Mining fails to deliver jobs to local communities
Despite R72 billion in profits, mining towns report extreme unemployment and missing development funds.
Mining companies are failing to create jobs for the communities where they operate, recent statistics released by the organisation, Mining Affected Communities United in Action (Macua), indicate.
These show that the unemployment rate in communities situated near the biggest mining operations is more than 65%.
This means mining firms are not fulfilling their role in the Social Labour Plan (SLP) to create jobs for local communities.
Mining firms not fulfilling role in SLP
'Macua is deeply alarmed but not surprised by the latest unemployment data released [last week] by Statistics SA.
'Our research confirms that unemployment in communities located next to some of the wealthiest mining operations consistently exceeds 65%, with some areas having 82% unemployment rate.
ALSO READ: Here's why Amplats will still pay Anglo R1.6bn a year after unbundling
'These figures dwarf the official national average. They expose a central truth that policymakers continue to ignore – that the growth of mining profits is not translating into jobs, justice or dignity for those most impacted by the extraction,' said Macua spokesperson Magnificent Mndebele.
'Government leaders parade Operation Vulindlela and sectoral reforms as solutions to inequality and unemployment. But our audits reveal the opposite.
'The mining sector, empowered by expedited licences, deregulation and policy favouritism, has become a site of elite enrichment, not shared prosperity.
Site of elite enrichment
'With record profits of over R72 billion from just 11 audited mining companies, communities have seen less than 0.13% of that reinvested in their development.
'Our audits uncovered over R284 million in missing SLP funds across 11 sites, with more than 75% of committed development projects incomplete or undocumented.'
ALSO READ: SA opened 159 new mines in five years, creating over 15 000 jobs
Mining expert David van Wyk said Macua's report was an accurate reflection of what is happening in the mining-affected communities.
'I fully agree with Macua – mining does not create jobs. This country needs to move up into a post-mining economy.
'On a post-mining economy, I mean that we need not export strategic minerals necessary for manufacturing, for example iron, chrome, manganese, lithium and rare earth minerals. These are all required for manufacturing in general and for batteries and AI technologies in particular.'
Need for focused state and foreign investment
'Then we need focused state and a foreign investment to kickstart a manufacturing base.'
'That means moving away from the low-wage economy. We have 60 million people either on low wages or unemployed. They cannot afford manufactured goods. This is a disincentive for manufacturing.'
ALSO READ: Millions unaccounted for as ex-mine bosses face court over fraud
'We could, for example, manufacture batteries and cars [not assemble foreign cars as we are doing currently] but make electric vehicles as these are replacing combustion engines globally.'
Van Wyk said dying mining towns should be repurposed into suppliers of gas and solar energy using old mine electricity substations to feed solar power from mine wastelands into the national grid, and extract methane from old mine shafts.
Large-scale mining in decline
As large-scale mining is in decline, the state should create the conditions for artisanal, smalland medium-scale mining and facilitate community-based industries to add value to the diamonds, gold and platinum extracted, such as by jewellery manufacturing for example, he said.
National Association of Artisanal Miners spokesperson Zethu Hlatshwayo said mines were not equipping people with skills. 'So mines employ people from other areas.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Inflation unchanged in May at 2.8% as economists expected
While the inflation rate remained under the bottom band of the Reserve Bank's inflation target, it is not expected to stay there. The inflation rate remained unchanged in May at 2.8% as economists expected, but geopolitical risks could see it drift higher than expected in the months ahead. Statistics South Africa (Statistics SA) announced on Wednesday morning that the inflation rate remained the same as in April, with food prices being the only category that pushed inflation up in May by 0.2% compared to April. Jee-A van der Linde, senior economist at Oxford Economics Africa, says the outcome was in line with their expectations, and they continue to see a mild increase in price inflation heading into the second half of 2025. The main contributors to the inflation rate in May were housing and utilities, which increased by 4.5% and contributed 1.0 percentage point, food and non-alcoholic beverages, which increased by 4.8% and contributed 0.9 percentage point and alcoholic beverages and tobacco, which increased by 4.3% and contributed 0.2 percentage point. Statistics SA noted that higher meat prices (+4.4%) were a key driver of prices, with the biggest monthly increase recorded for beef products. Van der Linde points out that South Africa is in the grip of a widespread outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease, which intensified in June and will have an impact on domestic food prices going forward. ALSO READ: Inflation steady in May but food prices still increased Fuel levy offset lower fuel prices in May, keeping inflation at 2.8% 'Elsewhere, the latest data shows that domestic fuel prices declined further in June, but this is likely to be offset by the simultaneous increase in general fuel levies this month. Mid-month fuel prices data from the Central Energy Fund (CEF) indicates that petrol and diesel are likely to cost more in July after the latest upsurge in international oil prices.' He also notes that international oil prices rallied after Israel's strikes on Iran, with Brent Crude Oil prices briefly hitting $80.0 per barrel before settling around $74 per barrel. 'Due to the flare-up in tensions in the Middle East, we now forecast Brent Crude Oil prices to average $67.8 per barrel in 2025, slightly higher than our previous estimate of $67.3 per barrel. 'While oil supply remains unaffected, further escalation could see Iran close the Strait of Hormuz, cutting off around 20% of global supply and potentially driving prices to $120 per barrel. At that point, oil prices would be near the levels recorded when Russia invaded Ukraine and domestic fuel prices shot up to record levels.' However, Van der Linde says the latest inflation data does not alter their updated inflation outlook, and they still forecast inflation will average 3.4% in 2025 compared to 4.4% in 2024. 'Although headline inflation will drift higher throughout the second half of the year due to base effects, the overall outlook remains benign and unchanged from our earlier views, although several risks have emerged recently that could lead to prices increasing faster.' ALSO READ: What Israel–Iran conflict means for South African economy Risks to inflation outlook worsened over past few days Busisiwe Nkonki and Johannes (Matimba) Khosa, economists at the Nedbank Group Economic Unit, also expect inflation to drift upwards in the second half of the year, but still average a muted 3.5% in 2025. However, they say, risks to the inflation outlook have worsened in recent days as the rand weakened, and global oil prices jumped due to the conflict in the Middle East. 'Food prices will increase as the base continues to normalise. However, favourable crop prices resulting from good rainfall, as well as increased livestock slaughtering, will contain the upside. The biggest concern is the rand. 'While the domestic currency has been resilient in recent weeks, it remains vulnerable to unfavourable global economic and geopolitical developments. 'The Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) of the South African Reserve Bank (Sarb) will have to weigh the benign inflation outlook against the potential upside risks emanating from the highly volatile and uncertain global environment. At this stage, we still see room for the Sarb to cut further in July.'
The Star
3 days ago
- The Star
Rethinking social and labour plans: from compliance to transformational community development
Mzila I. Mthenjane | Published 9 hours ago The consequences of climate change amplify vulnerabilities in communities, placing additional stresses on water availability, agricultural productivity, health outcomes, and infrastructure resilience, such as roads and housing susceptibility to severe weather conditions. Too often, when the disaster or distress hits, communities turn to mining companies to provide services and infrastructure. Despite this reality, there remains a disconnect between intention, impact, and outcomes in these interventions. Mining is on the cusp of a once-in-a-generation investment boom. The global population is approaching 10 billion people, and many parts of the world, including us, are pursuing a net zero economy towards 2050 and beyond. With an estimated $100 billion in additional capital investment in the resources sector required each year to meet the demand outlook associated with urbanisation and the decarbonisation of the global energy system, sizeable increases in material production and infrastructure are also necessary. For emerging economies, there is a narrow window of opportunity to seize now. Such growing demand brings an opportunity to benefit communities, countries and investors committed to enabling and facilitating the mining and investment activities needed to meet our needs, such as skills-to-employment ecosystem, generating local value addition and create revenue flows capable of decarbonized economic development. South Africa's mining sector is a significant driver of economic growth and critical for the socio-economic transformation of our society. Central to this transformation agenda are Social and Labour Plans (SLPs), elements of the mining licensing regime which were introduced through the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act, 2002 to ensure mining contributes to sustainable community development. SLPs were conceived as strategic tools to promote socio-economic development, stimulate and broaden economic opportunities, and enhance skills development to support the creation of sustainable communities during and after mining. However, nearly two decades after their inception, the question remains: Have SLPs truly driven sustainable, transformative change within mining-affected communities This ongoing struggle reveals a fundamental disconnect between the institutional understanding of challenges within communities and the intended goals and actual community-level outcomes, raising the question of why there is this persistent gap and what are the possible solutions. Despite the significant resources mining companies have committed under SLPs, informed by local integrated development plans (IDPs), tangible and sustained improvements in the quality of life and long-term socio-economic resilience remains elusive. A significant contributing factor is the prevailing and compliance-driven mindset underpinning SLP implementation, amongst mining companies, regulator and beneficiaries. Too often, SLPs, being regulatory obligations, are limited from being approached as strategic investments for genuine socio-economic empowerment and, in today's terms, transforming communities in response to climate change and commence the just transition journey. As it stands, the law ringfences SLPs to individual mining rights, leading to less effective deployment of resources for joint projects which would deliver greater impact and minimise duplications. Such an approach frequently leaves underlying structural challenges unaddressed. For example, projects may initially improve conditions but deteriorate without municipal long-term planning, community stewardship, financial constraints and skills shortages to adequately sustain them. Under such a compliance framework, companies prioritise with local government , short-term deliverables—such as building municipal and district roads, donating to local charities, a clinic here and school classroom there, or sponsoring temporary initiatives—over comprehensive, sustained, and systemic socio-economic transformation projects. This situation ultimately limits the durability and scale of impacts, leading communities to cycle back into dependency and vulnerability. Even though, not directly affected by the SLP, lessons from the decommission of power stations, and associated mine closures in areas like Komati has brought this reality to the fore. Recently mining companies have been trying to pool their SLP projects with amendments to legislation also being advocated. The overarching idea is to bring the benefits of mining to communities through collaboration. But this is not often the case, as some IDPs do not exhibit the essential elements of integration along a clear developmental trajectory -resulting in sub-optimal developmental outcomes, leading to mistrust and finger-pointing. Whereas mining companies correctly complain of the failure of government in creating an enabling environment for development, host communities often bear the brunt of such failures, including poor service delivery and ineffective local economic development. A further complication is the apparent inadequacy of meaningful community engagement during IDP and SLP formulation. Inadequate measurement of actual impacts exacerbates the problem. Without robust metrics to measure true progress—such as improvements in health and education outcomes or enhanced local economic development—SLPs risk remaining exercises in compliance rather than vehicles for genuine and sustained socio-economic development. Furthermore, what is necessary to maximise this developmental impact through increased collaboration not just among mining companies within a municipality, but also with entities in other economic sectors. An appropriate legislative frameworks to guide collaboration between all economic players operating in the same mining region is urgently required. Mining companies, together with other economic players, government, communities and other stakeholders involved can reorient SLPs away from transactional, fragmented efforts towards comprehensive, integrated, and strategic frameworks. By doing so, SLPs can effectively contribute to the fulfilment of the developmental objective by serving as powerful catalysts for inclusive and enduring transformation in the communities that host South Africa's critical mining operations. Mzila I. Mthenjane is PCC Commissioner and CEO, Minerals Council South Africa.
Daily Maverick
4 days ago
- Daily Maverick
Why Web3 is the career path Africa didn't see coming
For years, Africa's most ambitious youth were told success meant becoming a doctor, lawyer, or engineer. Traditional careers were seen as the only reliable path to upward mobility. But today, a quiet revolution is underway, not in boardrooms, but on the blockchain. This is more than a shift in technology; it's a transformation in how we work. Web3 is no longer a fringe concept; it's fast becoming one of the most exciting career opportunities for young Africans. One that accommodates everyone, whether you're a beginner or a seasoned professional. No one has missed the boat; it's never too late to start. A generation rewriting the rules Across the continent, young people are becoming increasingly mobile-first, digitally savvy, and actively seeking alternatives to traditional career paths, many of which are oversaturated and struggling to absorb a growing workforce. With South Africa's youth unemployment rate at 44.6% in Q4 2024 (Statistics SA), the search for new opportunities is urgent. Web3 offers a compelling alternative: a borderless, decentralised ecosystem where postcodes matter less than skill sets and ambition. As part of our commitment to empowering South African youth through education and community engagement, Binance proudly sponsors The Inside Show, a platform dedicated to amplifying youth perspectives on digital innovation. 'Young South Africans aren't just learning about Web3, they're living it. From creating NFT art to hosting crypto conversations online, we're seeing a surge in digital confidence and curiosity. For many, it's not just a career shift, it's a mindset shift,' says George Avakian, Founder and Host of the podcast at The Inside Show, a platform dedicated to amplifying youth perspectives and spotlighting new digital frontiers. At Binance, we're witnessing this transformation firsthand. From smart contract developers to NFT artists and community managers, young Africans are staking their claim in a digital economy that rewards creativity, agility and openness. Real career paths in Web3 What makes Web3 different is its breadth. You don't have to be a developer to thrive. Career paths include: Content creators and educators demystifying blockchain for new audiences Project managers and community leads are building trust across decentralised communities Designers and product thinkers shaping crypto user experiences Policy specialists and legal minds guiding responsible innovation across African markets And demand is growing. In our 2022 education initiative, we received over 80,000 applications worldwide from individuals eager to learn about Web3, a powerful signal of Africa's appetite for blockchain knowledge and readiness to work in this space. Education is the gateway But opportunity means little without access. That's why Binance is committed to making Web3 education accessible, practical, and locally relevant. Through Binance Academy, campus initiatives, and partnerships with African universities and youth networks, we're building pathways into the space, no coding background required. Recently, Binance partnered with AltSchool Africa, a platform reimagining education for the modern workforce, to offer structured Web3 training tailored to young Africans seeking digital skills. This collaboration brings together Binance's blockchain expertise with AltSchool's learner-first approach, offering accessible courses that blend theory with real-world application. We believe blockchain literacy is a 21st-century skill, just like financial literacy or digital security. And we're working to ensure that young Africans aren't just users of crypto, but the creators and builders of the next wave of innovation. The future is already here Young Africans are no longer waiting for an invitation to participate; they are building their platforms and creating opportunities for others to join. They are using Web3 not only for personal advancement but also to foster community empowerment and economic inclusion. A platform like Momint demonstrates how blockchain can be used to help creators and institutions monetise content and fund meaningful initiatives from preserving cultural heritage to supporting clean energy projects, showcasing the potential of African Web3 innovation to deliver real-world impact at scale. A new generation is redefining success and unlocking opportunities that didn't exist a decade ago, not through legacy systems, but by building the future of work block by block in Web3. DM
