Man City sheikh was ‘shadow owner' of hospital tainted by fraud, claims EY
Manchester City owner Sheikh Mansour was 'effectively a shadow owner' of failed hospital operator NMC Health, EY has claimed.
The Emirati royal had links to two Emirati businessmen accused of stealing billions from the former FTSE 100 company, the accountancy giant has alleged.
It was claimed his connections to NMC Health saw it shielded from proper scrutiny, meaning banks ignored 'red flags' to lend billions to the London-listed healthcare giant before its 2020 collapse.
EY made the claims in submissions to the High Court as it seeks to defend itself against a £2bn lawsuit brought forward by bankruptcy administrator Alvarez & Marsal.
The 'big four' firm claims Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan had close ties to two of NMC Health's top shareholders, Saeed and Khalifa bin Butti.
They are accused of stealing billions from the healthcare company alongside BR Shetty, its founder.
The three shareholders, who together owned two thirds of all shares in NMC Health, are accused of defrauding the company by borrowing more than $4bn (£3bn) worth of secret debt.
Dr Shetty has instead claimed he was the victim of a wider fraud. The High Court subsequently froze Dr Shetty's assets in 2022, including a luxury London penthouse.
EY claims fraudsters inside NMC Health used their links to Sheikh Mansour to secure loans from banks, who were willing to lend billions to the chain headquartered in Abu Dhabi because of the Emirati royal's 'name' and credibility.
The accounting firm's submissions to the High Court say: 'The evidence ... suggests that Sheikh Mansour stood behind the Bin Buttis in some informal way, making him effectively a shadow owner of NMC.'
Sheikh Mansour's links to NMC Health were 'well understood in the region,' EY's submissions add.
It claimed that banks conducted due diligence with the 'lightest of touches' due to the credibility given to the company by the Emirati royal.
NMC Health's lenders 'failed to take obvious steps to protect their own interests by conducting proper due diligence on the loans they were advancing to the NMC Group,' EY's submissions to the High Court say.
Sheikh Mansour is a member of Abu Dhabi's royal family, and is currently the United Arab Emirate's vice president. The Emirati billionaire is also the owner of Manchester City Football Club.
The accountancy giant says Alvarez & Marsal have also 'shied away' from pursuing the Bin Butti brothers, because of their links to Sheikh Mansour.
EY's submissions to the High Court say: 'No serious attempt seems to have been made to pursue the money stolen by the Bin Buttis.'
The claims come as EY is accused of 'extremely serious' failings in its audits of NMC Health that resulted in the accountancy giant allegedly missing one of the biggest frauds ever involving a London-listed company.
Alvarez & Marsal claims EY's accountants 'never even opened the books' at NMC Health. EY said it was a 'principal target and victim' of the alleged fraud.
Lawyers for the accountancy firm separately accused Abdul Rahman Basaddiq, the former head of EY's Abu Dhabi office, of having enabled the fraud. At a hearing on Wednesday, lawyers for EY told the High Court that Mr Basaddiq was 'plainly a fraudster'.
The Bin Butti brothers did not respond to Telegraph requests for comment. Khalifa bin Butti told The Times in 2020 that 'any suggestion that I have been involved in wrongdoing is categorically rejected'.
Abdul Rahman Basaddiq did not respond to requests for comment.
An EY spokesman said: 'This was a complex, pervasive and collusive fraud, and responsibility for it lies squarely with its perpetrators, including NMC's owners, directors and the treasury and finance team.
'This case is without merit and the full extent of this unprecedented fraud – of which EY was one of the targets – will be exposed during the course of the trial.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Several Insiders Invested In B&M European Value Retail Flagging Positive News
It is usually uneventful when a single insider buys stock. However, When quite a few insiders buy shares, as it happened in B&M European Value Retail S.A.'s (LON:BME) case, it's fantastic news for shareholders. Although we don't think shareholders should simply follow insider transactions, logic dictates you should pay some attention to whether insiders are buying or selling shares. We've found 21 US stocks that are forecast to pay a dividend yield of over 6% next year. See the full list for free. In the last twelve months, the biggest single purchase by an insider was when Independent Non-Executive Chair Tiffany Hall bought UK£201k worth of shares at a price of UK£2.87 per share. That means that an insider was happy to buy shares at above the current price of UK£2.64. It's very possible they regret the purchase, but it's more likely they are bullish about the company. We always take careful note of the price insiders pay when purchasing shares. Generally speaking, it catches our eye when insiders have purchased shares at above current prices, as it suggests they believed the shares were worth buying, even at a higher price. While B&M European Value Retail insiders bought shares during the last year, they didn't sell. The chart below shows insider transactions (by companies and individuals) over the last year. If you click on the chart, you can see all the individual transactions, including the share price, individual, and the date! Check out our latest analysis for B&M European Value Retail There are always plenty of stocks that insiders are buying. If investing in lesser known companies is your style, you could take a look at this free list of companies. (Hint: insiders have been buying them). Over the last three months, we've seen a bit of insider buying at B&M European Value Retail. CFO & Executive Director Mike Schmidt purchased UK£20k worth of shares in that period. It's great to see that insiders are only buying, not selling. But the amount invested in the last three months isn't enough for us too put much weight on it, as a single factor. Looking at the total insider shareholdings in a company can help to inform your view of whether they are well aligned with common shareholders. I reckon it's a good sign if insiders own a significant number of shares in the company. B&M European Value Retail insiders own about UK£185m worth of shares (which is 7.0% of the company). Most shareholders would be happy to see this sort of insider ownership, since it suggests that management incentives are well aligned with other shareholders. Our data shows a little insider buying, but no selling, in the last three months. The net investment is not enough to encourage us much. However, our analysis of transactions over the last year is heartening. With high insider ownership and encouraging transactions, it seems like B&M European Value Retail insiders think the business has merit. In addition to knowing about insider transactions going on, it's beneficial to identify the risks facing B&M European Value Retail. To assist with this, we've discovered 2 warning signs that you should run your eye over to get a better picture of B&M European Value Retail. If you would prefer to check out another company -- one with potentially superior financials -- then do not miss this free list of interesting companies, that have HIGH return on equity and low debt. For the purposes of this article, insiders are those individuals who report their transactions to the relevant regulatory body. We currently account for open market transactions and private dispositions of direct interests only, but not derivative transactions or indirect interests. — Investing narratives with Fair Values Vita Life Sciences Set for a 12.72% Revenue Growth While Tackling Operational Challenges By Robbo – Community Contributor Fair Value Estimated: A$2.42 · 0.1% Overvalued Vossloh rides a €500 billion wave to boost growth and earnings in the next decade By Chris1 – Community Contributor Fair Value Estimated: €78.41 · 0.1% Overvalued Intuitive Surgical Will Transform Healthcare with 12% Revenue Growth By Unike – Community Contributor Fair Value Estimated: $325.55 · 0.6% Undervalued View more featured narratives — Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team (at) article by Simply Wall St is general in nature. We provide commentary based on historical data and analyst forecasts only using an unbiased methodology and our articles are not intended to be financial advice. It does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and does not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. We aim to bring you long-term focused analysis driven by fundamental data. Note that our analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material. Simply Wall St has no position in any stocks mentioned. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
This dividend stock's yielding 5.5% but its directors have sold nearly 15m shares this month!
Brickability Group's (LSE:BRCK) a distributor of construction materials (not just bricks) and has built (excuse the pun) a reputation as a dividend stock. And with earnings growing strongly I'm sure shareholders will be hopeful that its payout will continue to rise. On 24 April, the group released a pre-close trading update stating that revenue for the year ended 31 March (FY25) is expected to be 7% higher than in FY24. Also, adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) is forecast to be 11% better. Some of the improvement is due to its specialist cladding and fire remediation division delivering projects ahead of schedule. This is a shift of turnover between accounting periods rather than new business. But the group said there was 'good momentum in trading' more generally. Within a week of this announcement, the group's share price had risen 15.5%. But its shares are now changing hands for only fractionally more than before the news was released. It means nearly all of the benefit to shareholders from its FY25 results being ahead of expectations has been lost. So what's going on? A quick look at the company's other stock exchange announcements is revealing. On 13 June, Alan Simpson, a non-executive director (NED), and Sarah Simpson, a close associate, reduced their combined stake from 11% to 7.23%. The shares fell nearly 6% when this news was announced. The amount received hasn't yet been disclosed but it's likely to be around the £7m mark. And two days earlier, the managing director of Brickability's Distribution division sold 3m shares and another NED offloaded 1m. These sales realised proceeds of £2.07m and £690,000 respectively. Of course, I've no idea why these individuals have decided to reduce their stakes in the company. Everyone has different financial circumstances and I don't think it's unreasonable to 'cash out' at some stage. After all, you can't spend shares. But whatever the reasons, these sales aren't a good look. These senior managers are going to miss out on generous levels of passive income. Based on amounts paid over the past 12 months, the stock's currently (20 June) yielding 5.5%. The FTSE AIM All-Share index is offering 2.27%. We don't yet know what the final dividend for FY25 will be but it looks as though it's likely to be higher than it was in FY24. If so, it means the group will have increased its annual payout for four consecutive years. But the group's relatively small. As its listed on the Alternative Investment Market (AIM) with a market-cap of just under £200m, it doesn't have the financial firepower to cope with a sustained downturn in the UK construction industry. And even though I'm sure there are perfectly valid reasons for the directors' share sales, they're likely to dent investor confidence. But the group has lots going for it. Revenue and earnings are heading in the right direction and the green shoots of a recovery are starting to show in the housebuilding sector. Also, the UK cladding 'scandal' is providing plenty of opportunities for further work. For these reasons, when combined with a healthy 5%+ yield, investors could consider adding the stock to their portfolios. The post This dividend stock's yielding 5.5% but its directors have sold nearly 15m shares this month! appeared first on The Motley Fool UK. More reading 5 Stocks For Trying To Build Wealth After 50 One Top Growth Stock from the Motley Fool James Beard has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Motley Fool UK 2025
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
British Airways trials removing individual water bottles from flights
British Airways is trialling removing water bottles from in-flight drinks services as part of 'efforts to reduce plastic waste'. Economy passengers on long-haul flights connecting London Heathrow with three US cities – Miami, Boston, and Los Angeles – will instead be served cups of water as part of the new sustainability trial. Paper cups provided by cabin crew have temporarily replaced individual plastic water bottles on these select routes for travellers in BA's economy and premium economy cabins. On a FlyerTalk forum, a passenger flying from Miami to Heathrow said: 'There were no bottles of water they could give me as BA is trialling not offering any bottles of water for two weeks now.' They added that the individual water cuts were 'obviously a cost-saving exercise under the guise of saving the polar bears'. The airline confirmed that a one-week trial reducing single-use plastic onboard is running between 16 and 22 June. BA's Club World and first class passengers are not currently impacted by the experimental plastic bottle ban. A spokesperson for British Airways told The Independent: 'This is a one-week trial on three routes as part of efforts to reduce plastic waste. The views of our customers are very important to us, and we'll be listening very carefully to their feedback.' In October 2024, BA was accused of scrambling to cut costs by frequent flyers after introducing a new brunch service on long-haul flights. The extended breakfast for lunch meals are served on flights that depart between 8.30am and 11.29am. Menu items for the primary inflight meal across seat categories now include cheese frittatas, Belgian waffles and poached eggs on sourdough, rather than a full meal. Several frequent flyers said they considered the changes 'cheap' and a 'major downgrade' of the service. BA said the new brunch service was implemented in line with positive customer feedback on classic brunch dishes and lighter lunch options.
