P.E.I. premier says he would use notwithstanding clause to secure Lands Protection Act
Social Sharing
Premier Rob Lantz says he will do whatever it takes to protect P.E.I.'s Lands Protection Act amid concerns about how that legislation would be affected by the governing Progressive Conservatives' proposed bill to eliminate trade barriers between provinces.
"I will never compromise our Lands Protection Act," Lantz said Wednesday in the legislature, as PC MLAs applauded loudly.
"I would go so far as using the notwithstanding clause to protect our Lands Protection Act here on Prince Edward Island."
Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms — known as the notwithstanding clause — allows for premiers or prime ministers to override rulings on legislation that judges have determined would violate sections of the Charter for a five-year period.
The clause can only override certain sections of the Charter — including Section 2 and sections 7 to 15, which deal with fundamental freedoms, legal rights and equality rights — but can't be used to override democratic rights.
'Critically important'
The PC government's proposed interprovincial trade bill introduced last Friday, would ease the flow of goods to and from other provinces that enact similar legislation, and make it easier for workers in some regulated professions to find employment on the Island.
The opposition parties are concerned the legislation would supersede all other laws, including the Lands Protection Act, which limits non-residential land ownership in the province.
Green MLA Matt MacFarlane said Wednesday that the lands act is "one of our most unique and important pieces of legislation," adding that it is up to the PC government to ensure nothing is removed from the "critically important protections on land."
He noted that Erin McGrath-Gaudet, the province's deputy minister of intergovernmental affairs, said on the floor of the legislature Tuesday that she was only reasonably confident that the Interprovincial Trade and Mobility Act would not negatively impact land protections.
"Islanders expect the premier to ensure, without a shadow of a doubt, that our land protection laws are going to be secure," MacFarlane said.
When asked whether he would commit to reviewing the interprovinical trade bill to guarantee that no part of it can override or weaken P.E.I.'s land protection laws, Lantz said he is committed to doing so.
Federal free trade
Prime Minister Mark Carney said last month that he's committed to removing all federal exemptions under the Canada Free Trade Agreement by July 1.
MacFarlane asked Lantz whether he is willing to gamble the protection of Island land to be first out of the gate when it comes to removing trade barriers between provinces.
"I have heard the federal government — the prime minister and the trade minister — commit to removing federal exemptions from the Canada Free Trade Agreement. I have heard provincial premiers talk about removing all of their party-specific exemptions from the Canada Free Trade Agreement. You haven't heard me say that," Lantz said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
16 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
Canada's tax court rejects appeal from accused in B.C.'s largest alleged money-laundering operation
The Tax Court of Canada has dismissed appeals over undeclared income of more than $6 million from two people who were implicated in B.C.'s largest alleged money-laundering operation. Paul King Jin and his wife Xiaoqi (Apple) Wei had appealed Canada Revenue Agency reassessments of 'undeclared' income, which the CRA said came from a money-lending business that charged steep interest, as much as 10 per cent a week, a massage parlour business since sold, and a property sale. The appeals were rejected, in part, because Jin and Wei did not show up for hearings last year, according to judgments obtained by Postmedia. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. The CRA had asked for a dismissal of the appeals, which Tax Court Justice David Spiro granted, for Jin and Wei's 'failure to prosecute them with due dispatch.' The court allowed appeals from Caixuan Qin and Silver International, an alleged and now defunct underground bank in Richmond, and sent their cases back to the minister of national revenue for reconsideration. The Canada Revenue Agency would not say what are the next steps or whether they would seek taxes and penalties from Jin and Wei for the undeclared income, citing privacy laws. The CRA had alleged that Jin and Wei made or assented to making false statements or omissions in their tax returns, that included failing to report income from the money-lending business. 'Those false statements or omissions were made … knowingly or under circumstances amounting to gross negligence,' said the CRA's court filings. A gross negligence penalty can be as much as 50 per cent on top of the tax owed on unreported income. In its court filings, the CRA said Jin had undeclared income of $3.62 million from 2009-2015 and Wei had $2.76 million in undeclared income from 2012-2015. During that period, Jin reported income of just more than $269,000, an average of less than $40,000 a year, said the CRA. Wei reported income of $69,301, including $1 in 2013. All four parties argued the information used to make the tax reassessments violated their Charter rights because it came from a failed 2015 RCMP investigation into money laundering. Of the parties, only Qin faced criminal charges as a result of the RCMP investigation, charges that were stayed in 2018. No criminal charges were laid against Jin and Wei in the case, which alleged as much as $220 million in dirty money was washed using wealthy Asian gamblers. Qin was accused of operating the underground bank. Jin was accused of receiving nearly $27 million from the bank during a 4½ month period in 2015, as well as running extortion and illegal gambling operations in Richmond. Records filed by Jin and Wei in the Tax Court case say they were informed in 2018 they were no longer under investigation and would not be charged in the RCMP's 2015 E-Pirate investigation. Jin was also cleared in another major money laundering investigation . A special prosecutor appointed by Premier David Eby, when he was the attorney general, declared no charges would be laid in the case that involved millions of dollars that moved through bank accounts, including in China, and bulk cash supplied to Jin. In Qin's case, the CRA's court filing said her undeclared income of $2.33 million between 2011 to 2015 was in part from 'large sums of money' earned by Silver International. Silver International's undeclared income was put at $1.94 million. During that period, Qin had stated her total income as $25,427, less than one per cent of her alleged unreported earnings. Qin was the sole shareholder and director of Silver International, had control of its operations, including sole signing authority, and she deposited cash in 'round' numbers into her personal bank accounts, said the CRA's court filings. Qin's 'lifestyle was far beyond what she could have afforded based on her reported income,' said the CRA. The tax appeal cases had moved slowly, delayed in part by the pandemic. Some reassessments were filed by the CRA as far back as 2017, and some court actions started more than 5½ years ago. ghoekstra@
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
It doesn't have to be politics as usual
Opinion It usually takes a while for a new administration to slide into political gamesmanship. At first, it's all hearts and flowers and fair play — such as Prime Minister Mark Carney's pledge to call a byelection as quickly as possible to let Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre try to win his way back into Parliament. The byelection in question hasn't been called yet, primarily because there are rules and timelines that have to be followed for a newly elected Conservative to resign to create a space for a byelection. Battle River-Crowfoot MP Damien Kurek officially resigned on Tuesday. Kurek had to wait 30 days after his election was posted in the Canada Gazette before he could resign, the Speaker of the House of Commons has to inform Elections Canada of the vacancy and the earliest a byelection call could come is 11 days after that. JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESs fileS Premier Wab Kinew The Governor General sets the byelection day chosen by Carney, who can pick a date as far as 180 days after Kurek's resignation. If Carney lives up to his word, Poilievre can quickly either be back in Parliament after a win, or leave the Opposition leader's official Ottawa residence and no longer be the Stornoway stowaway. But byelections don't always move that quickly — and a case in point is happening here in Manitoba. Back in late March, Progressive Conservative MLA Grant Jackson resigned his Spruce Woods seat to run in the federal election under the Conservative banner. Ever since then, his seat has sat vacant — meaning that, for 88 days now, his former constituents haven't had a representative in the Legislature. That's a point that's been made directly to Premier Wab Kinew in a letter from PC Leader Obby Khan: 'Summer is an important time in rural constituencies full of fairs, festivals and events and whomever should be elected to represent Spruce Woods deserves this opportunity to engage with their constituents,' Khan wrote. Likewise, constituents deserve the opportunity to make their concerns known to their elected representative. There's not much drama involved with a byelection in Spruce Woods. It's a reliably PC seat — since its creation in 2011, it has always elected Progressive Conservatives — and the governing NDP is comfortably in a majority position and doesn't have to pull out all the stops to try to win there. Kinew has moved more quickly on two other byelections — to fill the seats left vacant by the resignation of former PC premier Heather Stefanson and the death of NDP cabinet member Nello Altomare. Both of those seats — Tuxedo and Transcona and were seen as likely to elect NDP candidates and both did. And that brings the political gamesmanship back into play. Wednesdays Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture. Kinew could choose to delay the Spruce Woods byelection until as late as Sept. 24 — and it's entirely within his purview to do exactly that. But just because you can do something, doesn't always mean that you should. The only real questions are who benefits by delaying the byelection, and who loses out? If, in any way, it's voters who are losing out, the answer is a simple one. Set a byelection date as quickly as possible and leave the political strategy by the wayside. A significant portion of the public already believes that politicians don't have their best interests at heart and petty politics just strengthens the impression that politicians put their parties and their own futures ahead of the public good. Why fuel voter apathy and mistrust — especially in the case of Spruce Woods, where the prospective gains seem so small — when there's a chance to take the high road instead?
CBC
3 days ago
- CBC
Manitoba declined to follow through on urgent plans to review wildfire preparedness after NDP took power
Manitoba declined to follow through on urgent plans outlined in provincial documents to conduct an external review of wildfire preparedness after the NDP took power in 2023. The minister in charge said the province conducted internal assessments of the wildfire service instead. In a note prepared for the incoming government marked as an "urgent issue" in the fall of 2023, Manitoba's wildfire service said it wanted to review how prepared it was to respond to the next wildfire season, detect wildfires and make tactical decisions. That note was part of a government-transition binder prepared for NDP officials following the provincial election in October 2023, in which the previous Progressive Conservative government was defeated. That binder was later published, with some redactions. The service said in the note that it was "exploring opportunities" to hire a consultant to conduct a forensic examination of the 2023 wildfire season and assess the preparedness of the wildfire service for the next wildfire season. "The focus of the study would be on identifying opportunities for improvement and addressing gaps," read the note, which listed assistant deputy minister Kristin Hayward as the official responsible. The study would have examined how decisions were made both before and during the wildfire season, whether staff requested, collected and examined the right information to prepare for and manage wildfires, and whether the service had the right systems in in place to to support "safe, efficient and effective decision-making and operations," according to the note. The study also would have looked at "whether the right information got to the people that needed it, both on a daily operational basis and during incidents," and whether existing policies and practices were followed, according to the note. In addition, the study would have looked at whether key wildfire service personnel had the appropriate training and experience, the note said. 'Reviewed the options': province Since the 2023 note, the government has not hired a consultant to assess Manitoba's wildfire preparedness, according to a statement from the province, which was not attributed to any official. "The province reviewed the options but ultimately did not proceed with using an external consultant at that time," the statement said. Ian Bushie, Manitoba's minister of natural resources and Indigenous futures, said in a statement the province conducted internal assessments of response times, protection and wildfire forecasting in 2024 and 2025. Those assessments were led by the wildfire service, in collaboration with other departments and agencies, he said, with a focus on "building capacity within our public service" rather than outsourcing. "Their deep knowledge and expertise provide strong internal capacity to identify what worked and where improvements are needed," Bushie said. In an interview late Wednesday, Bushie said he could not say whether the internal assessments conducted over the past two years replicated the external review envisioned in 2023. "Those things are a work in progress," the minister said. "As we go forward in each season, we learn from each season, we learn in real time to be able to assess. "So I couldn't actually go back and refer to old documents and say, yes, we've checked this box." Bushie also said he is not aware what transpired in 2023, when a PC government was in power, to warrant a forensic examination of wildfire preparedness. Infrastructure and Transportation Minister Lisa Naylor said during a Monday news conference that wildfire officials were prepared for everything that has transpired during the 2025 wildfire season, the worst in recent memory. A total of 9,022 square kilometres of the province have burned so far this year, displacing roughly 22,000 people. The burned area works out to 1.6 per cent of Manitoba's land mass. Manitoba Progressive Conservative Leader Obby Khan questioned whether the province was in fact prepared for a wildfire season of this magnitude. "The question becomes, was this government completely caught off guard by this?" Khan asked during an interview from Ottawa. He questioned why Manitoba did not hire an external consultant to review wildfire preparedness. "This recommendation was made to the NDP. The NDP chose not to take action," he said.
