SNP councillors defy Swinney over Kneecap TRNSMT ban call

Kneecap have faced a slew of cancelled gigs in recent weeks after videos emerged appearing to show the band calling for MPs to be killed.
READ MORE
The trio have apologised to the families of murdered politicians but claimed footage of the incident had been 'exploited and weaponised'.
The videos emerged after their performance at Coachella music festival in the US where they ended their set with pro-Palestinian messages.
The first message said: "Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people," followed by: "It is being enabled by the US government who arm and fund Israel despite their war crimes."
Shortly after the set, footage of the group at a November 2023 gig then emerged online, appearing to show one member saying: "The only good Tory is a dead Tory. Kill your local MP."
There have been calls for the band to be axed from TRNSMT (Image: Newsquest) First Minister John Swinney condemned the group's language as 'completely and utterly unacceptable'.
He told reporters: 'There is no way that is acceptable in a debate about free speech, it is completely beyond the pale.
'I think that makes it incredibly difficult for a band like Kneecap to perform at TRNSMT — I think they have crossed a line, to be honest.'
At a meeting of Glasgow City Council on Thursday, Scottish Green councillor Jon Molyneux tabled a motion about Gaza, which condemned Israel and accused it of genocide.
It also noted its "concern about the reaction to Irish musical act Kneecap's performance at California's Coachella Music Festival and the resulting smear campaign, which has included calls by politicians for Kneecap to be removed from this year's TRNSMT festival on Glasgow Green."
He linked the calls to ban Kneecap to their criticism of the Israeli government. He urged colleagues to resist attempts to 'shut them up'.
He said: 'The other threat we must counter is the increasing efforts by pro-Israel groups to silence those voicing opposition to its actions. The highest-profile example of this, which is mentioned in the motion, is the Irish band Kneecap. But they are by no means alone in this. There are countless other examples here in Scotland and elsewhere.
'I want to be absolutely clear, I do not condone Kneecap's previous on-stage comments about politicians. I think they were stupid comments to make, and it is right they should be held to account for them — and they have apologised for the hurt they have caused.
'But while some of those who have called for them to be cancelled might best be described as pearl-clutching, others have done so unashamedly because of the band's pro-Palestine views and their appearance at the Coachella Festival in particular.
'This is deliberate. This is an attempt to shut them up, and we should not indulge this.'
READ MORE
SNP leader Susan Aitken said many people had been 'genuinely upset' by the emergence of comments about killing Conservative MPs and that 'the anger in many quarters was a sincere response to those comments'.
She added: 'The UK is a state where MPs have been murdered in recent years, and, as I have said previously today, words can and do matter.
'What I would add, however, is that that — certainly not on the part of the SNP group — does not translate into support for a ban on them playing in Glasgow, or indeed anywhere else.
'Nor does it take away from the point that the condemnation of Kneecap, particularly in the United States, does appear to be driven by a wider dislike of their stances — not only their position in support of the Palestinian people, but also their general stance of satirical provocation.
'Pop music, since it has existed, has generated outrage, and satire does characterise much of Kneecap's performances and personality. They are about being provocative.'
She said provocative statements by artists should not always be taken literally or assumed to be a call to arms.
'That is the role of art — to provoke. It is the role of art to make us uncomfortable.
'And we have to recognise also that artistic freedom applies to artists whose output is not to our tastes, whose outlooks are not to our tastes.
'Freedom, if it means anything, has to be for everyone. Freedom of expression has to be for everyone.'
Labour said they could not support the Green motion.
Councillor Bill Butler told the full council: 'I know something of satire, as do many people here, having studied it, and what we are discussing here is not A Modest Proposal by Swift or The Mask of Anarchy by Shelley.
"We are opposing — or considering — someone calling for murder, plain and simple. And murder is not satire, because we are talking about the murder of thousands of people before our very eyes.
'And freedom of expression should not be confused with licence to say anything — you cannot simply shout 'fire' in a crowded theatre because you want to.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The National

34 minutes ago

• The National

BBC axes Gaza doctors documentary over 'impartiality'

Gaza: Doctors Under Attack explored the destruction of the health service in Gaza under Israel's brutal bombardment, and was reportedly ready to be broadcast in February. We told how the documentary was shelved last month following the controversy around How to Survive a Warzone, which featured the son of a Hamas official. READ MORE: UK Government 'set to proscribe Palestine Action after RAF protest' The production firm behind Gaza: Doctors Under Attack, Basement Films, said at the time that the BBC had postponed airing their film until after a review into How to Survive a Warzone is complete. However, despite the fact that this review remains ongoing, the BBC has now officially scrapped plans to show the documentary after concluding that it "risked creating a perception of partiality" over the corporation's coverage of Israel and Gaza. In a statement published on Friday, the BBC said: 'Our aim was to find a way to air some of the material in our news programmes, in line with our impartiality standards, before the review was published. "For some weeks, the BBC has been working with Basement Films to find a way to tell the stories of these doctors on our platforms.' It added: 'Yesterday it became apparent that we have reached the end of the road with these discussions. "We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC. "Impartiality is a core principle of BBC News. It is one of the reasons that we are the world's most trusted broadcaster." READ MORE: Presiding Officer to step down at Holyrood election The BBC said it was transferring ownership of the film material to Basement Films, and that the documentary had "not undergone the BBC's final pre-broadcast sign-off processes", as some reports had suggested. The corporation also "thank[ed" those who contributed to the documentary and said "we are sorry we could not tell their stories". The BBC has been increasingly accused of failing to report on Israel's assault on Gaza in an impartial manner. A report published this week by the Centre for Media Monitoring found that the corporation's coverage showed a "pattern of bias, double standards and silencing of Palestinian voices". It found that the word massacre(d) was used 18 times more frequently in the context of Israeli deaths than Palestinian deaths in BBC articles. Emotive terms such as 'atrocities', 'slaughter', 'barbaric', 'deadly', 'brutal' were used four times more often when reporting on Israeli victims, while 'murder(ed)' was used 220 times in the Israeli context and just once for Palestinians. The report analysed a total of 3873 articles and 32,092 TV and radio broadcasts between October 7, 2023 to October 7, 2024.

The Herald Scotland

41 minutes ago

• The Herald Scotland

Alison Johnstone to stand down from Holyrood ahead of 2026

She told The Times: "I was elected in 2011 and it was always my intention that this would be my last term in Holyrood. 'I came from a wholly non-political background and got involved in a campaign to save a school playing field​. Read More: 'I was not in a political party but campaigned for the creation of a Scottish parliament​ and I then worked as an assistant for Robin Harper, the first-ever Green parliamentarian in the UK elected to the first-ever Scottish parliament.​' She was elected unopposed as presiding officer in May 2021, the second woman to hold the role and the first Scottish Green MSP. Ms Johnstone was recently involved in a row with Douglas Ross, the former leader of the Scottish Conservatives, after she ejected him from the chamber during First Minister's Questions. Here is the moment Douglas Ross was kicked out of the Chamber today during FMQs @heraldscotland — Hannah Brown (@HannahMargBrown) May 29, 2025 The MSP was warned over heckling before being excluded by the presiding officer. The former Tory leader accused Ms Johnstone of constitutional bias, suggesting she treats pro-union parties more harshly than those who supported independence in the 2014 referendum.

Belfast Telegraph

43 minutes ago

• Belfast Telegraph

Anger as bomb squad called to Belfast Islamic Centre after suspect device is hurled inside in ‘vile attack'

Latest | A man linked to a security alert at the Belfast Islamic Centre claimed he was "trying to save the world'. A device was thrown inside the building and a window was smashed during last night's incident. It happened between 10pm and 10.30pm at the Islamic centre on the University Road area of south Belfast. Staff at the centre told the Belfast Telegraph the centre had to be evacuated, disrupting evening prayers. A video from the first floor of the centre, seen by this newspaper, shows a man reaching into the building. One witness said he saw flames as the suspect allegedly attempted to set fire to the site. "I saw the flames in his hand from above but couldn't capture it in the video," they said. A pedestrian walking by stopped the suspect from doing any damage. A clip of the incident shows the young man grabbing the suspect and pulling him away. The suspect can be heard telling the pedestrian that he was "trying to save the world" as he was being dragged away. "He was the first to stop him," the witness continued. "Only then did we reach there." Officers subsequently arrested the man and cordoned off the site to conduct further investigations. A spokesperson for the Islamic Centre today said they strongly condemned the 'vile attack'. 'During evening prayers last night, one of the windows was broken and a device was thrown inside the building. 'Everyone was evacuated from the building and the police were quick to respond. 'We were unable to continue night prayers as the whole area was cordoned off and nobody was allowed near the building. 'A bomb squad eventually removed the device in the early hours of this morning. 'We have had incidents in the past but nothing of this kind.' "I think he'd be very well qualified": Leo Varadkar on Colum Eastwood Irish presidential run Alliance MLA Paula Bradshaw condemned the attack. 'This is just the latest example of an attack motivated by hate which does not reflect the diversity of South Belfast in 2025,' the South Belfast Assembly member said. 'This attack was again designed to cause fear among people inside the centre, who were at prayer at the time. 'Nevertheless, I am thankful for the intervention of a nearby passer-by and for the work of the police. Those were much more reflective of the true spirit of Belfast, where most people rejoice in diversity. 'I would like to express my solidarity with all those who were evacuated, and my thanks to all those who worked to ensure their safety.' A PSNI spokesperson said early this morning: 'Police are currently at the scene of a security alert at University Road in south Belfast. A number of cordons are in place in the vicinity. 'A 34-year-old man has been arrested and is currently in custody. 'Members of the public are asked to avoid the area at this time.'