"Rule Of Law Mandates...": Top Court On Kamal Haasan's Film's Karnataka Release

New Delhi:
Kamal Haasan 's new film, ' Thug Life ', has a censor board certificate and must be released in Karnataka, notwithstanding controversy over the actor-politician's comment about the Kannada language being "born out of Tamil", the Supreme Court said Tuesday afternoon.
The court also asked tough questions of the Karnataka government for failing to ensure the film's release - in the face of threats against its screening and a warning by the Karnataka Film Chamber of Commerce to 'ban' its release - and directed the state to file a reply in 24 hours.
"The rule of law mandates that a person must be able to release his film... a film with a CBFC (Censor Board of Film Certification) must be released," an irked Supreme Court said.
The film released worldwide on June 5 but has not been screened in Karnataka so far. Pro-Kannada groups claimed offence over the actor's comment at a pre-launch event in Chennai.
Kannada groups and activists had demanded an apology from the actor, but he refused to make one, saying his comments were misunderstood and that he deeply respects the language.
The court also noted the Karnataka High Court should not have called on Kamal Haasan to apologise for his remark. On June 3 the High Court served up a culinary-themed warning, telling the actor "... you cannot unscramble a scrambled egg" and urging him to make an apology.
The actor, however, refused to do so, as he has since the controversy broke.
The hearing in the High Court were over a plea by the actor to ensure his film's release is not blocked in any way; this was after warnings by pro-Kannada groups against screening the film.
The High Court, however, declined to offer any relief, declaring again he needed to apologise, "In this case you made a statement. Withdraw that statement... that is all. Crores can be earned from Karnataka... but if you don't need the people (of Kannada) then leave the revenue..."
That point was flagged today by the Supreme Court, which transferred the case from the High Court to itself, and pointed out, "... we can't let mob and vigilant groups take over the state..."
In the last Supreme Court hearing on this matter, advocate A Velan, appearing on behalf of the petitioner, i.e., Kamal Haasan, had accused the Karnataka government of bowing to pressure from "anti-social elements". The court's response to this was sharp and clear; Justice Ujjal Bhuyan said, "We can't let mob and vigilant groups take over the state... we cannot allow this."

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

New Indian Express

13 minutes ago

• New Indian Express

Vibin S Santosh's Omen uses the found footage format

Omen, as a title, stirs a sense of eerie intrigue, and that's no coincidence. This upcoming film yet again explores the horror genre with a bold choice: the found footage format, a style that is slowly picking up in Kannada cinema. Helmed by Vibin S Santosh, who has written, directed, and edited the film, Omen centres around a haunted house where a paranormal investigation takes a terrifying turn. The story unfolds as if the audience is sifting through raw, real recordings, intensifying the fear and suspense.

Time of India

19 minutes ago

• Time of India

Dhanush's heartfelt speech at the 'Kuberaa' event, praises 'Tourist Family' and celebrates human connections

Directed by , the film 'Kuberaa' starring , , Nagarjuna, and others was released on June 20 in both Tamil and Telugu languages. The film, which has been well received by the public since its release, was recently celebrated at a success ceremony held in Hyderabad. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Speaking at the ceremony, Dhanush expressed his gratitude to God and the fans for the success of the film. Dhanush celebrates human connections in cinema Speaking at the event, Dhanush said that in an environment where the very existence of a film in theaters has become a question mark, it is a false belief that action films featuring blood, knives, and helicopters will attract people. He emphasized that 'Kuberaa' has proven that even a film with human emotions can bring people to the theater. Dhanush said, 'There is nothing greater than human emotions,' and added that the experience provided by this film will be an inspiration to the new generation of directors. 'Kuberaa' actor urges future creators to focus on storytelling Dhanush also recalled the recent Tamil film 'Tourist Family', saying that the film, which spoke to the feelings of ordinary people, was also well received and attracted audiences to the theaters. Dhanush emphasized his point, saying, "We should not think that big budgets, superheroes, and graphics are the only things that will attract people from now on." Dhanush's tribute to family, producer, and the magic of movies As Dhanush concluded his speech, he recalled his parents' words. "My mother used to say that when you win, you should talk less. My father used to say that you should count your blessings. An actor can only feel true success when he sees the smile on his producer's face," said Dhanush, adding that he felt true success when he saw the happiness of the producer of 'Kuberaa'. His words had a huge impact on the fans, and they say that 'Kubera' will be remembered not only as a good film, but also as a film that shared good feelings.

Hindustan Times

22 minutes ago

• Hindustan Times

'We know where to tighten the nuts and bolts': Kiccha Sudeep calls out DK Shivakumar's remark

A quiet war of words is brewing between the Kannada film industry and the state's political leadership after actor Kiccha Sudeep publicly criticised Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar's comments on Sandalwood. Kiccha Sudeep urged the Congress leader to be more mindful of his remarks.(HT FILE) According to a report by Times of India, the actor urged the Congress leader to be more mindful of his remarks, stating that only those within the industry truly understand its inner workings. (Also Read: Bangalore University to offer life and health insurance to all students from 2025-26: Report) Speaking during a recent television programme, Sudeep said, 'I have great respect for DK Shivakumar. Cinema is a respectful and dignified space. But he should be careful with what he says.' His comments appear to be in response to Shivakumar's speech at the Bengaluru International Film Festival (BIFFES) in March, where the Deputy CM had expressed displeasure over the sparse participation of film stars, the report added. What DK Shivakumar said At that event, Shivakumar had also referred to the low turnout of Sandalwood celebrities at the Congress-led Mekedatu padayatra in 2022, making a pointed remark, 'Consider this a request or a warning. If the government does not cooperate, no film or shooting will happen. We know where to tighten the nuts and bolts and for whom.' On Saturday, when asked about Sudeep's remarks, Shivakumar declined to respond directly. 'I don't have to answer anybody,' he said. 'If you want to understand what I've done for the industry, go look at the history preserved in the film chamber. Time will answer.' Meanwhile, BJP leader and opposition MLA R Ashoka stepped in to back the actor, saying, 'We must speak only on matters we understand. If you comment on others, expect people to comment on you.' (Also Read: iPhones, EMIs and burnout: Bengaluru techie's brutally honest post on 'middle-class' lifestyle goes viral)