Whale song shows 'hallmarks' of human language
There's a reason "antidisestablishmentarianism" is more a piece of trivia than vital to the English language.
Because a word that long is not what human language favours. According to experts, we tend toward efficiency and brevity — with statistical laws that persist across cultures.
Perhaps now, even across species.
Two new studies this week focused on whale song and found striking, structural parallels to human language, especially in humpback whales.
To be clear, we're no closer to translating the meaning of those soulful, haunting, put it-on-a-best-selling-record songs from these ocean giants. But experts say it highlights the role of evolutionary pressures in complex communication.
A humpback whale jumps out of the water off the coast of Brazil in June 2024. New research suggests that whale communication shares structural parallels with human language. (Mauro Pimentel/AFP/Getty Images)
From the mouths of babes
The first study, published in Science, focused on humpback whale song because it is culturally transmitted — in other words, taught and changed over time just like human language.
The interdisciplinary collaboration took eight years as researchers painstakingly gathered recordings from a pod of humpbacks and broke them down into smaller components. The key to their analysis was a method based on how human babies learn.
"One of the first challenges that infants face in breaking into language is discovering what the relevant units are," explains author Inbal Arnon, professor of psychology at Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Though they don't know they're doing it, babies use low-level statistical reasoning to figure out which relevant sounds are more likely to follow others.
A volunteer at Endeavor Elementary's onsite daycare plays with an infant in Nampa, Idaho. How babies learn to decode adult speech was integral to new research on the structure of humpback whale song. (Darren Svan/Idaho Education News/The Associated Press)
"Let's think about the [word] 'baby.' How likely are you to hear bee if you just heard bay?" Arnon said, suggesting that infants figure out these likelihoods innately.
This logic led them to find a pattern in humpback whale song known as Zipfian distribution — which, in human language, dictates that the most frequent word is twice as used as the next frequent word.
"It's this kind of characteristic fingerprint of human language," said Simon Kirby, co-author and professor of language evolution at the University of Edinburgh.
"So it's a really surprising thing to find it in this completely unrelated species of humpback whales producing songs deep in the ocean."
The researchers theorize that it flips the idea that we've evolved to be good at language — instead, they suggest it implies both that language evolves in order to be passed down better, and that this applies to species other than humans.
"If a language has to be learned in order to get from one generation to the next," Kirby suggested, "then the languages that are learnable are the only ones that will survive."
WATCH | What did you say? Whales can't hear each other over all our noise:
Succinct Cetaceans
The other study, published in Science Advances, found that whale song has parallels to another hallmark of human language: efficiency.
"In general, in language, we try to convey as much information as we can," said Mason Youngblood, an animal behaviour and cultural evolution researcher at Stony Brook University in New York.
He says the cost is high for humpbacks to sing, considering they bellow their songs across vast distances under water while holding their breath and cycling it through their bodies.
"It's important to do so in the cheapest way possible," Youngblood said. "And the easiest way to do that is by reducing vocalization time."
The research found some whales — including humpbacks, bowhead, blue and fin whales — adhere to two linguistic laws: Menzerath's Law and Zipf's Law of Abbreviation.
Put simply, both laws mean you spend less time blabbing. While not quite universal, Youngblood says it points to the constraints that shape the evolution of communication in different species.
Moving, but not meaning
Shane Gero, a scientist in residence at Ottawa's Carleton University and the lead biologist for Project CETI, finds the cultural transmission aspect interesting.
"You learn these things from your mother and your grandmother and your grandmother's mother," said Gero, who was not involved with the study. "And that yields the need for speakers and listeners to … be concise, for lack of a better word."
But he and others warn that breaking down whale song in this way is not like breaking down a sentence into words — in other words, just because we can find patterns in their songs doesn't mean we know what whales are saying.
"Detecting a pattern like this doesn't make any direct connection to semantics," Gero explained from Ottawa. "In fact, there's plenty of science that shows you can find this in improvisational jazz."
A humpback whale waves its fin out of the water off the coast of Niteroi, Rio de Janeiro state, Brazil. Scientists say that just because we can detect patterns in whale song, it doesn't mean we know what they're saying. (Mauro Pimentel/AFP/Getty Images)
That comparison to musical structure might be the best way to appreciate the parallels, suggests Tecumseh Fitch, a cognitive biologist at the University of Vienna who studies bioacoustics.
"We really don't have any reason to think that these humpback whale vocalizations are telling a story," Fitch told CBC News from Sanibel, Fla. "I think the term song is perfectly appropriate. They're like melodies. It has some meaning, but it's not 'word meanings' the way [human] language does."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
4 hours ago
- Washington Post
Vera Rubin telescope is pointing the world's biggest camera at cosmos
On a mountaintop at the edge of the Atacama Desert in Chile, the world's newest telescope is poised to begin a revolutionary survey of the southern hemisphere's observable universe, one that promises to see more galaxies than ever seen before as well as millions of previously unidentified asteroids roaming our solar system.
New York Times
5 hours ago
- New York Times
Vera Rubin's Legacy Lives On in a Troubled Scientific Landscape
In January, the American Astronomical Society hosted a panel to discuss how the Vera C. Rubin Observatory would transform scientific studies of dark matter, dark energy and the faintest corners of the cosmos. All six panelists, each holding a leadership role related to the observatory, were women. The message, intentional or not, was clear: The legacy of the astronomer Vera C. Rubin, for whom the observatory was named, was not just the way her work revolutionized scientists' understanding of the universe. It was also the way Dr. Rubin charted a path for women and other historically underrepresented groups in science to do the same. 'The universe is universal,' Sandrine Thomas, the deputy director of construction at the observatory, said at the panel. The telescope is now poised to begin the widest, deepest scan of the southern sky in an altered political climate, one in which American science is facing sharp cuts to funding, research project cancellations and rollbacks of programs related to diversity, equity and inclusion, or D.E.I. Astronomers worry about what that means for the future of the observatory, which is funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the National Science Foundation and was renamed in 2019 near the end of the first Trump administration for Dr. Rubin. 'She was the ultimate role model for women in astronomy in the generation after her,' said Jacqueline Mitton, an astronomer based in England and an author of a biography of Dr. Rubin. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
18 hours ago
- Yahoo
'A beautiful partnership': Children take part in 'Summer at Sem, Explorations with the Y' program
Jun. 21—Which solution was the best for making lots of big bubbles? Turning to the 6- to 9-year-olds in her classroom, Wyoming Seminary science teacher asked them to remember their previous experiments. Did the store-bought solution work best? "No!" What about the homemade solution with sugar? "No!" Could it have been the homemade solution with glycerin? "Yes!" came the answer from a dozen budding scientists, who eagerly blew huge streams of bubble using their best solution and bubble blowers that had been handcrafted from plastic bottles with the bottoms cut off and replaced by a cloth that was held in place by a rubber band. The kids vied to make the tallest towers of bubbles, and some of them used their hands to sculpt bubbles into interesting shapes. It was all part of the fun at Summer at Sem, Explorations with the Y, a 3-week program that attracted 113 campers to Wyoming Seminary's Lower School campus in Forty Fort for sessions as diverse as LEGO robotics, photography, basketball and waterplay. "We have everything here," Cheryl Connolly, Wyoming Seminary director of advancement, said Friday, as children took part in the final day of camping activities. "It's a beautiful partnership," Sara Hargadon Michaels, camp director, said of this year's cooperative effort between Wyoming Seminary and the Y, which welcomed students from other schools to join Wyoming Seminary's program, which dates back to the 1990s. Michaels said she had seen children blossom at the camp. "You see the timidness of their first arrival turn into vibrancy and confidence as they soak up the energy of the camp." In one classroom, children sang about waddling ducks approaching a lemonade stand as they rehearsed a skit. In another, Wilkes-Barre Area kindergarten teacher Maria Hayward helped them use up some of their physical energy playing with balloons before they headed outdoors to draw with chalk. And in a gym, dozens of campers were dribbling basketballs. With faculty members from Wyoming Seminary and program specialists from the YMCA facilitating, Michaels said, "what has been provided has only enhanced what has traditionally been presented in the past. Favorites such as LEGO Stop Motion, Chemistry, Magic School Bus, Ocean Explorations, Cardboard Creations and Chef for a Day were joined by Pickleball, Speed and Agility and Sports from Around the World." While those camps were targeted at first through eighth graders, toddlers stayed busy with waterworks, sensory play and more with their teacher Margaret McCann in Arlington House, a separate building on the campus. "The partnership has been a fantastic experience, one that we hope to build on moving forward," Michaels said.
