Diddy trial judge rebukes lawyers after sealed information appears in media report

This is a free article for Diddy on Trial newsletter subscribers. Sign up to get exclusive reporting and analysis throughout Sean Combs' federal trial.
Today, U.S. government prosecutors attempted to put a finer point on the case they've presented over the last five weeks. They walked jurors through text messages, phone logs, hotel bookings and other evidence of what they say points to a sprawling criminal conspiracy led by a man with a relentless desire for 'freak offs.'
Diddy's defense team continued to forcefully push back, again suggesting that the women in Diddy's life were willing participants in the drug-dazed sexual episodes. Both sides' legal arguments are familiar at this point, but the lawyers are clearly trying to drive home their key points as the prosecution prepares to rest its case.
Here's what you need to know about Day 25 of the trial:
DeLeassa Penland, a special agent with the U.S. attorney's office, testified that Diddy appears to have paid for male escort Jules Theodore's round-trip air travel from Los Angeles to New York in August 2009 — potentially bolstering one of the U.S. government's charges against Diddy: transportation to engage in prostitution.
In an effort to illustrate that Diddy's 'freak offs' were consensual, the defense read text messages showing the hip-hop mogul and ex-girlfriend Cassie Ventura exchanging dates for their next marathon sexual encounter. 'It can be any date you choose,' Diddy told Ventura in one text in August 2009, according to the evidence.
Judge Arun Subramanian was furious this morning.
He rebuked the prosecution and the defense over an online article that appeared to include details from a sealed proceeding. He asked the lawyers whether they knew the report's source. 'Someone is lying,' Subramanian said. 'The transcript was sealed.'
'The court imposed a gag order on the government, the defendant, all attorneys for the defense, and anyone involved was made accountable,' Subramanian added. 'What happened here … may result in civil or criminal contempt charges for all involved.'
In other news: Diddy, wearing a cream-colored sweater, did not seem engaged in today's proceedings. He occasionally leaned forward to read papers on the defense table — but overall, he didn't look especially interested in the special agent's testimony.
Penland's testimony about Diddy appearing to have paid for a sex worker's air travel, by itself, may be enough for the jury to convict on Counts 3 and 5, 'Transportation to Engage in Prostitution,' also called the 'Mann Act.' In the last month, most of the focus has been on the other charges — sex trafficking and racketeering conspiracy.
The necessary elements for a Mann Act conviction are (1) knowingly transporting (or attempting to transport) a person in interstate or foreign commerce, (2) with intent that the person engage in prostitution (or other specified illegal sexual activity). There is no requirement of force, fraud, or coercion, as there is with the sex trafficking charges. There is no defense of consent.
As much as sex trafficking and RICO charges have dominated the coverage, the Mann Act charges are quietly the easiest charges for a conviction in this case. The government just needs evidence of interstate travel and a desire to get a prostitute to prostitute. The prosecutors pretty much got all of that with one witness: a special agent who wasn't even an eyewitness to anything, but who read records into evidence.
Here's what we know about the coming days:
The government will likely rest its case Friday, Assistant U.S. Attorney Maurene Comey confirmed.
Marc Agnifilo, Diddy's lead defense lawyer, said the defense needs two to five days to lay out its case, but that timeline isn't set in stone.
The jury could get the case as early as next week, Subramanian said.
PSA: Every night during Diddy's trial, NBC's 'Dateline' will drop special episodes of the 'True Crime Weekly' podcast to get you up to speed. 'Dateline' correspondent Andrea Canning chats with NBC News' Chloe Melas and special guests — right in front of the courthouse. Listen here.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

3 hours ago

• Yahoo

Diddy's Alleged Instructions For Male Escorts At His 'Freak-Offs' Revealed By Prosecutors In New Text Messages

Prosecutors in Sean "Diddy" Combs' sex-trafficking trial have released a text exchange between a male escort and the rapper's associate. The text messages reportedly contain detailed instructions for the escort on how to take part in the rapper's marathon "freak-off." New FBI raid photos from Sean "Diddy" Combs' Los Angeles mansion have also revealed a stash of weapons, drugs, and stacks of baby oil seemingly used during the rapper's wild parties. New evidence in Diddy's trial has unearthed shocking text exchanges between a male escort and someone described as a close associate of the music mogul. Court documents reveal that a male escort named Jules was in contact with an unnamed associate, whose identity is not disclosed, but is referred to as "device owner" in the message screenshots. According to the evidence, on August 26, 2009, the "device owner" reached out to Jules with a last-minute proposition to fly from Los Angeles to New York City to participate in the event. The associate offered Jules a "tip" for the short notice. Within two minutes, Jules responded affirmatively. Diddy's alleged associate then followed up by sending him flight details for a Virgin America trip from LAX to JFK. The "device owner" also instructed the escort to contact them whenever he was ready to leave the event, so they could book his return flight. According to the Daily Mail, after Jules landed in New York early on the morning of August 27, 2009, he messaged the "device owner" to confirm his arrival and let them know he was heading to his hotel room to freshen up. Roughly an hour later, the "device owner" instructed Jules to come to room 4901, to which Jules replied, "OK." Later that afternoon, around 2:45 p.m., Jules texted again, this time requesting help booking a return flight to Los Angeles. However, the associate told him the flight would be arranged after he came back to the room, asking him to return within the hour. Jules replied that he needed a bit more rest and asked if the timing could be flexible. He joked that he hadn't slept in two days and quipped, "u guys r rabbits lol." The associate responded reassuringly, writing, "Lol, Ok hit me when you wake. Sorry bro. No stress. U let me know." At 7:45 p.m. on August 27, 2009, nearly four hours after their previous conversation, Jules messaged that he was on his way to the room. Fifteen minutes later, he followed up to say he was "at the door knocking" and asked to be let in "if u are there." By 8:10 p.m., Jules speculated that whoever was inside had likely "stepped out." It wasn't until 8:21 p.m. that the associate responded with a simple instruction: "OK come up." Months later, in December 2009, text messages show Jules seeking help from the same associate to fabricate a cover story. On December 8, he requested a message he could show his girlfriend to hide his involvement: "Can u shoot me a text just saying you guys will be somewhere else this weekend so I can show her?" After some back-and-forth, Jules confirmed the excuse "worked" and proceeded to offer up his availability. Notably, in these texts, the events weren't referred to as "freak-offs" but more discreetly labeled as a "party." Diddy is currently facing a series of serious federal charges, including racketeering conspiracy, two counts of sex trafficking, and two counts of transporting individuals for the purpose of prostitution. Prosecutors allege that the "Bad Boy" mogul orchestrated a secretive network of drug-fueled sex events, where victims were manipulated, coerced, and subjected to violence. Diddy, however, denies the allegations, asserting that every encounter was consensual. This week, the case took a dramatic turn when prosecutors introduced newly uncovered text messages and a series of explosive photographs captured during a March 2024 FBI raid on Diddy's Los Angeles estate in Holmby Hills. The images, now part of the court record, offer a disturbing glimpse into what prosecutors describe as a lifestyle steeped in excess, control, and substance abuse. Jurors were shown high-powered rifles, bags of ketamine, suspected narcotics, and hundreds of bottles of baby oil and lubricant, many stored in glass cabinets or ornate display boxes. Adding to the mounting evidence, Paul, a 26-year-old former assistant to Diddy and a one-time Syracuse University basketball player, testified in court about his role within the rapper's inner circle. Paul admitted to cleaning up after the so-called "freak-off" sex marathons and said he regularly purchased a variety of drugs for Diddy, typically once a month. Still, he rejected claims that he acted as Diddy's "drug mule," insisting under oath that he never trafficked drugs. As the trial continues, Diddy risks being sentenced to life in prison if found guilty of racketeering. He could also face a minimum of 15 years in prison if found guilty of sex trafficking and a maximum of 10 years for transportation to engage in prostitution.

Yahoo

6 hours ago

• Yahoo

Former assistant describes putting on gloves to clean up Diddy's freak offs - as $6k bill for hotel damage revealed

The former assistant for Sean 'Diddy' Combs described how he set up and cleaned up hotel rooms after 'freak offs.' Brendan Paul, who worked as the rapper's assistant for 18 months until he was arrested in March 2024 for cocaine possession, testified about his role preparing and tidying up hotel rooms after his boss and his then-girlfriend had 'freak offs.' Clad in a blue suit, the former Syracuse basketball player spoke quickly and confidently while on the stand Friday morning. Paul, who worked 100-hour weeks for the mogul, recalled 'advancing' locations for his boss's hotel stays. This included setting up hotel rooms, bringing baby oil, lubricant, condoms, candles and liquor, as well as calling room service to bring up extra towels, sheets, and water, he testified. Although Paul said he didn't know what the 'wild king nights' — another term for 'freak offs' — entailed, he understood they involved sex and partying. When cleaning up, Paul recalled putting on gloves 'for sanity reasons' while placing towels and sheets 'in a nice pile.' He noted the rooms were often 'in disarray.' He said he understood he was tasked with tidying up the rooms after 'wild king nights' to 'avoid getting damage charges.' He then left cash tips for hotel staff. Later in the day, however, the jury learned that Diddy was charged hundreds, and sometimes thousands, for damages to hotel rooms. Records revealed that the mogul was charged $6,000 for 'losses and damages' during his stay at the St. Regis Bal Harbour Resort in Miami in December 2021. The mogul faces five federal charges of sex trafficking, racketeering conspiracy, and transportation to engage in prostitution. He's pleaded not guilty. The former assistant's duties were one of several shocking revelations during Friday's testimony. Paul recalled working three days straight without sleeping while the mogul worked on releasing his 2023 album 'The Love Album: Off the Grid.' Diddy told his team to 'move like SEAL Team Six,' which Paul took to mean 'be militant' and 'get things done without him asking,' he testified. Asked about how he feels about Diddy today, Paul replied: 'It's complicated.' The mogul shot a 'thumbs up' at his defense attorney Brian Steel after he cross-examined Paul. The government expects to rest its case as soon as Monday. If that's the case, the defense said it could rest its case on Tuesday or Wednesday, meaning the jury could have the case as early as next week. At The London West Hollywood in January 2023, records revealed a $3,750 charge for damaged furniture. A damage report read in court Friday stated that hotel staff noticed 'bodily fluids stained on the wood floor' as well as 'used linens in various sections of the room.' Months later in April at the same hotel, a damage report revealed a $1,800 charge for towels that 'appear to have been soaked in baby oil' and signs of smoking in the room. While on the stand, Paul clarified he was 'absolutely not' a drug mule. Brian Steel, one of Diddy's defense attorneys, asked if drugs were just a 'minor part' of what he did for his boss; Paul agreed. The witness also clarified that when he was arrested, he had Diddy's cocaine. 'I was sweeping his room earlier that morning' when he grabbed the drugs and put them in his bag and 'I forgot to put it elsewhere," he said on the stand. He had 0.7 grams of cocaine on him at the time of his arrest, he testified. Paul didn't tell police at the time that they weren't his drugs out of 'loyalty' to his boss, he told the court.

Washington Post

a day ago

• Washington Post

Key moments from the sixth week of Sean 'Diddy' Combs' sex trafficking trial

NEW YORK — The sixth week of the Sean 'Diddy' Combs' sex trafficking trial was shortened by a holiday and a juror's illness as prosecutors nearly concluded their case, setting the stage for a one- or two-day defense presentation next week. In the trial's first five weeks, jurors repeatedly heard testimony about drug-fueled marathon sex events described as 'freak-offs' by one of Combs' ex-girlfriends and as 'hotel nights' by another. In the sixth week, they were shown about 20 minutes of video recordings from the dayslong events.