Developers are bluffing when they say lower prices would undermine viability of house building
With full employment and buoyant public finances, Ireland has never been wealthier. Affluence, rather than insufficient home building, is the true source of our
housing challenges
.
Recognising this, and adopting more appropriate policies, is crucial to avoiding a deeper housing crisis.
In the popular debate, housing demand simply equals population growth. However, the economic definition of demand is the quantity of housing that society is willing and able to consume at each price.
Population growth is relevant to this. It creates competition that influences consumers' willingness to pay. But willingness does not translate into demand unless there is also an ability to pay. This explains why
the world's most densely populated cities
, which are in countries such as Bangladesh and Somalia, do not have the highest house prices.
READ MORE
Further emphasising the imperfect relationship between demography and housing demand, Bulgaria and Poland had the EU's hottest housing markets last year, despite contracting headcounts.
[
Residential construction fell 10% in first quarter of 2025 compared with last year, says CSO
Opens in new window
]
In Ireland, rising prices and rents signify that housing demand currently exceeds supply. Contrary to the mainstream view, this does not stem from demographic growth outstripping housing supply.
Between 2011 and 2022 the number of households in Ireland rose by 187,000. The housing stock only rose by 117,000, but the perception that this left a backlog of unmet housing need is mistaken, because 67,000 vacant homes were also reoccupied over the same period.
Together, these sources provided 184,000 units of accommodation – closely matching the growth in household numbers. Our economic definition helps explain how demand can exceed supply even when we are building enough homes for everyone.
This is possible because multiple factors, besides the number of bodies seeking beds, influence a society's willingness and ability to pay for housing. These include consumer preferences and wealth, with rich societies typically preferring, and having the resources, to live in smaller households.
All of this suggests that excess capital, rather than insufficient building, is the source of Ireland's housing challenges. This raises fundamental questions about the Government's fixation with increasing housing output.
Rather than striving to boost supply, Government should desist from fanning the flames of demand with subsidies such as
Help to Buy
and the First Home Scheme.
The unspoken purpose of these is to incentivise building by driving up property values. This is unnecessary and self-defeating. The State should subtract capital from the market by tightening credit conditions.
The Local Authority Home Loan is a flawed concept, while the
Central Bank of Ireland
's 2023 decision to relax mortgage rules unnecessarily fuelled demand. As a dominant buyer and renter of property, the State should also exercise its market power to pay less.
Government is frightened of flexing this muscle by the tacit threat of a developers' strike. Industry's trump card - which it recently played to have rent controls relaxed – is to scare up a panic that suppressing property values would undermine construction viability, causing the Government to miss its housing targets.
This is bluff. Developers only earn when they build, and development costs would adjust to reduced sales price expectations if the Government called it out.
Moreover, as outlined above, we are already constructing enough homes – regardless of what the industry-led targets say.
Six months ago, nobody was contemplating a global recession or plunging corporation tax receipts. But both are now clearly possible
Unfortunately, given the powerful interests that profit from housing development, none of this is likely. For now, the subsidies will remain and the State will continue competing against private households in the property market.
Consequently, house prices and rents will rise further. This is clearly negative for consumers. But higher rents and prices will draw out more supply and, somehow, this has become a greater political priority than providing affordable homes.
With population growth now slowing, increased housing output will unfold in one of two ways. If the economy remains strong, the additional homes will be occupied. By making sacrifices and taking on bigger mortgages, wealthier tenants and buyers will manage to fund themselves.
For the growing remainder, the State will simply increase the subsidies. The cost of this, and the environmental costs associated with excessive building, mean everyone will face higher taxes.
In this best-case scenario, the average household size will fall. Ireland currently has the EU's third-biggest households, and some consider this incongruous with our prosperity.
[
Median value of homes bought by first-time buyers has risen to nearly €372,000
Opens in new window
]
However, while Ireland's citizens aspire to small households like those in other wealthy countries, we also have the EU's highest proportion of children and teens. This makes larger households natural for us.
A salutary lesson can be learned from the last time affluence and ambition seduced us into overruling this reality.
Between 1996 and 2011, the average household size plunged from 3.14 to 2.73 persons. This was funded by prolific mortgage lending that facilitated a sharply reduced proportion of 18- to 34-year-olds living with their parents. However, the debt proved unsustainable when the economy turned, the banks failed, vacancy surged, the housing market crashed, the boomerang kids returned home and the average household size abruptly stopped falling.
We are in danger of repeating this mistake. This time, however, the State, rather than the commercial banks, is bankrolling the appetite for smaller households with its subsidies and schemes.
Six months ago, nobody was contemplating a global recession or plunging corporation tax receipts. But both are now clearly possible. In this scenario, the State would be unable to underwrite the occupancy of homes produced by excessive building targets – and we should know what follows.
Dr John McCartney is a lecturer in property economics at TU Dublin and adjunct associate professor at UCD
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Global stocks fluctuate as oil erases rally
Global equities were largely flat on Monday as investors vacillated over the US's entrance in Israel's war with Iran, and crude oil erased the rally that was expected after the White House launched air strikes on the Islamic Republic over the weekend. Dublin Slightly underperforming its European peers, the Iseq index closed the session down by almost 0.9 per cent after a tough day for aviation stocks globally. On relatively high volumes, shares in Ryanair slipped by 0.9 per cent to close at €22.90 per share. Jet fuel prices in Europe soared in early trading as oil prices climbed amid concerns about potential disruptions to oil supply stemming from war in the Middle East. READ MORE Irish bank shares also shed value, with Bank of Ireland sliding almost 1.6 per cent to close at €11.44 per share, AIB falling 0.7 per cent to €6.64 and PTSB closing down 1.7 per cent at €1.98. Shares in the up-for-sale hotels group Dalata slid by more than 1 per cent after announcing that the Pandox Consortium had increased its stake in the business. Dalata received and rejected a takeover bid from the group earlier this month. Kerry Group, up 0.3 per cent to €93.65 per share, and home builder Glenveagh, up 0.1 per cent to €1.74 were among the only stocks to finish the session in green. Europe European equities indices started and finished the session marginally in red, with the blue-chip Stoxx 50 closing down 0.2 per cent and the pan-European Stoxx 600 down 0.3 per cent. Dutch technology investor Prosus surged to the top of the blue-chip index, adding 3.5 per cent after swinging to a profit for the first time. Semiconductor stocks also rose with Dutch chipmaker ASML adding almost 3 per cent while its German rival Infineon jumped 1.1 per cent. Aviation stocks, meanwhile, sank amid fluctuating jet fuel prices and escalating tensions in the Middle East. Lufthansa fell 0.9 per cent, while Air France shed 1.8 per cent and Airbus was down by 0.3 per cent. Stellantis dropped by 2.1 per cent as the Fiat-maker's chief executive announced a reorganisation of top management at the struggling automaker. London A flat session saw the benchmark FTSE 100 and the mid-cap FTSE 250 close down by just over 0.1 per cent. Moving to the top of the mid-cap index, Spectris' shares jumped 15.3 per cent and hit a sixteen-month high after the company agreed to a £4.4 billion debt-inclusive takeover deal by private equity firm Advent over a rival proposal from KKR. Largely tracking shifts in crude oil prices, which touched five-month highs during the session before erasing much of the rally, shares in Shell and BP finished the session 0.2 per cent 0.4 per cent. The oil majors were up as much a 3 per cent earlier in the day. Airline stocks plummeted as carriers cancelled flights to the Middle East over safety concerns and jet fuel prices oscillated. Aer Lingus owner IAG dropped 1.4 per cent, EasyJet shed 2.4 per cent, and Wizz Air was off by 1.1 per cent on the mid-cap index. New York Wall Street's main indices dropped before paring losses on Monday after a Federal Reserve official hinted that more interest rate cuts are coming soon. The S&P 500, the Nasdaq Composite and the Dow Jones Industrial Average were all down by around 0.3 per cent at closing bell in Dublin. Tesla's shares rose 9.7 per cent after it deployed a small group of self-driving taxis picking up paying passengers on Sunday in Austin, Texas. Among other movers, drugmaker Eli Lilly edged up 0.7 per cent. Its rival Novo Nordisk fell 5.3 per cent after detailed trial data on its experimental obesity drug CagriSema failed to impress investors. Northern Trust surged 6.9 per cent after a Wall Street Journal report said Bank of New York Mellon approached the asset and wealth manager for a potential merger. – Additional reporting: Bloomberg, Reuters
Irish Times
29 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Legal challenges to Dart expansion plans dropped
The extension of Dart rail services to Maynooth, Co Kildare and the M3 Parkway near Dunboyne, Co Meath can finally go ahead following the withdrawal of legal action against the project . Irish Rail said it has reached a 'confidential settlement' with two parties which had taken judicial review proceedings blocking the €1 billion Dart+ West project granted permission by An Bord Pleanála last July. Burke Brothers, a hardware and electrical wholesale company close to the Navan Road and Ashtown train station, and its neighbour Gowan Motor Group, had separately challenged the board's decision to approve the project. The High Court had set June 23rd for hearing the judicial review challenges, but both have now been withdrawn. READ MORE Irish Rail said it hoped to award contracts for construction of the line by the end of next year with services to start from 2031. The project will double train services along the Maynooth line from six to 12 per hour per direction, increasing hourly passenger capacity from 5,000 to more than 13,000 each way. The extension of the Dart to Maynooth was part of the Government's Transport 21 strategy published in 2005. However, Dart expansion programmes fell victim to the economic crash and the project did not re-emerge until 2020, rebranded as Dart+. Irish Rail at that time intended to apply for permission for the Maynooth line in mid-2021, but following public consultations which resulted in changes to the project, it deferred submitting a railway order application to An Bord Pleanála until July 2022. The project is part of Irish Rail's plans for a major expansion of Dart services, which also includes the electrification of the rail line to Drogheda, Co Louth; Celbridge, Co Kildare; and a significant upgrade in capacity to Greystones, Co Wicklow. Once completed, the full Dart+ programme aims to treble the current network from 53km to 150km and the number of people living within one kilometre of a Dart station would increase from about 250,000 currently to 600,000.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Sky Ireland tells court it is not obliged to give end of contract notice
The communications regulator. ComReg, is seeking High Court orders requiring Sky Ireland Ltd to end its practice of automatically renewing customers' contracts without first informing them their contracts are about to end and of alternative tariffs. ComReg claims Sky is in breach of 2022 European Union regulations requiring communications service providers to inform consumers in a prominent and timely manner of the end of the contractual commitment and means by which to terminate the contract. It says Sky is also contravening the regulations by failing to provide consumers with 'best tariff advice' before the contract is automatically prolonged. Sky is the only one of the five big providers refusing to do so, ComReg says. Sky disputes ComReg's interpretation of the relevant legal provisions and says they only apply to contracts with a fixed duration. Its customers' contracts are subscription contracts of indeterminate duration, it says. READ MORE The regulations, Sky argues, are designed to address the potential harm of consumers getting automatically prolonged in the contract for a second term without their knowledge. This harm does not arise in relation to Sky customers as its contracts do not follow this type of model in Ireland, it argues. It also says the ultimate interpretation of the regulations is for the courts to decide. On Monday, Mr Justice Mark Sanfey admitted Comreg's proceedings against Sky to the fast track Commercial Court on the application of Eoin McCullough SC, for the regulator, and on consent from Andrew Fitzpatrick SC, for Sky. The case was adjourned to December. In an affidavit seeking entry of the case to the commercial list, Miriam Kilraine, ComReg compliance operations manager, said the purpose of end of contract information and best tariff advice, when a contract is nearing end and about to be 'auto-prolonged', is that customers are afforded an opportunity of making an informed decision to stay with their current provider on the same or different package or to switch to a new provider. This is important particularly as customers may be losing discounts and therefore incurring higher prices and, in the case of Sky customers, this could include bundled TV, broadband and telephone services, she said. As part of its review and enforcement functions, ComReg began an investigation last September and Virgin Media, Eircom, Three and Vodafone all confirmed they are in compliance but Sky said it did not do so. Further investigations into Sky followed and in December Sky said it would not be complying because of its interpretation of the regulations. Ms Kilraine said it is clear there is a fundamental disagreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the relevant legal provisions in this case. It is ComReg's position that Sky has failed and continues to fail to comply with its obligations under the 2022 regulations, she said. She also said Sky's UK arm, Sky UK Ltd, has taken a different position to its Irish counterpart and provides best tariff information to its customers. Th followed enforcement action against Sky UK by the UK watchdog, Ofcom, in 2021 which concluded in Ofcom's favour last December, Ms Kilraine said.
