We finally may be able to rid the world of mosquitoes. But should we?
They buzz, they bite and they cause some of the deadliest diseases known to humanity. Mosquitos are perhaps the planet's most universally reviled animals.
If we could zap them off the face of the Earth, should we?
The question is no longer hypothetical. In recent years, scientists have devised powerful genetic tools that may be able to eradicate mosquitoes and other pests once and for all.
Now, some doctors and scientists say it is time to take the extraordinary step of unleashing gene editing to suppress mosquitoes and avoid human suffering from malaria, dengue, West Nile virus and other serious diseases.
'There are so many lives at stake with malaria that we want to make sure that this technology could be used in the near future,' said Alekos Simoni, a molecular biologist with Target Malaria, a project aiming to target vector mosquitos in sub-Saharan Africa.
Yet the development of this technology also raises a profound ethical question: When, if ever, is it okay to intentionally drive a species out of existence.
Even the famed naturalist E.O. Wilson once said: 'I would gladly throw the switch and be the executioner myself' for malaria-carrying mosquitos.
But some researchers and ethicists warn it may be too dangerous to tinker with the underpinnings of life itself. Even irritating, itty-bitty mosquitoes, they say, may have enough inherent value to keep around.
Target Malaria is one of the most ambitious mosquito suppression efforts in the works. Simoni and his colleagues are seeking to diminish populations of mosquitoes in the Anopheles gambiae complex that are responsible for spreading that deadly disease.
In their labs, the scientists have introduced a gene mutation that causes female mosquito offspring to be born without functional ovaries, rendering them infertile. Male mosquito offspring can carry the gene but remain physically unaffected.
The concept is that when female mosquitoes inherit the gene from both their mother and father, they will go on to die without producing offspring. Meanwhile, when males and females carrying just one copy of the gene mate with wild mosquitoes, they will spread the gene further until no fertile females are left — and the population crashes.
Simoni said he hopes the project can move beyond the lab and deploy some of the genetically modified mosquitoes in their natural habitats within the next five years.
'We believe that this technology can really be transformative,' he said.
At the heart of Target Malaria's work is a powerful genetic tool called a gene drive.
Under the normal rules of inheritance, a parent has a 50-50 chance of passing a particular gene on to an offspring. But by adding special genetic machinery — dubbed a gene drive — to segments of DNA, scientists can rig the coin flip and ensure a gene is included in an animal's eggs and sperm, nearly guaranteeing it will be passed along.
Over successive generations, gene drives can cause a trait to spread across an entire species' population, even if that gene doesn't benefit the organism.
In that way, gene drives do something remarkable: They allow humans to overwrite Charles Darwin's rules for natural selection, which normally prods populations of plants and animals to adapt to their environment over time.
'Technology is presenting new options to us,' said Christopher Preston, a University of Montana environmental philosopher. 'We might've been able to make a species go extinct 150 years ago by harpooning it too much or shooting it out of the sky. But today, we have different options, and extinction could be completed or could be started in a lab.'
When so many wildlife conservationists are trying to save plants and animals from disappearing, the mosquito is one of the few creatures that people argue is actually worthy of extinction. Forget about tigers or bears — it's the tiny mosquito that is the deadliest animal on Earth.
The human misery caused by malaria is undeniable. Nearly 600,000 people died of the disease in 2023, according to the World Health Organization, with the majority of cases in Africa.
On the continent, the death toll is akin to 'crashing two Boeing 747s into Kilimanjaro' every day, said Paul Ndebele, a bioethicist at George Washington University.
For gene-drive advocates, making the case for releasing genetically modified mosquitoes in nations such as Burkina Faso or Uganda is straightforward.
'This is not a difficult audience because these are people that are living in an area where children are dying,' said Krystal Birungi, an entomologist for Target Malaria in Uganda, though she added that she sometimes has to fight misinformation, such as the false idea that bites from genetically modified mosquitoes can make people sterile.
But recently, the Hastings Center for Bioethics, a research institute in New York, and Arizona State University brought together a group of bioethicists to discuss the potential pitfalls of intentionally trying to drive a species to extinction. In a policy paper published in the journal Science last month, the group concluded 'deliberate full extinction might occasionally be acceptable, but only extremely rarely.'
A compelling candidate for total eradication, according to the bioethicists, is the New World screwworm. This parasitic fly, which lays eggs in wounds and eats the flesh of both humans and livestock, appears to play little role in ecosystems. Infections are difficult to treat and can lead to slow and painful deaths.
Yet it may be too risky, they argue, to use gene drives on invasive rodents on remote Pacific islands where they decimate native birds, given the nonzero chance of a gene-edited rat or mouse jumping ship to the mainland and spreading across a continent.
'Even at a microbial level, it became plain in our conversations, we are not in favor of remaking the world to suit human desires,' said Gregory Kaebnick, a senior research scholar at the institute.
It's unclear how important malaria-carrying mosquitos are to broader ecosystems. Little research has been done to figure out whether frogs or other animals that eat the insects would be able to find their meals elsewhere.
'The eradication of the mosquito through a genetic technology would have the potential to create global eradication in a way that just felt a little risky,' said Preston, who contributed with Ndebele to the discussion published in Science.
Instead, the authors said, geneticists should be able to use gene-editing, vaccines and other tools to target not the mosquito itself, but the single-celled Plasmodium parasite that is responsible for malaria. That invisible microorganism — which a mosquito transfers from its saliva to a person's blood when it bites — is the real culprit.
'You can get rid of malaria without actually getting rid of the mosquito,' Kaebnick said. He added that at a time when the Trump administration talks cavalierly about animals going extinct, intentional extinction should be an option for only 'particularly horrific species.'
But Ndebele, who is from Zimbabwe, noted that most of the people opposed to the elimination of the mosquitoes 'are not based in Africa.'
Ndebele has intimate experience with malaria; he once had to rush his sick son to a hospital after the disease manifested as a hallucinatory episode.
'We're just in panic mode,' he recalled. 'You can just imagine — we're not sure what's happening with this young guy.'
Still, Ndebele and his colleagues expressed caution about using gene-drive technology.
Even if people were to agree to rid the globe of every mosquito — not just Anopheles gambiae, but ones that transmit other diseases or merely bite and irritate — it would be a 'herculean undertaking,' according to Kaebnick.
There are more than 3,500 known species, each potentially requiring its own specially designed gene drive. And there is no guarantee a gene drive would wipe out a population as intended.
Simoni, the gene-drive researcher, agreed there are limits to what the technology can do. His team's modeling suggests it would suppress malaria-carrying mosquitoes only locally without outright eliminating them.
Mosquitoes have been 'around for hundreds of millions of years,' he said. 'It's a very difficult species to eliminate.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Forbes
7 hours ago
- Forbes
A Biologist Spotlights 3 ‘Extreme' Snakes — By Strike Speed, Ground Speed And Air Speed
It may not come as a surprise that snakes move quickly, as their prey – often fast-moving animals – ... More demands agility. What many don't realize, however, is just how many snakes are capable of outpacing even humans. In Kung Fu, 'striking like a cobra' symbolizes speed and precision – qualities that are quite real in the snake world. Many snakes feed on creatures like rodents, birds and other small vertebrates, all of which are impressively quick for their size. However, contrary to popular belief, cobras aren't the fastest strikers in the snake world. When it comes to sheer strike speed, few snakes rival the puff adder (Bitis arietans), whose deadly reputation in Africa is well-earned. Responsible for the majority of snakebite fatalities in Africa, the puff adder strikes with both speed and precision. Its strike can reach a blistering 19 feet per second. To put that in perspective, it takes just under 90 milliseconds for the snake's fangs to reach their target, while a typical human blink lasts around 200 milliseconds. In other words, the puff adder can strike faster than the blink of an eye. But while the puff adder is the meanest striker, it isn't the fastest when it comes to locomotion – the process by which an animal physically moves through its environment. Over land and air, there are two snake species that can very well outpace humans. Black Mamba – The Fastest Snake On Land The black mamba is the fastest snake on land, capable of reaching speeds up to 12 miles per hour. When it comes to land speed, few snakes are as fast as the black mamba (Dendroaspis polylepis). Native to sub-Saharan Africa, this long, slender, and remarkably agile species can reach speeds of 9 to 12 miles per hour over short distances, making it the fastest snake in the world on land. Don't be fooled by web searches claiming the sidewinder rattlesnake is the world's fastest snake – a misconception that's been widely perpetuated online. While sidewinding is an efficient way to move across loose desert sand, it's not particularly fast. Biomechanical research shows that sidewinders top out at around 2.2 miles per hour on the ground. By contrast, the black mamba's smooth lateral undulation and powerful muscular coordination allow it to traverse open ground with astonishing speed. Its movement is not only fast but also controlled and deliberate. Black mambas are often seen cruising the savanna with their head and neck held high, using their keen eyesight to scan for danger or track prey – typically small mammals such as hyraxes, bush babies, and rodents. Despite their fearsome reputation, black mambas are not inherently aggressive. In reality, they are shy, secretive snakes that go out of their way to avoid conflict. Like most snakes, they strike only when they feel threatened or cornered. (Sidebar: Long considered the world's second-longest venomous snake at up to 15 feet, the black mamba has recently slipped to fifth place. Curious which four venomous snakes outrank it in length? Read the full story here.) Paradise Flying Snake – The Fastest Snake In Air This gorgeous paradise flying snake has the amazing ability to use its body to control a free fall. ... More By flattening its ribs, it is able to "glide" through the air, making it a very unique species of snake. The paradise flying snake (Chrysopelea paradisi) is not capable of flight in the traditional sense, but it has evolved a remarkable ability to glide through the air, making it one of the most fascinating – and fastest moving – snakes in the world. Found in the rainforests of Southeast Asia, this snake uses its unique body structure to 'fly' from tree to tree by flattening its ribs and undulating through the air. Its gliding ability allows it to cover distances of up to 100 feet in a single leap, often traveling at speeds of up to 25 miles per hour. Measured by sheer velocity, that makes it the fastest snake in the world – though it only reaches these speeds while gliding. The snake's technique involves launching itself from a high point and using the air to support its long, flattened body, making it seem like it's flying. In reality, the snake is engaging in controlled freefall, steering with precise body movements to direct its glide. This specialized form of locomotion helps it escape predators, hunt for prey and move efficiently between trees in its dense forest habitat. There are five species in the genus Chrysopelea, but only four have documented gliding behavior. The exception is the Sri Lankan flying snake (Chrysopelea taprobanica), for which data on aerial locomotion is still lacking. While the other species are all considered skilled aerial travelers, biomechanical research suggests that the paradise flying snake is the fastest glider among them. While the paradise flying snake is venomous, its venom is mild and poses little danger to humans. Its primary diet consists of reptiles, birds and other small vertebrates, and its ability to glide gives it a distinct advantage in ambushing prey or escaping threats in the treetops. Curious to see how your fear of animals stacks up? Take our quick quiz to find out fast-moving creatures — like snakes that strike fast, slither, swim and glide — send a shiver down your spine: Fear Of Animals Scale
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
South African engineers freed after two years in Equatorial Guinea jail
Two South African engineers have returned home after spending more than two years in jail in Equatorial Guinea on what the UN has called "arbitrary and illegal" drugs charges. Frik Potgieter and Peter Huxham, both in their mid-50s, were arrested in February 2023 after drugs were allegedly found in their luggage. They were sentenced to 12 years in prison and fined $5m (£4m) but have been given a presidential pardon after a long campaign by their families and the South African government. Their arrest came days after luxury assets belonging to Equatorial Guinea's Vice-President Teodoro Nguema Obiang were seized in South Africa. A yacht and two Cape Town villas belonging to Obiang, who is also the son of Equatorial Guinea's president, were impounded in execution of a court ruling. "We are overwhelmed with relief and joy. The last two years and four months have been unimaginably painful for both of our families," according to a statement released by the two men's families. They were working for the Dutch oil and gas company SBM in Equatorial Guinea when they arrested the night before they were due to return home after a five-week stint in the country. The families had called for the assistance of the South African government as well as that of the UK government, as Mr Huxham has dual nationality. "South Africa expresses its sincere gratitude to the Government of Equatorial Guinea for considering and ultimately granting this Presidential pardon, allowing Mr Huxham and Mr Potgieter to return home to their loved ones," said a post on X by South African Foreign Minister Ronald Lamola. The United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention last year called for the pair's release, saying their detention was unlawful. Their families say the pair were arrested in retaliation for the seizure of the assets belonging to Equatorial Guinea's vice-president. The BBC has contacted Equatorial Guinea for comment. A South African official told the BBC it was for the courts to decide the fate of the yacht and villas, and the government couldn't intervene. Equatorial Guinea VP's superyacht and homes seized in South Africa The president's son who loves Bugattis and Michael Jackson World's longest-serving president to continue 43-year-rule Go to for more news from the African continent. Follow us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Facebook at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica Focus on Africa
Bloomberg
11 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Tanzania Arrests YouTubers as Pre-Election Crackdown Intensifies
Tanzanian police have arrested two local YouTubers as President Samia Suluhu Hassan's government steps up a crackdown on dissent ahead of elections. Jackson Kabalo, 32, and Joseph Mrindoko, 37, were arrested in the northern town of Arusha on Friday for 'improper use of social media,' police said in a statement.
