Uber's new shuttles look suspiciously familiar to anyone who's taken a bus
Every few years, a Silicon Valley gig-economy company announces a 'disruptive' innovation that looks a whole lot like a bus. Uber rolled out Smart Routes a decade ago, followed a short time later by the Lyft Shuttle of its biggest competitor. Even Elon Musk gave it a try in 2018 with the 'urban loop system' that never quite materialized beyond the Vegas Strip. And does anyone remember Chariot?
Now it's Uber's turn again. The ride-hailing company recently announced Route Share, in which shuttles will travel dozens of fixed routes, with fixed stops, picking up passengers and dropping them off at fixed times. Amid the inevitable jokes about Silicon Valley once again discovering buses are serious questions about what this will mean for struggling transit systems, air quality, and congestion.
Uber promised the program, which rolled out in seven cities at the end of May, will bring 'more affordable, more predictable' transportation during peak commuting hours.
'Many of our users, they live in generally the same area, they work in generally the same area, and they commute at the same time,' Sachin Kansal, the company's chief product officer, said during the company's May 14 announcement. 'The concept of Route Share is not new,' he admitted — though he never used the word 'bus.' Instead, pictures of horse-drawn buggies, rickshaws, and pedicabs appeared onscreen.
CEO Dara Khosrowshahi was a bit more forthcoming when he told The Verge the whole thing is 'to some extent inspired by the bus.' The goal, he said, 'is just to reduce prices to the consumer and then help with congestion and the environment.'
But Kevin Shen, who studies this sort of thing at the Union of Concerned Scientists, questions whether Uber's 'next-gen bus' will do much for commuters or the climate. 'Everybody will say, 'Silicon Valley's reinventing the bus again,'' Shen said. 'But it's more like they're reinventing a worse bus.'
Five years ago, the Union of Concerned Scientists released a report that found ride-share services emit 69 percent more planet-warming carbon dioxide and other pollutants than the trips they displace — largely because as many as 40 percent of the miles traveled by Uber and Lyft drivers are driven without a passenger, something called 'deadheading.' That climate disadvantage decreases with pooled services like UberX Share — but it's still not much greener than owning and driving a vehicle, the report noted, unless the car is electric.
Beyond the iffy climate benefit lie broader concerns about what this means for the transit systems in New York, San Francisco, Chicago, Philadelphia, Dallas, Boston, and Baltimore — and the people who rely on them.
'Transit is a public service, so a transit agency's goal is to serve all of its customers, whether they're rich or poor, whether it's the maximum profit-inducing route or not,' Shen said. The entities that do all of this come with accountability mechanisms — boards, public meetings, vocal riders — to ensure they do what they're supposed to. 'Barely any of that is in place for Uber.' This, he said, is a pivot toward a public-transit model without public accountability.
Compounding the threat, Philadelphia and Dallas have struggling transit systems at risk of defunding. The situation is so dire in Philly that it may cut service by nearly 45 percent on July 1 amid a chronic financial crisis. (That, as one Reddit user pointed out, would be good news for Uber.)
Meanwhile, the federal government is cutting support for public services, including transit systems — many of which still haven't fully recovered from COVID-era budget crunches. Though ridership nationwide is up to 85 percent of pre-pandemic levels, Bloomberg News recently estimated that transit systems across the country face a $6 billion budget shortfall. So it's easy to see why companies like Uber see a business opportunity in public transit.
Khosrowshahi insists Uber is 'in competition with personal car ownership,' not public transportation. 'Public transport is a teammate,' he told The Verge. But a study released last year by the University of California, Davis found that in three California cities, over half of all ride-hailing trips didn't replace personal cars, they replaced more sustainable modes of getting around, like walking, public transportation, and bicycling.
And then there's the fact cities like New York grapple with chronic congestion and don't need more vehicles cluttering crowded streets. During Uber's big announcement, Kansal showed a video of one possible Route Share ride in the Big Apple. It covered about 3 miles from Midtown to Lower Manhattan, which would take about 30 minutes and cost $13.
But here's the thing: The addresses are served by three different subway lines. It is possible to commute between those two points, avoid congestion, and arrive sooner, for $2.90. So, yes, Uber Route Share is cheaper than Uber's standard car service (which has gotten 7.2 percent pricier in the past year) — but Route Share is far from the most efficient or economical way to get around in the biggest markets it's launching in.
'If anything,' Shen said, 'it's reducing transit efficiency by gumming up those same routes with even more vehicles.'
This story was originally published by Grist with the headline Uber's new shuttles look suspiciously familiar to anyone who's taken a bus on Jun 3, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
20 minutes ago
- Business Insider
Tesla officially launches robotaxis in Austin to a small group of users, charging a $4.20 flat fee per ride
On a balmy Sunday in Austin, Tesla fans awaited the promise of the future. After a few hours of delays, that promise finally came true, and a select group took their first rides, livestreaming their experience. While Tesla robotaxis are meant to be fully autonomous, Tesla employees were still present in the passenger seat of the cars for safety reasons. Earlier this month, Tesla CEO Elon Musk teased the launch of the robotaxi, a driverless Tesla Model Y emblazoned with its namesake in Cybertruck-style font. "Beautifully simple design," Musk wrote on X. "These are unmodified Tesla cars coming straight from the factory, meaning that every Tesla coming out of our factories is capable of unsupervised self-driving," he added. On Sunday, Musk said the first Tesla robotaxi rides would be available for a flat fee of $4.20. A small group of invited users was the first to try them out. Tesla fans buzzed on social media in the lead-up to the official launch, which was initially delayed as users awaited the release of the official Tesla robotaxi app. "We are approaching the window where we expected to have the app and showing everything," Chuck Cook, one of the early invitees to try the Tesla robotaxi, said on X. "There looks like there will be a small delay in the distribution of the app for couple hours." Tesla AI, the division behind the robotaxis, said Sunday on X that Tesla robotaxis will eventually be deployed anywhere they are approved and are designed for "scalability." "It does not require expensive, specialized equipment or extensive mapping of service areas. It just works," the company said. The company launched a website where users can sign up for early access when the service becomes available in their area. It also launched an X feed dedicated to Tesla robotaxis. With the launch of Tesla robotaxis, Austin continued to solidify itself as a new theater for Silicon Valley's race to shape the new age of driverless transportation. In March, Google-backed Waymo launched its autonomous ride-hailing service in partnership with Uber. Waabi, a Canadian startup backed by Uber and Nvidia, is set to launch fully autonomous trucks in Texas this year. Zoox, backed by Amazon, opened its first robotaxi serial production facility in Austin last week. This is a developing story. Check back for updates.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Musk says robotaxi to launch in Austin, Texas on Sunday afternoon
(Reuters) -Tesla has started testing robotaxis with passengers in Austin, Texas, CEO Elon Musk said on Sunday, with customers paying a flat fee of $4.20, as the electric vehicle maker looks to roll out the much-anticipated service and gain a foothold in the self-driving technology race. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Business Insider
3 hours ago
- Business Insider
Tesla's robotaxi plans to 'launch' for a limited number of users in Austin. Here's what we know.
Tesla's robotaxi service launch in Austin is expected Sunday, and some are already being spotted on the road. The anticipated launch comes years after several missed deadlines and an increasingly competitive — but shrinking — field. General Motors's Cruise recently bowed out of the race, but Alphabet's Waymo has continuously ramped up its service and is now providing 250,000 rides a week in the San Francisco Bay Area, Los Angeles, Phoenix, and Austin, according to the company. There's also Amazon's Zoox, which makes its own purpose-built robotaxi, and other software-focused companies that hope to provide autonomous driving features to original equipment manufacturer vehicles. However, Elon Musk swears by Tesla's approach to autonomy. On June 10, Musk reshared a video of a driverless Tesla with " Robotaxi" written on the side in Cybertruck font, making a left turn in Austin. He called its design "beautifully simple." "These are unmodified Tesla cars coming straight from the factory, meaning that every Tesla coming out of our factories is capable of unsupervised self-driving," Musk said in another tweet. During the company's Q1 earnings call in April, Musk described Tesla's self-driving capabilities as a "generalized solution using artificial intelligence." The CEO has touted this approach before, which refers to Tesla's reliance on cameras, as opposed to a pricey hardware stack made up of sensors and cameras, and an AI that will use the visual input to drive the vehicle. This could allow for Tesla to scale autonomy quicker and at lower costs since, in theory, any Tesla model could be deployed as a robotaxi. "I predict there will be millions of Teslas operating autonomously — fully autonomously — in the second half of next year," Musk said during the call. Musk recently provided more details about the coming robotaxi launch. Here's what we now know about Tesla's robotaxi service — and some lingering questions. What will Tesla's planned robotaxi rollout look like? Morgan Stanley analyst Adam Jonas, who recently visited Tesla's Palo Alto office, said that the robotaxi launch will take place on public roads and will be "invite only." Jonas also wrote that there will be "plenty of tele-ops to ensure safety levels." Teleoperators refer to remote workers who can take some control of the vehicle if the autonomous driver gets stuck. This strategy differs from Waymo and Zoox, which also have remote human workers to provide suggestions or information about a potential path forward if a driver gets stuck. BI previously reported that there had been discussion around using remote operators as safety drivers for the debut. How many robotaxis will be at the launch? It'll start small. Musk said in a May 20 interview with CNBC that Tesla will launch with around 10 robotaxis in the first week. The automaker will "then increase it to 20, 30, 40," Musk said. "It will probably be at 1,000 within a few months," Musk said. Tesla was careful to call the robotaxi service we'll see in June a "pilot" rollout in the automaker's first quarter earnings call, which hints at the limited scale of the initial launch. Musk has said he plans to expand the robotaxis to other cities, like San Francisco, following the Austin rollout, although he hasn't given an exact timeline on the expansion. "We just want to put our toe in the water, make sure everything is OK, then put a few more toes in the water, then put a foot in the water," Musk said during Tesla's fourth quarter earnings call in January. "With safety of the general public and those in the car as our top priority." By the end of 2026, Musk said there could be over 1 million self-driving Teslas in the country. "Once we make it work in a few cities, we can basically make it work in all cities in that legal jurisdiction," he said during a first-quarter earnings call. Which Tesla cars will be used for the robotaxi launch? The first set of Tesla robotaxis is expected to be Model Ys through a software update, according to Musk. The car spotted in Austin appears to be a refreshed Model Y with a robotaxi logo printed on its side. "With the software update, it will become autonomous," Musk said in the company's first quarter earnings call. "To be clear, the Model Ys that we're talking about being autonomous in Austin in June are the Model Ys we make currently. There's no change to it." It's unclear if the first batch of robotaxis will be managed directly by Tesla or if it will consist of privately owned Teslas through which owners will opt in to the service. The CEO also clarified that the Cybercab is a separate product. In October 2024, Tesla unveiled a purpose-built, two-door robotaxi with no steering wheel. "We've got a product called the Cybercab," he said during the first-quarter earnings call. "And then if any Tesla — which could be a (model) S, 3, X, or Y that is autonomous — is a robotic taxi or robotaxi. It's very confusing." What will the business model look like? Musk has compared the robotaxi business model to "some combination of Airbnb and Uber." Musk said during the CNBC interview that Tesla has "millions of cars that will be able to operate autonomously," and Tesla owners will have the opportunity to "earn money by adding their car to the fleet for autonomous use." "It's a combination of a Tesla-owned fleet and also enabling Tesla owners to be able to add or subtract their car to the fleet," Musk said. Musk added in the interview that Tesla owners could make more in allowing the car to be added to the self-driving fleet than the lease would cost. The Tesla CEO has previously said owners could earn about $30,000 a year from the service. "Just like Airbnb, you can rent out your spare bedroom or your house if you're not using it, and make money on it," Musk said. "And that's what we expect Tesla customers to be able to do." Tesla has yet to unveil the commercial version of its FSD Unsupervised software. The software will be used in the robotaxi fleet and doesn't need a driver behind the wheel like its personal vehicles. How can we order a Tesla robotaxi in June? Tesla teased its ride-hailing mobile app last year. A video of the app reveals a user requesting the service by pressing a black-and-white circle with the word "summon." Within a few seconds, the app shows a map of a car three minutes from the pickup location. The app also allows users to adjust the climate settings before it arrives. As of Sunday morning, several invited participants said they were still waiting for the app's release. So, when will we get the Cybercab? Tesla's Cybercab was unveiled at the "We, Robot" event last October. It's also a robotaxi, but it's a bit further out than the service launch date. Volume production of Cybercab is still on schedule for 2026, Lars Moravy, Tesla's vice president of vehicle engineering, said during the company's first quarter earnings call. Moravy said that the company is currently at the "B-sample validation" of the vehicle, which means Tesla is building the prototype of the car but using material that will be close to the final product. "Big builds" or the next stage of vehicle-building before volume production is coming at the end of the second quarter, Moravy said. Tesla anticipates that it will be able to pump out Cybercabs quickly at scale by using what the company calls its "unboxed" method of manufacturing. Traditional car manufacturers build cars on an assembly line. Tesla is betting on a new method where different parts of the car are simultaneously assembled and then later combined.
