Murder, morality, and free speech: A killing that split public conscience

The justification of social media influencer Kamal Kaur alias Kanchan Kumari's murder by Sri Akal Takht Sahib head priest Malkit Singh has raised a troubling question: is society willing to risk freedom of speech and expression in favour of moral policing?
Harjeshwar Pal Singh, assistant professor of history at SGGS College, Chandigarh, said the murder, allegedly committed by Amritpal Singh Mehron and his associates, was not just a criminal act but also 'an assault on freedom of speech.'
'No one in a society has the business to dictate what others should wear, eat, think, or how they should behave—and no one has the right to take another person's life for their views or lifestyle. It is unjustifiable and barbaric,' he said.
He added that the widespread online support for such acts reveals deepening polarisation and radicalisation in society. 'There are enough laws around 'indecency' and 'outraging public morality' that can be updated to include social media. The problem is these laws are often applied selectively, usually by the state to serve its own political purposes. Giving the state more such powers only strengthens its hand against the individual,' he said.
Kiranjot Kaur, member of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee, said the Akal Takht head priest should have avoided making any remarks at all. 'But also, if anything posted on social media falls under freedom of speech, then why do we have a censor board? If the concern is that governments might use social media restrictions to silence criticism, that's already happening. Most mainstream media is toeing the government line.'
Social and environmental activist Gangveer Rathour also condemned the murder but questioned the inconsistency in how freedom of speech is applied. 'In 2022, Punjab Police booked an 11-year-old after his father posted a photo of him with a licensed weapon. If vulgar content is protected under free speech, why doesn't the same logic apply to that image? You can't show weapons, but you can show bodies? It's a delusion to think that restricting vulgar content will somehow empower the government to stifle dissent—it already does that regardless.'
Writer and director Pali Bhupinder Singh said, 'What the law doesn't prohibit falls within the scope of freedom of speech and expression. Even the censor board functions mostly to suppress critical voices—just look at the movie Punjab 95. It didn't block vulgar content, but it did block dissent. Censorship is always a tool of control.'
He added, 'People argue that mobile phones are in children's hands, so content should be censored. But the question is, why are children on phones unsupervised in the first place? And even if they are, who is responsible for teaching them how to use them? Moral policing—especially when done violently or by those misusing religious identity—is indefensible.'
Film and media critic Harpreet Singh said the murder was 'a shock to a civilised society' and pointed out that it has only intensified a pre-existing ideological divide.
'Kanchan Kumari made low-quality videos, yes, but there was clearly an audience for them. And while her murder can never be justified, the debate that followed has not been a debate at all—it has become a contest of entrenched opinions, motivated by hate, outrage, or ideological agendas,' he said.
He traced the trajectory of vulgarity in popular culture to mainstream media. 'B-grade cinema was once the domain of sleaze. But when Sunny Leone entered the family space via Bigg Boss, it quietly normalised sexual content. With smartphones and 4G, that boundary blurred further. Today, people from ordinary households create reels with similar themes. It's not just celebrities anymore—it's everyday content creators.'
'Between society, family, and discipline lies a delicate code that balances law, morality, and freedom of expression. But neither side is truly ready for an honest conversation—neither those who demand complete freedom, nor those who call for limits and censorship.'
Closing the debate, Punjab State Women's Commission Chairperson Raj Lali Gill said the Commission, in coordination with legal experts, will take strict action against those producing and circulating such material.
'The increasing use of vulgar language and explicit content on social media is having a harmful impact on children and society at large,' she said. 'We cannot allow the misuse of freedom of expression to promote obscenity. Those who are creating and profiting from such content will be dealt with under relevant sections of the IT Act.'
Gill added that freedom of speech must be exercised responsibly and within the bounds of social and legal norms. 'Both girls and boys should refrain from engaging in or encouraging objectionable content online,' she said.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

4 hours ago

• Time of India

Punjab Police Constable Recruitment 2025: Applied for 1,746 vacancies? Answer key released, objection window open, here's how to challenge errors

The Punjab Police has released the answer key for the Computer-Based Test ( CBT ) conducted to recruit constables in the District and Armed Police Cadres. Candidates who appeared for the exam can now check their responses and raise objections, if any, on the official website, until 7 PM on June 23, 2025. What was the exam for? This recruitment drive is to fill 1,746 constable vacancies. Online applications were accepted from 21 February to 13 March, and the CBT took place in phases from 4 May to 8 June. Admit cards were released according to the exam dates. The recruitment process includes four steps: Computer-Based Test (CBT) Physical Screening Test (PST) Physical Measurement Test (PMT) Document Verification Answer Key and Objection Window The answer key has been published for all exam phases, including the last round of exams held between 31 May and 8 June. Candidates are advised to review their recorded answers and check for any mistakes. If they spot any errors, they can raise objections through the online portal on the Punjab Police website. The objection window is open from 7 PM on 21 June to 7 PM on 23 June. Live Events The CBT was held in both English and Punjabi to make it easier for all candidates. Who is eligible? To apply, candidates must: Be Indian citizens Be aged between 18 and 28 Have passed 10+2 (or equivalent) Have passed Matriculation with Punjabi as a subject Both male and female candidates can apply. The minimum height requirement is: 5 feet 7 inches (170.2 cm) for men 5 feet 2 inches (157.5 cm) for women Postings could be anywhere in Punjab or even outside the country in some cases. Application Fees General category: Rs 1,200 SC/ST and EWS: Rs 700 Ex-servicemen and their family members: Rs 500 How to check the answer key and raise objections Go to Click on the 'Constable 2025 – District and Armed Police Cadres' recruitment section Select the link to view the CBT answer key Log in using your registration details To raise objections, click on 'Raise Objection', upload any supporting documents, and submit before the deadline Make sure you submit accurate details. Once the deadline passes, the police will not accept any further objections. What happens next? After the answer key is finalised and results are declared, shortlisted candidates will be called for the PST and PMT (physical tests). These are only qualifying in nature. Then comes the document verification before the final selection. Candidates should only follow updates from the official Punjab Police website to avoid any confusion or fake news.

New Indian Express

12 hours ago

• New Indian Express

Punjab Police book IAS officer, husband for attempted murder; gunman arrested

CHANDIGARH: Punjab IAS officer Babita Kaler, husband Stephen Kaler, and gunman Shubh Karan Singh have been booked by the Punjab Police on charges of attempt to murder; the gunman has been arrested. As per the complaint given to the police, the gunman shot at and injured the manager of an industrial house following a dispute over the dumping of sand onto a vacant plot adjacent to the Kalers' house in Chhoti Baradari area of Jalandhar. The manager, Harpreet Singh, was shot in the thigh and later admitted to the civil hospital, sources said. On Saturday, a case was registered against the three persons under Sections 109 (attempt to murder), 115(2) (voluntarily causing hurt) and 61(2) (criminal conspiracy) of the BNS and Arms Act. One Lakhbir Singh said, based on the plot owner's direction, the workers had started dumping sand to fill the land. However, the immediate neighbours--the IAS officer and her husband--asked them to stop the work and started misbehaving with the workers. "In the scuffle, Kaler's gunman opened fire," he alleged.

Hindustan Times

13 hours ago

• Hindustan Times

Punjab Police Constable Recruitment 2025: Objection window closes tomorrow at punjabpolice.gov.in, link here

Punjab Police will be closing the window to file objections against the provisional answer key for constable recruitment examination 2025 on Monday, June 23, 2025. Candidates who wish to challenge the answer key can do so on the official website of Punjab Police at Punjab Police Constable Recruitment 2025: Objection window closes on June 23 at Candidates can click on the direct link given here, Candidates should note that the link to challenge the answer key will be active till 7 PM. The Punjab Police Constable Recruitment CBT - 1 Computer-Based Test) Examination 2025 was conducted on May 4 to June 8, 2025. As per the schedule, the answer key was released and objection window was opened on June 21, 2025. Also read: DU calls 'Muslim' as language a clerical error after outrage over Urdu omission It may be mentioned here that the selection process for the recruitment of Punjab Police constables includes three stages: Stage 1 consists of two common Computer Based Test (CBT), multiple Choice Question (MCQ) type Paper, namely Paper-I and Paper-II, of which Paper-II shall be qualifying in nature. Also read: JoSAA Counselling 2025: Seat acceptance, fee payment for Round 1 ends today at direct link here Whereas Stage 2 includes Physical Screening Test (PST) and Physical Measurement Test (PMT). Both Physical Screening Test and Physical Measurement Test will be qualifying in nature. Stage 3 consists of Document Scrutiny. Also read: TS ICET Answer Key 2025: Objection window opens today at here's how to challenge answer key Through this recruitment exam, Punjab Police aims to fill tentatively 1,746 vacancies are to be filled through this recruitment drive. Of this, 1,261 vacancies are for District Police Cadre and 485 are for Armed Police Cadre. Punjab Police Recruitment 2025: How to submit objections Candidates can follow the steps mentioned below to submit objections against the answer key: Visit the official website at On the home page, click on the Recruitment tab. Click on the link for Punjab Police Recruitment 2025. Enter your credentials to log in, and submit. Check the answer key and click on the option to submit objections, as required. Submit your objection supported by valid proof. Download your confirmation page and keep a printout of the same for future reference. For more details, candidates are advised to visit the official website of Punjab Police.