Why Most Retail Launches Fail: And What Successful Suppliers Do Differently
Breaking into retail is exciting. It feels like validation, momentum, and scale all at once.
But that moment of 'we got in' is where most companies start to unravel. Because landing shelf space is not the same thing as staying on the shelf. And if your backend isn't ready, it doesn't matter how good your product is. Retailers will drop you the moment you miss a shipment, botch a barcode, or get flagged in their compliance system.
In this article, we're unpacking why most retail launches fail—not because of bad products, but because of poor preparation. And more importantly, what the successful ones do differently.
Let's start with the biggest mistake of all.
Getting a meeting with a major retailer is hard. Getting a yes is even harder. But here's what trips most suppliers up: they treat the pitch as the goal, not the starting point.
The moment you're accepted by a big-box retailer, everything changes. You're no longer just a product brand. You're a logistics company, a compliance company, and an operations company—whether you like it or not.
That means: You need a warehouse (or 3PL) that can ship at scale, on schedule, and label everything correctly.
You need EDI integration up and running—not 'in progress.'
You need to know your modular set windows, your OTIF (on time in full) targets, and what happens if you miss them.
Most brands don't figure this out until the first test order comes in. And by then, they're already behind.
If you're aiming specifically for Walmart, this transition is even more extreme. Their backend systems are complex, and the compliance bar is unforgiving. There's a step-by-step guide on how to get your product into Walmart that breaks down what actually happens after the pitch—it's worth reading before your first PO.
Compliance sounds like a boring formality—until it starts draining your margins or getting your products delisted.
Here's what that actually looks like in practice: Incorrect barcodes that don't scan at checkout.
that don't scan at checkout. Label placement that's off by half an inch, triggering chargebacks.
that's off by half an inch, triggering chargebacks. Case dimensions that throw off pallet configurations.
that throw off pallet configurations. Missing ASNs (Advance Ship Notices) that make your shipment invisible to the system.
None of these are dramatic failures. They're minor oversights. But in retail, minor oversights are what get you flagged.
Retailers track everything. And they score you on it. If you consistently miss small requirements, your performance score drops—and you're replaced by the next supplier in line.
Retail compliance isn't optional. It's the invisible gatekeeper that decides whether you get a second order.
It's not uncommon to see beautiful packaging, slick DTC campaigns, and strong social traction—but behind the scenes, the operation is duct-taped together with spreadsheets and late-night panic.
The problem? Retail doesn't care about your branding once the PO hits. It cares whether you can deliver on time, in full, and without friction.
Here's what that disconnect looks like: A company spends $15,000 on a brand video, but hasn't tested barcode placement.
The founder knows their CAC inside out, but can't answer how many units they can ship in 14 days.
The team builds an influencer campaign, but ignores EDI setup until two days before the first shipment is due.
Retail performance isn't about potential. It's about execution. The companies that succeed aren't always the most inspiring—they're just the ones who are prepared when the clock starts ticking.
Systems beat stories when the shipment is due.
The first order you get from a retailer isn't an invitation. It's an evaluation.
Trial orders—regional rollouts, limited store placements, or seasonal tests—are how buyers verify that you're not just a good pitch, but a reliable supplier. Most companies celebrate that first PO like a victory, but that's premature. The buyer is watching.
What they're looking for isn't complicated: Was the shipment routed correctly?
Did everything arrive exactly on time?
Were labels, pallets, and cartons 100 percent compliant?
Did the store staff report any receiving issues?
Are your replenishment cycles working?
And on the backend, retail systems are scoring you: OTIF metrics
Fill rates
Barcode scan success
Chargeback rate
Inventory availability
You're on probation. You don't get a second order just because the first one arrived. You get it because it arrived the right way, and the data backed it up.
Retailers don't chase you with reminders. They expect you to be watching the numbers.
Once your product is in stores, your job isn't over. It's just changed. You're no longer pitching or prepping—you're monitoring performance. And if you don't, someone else will, and they'll be ready to take your spot.
Here's what gets missed: Inventory stalls in 120 stores , but no one flags it in time.
, but no one flags it in time. A DC runs low , but the supplier doesn't replenish.
, but the supplier doesn't replenish. OTIF scores dip , and no one investigates why until the next PO is quietly pulled.
, and no one investigates why until the next PO is quietly pulled. Chargebacks are deducted, but go unnoticed for months because there's no system to reconcile them.
Most retailers offer portals like Retail Link (in Walmart's case), which show near real-time data. But these tools aren't easy to use, and most new vendors either underuse them or ignore them altogether.
The companies that last are the ones that don't wait for problems to show up in an email. They build dashboards, set alerts, and treat the backend like a control room. Data becomes not just an asset, but an early warning system.
Here's how the story often goes: a product enters retail, it gets some early traction, but then things slow down. Sales flatten, chargebacks rise, the buyer goes silent—and the supplier assumes the product just didn't click with customers.
But more often than not, the problem wasn't demand. It was operations.
Bad replenishment timing. Inventory blackouts. Compliance flags. Delays in response when something went wrong. These aren't things that show up on the shelf. They show up in buyer meetings—and in the absence of a second PO.
What separates the winners in retail isn't just a good product or a good pitch. It's operational maturity. The ability to handle complexity, ship without drama, and act on data before the buyer even sees a dip.
If you're gearing up for a major retail launch—or just got your first trial order—it's worth understanding what that really entails. Especially with Walmart, where the expectations are both higher and less forgiving than most new suppliers realize.
The opportunity to launch into retail is real—but so are the risks.
Buyers want new, high-performing products. But what they need are suppliers who won't become a liability the moment orders get complex. That means having more than a good pitch. It means having infrastructure, discipline, and visibility before the first shipment leaves the dock.
The mistake isn't moving too fast. It's moving without a system.
If you're approaching your first major retail launch, step back and assess the full picture: not just what you're selling, but how you're operating. Because retail doesn't make room for learning curves—it makes room for execution.
TIME BUSINESS NEWS
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Stablecoin Disruption: Time to Sell Your Visa Stock?
Large retailers are trying to build stablecoins to circumvent Visa. The company has plenty of firepower to defend its position in the payments ecosystem. Investors should not panic and sell their Visa stock today. 10 stocks we like better than Visa › This week, stablecoin legislation was approved by the United States Senate. The bill -- called the GENIUS Act -- still needs to go through the other side of Congress and on to the President's desk, but it is one step closer to bringing stablecoins into the financial system. By regulating the new currencies pegged to the U.S. dollar, issuers of the coin will now need to keep ample reserves to pay back customers and also go through regular audits. Investors are betting that legislation will spur customer adoption, which is a threat to Visa (NYSE: V). If stablecoins are adopted wholesale by consumers, it could mean less payment volume through Visa's network. Less volume means less profit. Does that mean it is time to sell your Visa stock? Not really. Here's why stablecoins are not a large threat to Visa's business model today. This legislation is inspiring companies to investigate making their own stablecoins. According to reports, both Walmart and Amazon -- the two largest retailers in the United States -- are exploring making stablecoins for shoppers. Retailers are incentivized to do this because of the high fees paid to the credit card networks every year, which range from 2% to 3% of every transaction. Visa only collects 0.1% or a little more of every dollar spent, while most goes to the banking partners that issue credit cards and give consumers cash-back rewards. By adopting stablecoins, merchants see an avenue to avoiding the credit card fees that are a huge expense on their operations. Wal-Mart and Amazon alone could save billions of dollars a year that are now going to the financial system. It only needs to see mass adoption of stablecoins for this to happen. Easier said than done, but there are a lot of profits on the line for trying. Defeating Visa and credit card fees is not going to be easy. If it were, the companies would simply stop accepting Visa altogether. But they cannot, because of Visa's immense scale in merchant acceptance and consumer usage that is difficult to replicate. Visa has operations in 200 countries and territories, accepted by 150 million merchants and growing. It also has 4.8 billion total debit and credit cards in circulation. Over $15 trillion in total payments volume is processed by Visa every year. For stablecoins to succeed, they will need to replicate not one but both sides of this network. Shoppers will not use stablecoins for everyday use unless they are accepted everywhere. Merchants will not care about accepting stablecoins if nobody uses them. Call me skeptical that they will reach Visa's scale anytime soon. This is a classic example of a network effect competitive advantage, which reinforces Visa's growing dominance in the industry. Plus, we shouldn't forget about the thing consumers love about credit cards: cash back and reward points. Credit cards are able to offer so many perks to customers because of the 2% to 3% fees charged to merchants. Without them, it is a much worse customer value proposition, another hurdle for stablecoin adoption. No, you should not sell your Visa stock just because iy is dipping on stablecoin news. It is clear that this company has a strong competitive advantage and massive scale that stablecoin issuers are nowhere close to matching. The legislation has not even been approved yet, so there is no reason to panic. That does not mean the stock is necessarily a buy at these prices. Its earnings per share (EPS) grew 10% year over year last quarter, which is right around Visa's long-term growth. As such a large business already, it is not going to produce hypergrowth in the form of earnings, but steady durable growth over time. Today, the stock trades at a premium price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) of 34 even after this stock dip, making the stock expensive. Don't rush out and sell your Visa stock. But don't think the stock is a home run buy just because it slipped 10%, either. Before you buy stock in Visa, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the for investors to buy now… and Visa wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $664,089!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $881,731!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 994% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 172% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join . See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of June 9, 2025 John Mackey, former CEO of Whole Foods Market, an Amazon subsidiary, is a member of The Motley Fool's board of directors. Brett Schafer has positions in Amazon. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Amazon, Visa, and Walmart. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Stablecoin Disruption: Time to Sell Your Visa Stock? was originally published by The Motley Fool Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
10 hours ago
- Yahoo
Circle Internet (CRCL) Soars 80% W/W as Analyst Recommends to 'Buy' Its Stock
Circle Internet Group (NYSE:CRCL) is one of the . Circle Internet skyrocketed by 80 percent week-on-week, closing at $240.28 versus the $133.56 on June 13, with investor sentiment bolstered by a flurry of catalysts, including a 'buy' recommendation and growth opportunities from the Senate's passage of the Stablecoin bill. On Friday, Circle Internet Group (NYSE:CRCL) earned its first 'buy' recommendation from Seaport Global following the Senate's passage of a legislation that would allow the wider usage of Stablecoin. Earlier last week, Circle Internet Group's (NYSE:CRCL) announced that its USDC Stablecoin is being adopted by retail giants Amazon and Walmart, as well as e-commerce operator Shopify, which began rolling out its feature enabling merchants to accept the digital currency for payments and order fulfillment flows. A man and a woman in matching suits with a a digital tablet highlighting a payment solution. Circle Internet Group (NYSE:CRCL) also said that it partnered with blockchain firm Ripple to bring USDC Stablecoin to the latter's XRP Ledger blockchain, as well as with digital identity company World for the addition of USDC and CCTP V2 (Cross-Chain Transfer Protocol) on World Chain. While we acknowledge the potential of CRCL as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an extremely cheap AI stock that is also a major beneficiary of Trump tariffs and onshoring, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock. READ NEXT: 20 Best AI Stocks To Buy Now and 30 Best Stocks to Buy Now According to Billionaires. Disclosure: None. This article is originally published at Insider Monkey. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Engadget
13 hours ago
- Engadget
How to buy the Nintendo Switch 2: Latest stock updates at Target, Best Buy, Walmart and more
The Nintendo Switch 2 has been available in the US for more than two weeks — but good luck finding one. While millions of people have been able to snag the $450 console since it officially went up for sale on June 5, online inventory dried up fairly quickly at most stores soon after launch and remains difficult to find today. Target and Best Buy restocked shortly after launch, but those didn't last long, and the latter required in-store pickup. You may also be able to grab a bundle at Costco if you're a member there. Otherwise, it's been slim pickings. As of today, we're not seeing any availability — though you may have different luck in your locality when checking inventory, online or in person. To that latter point, people had a bit more luck on launch week by venturing to a physical retail store. We can't guarantee you'll still be able to snag a Switch 2 the old-fashioned way, but it's worth checking if a local Target, Best Buy, Walmart or GameStop — the four official retailers Nintendo lists on its store page — still has consoles in stock. For now, you can skip Amazon, though: For whatever reason, the biggest online retailer doesn't even have a product page for the Switch 2 (but it does seem to be selling games and accessories). All that said, if you're still on the hunt, we've rounded up all of the latest information we could find on how to buy the Nintendo Switch 2 and where you can pick one up. Walmart began online purchases at midnight ET on June 5. Currently, both the Mario Kart World bundle and the standalone console are "available" via third-party retailers, but listed for much higher than their standard $500 and $450 price tags — with limited quantities available. We wouldn't recommend buying these; instead, wait for the console to be listed at its regular MSRP. Naturally, the world's largest retailer is also selling the console at its brick-and-mortar locations, though the company has noted that quantities are limited and inventory will vary by location. Best Buy started selling the Switch 2 at its retail locations on June 5. It previously said it wouldn't sell the handheld at its online store during launch week, but it made additional consoles available on June 11 around 12PM ET. That restock lasted for the better part of an hour and required in-store pickup, but the device is now sold out again. Target had the Switch 2 in stores on June 5 and restocked its online inventory for at least a couple of hours starting around 3:30AM ET on June 6. It then had another restock on June 12 around 2:30PM ET, but that appears to have died out in less than an hour. It still looks to be fully sold out as we write this, but you should see if there's any stock at the stores closest to you just to be safe. GameStop has advertised in-store availability, though exactly how much stock your local store may have will vary by location. Online, the device has been unavailable for the past week, with the listings for the base console and Mario Kart bundle now pointing to a "Find a Store" page. We saw a $625 bundle that includes Mario Kart World , a microSD Express card and a few other accessories pop up a bit more frequently than the standard SKUs, but it's no longer listed (and it was kind of a raw deal anyway). You may still have some luck at certain membership-based retailers. A Mario Kart World bundle at Costco that includes a 12-month Switch Online subscription has gone in and out of stock since launch day. Sam's Club has had a bundle without the Switch Online sub as well, though it's out of stock now. We also saw the console at BJ's early on June 5, but it's no longer live there. Verizon briefly had the Switch 2 available on launch day, but that's dried up, and only those with Verizon service were able to order. Amazon hasn't had any form of Switch 2 listing on its website, nor has it listed Mario Kart World . The company didn't take pre-orders for the Switch 2 either, so it's unclear if and when it will sell the device. You can, however, find some Switch 2 games. Newegg has listed the Switch 2 on its site for several weeks, but it's given no indication as to when it'll begin sales. It previous showed a couple listings from a third-party seller, but at massively inflated prices. With all of these stores, we've seen the Mario Kart World bundle available in greater quantities online than the base console, which costs $50 less. But given that Mario Kart is the Switch 2's biggest launch game and retails for $80 on its own, that may not be the worst thing. Nintendo, meanwhile, is only offering the Switch 2 via an invite system. This requires you to have been a Switch Online member for at least 12 months and logged at least 50 hours of Switch 1 playtime as of April 2. It can't hurt to sign up if you meet the criteria, but don't expect it to bear fruit immediately — it's taken weeks for many people who registered in April to receive their invite. You can find a list of every Switch 2 retail listing we could find below. Just be aware that this is meant to be a reference, not a rundown of everywhere the device is available right this second. Where to buy Switch 2 + Mario Kart World bundle: Where to buy Switch 2: Nintendo is selling a number of Switch 2 accessories alongside the console, from its (pricey) Pro Controller to cases to cameras for the new GameChat feature. Most of these became available on June 5. The same goes for games like Mario Kart World and the Switch 2 version of The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom . Another big Switch 2 release, Donkey Kong Bananza , won't be available until mid-July but is still up for pre-order now. As of this publication, just about all Switch 2 games are broadly available. Stock for the accessories remains a little spottier, but most devices are still available at multiple retailers. Nintendo's official Switch 2 carrying cases have been the main exceptions, so you may need to look to third-party alternatives if you want some protection for your console right away. Mario Kart World ($80) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Donkey Kong Bananza ($70) Nintendo Amazon Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Costco (membership required) Additional Switch 2 games Nintendo Amazon Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Samsung microSD Express Card (256GB) for Nintendo Switch 2 ($60) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Amazon Joy-Con 2 bundle ($95) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Switch 2 Pro Controller ($85) Switch 2 Camera ($55) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Hori Nintendo Switch 2 Piranha Plant Camera ($60) Joy-Con 2 Charging Grip ($40) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Joy-Con 2 Wheels (set of 2) ($25) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Switch 2 All-in-One Carrying Case ($85) Nintendo Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Switch 2 Carrying Case and Screen Protector ($40) Nintendo (invite required) Walmart GameStop Best Buy Target Nintendo Switch 2 Dock Set ($120) Nintendo GameCube Controller for Switch 2 ($65) Nintendo (Switch Online required)
