Canada's threat of sanctions on Israel came when 'enough was enough': ex-ambassador
A former Canadian ambassador to Israel says that the dire humanitarian situation in Gaza may have been what finally pushed the leaders of Canada, France and the U.K. to threaten action.
"I think they just realized that enough was enough and that Prime Minister [Benjamin] Netanyahu seemed to have no bounds and no restrictions on his action," said Jon Allen, who was Canada's ambassador to Israel from 2006 to 2010.
Israel had blocked all humanitarian aid from entering Gaza since early March, after a short-lived ceasefire broke down. Under increasing international pressure, the Israeli government began allowing some aid into the enclave earlier this week, but aid groups said Wednesday that much of it is not reaching people who desperately need it. The United Nations has warned of looming famine, including 14,000 babies at risk of acute malnutrition in the coming year, if food sitting at the border is not allowed to reach them.
Canada, France and the U.K. issued a joint statement Monday threatening punitive action, including targeted sanctions, if Israel did not lift aid restrictions and scrap plans to escalate military action in Gaza. On Tuesday the U.K. paused free trade talks with Israel, while the EU said it will review the pact that governs its political and economic ties with the country.
WATCH | Aid allowed into Gaza hasn't been distributed, says UN:
About 100 trucks of food have entered Gaza, but it hasn't been distributed, says UN
2 hours ago
Duration 5:25
No aid has reached people in Gaza, a UN aid official says, two days after the Israeli government lifted an 11-week-old blockade. The Israeli military said five aid trucks entered Gaza on Monday and 93 on Tuesday, but supplies haven't been distributed, say local officials.
Allen, who is now a senior fellow at the Munk School of Global Affairs and Public Policy, spoke to The Current's Matt Galloway about what this political rebuke might mean for the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Here is part of their conversation.
This statement released by Canada, France, and the U.K. is strongly worded. It says that those countries have always supported Israel's right to defend Israelis against terrorism, but describes the current escalation as wholly disproportionate. [It] says that the level of human suffering in Gaza is intolerable, and says that the actions of the Netanyahu government are egregious. What do you make of the language used in this statement?
Well, it's an extremely important statement. It's comprehensive. It is definitely strong. It's the strongest statement that I have ever seen these three governments make. But it's required at this time, given, as you just described, 11 weeks of a humanitarian siege, … attempted displacement of 1.1 million Palestinians from the north to the south into only 20 per cent of the Gaza Strip, and probably most importantly, overall, the disproportionate use of force.
Israel has a right to defend itself. The massacre of October 7, [2023] was horrific … and of course the hostages must be released, and the statement calls for that. But the response to that, what these three countries are saying — and others are saying now — has been disproportionate and is breaching international humanitarian law.
Why do you think the prime minister, Mark Carney, signed on to this statement now?
I can't say exactly. He was in the Vatican. He spoke with the Pope, who's been clear on this, as was his predecessor. He had an opportunity to meet with a very significant number of European leaders, who I'm sure are all concerned about this.
We are approaching levels of starvation, as described by multiple UN organizations on the ground. And I think they just realized that enough was enough and that Prime Minister Netanyahu seemed to have no bounds and no restrictions on his action. And so they decided finally — and I think necessarily — to move on this.
The statement comes at a time of increasing pressure and criticism toward Netanyahu from inside Israel and beyond. The former Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert has warned of possible war crimes. A former general with the Israeli Defence Force, Yair Golan, talked about Israel's actions being in his words, "unconscionable" and said that Israel risks becoming a pariah state.
Absolutely.
When you say absolutely, what do you make of the international context that this statement — and the internal context — that the statement arrives in?
We now have a situation in Israel where between 68 and 70 per cent of Israelis want the prime minister to resign and hold elections, which is one of the prime reasons that he broke the ceasefire and restarted the war. He does not want to face elections.
Yair Golan, not only a former senior military officer, but head of the third-largest [political] party in Israel right now. [He's] one of the few people who got down to the kibbutzim to help save people before the IDF did.
WATCH | Israel cut out of U.S. deal for Hamas to free Edan Alexander:
Hamas frees American Israeli hostage ahead of Trump's Middle East trip
9 days ago
Duration 2:12
Do you believe he's right that Israel risks becoming a pariah state?
I think in the minds of many of its former supporters and many progressive Jews and many people who have always seen Israel — at least for many years — as the David, not the Goliath. I think many people do see Israel as... this government, as a pariah state.
Netanyahu says this statement is a win, in his words, for Hamas. And those words have been echoed by the Canadian Conservative leader, Pierre Poilievre, as well. What do you make of that?
I think it's completely false. Hamas and the extremists in Israel are not interested in two states. This statement made clear that two states is the only way forward for these two peoples who are trying to share this land.
Hamas wants one state. [Israel's Finance Minister Bezalel] Smotrich and [National Security Minister Itamar] Ben-Gvir, the prime minister's two right-wing messianic leaders, want one state. They want to resettle Gaza, they want to annex the West Bank. So those are the extremists.
This statement is not meant to support Hamas. It's obvious that Hamas would love a ceasefire. They're a terrorist group, they want to survive. But this statement is meant to try and give succour to the suffering of the Palestinian people right now — innocent women, children, the elderly.
WATCH | Conduct of war is 'damaging' relationship: U.K. foreign minister:
U.K. suspends free trade talks with Israel over Gaza offensive
1 day ago
Duration 8:39
The U.K. has suspended talks over expanding its free trade agreement with Israel. The European Union is reviewing its trade agreement with Israel. We haven't heard what steps Canada is going to take, but this statement comes with the threat of targeted sanctions toward Israel. Is any of that likely to have a material impact on what we're seeing in Gaza right now and the actions of the current Israeli government?
I absolutely think so.
A trade agreement with the EU, which is Israel's largest trading partner … right now they're talking about suspending negotiations for an enhanced agreement, but they could suspend the agreement.
We could suspend our bilateral agreement. There's always weapons exports that can be suspended. There [could be] sanctions on ministers who say outrageous things. There are sanctions on the settlers and the settlements that can be imposed. You can withdraw your ambassador.
There are a lot of tools that can be used, but I think Israel is already beginning to feel the pressure. And I think the Israelis themselves want support from the international community and from the diaspora to end what they are experiencing within Israel and what we are seeing going on in Gaza.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Tarnished by Oct. 7, Netanyahu's legacy may be reshaped by war with Iran
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — In the days after Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu seemed a shellshocked shadow of himself. He looked diminished and downtrodden by the surprise assault that created a national emergency and caused his public support to plummet. Now, as Israel faces another unprecedented crisis in a war with Iran, Netanyahu appears rejuvenated. With the U.S. lending its support against a threat he has devoted his life to confronting, Netanyahu is demonstrating a resurgent confidence that could signal a new turning point in his lengthy political career. Even as Iranian missiles pound Israeli cities, Netanyahu, 75, has the chance to salvage his sagging political fortunes and reshape a legacy punctured by Hamas' attacks, a corruption trial and a history of divisive rule. If he succeeds, it will cement his reputation within Israel as a political wizard who can rise from the ashes. 'Netanyahu has proven that he is a phoenix,' said veteran Israeli journalist and Netanyahu biographer Mazal Mualem. Netanyahu's troubled legacy is granted a lifeline The war is far from won. Israel is still vulnerable to Iranian attacks, and whatever political boost Netanyahu gains from the latest developments could dissipate by elections scheduled for next year. He is the same polarizing leader he was yesterday. Internationally, he faces an arrest warrant for charges of war crimes in Gaza. He is widely reviled across the Arab world. And after nearly two years of regionwide conflict, many critics see him as a warmonger responsible for tens of thousands of deaths in Gaza and elsewhere in the Middle East. But domestically, where Netanyahu's eyes are always focused, his legacy has been granted a lifeline. Many Israelis are attuned to Netanyahu's campaign against Iran's nuclear program, which they view as a major threat to their country and are therefore relieved by the direct involvement of the U.S. military. 'Netanyahu is seen as a very divisive and destructive leader. He is seen as someone who talks a lot and doesn't do anything,' said Aviv Bushinsky, a former Netanyahu aide. 'Today, Netanyahu redeemed himself, big time.' In an early morning video statement after the U.S. strike on Iran's nuclear facilities, Netanyahu could barely contain a smile as he thanked President Donald Trump. He said the intervention would 'change history.' It's a stunning turnaround for an Israeli leader who critics and analysts largely wrote off in the days after Oct. 7, when he presided over the deadliest attack in Israel's history. Many hold Netanyahu personally responsible for overseeing policies that enabled Hamas to retain power in Gaza for many years and build up a formidable arsenal. Netanyahu has been buoyed occasionally since then by military successes against Hamas and the Iran-backed Hezbollah in Lebanon. But with the Gaza war dragging on with no end in sight, and dozens of Israeli hostages still in captivity, his approval ratings have remained low. The week-old assault on Iran, highlighted by Sunday's U.S. attack, grants Netanyahu a chance for salvation. Netanyahu's yearslong focus on Iran The war caps a yearslong focus — some would say obsession — by Netanyahu on Iran and its nuclear program. Since his first term as prime minister in the 1990s, and throughout his current, nearly uninterrupted 16-year rule, he has made challenging Iran's nuclear program his life's work. Netanyahu has long portrayed Iran as an existential threat — pointing not only to its nuclear program, but also its development of long-range missiles aimed at Israel and support for hostile militant groups on Israel's borders. Iran became a repeated theme in his speeches to the Israeli and international public. He famously hoisted a cartoon bomb from the dais of U.N. General Assembly as he accused Iran of developing a nuclear weapon. Iran insists the program is for civilian purposes. At the same time, Netanyahu has made no mention of Israel's own widely suspected nuclear weapons arsenal. Netanyahu took significant diplomatic risks to pursue his crusade, including with a 2015 speech to Congress that was organized by Republican lawmakers, angering the Obama administration. During the speech, he railed against a U.S.-led deal on Iran's nuclear program just as negotiators were wrapping up its details. Trump unilaterally withdrew the U.S. from the agreement during his first term. Some critics say that it was Netanyahu's laser focus on Iran, and the military and intelligence resources devoted to it, that blinded the Israeli leader and the defense establishment to the threat Hamas in Gaza. Hamas' attack is a stain on Netanyahu's legacy Hamas' attack, in which 1,200 people were killed and 251 taken hostage, blindsided Israel. Netanyahu, who likes to portray himself as a security hawk and the only true guardian of Israel, is seen by many as having promoted a failed strategy in the years preceding the Oct. 7 attack by sending huge amounts of aid into in Gaza under the misconception that Hamas was deterred. In fact, the Palestinian militant group would stage a brutal assault that would crush Israel's vaunted defenses and change the course of history. In the aftermath of Hamas' attack, Netanyahu's public support plummeted. Netanyahu shrugged off accountability for Hamas' attacks, pointing a finger at his security chiefs and rejecting demands for a public inquiry into the failures. He says he will answer tough questions about his role after the war, now in its 21st month. Any political boost from the war could fade by elections Netanyahu's work is not done. The war in Gaza grinds on, and Netanyahu still dreams of seeing a normalization deal between Israel and Arab powerhouse Saudi Arabia as part of his legacy. The question remains whether Netanyahu will rebound politically from the Iran war. Polls taken last week showed that Netanyahu would still struggle to form a coalition if elections were held today. Even if he gets a bump from Sunday's U.S. attack, it's not clear how long that might last. Bushinsky compared Netanyahu's potential political predicament to a world leader he likes to compare himself to, Winston Churchill, who, after leading the allies in triumphantly defeating the Nazis in World War II, did not get reelected in a 1945 vote in part because public priorities shifted dramatically. 'Bibi may be 'King of Israel,' Bushinsky said, using a nickname for Netanyahu popular among his supporters, 'but even a king has his limits.'
CBC
4 hours ago
- CBC
Hundreds trek to Iran-Turkey border to flee conflict
After attacks on Iran from Israel and the U.S., many people, including several Canadians, made the long trek to an overland crossing in Turkey to try and get to safety.
Globe and Mail
5 hours ago
- Globe and Mail
Ottawa advises Canadians to leave Iran or stay near a bomb shelter
Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand says she has spoken with Iran's Foreign Minister and pressed him to ensure the safe departure of Canadians from the country. Ottawa is advising Canadians to leave Iran if they can do so safely, warning that Iranian authorities have detained dual nationals in the past to exert influence on their government. Global Affairs' warning came in updated travel advice on Saturday, just before President Donald Trump announced the U.S. strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities. The warning also advised Canadians remaining in Iran to 'stay close to a bomb shelter or be prepared to shelter in a hardened structure away from windows.' Canada has not had diplomatic relations with Iran since 2012 and has had to rely on other foreign embassies to help Canadians in the country. According to Global Affairs, Canada has boosted the number of consular staff in neighbouring countries and in the past week has sent diplomatic staff to the borders in Turkey and Armenia to help Canadians crossing from Iran. Speaking to reporters in Brussels on Sunday, Ms. Anand urged Canadians in Iran to register with Global Affairs, saying they would be contacted directly by government officials with advice about how to get back to Canada. She says that in her call with Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi she 'emphasized the importance of the safety and security of Canadian citizens in the region.' U.S. military officials say they are not pursuing war with Iran after striking key nuclear sites Ottawa has been helping Canadians in Israel and Iran find seats on commercial flights to Canada after they cross into neighbouring countries since the conflict between Israel and Iran escalated earlier this month. But Canadians visiting Israel, who included former Conservative MPs Michelle Ferreri and Rick Perkins, have said they had to make their own way to Jordan to board flights after the bombing started. In the past few days, Global Affairs has been arranging buses to the borders for Canadians. But in a statement on Sunday evening, it said that day's planned departure from Israel over land had to be postponed until Monday. It said it is in 'regular communication with Canadians who have requested assistance in Iran, Israel and the West Bank.' After the U.S. strikes on nuclear facilities in Iran, 'we are reviewing our mission security posture across the region in close collaboration with our international partners,' it added. Global Affairs has deployed more than 20 members of its Standing Rapid Deployment Team to Israel, the West Bank, Jordan, Turkey, Azerbaijan, Greece, Cyprus and Armenia to help hundreds of personnel already on the ground. But it said Canada is unable to provide assistance within Iran because it has no embassy there. Canadians fleeing war in Iran face obstacles in absence of diplomatic ties Ottawa facing criticism for not doing more to help Canadians leave Middle East On Sunday, after the U.S. strikes on Iran, Israel reopened its airspace during the day to allow flights. Israel's Airports Authority said flights departing Israel would expand on Monday. Israeli airline El Al is reported to have already received 25,000 inquiries about leaving the country. In Iran, the airspace remains closed. Mona Ghassemi, president of the Iranian-Canadian Congress, said on Sunday that 'enough is not being done' by Ottawa to help Canadians leave Iran. 'From what we have heard, it seems to be not enough as Iranians reaching the emergency number were told it was up to them to get to the border to get a flight from a neighbouring country,' she said, adding that because there is an internet blackout, it is hard to reach people in Iran at the moment. More than 4,000 Canadian citizens were registered as being in Iran earlier this month. Maryam Marissen, a Canadian-Iranian from Vancouver with relatives in Iran, said a Canadian cousin is trying to leave the country, but without the internet, it is hard for them to access information, including security updates and travel advice from Ottawa. She said Canadians with family or friends in Iran have been trying to keep them updated about the situation by phone. 'It's really troubling,' she said. 'Right now, people are just relying on news outlets, and there is a lot of confusion. You really would have to have people on this side, finding the information for you and trying to get it to you.' In an interview on Friday, Setareh Shariati described how she had travelled to Tehran on June 1 for knee surgery that she had been waiting months to receive in Canada. Taking leave from her job at the University of British Columbia, she didn't expect to spend her recovery in a war zone. She is a permanent resident in Canada, but Ms. Shariati said she was denied services from the Canadian embassy in Turkey, which is only supporting citizens. She said recent surgery prevents her from being able to drive to the Iranian border, and even then, she's unsure where she'd go or how she'd get to Vancouver. A 20-litre per car per day gas ration further complicates leaving Tehran. The city is more than 1,000 kilometres away from the nearest bordering countries. 'The roads leading out of the city are basically lost to traffic. Everyone is trying to leave, and gas is really hard to come by,' Ms. Shariati said.
