‘Where was God?' The Mother Emanuel AME Church shooting 10 years later.

Get The Gavel
A weekly SCOTUS explainer newsletter by columnist Kimberly Atkins Stohr.
Enter Email
Sign Up
This was quite remarkable, because less than 48 hours earlier, on the night of June 17, 2015, Sanders had just closed her eyes in benediction — during Bible study at her beloved Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church — when she was jolted by an explosion of gunfire. The 57-year-old woman, a fourth-generation member of 'Mother Emanuel,' the oldest A.M.E. church in the South, dove under a table and pulled her 11-year-old granddaughter down with her. She squeezed the child so tightly she feared she might crush her, instructing her to play dead as a 21-year-old white supremacist methodically assassinated nine of the 12 Black worshippers in the basement fellowship hall. Those she watched die included her 26-year-old son, Tywanza Sanders, who had tried vainly to distract the shooter, and her 87-year-old aunt, Susie Jackson, who was shredded by 10 hollow-point bullets. At one point, Sanders smeared her legs with the blood pooling at her feet so that the killer might think he had finished her off. It worked.
What happened in court two days later, a procession of forgiveness by Black victims for a remorseless racist murderer, both awed and befuddled the world. Many found it to be the purest expression of Christianity they had ever witnessed and could not imagine ever being graced in any such way. With the help of a soaring and melodic eulogy for the victims by President Barack Obama, the church known as Mother Emanuel soon became an earthly emblem of amazing grace.
FILE - Tyrone Sanders and Felicia Sanders comfort each other at the graveside of their son, Tywanza Sanders, on June 27, 2015, at Emanuel AME Cemetery in Charleston, S.C. (Grace Beahm/The Post And Courier via AP, File)
Grace Beahm/Associated Press
Now fast-forward to December 2016. Felicia Sanders is back in court, the lead witness in the death penalty trial of Dylann Roof. She is under cross-examination by Roof's attorney, who is trying to establish that Roof threatened to kill himself that night, a desperate stab at a psychiatric defense. This time there is no nod by Sanders at forgiveness, no prayer for the soul of her son's unrepentant executioner. 'He say he was going to kill himself, and I was counting on that,' Sanders responds coolly in her Lowcountry lilt, glaring at Roof from the stand. 'He's evil. There's no place on earth for him except for the pit of hell.' Roof's lawyer, blindsided, tries once more to prompt Sanders about Roof's suicidality. She is having none of it: 'Send himself back to the pit of hell, I say.'
Had something changed about Felicia Sanders? Had she, in the 18 months between the Emanuel murders and the trial, forsaken the commitment to forgiveness that was such a hallmark of her faith and that had so moved the world? Not in the slightest, I concluded, while researching a book about the history of Mother Emanuel and the meaning of forgiveness in the African American church. To the contrary, Sanders and other church stalwarts helped me understand that the forgiveness expressed
toward
Dylann Roof had not been
for
Dylann Roof but rather for themselves.
Those who appeared at Roof's bond hearing did not speak for everyone in the congregation, or even in their families. A decade later, some still describe the path to forgiveness as a journey they travel at their own pace. But the grace volunteered in June 2015 grew organically from the fiber of African Methodism, a denomination two centuries old. It obviously had deep scriptural roots — 'Forgive us our trespasses' and 'Forgive them, for they know not what they do.' But it also was an iteration of a timeworn survival mechanism that has helped African American Christians withstand enslavement, forced migration, captivity, indentured servitude, segregation, discrimination, denial of citizenship, and the constant threat of racial and sexual violence with their souls and their sanity still, somehow, intact.
One year after the shootings at Mother Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, S.C., relatives and friends of the slain gathered to honor their lives.
Grace Beahm/Associated Press
Churches like Emanuel, which has roots in antebellum Charleston, have long served as physical and spiritual refuges from the scourges that confront Black Americans. Its own long history, a two-century cycle of suppression and resistance, illuminates the relentless afflictions of caste in the city where nearly half of all enslaved Africans disembarked in North America and where the Civil War began.
Emanuel's predecessor congregation, which formed in 1817 after a subversive walkout from Methodist churches by free and enslaved Black Charlestonians, faced immediate harassment from white authorities. The police raided services and jailed worshippers by the scores. When an incipient slave insurrection plot was uncovered in 1822 and traced back in part to the church, 35 men were led to the gallows, nearly half of them from the congregation. The wood-frame building was dismantled by order of the authorities and the church's leading ministers forced into exile.
Emanuel's founding pastor after the Civil War, Richard Harvey Cain, used its pulpit as a springboard into politics, winning seats in the state legislature and Congress in a career that mirrored at first the heady hope and then the stolen promise of Reconstruction. During the depths of Jim Crow, Charlestonians assembled at Emanuel to voice outrage over lynchings and jurisprudential travesties. Its civil rights era pastor, Benjamin J. Glover, also led Charleston's NAACP, staged peaceful protest marches from the church, and was repeatedly jailed. Congregants were urged to action there by Booker T. Washington (1909), W.E.B. DuBois (1921), and Martin Luther King Jr. (1962), and then, a year after King's assassination, by his widow, Coretta Scott King (1969). She came to support a hospital workers' strike that bore eerie echoes of the sanitation workers' strike that had drawn her husband to Memphis. Nearly five decades later, the first person shot by Dylann Roof on June 17, 2015, was the Rev. Clementa Pinckney, a remarkable prodigy who had been the youngest African American elected to South Carolina's legislature and was serving his fourth term in the state Senate.
A horse-drawn carriage carried the casket of the late South Carolina State Senator Clementa Pinckney past the Confederate flag and onto the grounds of the South Carolina State Capitol in Columbia, S.C. on June 24, 2015.
REUTERS
The weight of it all takes the breath away. And for many, forgiveness might seem an inadequate response, given available options like anger, bitterness, hatred, revenge, retribution. A more natural one, perhaps a more human one, might even be 'Where was God?'
But in interviews over the years, each of the six family members who spoke mercifully toward Dylann Roof explained that they did so for their own spiritual release. They depicted the moment in mystical terms — unpremeditated, unexpected, the words just flowed, it was God talking. But none said they meant for their words to be read as a grant of exoneration or a pass from accountability. No slate had been wiped. Indeed, some did not care much whether Roof lived or died (he remains on federal death row in Indiana, one of three inmates whose sentences were not commuted to life in prison by President Joe Biden at the close of his term).
Rather, the mothers and children and widowers of the dead described their brand of forgiveness as a purging of self-destructive toxins, a means for reversing the metastasis of rage, and at its most basic a way to get out of bed each morning in the face of it all. It served as an unburdening, not an undoing, a method not only of moral practice but of emotional self-preservation. Because the choice to forgive was one dignity that could not be taken away, it also served as a path to empowerment. It might be mistaken for submission, but in Charleston it resurrected agency for victims who had been robbed of it.
'He is not a part of my life anymore,' the Rev. Anthony Thompson, the widower of Bible study leader Myra Thompson, told me in explaining his forgiveness of Roof. 'Forgiveness has freed me of that, of him, completely. I'm not going to make him a lifetime partner.'
This may be disconcerting for some white Americans who found reassurance in the notion that those who forgave Dylann Roof were, by association, also forgiving — or at least moving beyond — the four-century legacy of white supremacy that contributed to his poisoning. They decidedly were not, and the question of whether we make serious progress toward eradicating the psychosis of race in this country and the inequities it bequeaths in wealth, education, housing, justice, and health, not to mention hope, awaits an answer on the 50th or 100th anniversary of the massacre at Mother Emanuel.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Yahoo

an hour ago

• Yahoo

IOC is in 'best of hands', says Bach as he hands over to Coventry

Kirsty Coventry became the president of the International Olympic Committee (IOC), the most powerful person in sport, on Monday in a handover ceremony with her predecessor Thomas Bach. The Zimbabwean is the first woman and African to head the body and at 41 the youngest since Baron Pierre de Coubertin, who is credited with founding the modern-day Olympics. Advertisement Coventry accepted the Olympic key from Bach, who like her is an Olympic champion -- he won a team fencing gold in 1976 and she earned two swimming golds in 2004 and 2008. Stepping down after a turbulent 12-year tenure, Bach expressed his confidence that the Olympic movement was "in the best of hands" and Coventry would bring "conviction, integrity and a dynamic perspective" to the role. Coventry, who swept to a crushing first-round victory in the election in Greece in March, leans heavily on her family. Aside from her parents, who were present at the ceremony in Lausanne, there is her husband Tyrone Seward, who was effectively her campaign manager, and two daughters, six-year-old Ella, who Bach addresses as "princess", and Lily, just seven months old. Advertisement "Ella saw this spider web in the garden and I pointed out how it is made, and how strong and resilient it is to bad weather and little critters," said Coventry, who takes over officially at midnight Swiss time Monday (2200 GMT). "But if one little bit breaks it becomes weaker. That spider web is our movement, it is complex, beautiful and strong but it only works if we remain together and united." - 'Pure passion' - Coventry said she could not believe how her life had evolved since she first dreamt of Olympic glory in 1992. "How lucky are we creating a platform for generations to come to reach their dreams," she said to a packed audience in a marquee in the Olympic House garden, which comprised IOC members, including those she defeated, and dignitaries. Advertisement "It is amazing and incredible, indeed I cannot believe that from my dream in 1992 of going to an Olympic Games and winning a medal I would be standing here with you to make dreams for more young children round the world." Coventry, who served in the Zimbabwean government as sports and arts Minister from 2019 to this year, said the Olympic movement was much more than a "multi-sport event platform." "We (IOC members) are guardians of this movement, which is also about inspiring and changing lives and bringing hope," she said. "These things are not to be taken lightly and I will be working with each and every one of you to continue to change lives and be a beacon of hope in a divided world. Advertisement "I am really honoured to walk this journey with you." Bach, who during his tenure had to grapple with Russian doping and their invasions of the Crimea and Ukraine as well as the Covid pandemic, said he was standing down filled with "gratitude, joy and confidence" in his successor. "With her election it sends out a powerful message, that the IOC continues to evolve," said the 71-year-old German, who was named honorary lifetime president in Greece in March. "It has its first female and African to hold this position, and the youngest president since Pierre de Coubertin. She represents the truly global and youthful spirit of our community." Advertisement Bach, who choked back tears at one point during his valedictory speech, was praised to the rafters by Coventry, who was widely seen as his preferred candidate of the seven vying for his post. After a warm embrace she credited him with teaching her to "listen to people and to respect them," and praised him for leading the movement with "pure passion and purpose." "You have kept us united through the most turbulent times. "You left us with many legacies and hope, thank you from the bottom of my heart for leading us with passion and never wavering from our values." pi/gj

Politico

2 hours ago

• Politico

Newspaper death and taxes

Good Monday morning! The U.S. bombed Iran, and it's hard to start any newsletter without a nod to the nation's possible entanglement in a Middle East war whose justification involves the threat of weapons of mass destruction. But here in New Jersey we're focused on the budget. There are no budget committee meetings scheduled for today in either house, and so far not for this week. But there will have to be. Right now, it's looking like budget committees will meet Tuesday — one week before the budget is due. So we're all waiting to find out what will happen to several proposed tax increases. Of course, the budget will be accompanied by all kinds of other legislation, some of it likely controversial. And one of those bills, while sounding boring, is very important: the law on publishing legal notices. And we finally have some clarity on that. Senate President Nick Scutari on Friday introduced legislation that would cut the news media out of any mandated role in publishing legal notices for public entities. They'd be required to host the notices on their own websites by March. However, legal notices from individuals and companies — say, a notice of a person's name change — would still be required to be published in a news publication. Bills like this typically change before they gain final passage, but given that this bill is sponsored by the Senate president, whatever ultimately passes will probably at least resemble it. And this issue has to be resolved — or at least delayed again — by the end of the month. One thing that sticks out to me is that the towns would only be required to keep archives of the notices for one year. That seems particularly short. When they were published in newspapers, even if the notices were no longer archived online, you could as a last resort find the notice in an archived printed copy or microfilm. When former Gov. Chris Christie tried to do this in 2016, it was known around Trenton as the 'newspaper death bill.' Maybe it would have hastened it, but death came anyway. Still, even if politicians love to take shots at the publications owned by big companies like Gannett and Advance, the publications that will likely be most hurt are the tiny ones that still cover quite a bit of local news. FEEDBACK? Reach me at mfriedman@ WHERE'S MURPHY — No public schedule QUOTE OF THE DAY: 'Right now, I do not.' — Jack Ciattarelli, when asked if he disagrees with President Donald Trump on anything HAPPY BIRTHDAY — Daniel Han, Pedro Mejia, Michael Clarke, Burt Ray Simpson, Larry Yudelson, Asia Norton WHAT TRENTON MADE YOU CAN CALL THE AL — Ciattarelli courts Black faith leaders in governor's race, by POLITICO's Daniel Han: Republican Jack Ciattarelli's gubernatorial campaign has reached out to Black faith leaders across the state — trying to broaden the GOP coalition headed into November. Two prominent Black faith leaders said they have been in contact with Ciattarelli representatives to possibly have him meet their congregations — with one saying he is trying to broker a meeting with Republican nominee Ciattarelli and Democratic stalwart Rev. Al Sharpton. The move underscores Republicans' efforts to make inroads with Black voters who have traditionally been a key part of the Democratic coalition … Rev. Charles Boyer, a prominent social justice activist, said in an interview that it was not out of character for Ciattarelli to reach out to him — and that he has observed Ciattarelli making more outreach to Black faith leaders than his Democratic opponent, Rep. Mikie Sherrill. 'She hasn't outreached to me and I've heard from far more people that Jack Ciattarelli has reached out to them than Mikie Sherrill,' Boyer said, speaking of fellow Black faith leaders. 'I've heard Jack Ciattarelli reaching out [from] multiple folks. I have not heard multiple congregations saying that about Mikie Sherrill. That's not a critique, that's just a reality.' — After this story ran Friday, Boyer told Han he had an 'encouraging discussion' with Sherrill and that her campaign's outreach was 'ramping up.' HOT MATCHING FUNDS IN THE SUMMERTIME — 'N.J.'s red-hot governor race cooling off for summer? Don't bet on it,' by NJ Advance Media's Tom Martello: 'In the last week along, things got particularly snippy on social media: Sherrill accusing Ciattarelli of bowing to every action Trump takes, even ones that will hurt New Jersey; Ciattarelli saying Sherrill is a Phil Murphy clone who doesn't have a clue when it comes to state issues. The breathless news releases continue. Each campaign continues to post unflattering videos clips of the other, in the hopes of going viral. But what should the campaigns be doing this summer, while the rest of us are trying to enjoy some peace and quiet down the Shore? Their challenges might be bigger than even they realize.' LOOKING FORWARD TO ANOTHER NINE-HOUR COMMITTEE MEETING — 'With minor amendments, anti-Semitism bill will get Assembly consideration on Monday,' by New Jersey Globe's David Wildstein: 'Assembly Democrats will move forward on legislation establishing a state definition of anti-Semitism, ending a four-month standoff with Jewish leaders that pushed consideration of the bill until after the June 10 primary election. The proposed legislation sponsored by Assemblymen Gary Schaer (D-Passaic) and Michael Inganamort (R-Chester) used the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) working definition of anti-Semitism that includes rhetorical or physical manifestations directed at Jews. The new language, obtained by the New Jersey Globe, requires law enforcement to take the state's definition of anti-Semitism into consideration during a review, investigation, or determination of whether the federal anti-bias statute was violated and prior to deciding whether an incident was motivated by anti-Semitic intent.' FLIGHT OF THE VALKEARNYS — 'Low-flying helicopters buzz over N.J. every day. There's a crusade to ground them forever,' by NJ Advance Media's AJ McDougall: 'Scores of helicopters pass over Hudson County — mainly Jersey City, Hoboken and Bayonne — every day on their way to and from New York. Though a handful carry first responders or news crews, the vast majority of these flights are what critics deem 'nonessential,' ferrying tourists on sightseeing quests and well-heeled commuters who can afford to ride to work in style. Depending on the weather, anywhere between 20 and 140 of these flights will buzz over the same neighborhoods from early in the morning until long after dark, many of them at low altitudes … On June 4, Hudson County Executive Craig Guy announced an agreement that would scale back 'rampant helicopter activity' in the area … Those assurances were made by Jeff Hyman, CEO of HHI Heliport, a private facility in Kearny that's long been 'public enemy No. 1' to anti-chopper nonprofit groups like Stop the Chop NY-NJ and Safe Skies Coalition, its younger Hudson County-based sibling. Both organizations see Guy's announcement as a small step in the right direction. But what they really want is a wholesale ban on nonessential flights — to put Hyman and his heliport out of business.' HUNGRY HUNGRY ONES AND ZEROES — 'NJ lawmakers target energy-hungry AI data centers,' by NJ Spotlight News' Joanna Gagis: 'With New Jersey residents facing steep hikes in electric bills, some lawmakers are taking aim at a growing industry that has been singled out for driving up costs: artificial intelligence data centers. Assemblyman Dave Bailey (D-Salem), has sponsored a bill to create a rate structure, known as a tariff, for any new data centers built in the state. 'We've got to strategize. We have to think, what are the positive impacts of this type of technology, what are the potential negative impacts, especially on the ratepayer and the increased use of energy that will come about because of the use of the data centers,' Bailey said.' SO IS THAT A 'NO'? — 'Murphy: State 'partnership' with Atlantic City is working, and Mayor Small agrees,' by The Press of Atlantic City's Wayne Parry: 'A law giving the state vast control over the city's activities is set to expire in December, just over a month before the term-limited Democratic governor leaves office. In an interview with The Press of Atlantic City, [Gov. Phil] Murphy was asked whether the Municipal Stabilization and Recovery Act, widely referred to as the state takeover law, should continue or be allowed to expire. 'As I sit here, you've got a successful partnership,' Murphy said. 'We've done a lot of really good things together. You have to have a very compelling rationale to break that partnership up.' … Mayor Marty Small Sr. agreed. 'I was the biggest one against the state takeover, but it turned out to work,' he said.' — 'Ras Baraka isn't ready to give up national spotlight after primary loss: 'My voice is going to continue to grow'' — 'Kim campaigns with Sherrill in Paterson' — 'N.J. increasing security at Jewish, Muslim houses of worship after Iran strikes' TRUMP ERA THE NEW POLLUTION — 'Dozens of sites may soon release more air pollution in NJ. Here's why,' by NJ Spotlight News' Benjamin J. Hulac: '[President Donald Trump] is poised to sign legislation into law to allow roughly 1,800 polluting sites nationwide, like mills, power stations, chemical plants and oil refineries, to increase the volume of hazardous air pollutants they can release … 'What it will mean for the public is more hazardous air pollution from industrial facilities that cause cancer, brain damage, birth defects, infertility, heart attacks, strokes and even premature death,' John Walke, an attorney for the Natural Resources Defense Council, an environmental and legal advocacy group, said in an interview with NJ Spotlight News. New Jersey is downwind of heavily industrialized states, including Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky, Pennsylvania and West Virginia … New Jersey's congressional delegation split along party lines.' — 'Mahmoud Khalil arrives in New Jersey after release from ICE custody' — 'VA cuts spell major trouble for New Jersey veterans. Here's how | Opinion' — 'Biden's DOJ found lingering issues in Newark's English language learner program. Trump's team closed the case' LOCAL NJ TRANSIT TO ALSO STUDY EXTENDING THE WILDWOOD TRAMCAR TO ENGLEWOOD — 'Officials, NJ Transit riders frustrated as Bergen light rail extension study delayed until 2026,' by NJ Advance Media's Larry Higgs: 'Commuters who've waited 25 years for a promised light rail extension to Bergen County will have to wait longer for NJ Transit to start a study that a federal agency mandated be done in August 2023. A critical study needed for extending the Hudson-Bergen Light Rail to Englewood won't start until mid-2026 when a consultant to do it is expected to be hired, NJ Transit officials said. That study, which would technically be the fourth for the project that has been pending for 25 years, was mandated by the Federal Transit Administration in August 2023 in a move that surprised and angered public officials …. Some officials said they are just as dismayed that little progress has been made to update that study in almost two years. 'I'm very frustrated,' said State Assemblywoman Shama Haider, D- Bergen. 'It should have taken a few months.'' ROSELLE PARK TO CHANGE NAME TO TOXI CITY — 'Families of cancer victims demand answers as N.J. town shutters site of possible toxic exposure,' by NJ Advance Media's Jackie Roman: 'Roselle Park council members voted to lay off six people, spend $1.4 million to outsource public works to Kenilworth and knock down the crumbling building located on contaminated land — part of what the outspoken workers say has led to multiple illnesses and deaths. The decision comes three weeks after NJ Advance Media published an article detailing a 30-year history of contamination at Roselle Park Department of Public Works and employees' concerns about it … 'I think it's retaliation for the safety and health concerns being brought to light,' said laborer Josh Regan, one of the employees laid off Thursday who spoke up about his concerns. The employees say that more than a half dozen former public works employees have died from different types of cancer between 2017 and 2024.' NEWARK — 'Here's what happened in [Newark] when some got $12,000, no strings attached,' by NJ Advance Media's Steve Strunsky: 'The $4.8 million [guaranteed income pilot program] was funded by some of Newark's best-known philanthropic organizations, including the Geraldine R. Dodge Foundation, the Prudential Foundation and Victoria Foundation. The Morristown-based MCJ Amelior Foundation, the Princeton-based Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and the Stadler Family Charitable Foundation in Titusville also contributed. Tuesday's forum, which included the income program's manager, Kaleena Berryman, coincided with the release of an analysis of the trial by the University of Pennsylvania's Center for Guaranteed Income Research. The study found that the program improved income stability, stress levels, food security and other quality of life indicators for individual recipients and their families, though the improvements faded after the payments ended.' — 'Trump cuts target Newark's most effective anti-violence program | Opinion' CASTING A PRINCIPALL — 'Passaic High School loses popular principal as budget cuts hit district,' by The Record's Mary Ann Koruth: 'In just two years as principal of Passaic High School, José Blankley-Celis had already made an impact. Graduation rates went up, and schoolwide test scores were meeting federal targets after steadily failing. Blankley-Celis managed to improve school engagement among the school's mostly Hispanic, working-class families — a huge challenge in low-income, urban districts like Passaic City. Yet Blankley-Celis was among 51 employees laid off in March due to budget cuts, months before the high school closes down to be demolished and rebuilt and its students transition from their old building to a city-wide campus in the fall, a move that Blankley-Celis and his team also planned. The district rehired eight employees in early June. Blankley-Celis was not among them. Seniority protections and 'bumping rights' awarded by state law drove the rehiring, said superintendent Sandra Montanez-Diodonet.' FOR RAEL? — 'Reporter enters politics: Israel joins O'Dea to run for council in Jersey City's Ward E,' by Hudson County View's John Heinis: 'Former Hudson Reporter and TapInto journalist Dan Israel is entering the political arena as a candidate, seeking the Jersey City Ward E council seat on Hudson County Commissioner Bill O'Dea's (D-2) slate. 'I'm tired of sitting in dismay as a reporter while I write about local happenings wishing for a better outcome. So I'm putting down my pen and running for local office to be the change I seek in the world,' he wrote on Instagram.' — 'Mapping the 2025 Hudson County war' — 'Tears, memories as students, alumni say goodbye to Passaic High' — 'Hackensack appoints acting superintendent in place of suspended official' — 'Paterson Dems ready to vote for new party leaders for first time in more than a decade' — 'Grand jury declines to indict Orange councilman' EVERYTHING ELSE — 'N.J. nursing homes ordered to pay $2.1 million to Medicaid for understaffing' — 'Meet the robots that are helping keep the planes flying at this N.J. airport'

Business Insider

3 hours ago

• Business Insider

‘Our people were armed by the Russians' during apartheid, South African official reveals

South Africa's vice president, Paul Mashatile, paid a visit to Moscow last week where he met with Russian President Vladimir Putin and his team. During the meeting, the subject of apartheid was revisited. The vice president expressed gratitude for Russia's aid during the apartheid era. South Africa's vice president met with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Moscow last week. The discussion revisited topics including Russia's support during South Africa's apartheid era. The ongoing friendship and cooperation between Russia and African nations were emphasized. Subsequently, Russia history with South Africa's apartheid period was futher elaborated on by Keith Khoza, the acting spokesman for South Africa's deputy president, during his interview with Sputnik. 'During the time when apartheid was an issue, our people were trained in Russia, were armed by the Russians, and in some instances, they gave us other forms of support, so our relationship is historic,' the spokeman stated. 'We've continued to be friends to Russia, and they've continued to be friends to us, so why we are here and why Africa is responding is because Russia has always been there, at the time of need for most of African countries to see how they can assist, support, and be with them in terms of the struggles that they went through,' he added. The topic of media portrayal and narrative framing also came up, as Khoza praised Sputnik 's intentions to open an office in South Africa, saying that doing so is essential to accurately representing African reality. 'You may try and understand issues from a distance, but when you get closer and more intimate with the situation, you get a different understanding of the dynamics, issues, and the perceptions of people in that particular area,' Khoza remarked. In February, Russia fast tracked its cultrual engagement with Africa with the establishment of an editorial center in Ethiopia. The media center which is based in Ethiopia will be Russia's first large-scale, multi-functional editorial center on the continent. Vladimir Putin and Paul Mashatile's meeting last week During the meeting last week, President Vladimir Putin emphasized that Russia and South Africa have a common viewpoint on a number of global issues. "We share solidarity when it comes to international agenda items," he added, adding that both nations always coordinate their efforts on multilateral forums. Putin also emphasized that improving cooperation with African states, notably South Africa, is a top priority for Russian foreign policy. This heightened emphasis on bilateral cooperation is seen in the larger context of Russia's strategic shift to Africa, particularly as it seeks deeper ties amid geopolitical tensions with the West. In response, Deputy President Mashatile echoed the aforemtioned sentiments of Keith Khoza during the formal meeting, stating, "The people of South Africa will never forget Moscow's help in their liberation from apartheid."