AFL 2025: Match review officer wants more options for bans
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News.
The AFL's match review officer is hoping to get 'more levers' to bridge the gap between lengthy and small suspensions but remains adamant the game is better for a crackdown on dangerous tackles.
Michael Christian also moved to debunk a theory that the outcome of incidents, particularly concussions, was the starting point for reports, declaring the bump and tackle remained 'integral' parts of the game.
A three-week ban given to North Melbourne's Paul Curtis for a run-down tackle that resulted in a concussion for Port Adelaide's Josh Sinn sparked widespread debate, with some coaches labelling it the 'perfect tackle'.
Christian defended the suspension but conceded there could be more flexibility in the table that landed on an automatic three-week ban, something he hoped would be fast-tracked by the arrival of former Brisbane Lions chief executive Greg Swann on the AFL executive.
But Christian also said the MRO's own review of the past three years made it clear that players had adapted to the crackdown on dangerous tackles and refined techniques to ensure they remained part of the game.
'We did a review after round of 12 of 2025, looking at the past few years. In 2023 there were 20 tackling suspensions, last year there were seven, this year there were three,' Christian said.
'We've had this situation where players have really adapted incredibly well to exercising a duty of care to their opponent.
'The game allows you to bump and allows you to tackle, it's an integral part of the game, but there needs to be a duty of care.
'In 2023, it was a real shift in terms of trying to clamp down on players, asking them to exercise a duty of care in the tackle.
'As the focus became defensive and on tackling, we tended to see people hurt.
'I would defy anyone who watches the game now, you can see the players when they tackle, they do exercise a large degree a duty of care.'
Christian said the players were in no doubt what was expected of them when it came to executing tackles despite having only 'split seconds' to make decisions.
'You can pin both arms, but you have to try, before that player's head hits the ground, try and loosen or release that grip,' he told SEN.
'The tackle can still be effective, but you've got to try and minimise the risk of injury by loosening or letting go in that downward action. To try and turn the player on to their shoulder to minimise the risk of head injury.'
The AFL has vowed to review the MRO operation that has so far this year given three-week bans to players for tackles that resulted in concussions, only for Fremantle captain Alex Pearce, whose bump ended with the same result, to be cleared at the tribunal.
It's a move Christian has welcomed, as he made it clear a concussion to one player would not always result in a suspension to the other player involved in the incident.
'I think, as many levers as I can have, it's appreciated,' Christian said.
'The AFL have put it on the table this is something they are looking at closely.
'There's no doubt there are highly careless acts and some probably at the low end of being careless. That extra discretion would be helpful.
'The absolute first point of call for me is to assess the conduct of an action. It's not all outcome based. Yes, outcome becomes a factor when an action is deemed reportable.
'Then impact does have a significant say, as in the Curtis case, but the act first needs to be reportable.'
Originally published as AFL match review officer wants more options when it comes to suspensions but defends crackdown on dangerous tackles
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
2 hours ago
- AU Financial Review
Bears and De Ceglie look for mining friends in NRL push
NRL chief Peter V'landys and WA Premier Roger Cook's plans to convert Perth from an AFL-only town to a rugby league outpost are continuing apace. Even if Kerry Stokes is yet to get behind the cause. Fresh from poaching Seven news boss Anthony De Ceglie to head the new Perth Bears, the city's wheelers and dealers are now working hard to get on its board.
Mercury
5 hours ago
- Mercury
Man, 71, charged with assaulting 14yo girl on cruise ship off Queensland
Don't miss out on the headlines from Breaking News. Followed categories will be added to My News. A 71-year-old man has been charged after he allegedly assaulted a teenage girl onboard a cruise ship off the coast of Queensland. Police allege the man - who was not known to the 14-year-old - approached the girl near a lift shortly before 11pm on Thursday and grabbed her. The teenager alerted nearby staff, who quickly intervened. The girl was not physically harmed. Detectives from the Gateway Child Protection and Investigation Unit arrested the man at the Port of Brisbane on Saturday morning, following the alleged incident late Thursday night. The man has been charged with deprivation of liberty and two counts of common assault. Police have objected to the man's bail and he is expected to appear in Brisbane Magistrates Court on Monday. Originally published as Man, 71, charged with assaulting 14yo girl on cruise ship off Queensland Breaking News From data centres to renewable energy, major projects in one Aussie state could soon get fast-tracked under a sweeping new plan. Breaking News US intervention 'devastated' Iran's nuclear programme says Pentagon
Courier-Mail
7 hours ago
- Courier-Mail
Lewis Bishop makes Aussie Dolphins team for the 2025 World Para Swimming Championships in Singapore, September 21-27
Don't miss out on the headlines from Local sport. Followed categories will be added to My News. Aussie World Para Swimming Championship selection, Queensland's Lewis Bishop, knows the highs and lows of life like few others. Why? Because he saw rock bottom, a near-death experience 10 years ago which motivated him to strive for one of his proudest moments - winning at bronze medal at the 2024 Paris Paralympic Games 'There were so many years building up to that moment, and the fact that my parents were there was special,'' said Lewis, a butterfly ace. 'It was my first team and I did not have the expectation of winning a medal so the bronze medal was almost unbelievable at the time.'' Para Swimming Athlete Lewis Bishop at QSAC Picture David Clark To think it was just 10 years ago when Bishop, aged nine, went to hell and back. Bishop, now 19, was living in PNG with his mum and dad, Clare and Damon, where his dad worked in the mines and his mother ran a swimming squad for locals. One day he was out on the water knee boarding with family friends when he jumped into the water and got his leg caught in the propeller. The injuries were so horrific, he was at death's door. 'I almost died,'' 19-year-old Bishop said. He was in a critical condition, flown to Townsville hospital that night, and after a week transported to Brisbane. Bishop had his leg amputated below the knee, but the wound became infected and had to be amputated higher up. That, ladies and gentlemen, is what the bottom of the barrel looks like and Bishop saw it. He then continued to push through more adversity before, 12 operations later, Bishop's life started to swing around. 'Within a few months (after the accident) I was walking again, and a few months after that I was active again back in the pool.'' Lewis Bishop with his 2024 Paris Paralympic Games. Picture: QUT A bit of tough love from mum helped him get back into the pool. 'I'd like to say mum basically tipped me out of my (wheel) chair and into the pool. 'She said 'you are not going to be sitting around because of your disability'. You are going to be active,'' Bishop recalled. 'I learned to do that (swim) before I learned to walk again.'' First stop in the rebirth of his sporting journey was the Somerville House school pool, not far from the hospital where he was staying. 'I don't remember swimming being too difficult. Obviously the kick was not as strong, but I could float and I made it to the other end, so I was happy.'' Joining Bishop in the water was his mum, Clare. 'As soon as his wounds were healed, I took him in a wheelchair up to Somerville House pool and tipped him in and it was the first time he had probably smiled since the accident,'' Clare said. Lewis Bishop and his parents, at the Red Carpet arrival of Paris Olympians and Paralympians for 2024 Swimming Australia Awards - Photo Steve Pohlner 'We knew the only way forward was to keep him active the best way we could,'' said his mother Clare. 'It was hard. You want to wrap him up in cotton wool, but we also knew the only way forward was to be mentally engaged. And being a sporting boy, we needed to follow his natural inclination (of being involved in sport). 'He loved the water as a baby. I think he swam before he walked,'' Clare recalled. 'He loves a challenge and he took it.'' Paralympian Lewis Bishop arrives home from Paris in 2024 to friends and family. Pics Adam Head Bishop's love of the water came from his time in coastal Gove, the Northern Territory, when his father was working in the mines. 'It was amazing fishing,'' Bishop recalled. From there the family moved to PNG where Bishop's love affair with the water continued. So when he was looking to resume a sporting life following his accident, it was only natural that this water baby hit the pool. Bishop, who attended St Bernard's Primary School and then Clairvaux MacKillop College, trains under Josh Smith at Rackley Swimming Hibiscus. Last week his progression continued when he made the world championship squad headed to Singapore in September. Lewis Bishop, left, is part of the QAS program along with fellow athletes Abby Carswell and Seth Macdonald. Bishop is a part of the Paralympics Australia's Imagine Education Program which educates students about the Paralympic movement, the Games and Para sports. Paralympians like Bishop from the Queensland Academy of Sport visit primary schools to help break down stigma around disability. Currently, only 25 percent of people with a disability participate in sport and Bishop would like to help that to change. The tension mounts for Lewis Bishop in Paris. (Photo by) Having once looked up to Olympians and paralympians, Bishop is now one of those young men educating the youth of today about disability in sport. 'I hope to inspire the future generation,'' Bishop said. 'When I was in primary school (at St Bernard's School) and a Paralympian had visited, that would have been pretty special. And now I do that. It is an honour to be able to give back.'' For Bishop, he is only in the middle of his sporting dream. It all started in that Somerville House pool when he entered the water from a wheelchair 10 years ago, it continued in Paris at the Games, and it could end in Brisbane at the 2023 Olympic and Paralympic Games. 'I feel like I am just getting started. Brisbane (2032) is coming up on the horizon so I want to stay around for that.'' Bishop dares to dream because he knows dreams do come true. After all, he is alive, isn't he, he can walk and he can swim - very, very well.
