Gov. Cox's veto preserves 'lifesaver' tax relief for low-income seniors, advocates say
SALT LAKE CITY — Cheryl and Gary Johnson bought their South Salt Lake home for just $10,500 — more than 60 years ago — hoping to start a family.
The young couple did just that, and the house soon became home for their three kids and, eventually, grandchildren and great-grandchildren. It is filled with photos chronicling the joy and heartbreak of more than six decades living there, but the Johnsons have left a more permanent mark on the home in the form of several added rooms they built in the 1980s that more than doubled the home's footprint.
The couple would plant willow saplings to mark the birth of each child — the two remaining trees now stand more than 40 feet tall.
Cheryl Johnson is particularly proud of the large brick fireplace and hearth her husband built from the ground up in the dining room. She said the company that installed the firebox asked if it could include photos of the hearth in its catalog, but her husband, a brick mason by trade, declined.
'I said, 'Honey, that's an honor. Why would you not want that?'' she recalls telling her husband. 'He said: 'I just don't want anyone to steal my pattern.' ... His dad was a brick and stone mason, and he took up the trade business. He loved it, and he was good. He was the best.'
The home — where Cheryl Johnson, 83, now lives with her cat, Jojo — is now valued at more than $400,000, and the annual increases in property tax have stretched her budget, especially since her husband died in 2013.
'I'm so proud of my home,' she said. 'I'm going to be here the rest of my life. Nobody can take this house; and after, I'm hoping one of my kids can buy it.'
Johnson is able to stay in her house in part because of the so-called Circuit Breaker program, which provides tax relief to older Utahns who may not be able to afford annual property tax payments. Those who qualify based on annual income can have a portion of their property tax bill abated, a program just shy of 10,000 Utahns have taken advantage of in recent years.
'They call it the Circuit Breaker for a reason — because, essentially, this is at the point where people are struggling to keep their lights on,' said Salt Lake County Treasurer Sheila Srivastava, who oversees the county program.
It's a program that has existed for decades but one that Utah lawmakers planned to substantially change by making tax forgiveness unavailable to new applicants going forward — until the governor stepped in and vetoed the bill hours before the deadline to do so last week.
Tax relief for low-income older adults comes in several forms, including the tax forgiveness program and a tax deferral program. The deferral allows homeowners to hold off on paying property taxes until they sell the house or until it is passed down to a relative, at which point the owner would be responsible for paying the back taxes. Other programs provide tax relief for those with disabilities, active duty service members and veterans, among others.
Under SB197, state Sen. Dan McCay, R-Riverton, said the Circuit Breaker program would stop taking new applicants after a couple of years, requiring low-income homeowners to rely on the tax deferral program.
Those already receiving abatement would be grandfathered in, he said, meaning nobody would be kicked off of the benefits they currently enjoy.
As the Circuit Breaker program is designed to prevent people who are 'house rich, cash poor' from being kicked out due to indigence, McCay argues the deferral program still provides relief, while ensuring the county is eventually paid back for those taxes when the homeowner receives the windfall from selling their property.
'If they don't have cash to contribute to the property tax system, we want to make sure that taxes are not the reason that they have to leave their home,' he told KSL.com Monday. 'This person gets a tax benefit for a number of years, but then when they go to sell their home, they pay back the taxpayers, and everybody else's property tax goes down incrementally for paying those property taxes over the years.'
SB197 would also have frozen property tax increases for those on the deferral program even if the value of the home went up, McCay said, adding the difference to the amount to be paid upon sale of the home.
While presenting the bill to the Senate Revenue and Taxation Committee in February, he argued the tax forgiveness program can be used to pass on property to heirs without having to pay taxes on it.
'The idea of protecting the inheritance of a future generation by not having someone pay property tax should concern everybody,' McCay said. 'The key thing here is making sure that low-income seniors are protected and not forced out of their homes for tax purposes.'
SB197 passed on the final night of this year's legislative session after it was amended, with just hours to go, to include a prohibition on receiving Circuit Breaker benefits along with other forms of tax relief. Upon passage, several groups and individuals who had organized against the bill pivoted to urge Gov. Spencer Cox to veto it.
Groups such as the Utah Housing Coalition, Crossroads Urban Center and the Utah Disability Law Center wrote to the governor arguing that the tax relief amounts to only a small expense and said the bill would hurt low-income Utahns. Tim Funk, who works in advocacy for the Crossroads Urban Center, said he has worked with the program since its inception and called McCay's bill 'perplexing.'
'I'm a person who's just short of 80 years old, and I understand what that means in terms of tax forgiveness for people. The reason I came back into working on this, about three or four years ago, was (because) it was obvious that people needed more help,' Funk said. 'It's a humble program. It's not giving away the store.'
Phil Conder, the chief deputy treasurer of Davis County, and others have argued eliminating the Circuit Breaker would lead to some Utahns going without food or medication so as not to leave their heirs with a deferred tax bill upon their death. He said the current program is more cost-effective for taxpayers.
'If you were to take away the Circuit Breaker program, you're going to create a hardship on this demographic that will have to be accounted for in other ways,' Conder said. 'Do we force them into a care center that's now being paid for by different taxes? I believe it's the most cost-effective way to help these people.'
Eventually, treasurers from 27 of the state's 29 counties joined the chorus of voices calling for a veto. Grand County Treasurer Chris Kauffman led a letter explaining their position.
'We are especially concerned that seniors will forgo medicine, food and other essentials in order to stay in their home and avoid burdening their children,' the letter stated.
Srivastava estimated the program in Salt Lake County adds about $3 per month to the average homeowner's property tax bill — an increase she is willing to defend.
'It's going to be a really big impact for the people that it serves,' she said of the Circuit Breaker. 'They come into the office crying and struggling, and this feels like it's a lifesaver for them.'
The governor appeared to agree. On March 27, he vetoed SB197 — one of only six bills he rejected this year.
'A number of our county government leaders expressed concerns and asked for a veto due to administrative challenges with this policy change,' he wrote in a letter explaining his decision. 'They also expressed concerns about the impact this would have on our senior population. I agree with both of those concerns.'
Cox said he believed the bill had 'well-intentioned goals' but said it 'risks cutting off the most vulnerable of Utah's expanding senior population from a critical tax relief lifeline.'
In his letter, Cox said he is 'committed to working' with lawmakers on broader reforms to the state's tax system, and efforts to change the Circuit Breaker should be undertaken as part of a 'comprehensive' overhaul. McCay was skeptical that such overhauls are possible.
'I'm optimistic in that ... we can work on the issue going forward,' he said. 'My confidence in broader tax reform is low, having seen how broader tax reform goes with the public. ... We are far better off looking at small policies and making changes as we can, and I felt like (SB197) was a great step in the right direction. However, this process requires 38 votes in the House and 15 votes in the Senate, and I fell one vote short in the executive branch.'
The bill passed, initially, without enough votes to overturn Cox's veto, and McCay didn't say whether he plans to push for a veto override.
Srivastava was thrilled by the veto.
'I love it so much,' she said. 'I think that hearing (Cox) say those words was a really big testament to the fact that we can come out of this in a better way and that there is hope to see our politicians and our local elected officials working together for the common good.'
Although Johnson's own benefits would remain intact either way, she thinks Cox made the right call and said the veto will continue to let people have the same opportunities she has had — at least for the time being.
'It means a lot to me, and to my family,' she said. 'I don't know what I would do without it, for sure.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10-06-2025
- Yahoo
Cheryl Louise Johnson, Youngstown, Ohio
YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio (MyValleyTributes) – Cheryl Louise Johnson departed this worldly life on Wednesday, June 4, 2025, at Hospice House. Cheryl was born in Youngstown on June 6, 1945, to Donald and Mildred (Neville) Johnson. Find obituaries from your high school Little is known about Cheryl's early years or any extended family members but she became part of the Gateways to Better Living family on February 7, 1991. Prior to moving to Gateways, Cheryl was also a resident at the Youngstown Developmental Center. Cheryl enjoyed the simple pleasures in life. She loved to listen to music and watch television, oftentimes simultaneously. She was active in Gateway's Day programs where she got to spend time doing arts and crafts, going on outings and enjoying parties and day-to-day life with her fellow housemates. Cheryl loved sitting in her rocking chair and looking out into her wooded yard to see if she could spot any birds or a friendly squirrel. She will be dearly missed by her roommates, whom which she made her home; her caregivers and her entire Gateway's family. Cheryl also leaves a sister, Cynthia Buck. Friends may call on Tuesday, June 17, 2025, at Lane Family Funeral Homes, Austintown Chapel from 10:00 – 10:45 a.m., followed by a memorial service at 11:00 a.m. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Yahoo
09-06-2025
- Yahoo
Utah No. 4 for childhood well-being, but there are rocky spots
Utah ranks No. 4 in the nation for child well-being, with gains in reducing poverty and youth engagement. But there are persistent challenges in housing and access to early education, according to the Annie E. Casey Foundation's annual evaluation, which is now in its 36th year. The '2025 Kids Count Data Book' ranks the states from 1 to 50 on 16 indicators of child well-being. The report considers four factors in each of four categories: Economic well-being, education, health and family and community. Utah came in behind New Hampshire, Vermont and Massachusetts. New Mexico was the state with the lowest ranking. It notes that a quarter of Utah children in 2023 (the last year for full data) lived in households that spent more than the recommended 30% of household income on housing and reports an increase in the share who have challenges finding affordable housing in the Beehive State. Additionally, 9% of children live in poverty, which is down from 10% five years ago. But while 3,000 children who lived in poverty in 2019 no longer do, that means 88,000 still lived in poverty in 2023. Other bad news, despite Utah's high ranking: More Utah fourth-graders are not proficient at reading, at 64% compared to 60% in 2019. The share of eighth-graders not on grade level in math is 65%. That's a sad number that's still better than the nation's 73% who are not proficient. The number of Utah teens ages 16-19 not in school or working has risen to 7% — that's 16,000 teens. On the plus side: The poverty rate dropped from 10% to 9% for children. The share of children in households where no parent has full-time year round employment fell to 18%. Paying attention to how children fare is vital in Utah, said Martín C. Muñoz, Kids Count director at Voices for Utah Children, because a third of the state's residents are younger than 18. 'When we strengthen families and communities, we're securing our future, for our state and for our country. On the education front, 57% of children ages 3 and 4 are not in school, which is the same as during the last ranking. But Utahns are faring slightly better in terms of high school students who are not graduating on time, at 12%, which is down from 13% last time and which is slightly better than the national average, which is also 13%. The health category is a very mixed bag for Utah, where the state ranks 13th overall. The Beehive State is slightly better than the national share of 8.6% for low-birthweight babies, at 7.4%. That's been pretty consistent since 2019. But that still means 3,308 babies were born with low birthweight in Utah. And many low-birthweight babies face long-term complications in their development. Utah continues to have 26 teen and child deaths per 100,000 each year, compared to the national average of 29 per 100,000. The state's gotten worse, though, in terms of the number of children ages 10 to 17 who are overweight or obese. That used to be 1 in 5, but has risen to 1 in 4 in the last few years. Nationally, the overweight/obesity rate is slightly more than 3 in 10. Fewer Utah children, however, lack health insurance, at 7%, compared to 8% in 2023. Still, that's worse than the national average of 5% of children without insurance. Utah's No. 2 overall in the family and community category, with a stable share of children in single parent homes (19%), just 6 % in families where the household head lacks a high school diploma, and a mere 1% of children living in high-poverty areas, though nationwide 8% do. Utah teen birth numbers are also better than national numbers, at 9% compared to 13% nationally. The report also looked at trends since 2019, noting seven of the indicators nationally have improved, six have gotten worse and three have been unchanged. Since 2019, the nation has seen less poverty among children, fewer teen births, more children covered by health insurance and a rise in on-time school graduation. The report also notes increases in parental education and the share of parents with secure employment. 'Some of these trends reflect years of progress,' the report says. 'Others highlight the resilience of children and families after the COVID-19 pandemic and the success of strong policies that provided support during that time.' Nationally, the area with the worst news was in education, where three out of four indicators show decline since 2019. Those include preschool participation that hasn't returned to pre-pandemic levels, a decline in reading and math scores and the note that chronic absenteeism has become a 'major challenge.' On the plus side, high school graduation rates have been going up. The report notes that 'serious challenges remain, as 16% of U.S. children still live in poverty and nearly 1 in 3 children live in households struggling with high housing cost.' And the foundation adds that where a child lives 'continues to matter deeply, with stark geographic disparities shaped by local and state policies, economic conditions, community investment and infrastructure.' The report says that's clear in the most challenged areas, which are largely in the South and Southwest: Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas and West Virginia. It adds that many Northeast and Midwest states rank well: Connecticut, Iowa, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, North Dakota and Vermont. Utah gets a special call-out, the only one in the West, as the report says that 'Utah also stands out as a strong performer.' Muñoz said that besides showing state policymakers and parents where more could be done to improve, it also highlights areas that can be emulated because of their high ranking. Policies and programs that are working can be built upon, he said. 'Utah is doing well,' he said. 'We are a success story but there are little pockets in our state that need some attention.' What helps families, he added, is true 'trickle-down economics. When we help families, it trickles down to help the kids.'
Yahoo
09-06-2025
- Yahoo
Utah Gov. Cox wants you and your family to unplug this week. Here's why
For "Family Connection Week" from June 9 to June 15 2025, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox wants Utahns to put down their screens and spend time with their families. (Stock photo by Daniel de) Utah Gov. Spencer Cox has declared this week as 'Family Connection Week' to encourage Utahns to put down their phones and 'disconnect to reconnect' with loved ones. 'Spending quality time together strengthens our bonds, fosters better communication and creates lasting memories that carry us through life's challenges,' Cox said in a prepared statement. 'This week is a chance to really listen, connect and to make sure the people around us know they are valued.' From Monday to Friday this week, Cox wants Utahns to dedicate time to 'unplug from devices and reconnect through meaningful, screen-free activities,' he office said in a news release. 'This special week encourages families to be fully present with one another to create lasting memories and stronger bonds. It's the latest way Cox has encouraged Utahns to cut back on social media. He's been an outspoken critic of the addictive nature of social media algorithms and especially their negative impacts on kids. In 2023, his office launched a public awareness campaign urging parents to learn about the harms social media can have on youth. SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX That campaign announcement highlighted a 2023 survey of 609 Utahns conducted by Lighthouse Research that found Utah parents reported 76% of their children use social media in some capacity, 57% use it seven days a week, and 53% use it one to three hours a day. That survey also found 88% of Utahns said social media had a detrimental impact on children and youth. According to another study published last month, researchers at the University of California San Francisco found that as preteens used more social media, their depressive symptoms increased. Using data from nearly 12,000 kids ages 9 to 10 and then three years later at 12 and 13, the study found on average, kids' social media use rose from seven to 73 minutes per day over the three years of the study, and their depressive symptoms went up 35%. In the announcement for 'Family Connection Week,' Cox's office data from the Utah Student Health and Risk Prevention (SHARP) survey that 'supports the importance of shared time, especially mealtime.' 'Mealtimes are critical to foster communication and connection. In fact, Utah youth who sit down to eat at least one meal a week with their family are 45% less likely to report feeling depressed, 70% less likely to use vape products and 54% less likely to consider suicide,' the governor's office said, citing the SHARP survey. Social media companies applaud Utah's latest bill aimed at teen social media use 'At the same time, excessive screen time — especially on social media — can take a toll on mental health and family cohesion,' the governor's office added. 'Positive, in-person interactions lay the foundation for resilience and safety for children and adults alike. Family Connection Week encourages families to 'disconnect to reconnect' and take time to talk, laugh and connect without distractions.' In a Youtube video announcing the 'Family Connection Week' declaration, First Lady Abby Cox said their family this week will be 'making a conscious effort to put down our screens and be fully present with one another, and we invite you to do the same.' 'We are carving out time to play board games, cook meals, and participate in recreational activities together,' Abby Cox said. Encouraging Utahns to learn more about the effort, Cox's office pointed to a page on the state's website that offers a list of activities Utahns can do in their areas. The website also offers resources for parents, including stress management advice, parenting tips, child development information, and a directory for assistance programs for food, housing, access to physical and mental health care, affordable child care, utilities assistance, and more. SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
