Delay in convicted BJP MLA's disqualification upsets Opposition in Rajasthan
The delay in the disqualification of Bharatiya Janata Party MLA Kanwar Lal Meena, whose conviction in a 20-year-old case was upheld by the High Court, has upset the Opposition Congress in Rajasthan. The Congress has sought an immediate intervention of Governor Haribhau Bagade in the matter.
Mr. Meena, elected from Baran district's Anta, was sentenced to three years' rigorous imprisonment in a case of threatening a Rajasthan Administrative Service (RAS) officer with a revolver and damaging public property in Jhalawar. A sessions court convicted the MLA in December 2020, while the High Court upheld the order on May 1.
Mr. Meena moved a special leave petition (SLP) in the Supreme Court, which has directed him to surrender in the trial court in two weeks. The Congress has contended that Mr. Meena's membership of the Assembly should have been cancelled forthwith after the high court's judgment as per the Representation of the People Act, 1951.
Section 8(3) of the Act provides for the disqualification of a lawmaker following conviction for an offence with a two-year sentence or more. Assembly Speaker Vasudev Devnani has reportedly sought the opinion of Advocate-General and legal experts in the matter, but his decision is still awaited.
Mr. Meena, who has to surrender in the court by May 21, was not elected to the State Assembly at the time of the crime and already had 15 criminal cases against him. In 2016, he led a mob which allegedly attacked the activists of Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan, founded by Magsaysay Award winner Aruna Roy, during a march in Jhalawar district.
A two-time MLA, Mr. Meena first won the election from Jhalawar's Manohar Thana in 2013, and later from Anta in 2023.
Congress MLA and Leader of Opposition in the Assembly Tika Ram Jully, has shot off a letter to the Governor, while accusing the Speaker of deliberately delaying Mr. Meena's disqualification process. 'As per Article 191 of the Constitution and the provisions of the RP Act, an elected representative sentenced to more than two years stands automatically disqualified from holding office,' Mr. Jully said.
Mr. Jully said the Speaker's inaction in the matter was a 'blatant disregard of constitutional duty and democratic norms'. He urged the Governor to uphold the constitutional mandate and give direction for Mr. Meena's disqualification with effect from May 1, when the high court had upheld his conviction and sentence.
Mr. Jully pointed out that a similar decision was taken in 2016 when Bahujan Samaj Party MLA B.L. Kushwaha was sentenced to life imprisonment in a murder case. Mr. Kushwaha was disqualified and a by-election was held in his constituency, Dholpur. The high court had also rejected his plea to allow him to cast his vote in the Rajya Sabha election when he was incarcerated before his conviction.
However, Jhalawar Bar Association president Ram Maheshwari said the Supreme Court would hear Mr. Meena's SLP for admission after he surrenders. Any decision on Mr. Meena's membership of the Assembly would be subject to the judgment of the Supreme Court until his petition challenging the high court's verdict remains pending in the apex court, Mr. Maheshwari said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Wire
22 minutes ago
- The Wire
Priyank Kharge Asks Why MEA First Denied Him Clearance to Visit the US, Before Granting Permission Later
New Delhi: Congress leader and Karnataka minister Priyank Kharge on Saturday (June 21) said after initially denying him a clearance to visit the US, the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) has now granted him a clearance. Kharge questioned the reasons for this back and forth by the MEA and demanded an explanation. 'So in a U-turn, the Ministry of External Affairs has now decided to revoke its earlier decision and grant me a clearance for an official visit to the United States. I had sought permission on 15 May to travel between 14–27 June to represent the Government of Karnataka at two major global forums and over 25 official meetings with top companies, universities and institutions for collaborations and pitch for investments,' Kharge wrote on X on Saturday. Kharge added that the application for the visit of minister and officers' delegation to the US made on May 15 was rejected on June 4. Thereafter, another application for officers' delegation without Minister made on June 6 was cleared on June 11. 'My application was denied without any official explanation. On 19 June, I addressed a press conference, laying out the full chronology, questioning the basis of the denial and raising concerns about possible political interference. The matter was widely reported in the media. By the evening of the same day, the MEA revoked its earlier denial and issued a No Objection clearance dated 19 June,' said Kharge. He added that the clearance was received 36 days after his original application, 15 days after the official denial and five days after his scheduled departure. 'The timing raises serious questions: Why was the clearance denied in the first place? Was the previous order revoked to avoid accountability after the matter became public? What is the point of granting clearance after the key events are either over or nearing completion? Will the MEA now avoid explaining the original decision by pointing to the belated approval?' asked Kharge. Kharge was scheduled to attend the BIO International Convention in Boston and the Design Automation Conference (DAC) in San Francisco, Deccan Herald had earlier reported. 'While the Centre gives us slogans like 'Make in India,' 'Digital India', 'National Quantum Mission' and 'India AI Mission,' the real work to realise these aspirations is happening here in Karnataka. They coin the vision, but when we do the work to bring investments, create jobs and position India as a global leader – they block us,' he added. Kharge said that Karnataka deserves answer on the issue. 'The Prime Minister once said MAGA MIGA = MEGA. But what does that even mean in practice, when the very state driving India's tech and innovation engine is denied the support it needs to lead globally?' said Kharge.
News18
25 minutes ago
- News18
'Usual Mix Of Lies': BJP Responds With 'Reality' To Rahul's 'Claims' Over PM's 'Make-In-India'
Last Updated: BJP leader Vishnu Vardhan Reddy accused Rahul Gandhi of "mixing lies, drama, and twisting facts". The Bharatiya Janata Party on Saturday attacked Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha and Congress MP Rahul Gandhi after he criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi saying that despite promises of a "Make in India" factory boom, manufacturing in the country is at a record low and youth unemployment is very high. Rejecting the Congress leader's claim, the BJP leader and the party's Andhra Pradesh vice-president, Vishnu Vardhan Reddy, accused Rahul Gandhi of 'mixing lies, drama, and twisting facts". Elaborating on Rahul Gandhi's claims over the effectiveness of the 'Make in India" initiative, the BJP leader took to X and listed out the Congress leader's 'claims" with 'reality check". Rahul Gandhi at it again with his usual mix of lies, drama, and twisted facts. Here's a simple takedown of his latest claims on 'Make in India":* Claim: Manufacturing is downReality: India is now the 2nd largest mobile maker, rising in semiconductors, defence, EVs, solar… — Vishnu Vardhan Reddy (@SVishnuReddy) June 21, 2025 He also pointed to rising youth unemployment and a doubling of imports from China, accusing Prime Minister Narendra Modi of focusing on slogans rather than real solutions. In a post on X, Rahul Gandhi shared a video and wrote, 'Make in India" promised a factory boom. So why is manufacturing at record lows, youth unemployment at record highs, and why have imports from China more than doubled? Modi ji has mastered the art of slogans, not solutions. Since 2014, manufacturing has fallen to 14% of our economy." 'Make in India" promised a factory boom. So why is manufacturing at record lows, youth unemployment at record highs, and why have imports from China more than doubled?Modi ji has mastered the art of slogans, not solutions. Since 2014, manufacturing has fallen to 14% of our… — Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) June 21, 2025 The Congress leader also highlighted the challenges faced by India's youth. "With no new ideas, Modi ji has surrendered. Even the much-hyped PLI scheme is now being quietly rolled back. India needs a fundamental shift – one that empowers lakhs of producers through honest reforms and financial support. We must stop being a market for others. If we don't build here, we'll keep buying from those who do. The clock is ticking," the post read.
Indian Express
34 minutes ago
- Indian Express
‘Mastered art of slogans, not solutions': Rahul Gandhi takes dig at PM Modi over India's ‘record low' manufacturing
Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Saturday said Prime Minister Narendra Modi has mastered the 'art of slogans' but offers no solutions, and claimed that India's manufacturing was at a record low despite the 'Make in India' initiative. ''Make in India' promised a factory boom. So why is manufacturing at record lows, youth unemployment at record highs, and why have imports from China more than doubled? 'Modi ji has mastered the art of slogans, not solutions. Since 2014, manufacturing has fallen to 14 per cent of our economy,' he said in a post on X. 'Make in India' promised a factory boom. So why is manufacturing at record lows, youth unemployment at record highs, and why have imports from China more than doubled? Modi ji has mastered the art of slogans, not solutions. Since 2014, manufacturing has fallen to 14% of our… — Rahul Gandhi (@RahulGandhi) June 21, 2025 Gandhi, the leader of opposition in Lok Sabha, said Modi has 'no new ideas' and has 'surrendered'. 'Even the much-hyped PLI scheme is now being quietly rolled back,' he alleged. Gandhi said India needs a fundamental shift, one that empowers lakhs of producers through honest reforms and financial support. 'We must stop being a market for others. If we don't build here, we'll keep buying from those who do. The clock is ticking,' he said. Gandhi met mobile repair technicians at Nehru Place, Delhi and attached a video of the conversation to the post. 'In Nehru Place, New Delhi, I met Shivam and Saif – bright, skilled, full of promise – yet denied the opportunity to fulfil it.' Noting that there is a difference between 'Made in India' and 'Assembled in India', he said: 'The truth is stark: we assemble, we import, but we don't build. China profits.' 'China is the world's electronic market. There is no other electronic market anywhere. Assembly as many iPhones as you want, all you are doing is giving money to the big oligopolies of India. Start making iPhones, it's a completely different ball game,' he said in the video. The former Congress chief said to manufacture parts, whether it is a motherboard or 'small pieces', you need a certain level of machining, a certain level of quality, a certain level of understanding of tolerances of working with small components. 'That is a learnt skill. That is not something you can get in just two minutes. Until you start respecting the idea of physical labour, the man who is doing that work…But we have no respect for that guy on the street who is sitting there, selling his things, for hours together…' 'And, at the centre of it, and people don't like it when I say it, and at the centre of it is the idea of caste. We need to make this transparent. We need to show exactly how Indian society distributes power, exactly how Indian society distributes respect,' Gandhi observed. Rahul Gandhi and the Congress have raised the issue of conducting a nationwide caste census to ascertain if various castes in society have a proportionate 'share' of power.
