT vendor, representative employer, and the public officer of the company at the time of the commission of the offences. "He failed to submit Income Tax, VAT, PAYE (EMP 201) and PAYE (EMP 501) returns when they were due. "The offences were committed over several years: VAT returns for a year, PAYE (EMP 201) for two years and PAYE (EMP 501) for five years," Ntabazalila said. "The returns remained outstanding until they were submitted on May 27, 2024. "The accused and his company were convicted on an Income Tax return on behalf of A and Y Wholesale Retail Enterprise CC, two counts of failure to submit VAT returns, five counts of failure to submit PAYE (EMP 201) returns and eight counts of failure to submit PAYE (EMP 501) returns."
