Albertans for Carney? They're as impressed with new PM as they are with Poilievre: poll
EDITOR'S NOTE: CBC News commissioned this public opinion research to be conducted immediately following the federal election and leading into the second anniversary of the United Conservative Party's provincial election win in May 2023.
As with all polls, this one provides a snapshot in time.
This analysis is one in a series of articles from this research.
Alberta's politics are not without their complexity. Here's one striking new example.
While this is a province where many people are newly interested in separating from Canada because the Liberals won — again — and nearly all ridings went Conservative — again — Albertans appear as likely to express admiration for Mark Carney as for Pierre Poilievre.
Yes, Albertans.
A new Janet Brown Opinion Research poll conducted after the federal election for CBC News asked respondents for their impression of the federal Liberal and Conservative leaders, on a 10-point scale, where 0 means deeply unimpressed and 10 means utterly dazzled.
And the results for Carney and Poilievre are nearly identical.
Conservatives won nearly all the seats in the province and 65 per cent of the votes, compared to the Liberals' 28 per cent — far back, even if it was their best performance in Alberta in a half-century.
But the polling data suggests that the number of Albertans who are very impressed with Carney outstrips the number who voted for him. It also suggests that significant numbers of Conservative voters aren't enamoured with their own leader, though some may consider themselves hopeful about the new Liberal prime minister.
Typically, voter choices are largely driven by a party's leader, said John Santos, data scientist for the polling firm. The similarities in Albertans' views of Carney and Poilievre are a striking departure for that norm.
"The parties they lead couldn't have been more far apart in terms of results [in the province]."
Bryndis Whitson ran unsuccessfully for the Liberals in Calgary Signal Hill, finishing 24 points behind Conservative David McKenzie.
But she's been campaigning for Liberals in Calgary since 1997, and said this was the most positivity she ever encountered.
"There were some people who really, really liked Carney, and there was also a factor of people being very, very unsure about Pierre," Whitson said.
She had begun door-knocking as a Liberal while Justin Trudeau was still prime minister. She recalls getting praise for her own ideas and background in the supply chain sector, but people were turned off by her leader.
That all changed with Carney at the helm.
"I think most Conservatives were very willing to give him a chance," she said.
Poilievre certainly had his regional strongholds in the survey, with respondents far more likely to report a better impression of him outside Edmonton or Calgary, and among men.
In line with party preferences, Carney had higher rankings among women. Poilievre's and Carney's scores broken down by gender are nearly mirror images of each other.
OK with boomers
Poilievre narrowly edged out Carney's rating among millennial Albertans and Gen X.
But the wider gap was among seniors, who were far more impressed by Carney, and more unimpressed by his Conservative rival.
Karamveer Lalh, a lawyer and longtime Conservative campaigner, helped the party's candidate win in Edmonton Southeast, where Mayor Amarjeet Sohi ran as a Liberal.
He said older voters tended to be aware of Carney's background in finance and as the central bank governor in England and Canada, and that outshone the resumes of both Trudeau and Poilievre.
Who else is showing more warmth lately toward the new Liberal leader? Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, who stated after this week's premiers' meeting with the prime minister in Saskatoon that she saw an "immediate change" with Carney, after repeatedly crossing swords with Trudeau and his focus on climate action instead of boosting Alberta's oil and gas sector.
"I haven't heard a prime minister say we want to build a bitumen pipeline to the northwest coast in a long time," Smith told Power & Politics on Monday.
"The fact that we have a change of tone and a change of direction from this prime minister is very encouraging."
Still, Alberta's premier has warned of a "national unity crisis" if the Carney government doesn't clear hurdles to pipeline development and roll back other oil-and-gas-related regulations. And there's also renewed interest in Alberta separatism, although this poll also suggests just 28 per cent of Albertans would vote to break the province off from Canada in the aftermath of Carney becoming prime minister. (Notably less than the 37 per cent who say they are highly impressed by Carney.)
This is, of course, an early stage for Carney's leadership, and most new prime ministers enjoy a honeymoon period, said John Santos, data scientist with Janet Brown Opinion Research.
But it appears that for now, many Albertans perceive that a key figure during past economic crises is the appropriate person for this moment of U.S. tariffs and economic upheaval.
"If Albertans are going to be warm to any federal Liberal leader, one who comes from big business from that right flank of the federal Liberal party is going to be one of the Liberal leaders that, if they don't like more, will at least dislike less," Santos said.
Conservative voters in Alberta are still predominantly more impressed by their own leader — and since there are far more of them, Poilievre's impression scores pull roughly even with Carney. However, four in 10 Conservative voters give Carney either a high or moderate score, as opposed to fewer than one-quarter of Liberals doing the same for Poilievre.
"He was viewed favourably in Conservative circles before he came out as a partisan," Lalh says of Carney.
"He was sort of seen as technocratic, well respected, helped to navigate the financial crisis."
Conversely, 82 per cent of Liberal voters said they were highly impressed with Carney, compared to 68 per cent of Conservative voters who expressed that same sentiment about Poilievre.
It might be chalked up to how polarizing each leader is. When Lalh would knock on doors of Conservative supporters, they tended to dump on the Liberals but not much on their new leader. When he visited Liberal doors, he'd more often get an earful about Poilievre.
"Carney was fresh enough at the doors anyway that the people who were not particularly fans of Poilievre had a positive reason to vote for the Liberals," Lalh said.
As for himself, Lahl said he appreciates how Carney has signalled he wants to address Alberta's concerns about getting its natural resources to market, but added: "I am reserving judgment until I see if he can walk the walk."
Given that this survey measures how impressed Albertans are with the respective leaders, part of the lower score for Poilievre among his own partisans may have to do with voters being unimpressed his Conservatives lost, and that he lost his own seat, Santos noted. (Winning, of course, impresses more than losing does.)
But it appears from this poll that Carney has a reservoir of goodwill among even Albertans who didn't vote for him.
Smith has cautioned that while Carney's words and direction have impressed her, she's keen to see action on her priorities from the Liberals.
It's those next steps that could determine whether Albertans sour on Carney like they did with his predecessors, or if they have finally found a Liberal leader they can get behind.
The CBC News random survey of 1,200 Albertans was conducted using a hybrid method between May 7 to 21, 2025, by Edmonton-based Trend Research under the direction of Janet Brown Opinion Research. The sample is representative of regional, age and gender factors. The margin of error is +/- 2.8 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. For subsets, the margin of error is larger.
The survey used a hybrid methodology that involved contacting survey respondents by telephone and giving them the option of completing the survey at that time, at another more convenient time, or receiving an email link and completing the survey online. Trend Research contacted people using a random list of numbers, consisting of 40 per cent landlines and 60 per cent cellphone numbers. Telephone numbers were dialled up to five times at five different times of day before another telephone number was added to the sample. The response rate among valid numbers (i.e. residential and personal) was 12.8 per cent.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
28 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Prime Minister Carney in Brussels today for EU-Canada summit
BRUSSELS – Prime Minister Mark Carney is in Belgium today, where he visited a military cemetery before meeting with European Union leaders at an EU-Canada summit. Carney said on social media Sunday that he was in Brussels to launch 'a new era of partnership' between Canada and the European Union for the benefit of workers, businesses and security 'on both sides of the Atlantic.' Carney started the day with a visit to the Antwerp Schoonselhof Military Cemetery where 348 Canadian soldiers are buried. Later, he is expected to meet with Belgian Prime Minister Bart De Wever, European Council President António Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. Carney posted on social media early on Monday that he spoke with U.S. President Donald Trump overnight, noting the conversation addressed the need to de-escalate the conflict in the Middle East, their shared commitment of a stronger NATO and progress in ongoing trade talks between Canada and the United States. At the EU-Canada summit, Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand and Defence Minister David McGuinty are expected to sign a security and defence agreement with the European bloc in what one European official described last week as one of the most ambitious deals the continent's powers have ever signed with a third country. The security and defence agreement aims to open the door to Canada's participation in the joint purchase of weapons with European countries. It will also lead to Canada's participation in the ReArm Europe initiative, allowing Canada to access a 150-billion-euro program for defence procurement, called Security Action for Europe. Canada will need to sign a second agreement with the European Commission before it can take part in the program. A government official briefing reporters on the trip said the partnership is expected to make procurement easier and more affordable, while also allowing Canada to diversify the sources of equipment. At the EU-Canada summit, leaders are also expected to issue a joint statement to underscore a willingness for continued pressure on Russia to end its war on Ukraine, including through further sanctions, and call for an immediate and permanent ceasefire in Gaza. The joint statement is also expected to touch on climate change, trade and digital and tech policy. Leaders at the EU-Canada summit are also slated to discuss global trade and commit to working towards full ratification and implementation of the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, the Canada-Europe free trade deal known as CETA. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. The pact took effect provisionally in 2017, and most of its contents now apply. But all EU countries need to approve CETA before it can take full effect, with 10 members still left to ratify the deal. Carney, Costa and von der Leyen are scheduled to hold a joint press conference in the evening. On Tuesday, Carney travels to The Hague for the NATO summit. The international meetings come as Canada looks to reduce its defence procurement reliance on the United States due to strained relations over tariffs and U.S. President Donald Trump's repeated talk about Canada becoming a U.S. state. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 23, 2025.
Winnipeg Free Press
28 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
In the news today: Carney in Brussels for EU-Canada summit
Here is a roundup of stories from The Canadian Press designed to bring you up to speed… Carney in Brussels for EU-Canada summit Prime Minister Mark Carney is in Belgium today, where he will visit a military cemetery before meeting with European Union leaders at an EU-Canada summit. Carney said on social media Sunday that he was in Brussels to launch 'a new era of partnership' between Canada and the European Union for the benefit of workers, businesses and security 'on both sides of the Atlantic.' He begins the day with a visit to the Antwerp Schoonselhof Military Cemetery where 348 Canadian soldiers are buried. At the EU-Canada summit, Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand and Defence Minister David McGuinty are expected to sign a security and defence agreement with the European bloc in what one European official described last week as one of the most ambitious deals the continent's powers have ever signed with a third country. The security and defence agreement aims to open the door to Canada's participation in the joint purchase of weapons with European countries. Here's what else we're watching… Ontario and Quebec continue to fight high heat Much of Ontario and southwestern Quebec will continue to bake in high temperatures Monday and Tuesday as a heat dome lingers over the region. Environment Canada issued a heat warning for the area on Saturday, saying hot and humid conditions will likely continue until Wednesday. In Toronto, the agency says the city saw a daytime high of 35 C on Sunday, with the humidex making it feel like 46 degrees at times. The dangerously high temperatures are expected to affect communities from southwestern Ontario and north to Sudbury and Timmins. People are encouraged to drink plenty of water to stay hydrated and be on alert for early signs of heat exhaustion. Alberta votes to decide Nenshi seat in legislature Alberta NDP leader Naheed Nenshi is looking to finally win a seat in the legislature after a year of sitting on the sidelines. He's running in one of three provincial byelections today as a candidate in Edmonton-Strathcona, where his predecessor Rachel Notley last won 80 per cent of the vote. In Edmonton-Ellerslie, NDP candidate Gurtej Singh Brar could solidify the opposition party's hold on the city, but United Conservative Party candidate Naresh Bhardwaj is hoping to make an inroad. In rural central Alberta, the separatist Republican Party of Alberta is aiming to capitalize on discontent with Ottawa. Republican leader Cameron Davies has been campaigning in Olds-Didsbury-Three Hills against the UCP's Tara Sawyer, the NDP's Bev Toews and Bill Tufts of the Wildrose Loyalty Coalition. The seat became vacant after former legislature speaker and long-time UCP member of the legislature Nathan Cooper resigned to take a post as Alberta's representative in Washington, D.C. Hudson's Bay to seek approval to sell three leases Hudson's Bay is expected back in court this morning where it will ask a judge to let it sell three of its leases to a B.C. mall owner. The defunct department store wants to transfer its leases for Tsawwassen Mills, Mayfair Shopping Centre and Woodgrove Centre to Ruby Liu. The real estate maven, who leads a company that owns all three malls, has offered $6 million for the trio of leases. She also wants up to 25 more leases at malls she does not own but Hudson's Bay is still working on getting approval from landlords, who are overwhelmingly objecting. Aside from the request to sell three leases to Liu, the Ontario Superior Court will also be asked to change the name of the department store company in creditor protection to avoid confusion that could arise now that Canadian Tire owns the rights to the Bay name. Ontario proposes to weaken pending recycling rules Ontario Premier Doug Ford's government is proposing to weaken an impending slate of new recycling rules because producers of the materials said the system is getting too expensive. The province began transitioning in 2023 toward making producers pay for the recycling of their packaging, paper and single-use items. The companies' obligations were set to increase next year, but the government is now looking to delay some measures and outright cancel others, such as requirements to extend collection beyond the residential system. Environmental advocates say the proposed changes let producers off the hook and will mean more materials will end up in landfills or be incinerated. Producers say despite the rising costs, recycling rates don't actually appear to be improving, so it's time for a broader rethink. Environment Minister Todd McCarthy said the proposed changes are about ensuring the sustainability of the blue box system and protecting against unintended consequences such as job losses. The Canadian Retail Council estimates that producer costs have already increased by about 350 per cent in three years and would nearly double again just from this year to next if no changes were made to the impending new rules for 2026. The government says blue box collection costs could more than double between 2020 and 2030. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 23, 2025.
Ottawa Citizen
40 minutes ago
- Ottawa Citizen
Today's letters: AI could radically alter bilingualism training in the public service
Article content So, some seven country leaders plus the EC leader met in a nice place in Alberta, a tough job for Mark Carney. He wisely invited a few more leaders to try to get a bit more balance in this group where five of the eight guests come from western Europe, an area that has lagged economically for more than a decade and does not have a common foreign policy. Article content At present, their economies are barely equivalent to that of China who is not invited. Article content It is no wonder that Donald Trump does not pay much attention to that group since he does not care too much about western Europe. In fact, nobody really does except the media and some traditional protesters. This group now is mostly a pleasant outing for some European leaders, with Japan tagging along Article content And what did they do? They could not deal with the major conflicts in Sudan, Ukraine, Israel-Iran and Israel-Palestinians, because the leaders involved in these conflicts were not there (apart from Volodymyr Zelenskyy who usually come to beg for more money and arms). So, the European leaders could only demonstrate their weaknesses by once again using 'strong language' and offering 'unwavering support.' Article content Article content The group did not achieve results in the trade war between the U.S. and the rest of the world either, because most of the rest of the world was not there and these trade issues are complex. Article content In contrast to his predecessor, Carney handled this social event smoothly and managed to get along with Trump, no mean task. This was the best that could be expected from a group clearly past its prime. Article content People who criticize inviting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to attend the G7 fail to understand the purpose of diplomacy. Article content Canada does not need diplomatic relations to deal with friendly countries. The prime ministers of Canada and the United Kingdom, for example, can phone or visit each other any time, discuss how to advance shared interests and any problems, then hand the issues over to their public servants. Article content Article content Diplomacy was developed so that the governments of countries that have real differences, that may be at war or drifting towards war, can communicate with each other frequently and safely. Then they can listen to each other, get a good understanding of the others' views instead of relying on rumours and the views of those who want confrontation, appreciate the dangers and seek solutions. Article content 'Punishing' a foreign government by refusing to talk to its leaders or expelling its ambassadors may satisfy some citizens, but our government was right to invite Modi to the G7, to have discussions with him, to keep most of them secret, and to restore high-level diplomatic relations. All it took was common sense, courage, and a phone call.
