Unproven school board governance training in Texas is all hat and no cattle
Under the guise of improving academic outcomes, the Texas Education Agency has required some public school districts across Texas to adopt Lone Star Governance, a program that includes coaching and training for school board members. Texans who care about efficient government and local control should be concerned with the state's interference and how money is being diverted away from schools to well-connected consultants for an unproven and costly enterprise that is all hat and no cattle.
According to the TEA, Lone Star Governance is a continuous improvement model, 'founded on research' and focused on 'improving student outcomes.' TEA has required the board of trustees in several districts — including Austin ISD, Fort Worth ISD and Houston ISD — to adopt Lone Star Governance to address various issues, from special education-related failures to persistent low performance on state standardized assessments.
However, as education researchers, we are concerned that TEA is requiring public school districts spend public funds on an approach with no evidence of effectiveness.
A TEA-created flyer claims that districts implementing Lone Star Governance saw, on average, a 10-point increase in accountability scores between 2018 and 2019, compared to 3 points for districts not using that model. The flyer does not indicate which districts were part of this calculation. However, according to information we obtained from TEA through a public records request, starting in the 2017-18 school year, 13 districts were formally engaged in Lone Star Governance.
We were wary of drawing conclusions about Lone Star Governance from such a small group of districts over one year. So we tracked accountability score changes between 2018 and 2023 for all districts that had been involved in Lone Star Governance in 2018 and 2019. In this time, overall district accountability ratings for Lone Star Governance districts declined 12.4 points, a much steeper decline than those districts not using that model (7.4-point decline).
The gap in average accountability ratings actually widened between districts using Lone Star Governance and those that didn't. In 2018, the average accountability rating in Lone Star Governance districts was only two points below other districts (84 vs. 86 points). By 2023, this gap widened to seven points (74 vs. 81 points).
Several districts that were required to adopt Lone Star Governance five years ago are now facing potential state intervention because of a lack of progress on improving student outcomes.
TEA required the program in Houston ISD, where trainees have characterized Lone Star Governance as 'a fear-based system of control' where 'any sort of independent thought is not tolerated.' Houston ISD's accountability rating has declined since its forced adoption of Lone Star Governance. Fort Worth ISD adopted Lone Star Governance in 2018, but, similarly, the district's state accountability ratings have declined.
TEA has forced Austin ISD to adopt Lone Star Governance twice — first in 2016 and again in 2024. Yet, Austin ISD has not experienced substantial improvement in its state accountability ratings. The need for repeated training calls into question the effectiveness of Lone Star Governance and begs the question: Who is benefiting from this costly, unproven training?
In 2024, Austin ISD was required to pay $60,000 to a national organization called the Council of Great City School (CGCS) for Lone Star Governance training and coaching. The person who leads CGCS's governance efforts — including facilitating Lone Star Governance workshops across the state — is AJ Crabill, a former TEA deputy commissioner who was appointed in 2016 by TEA Commissioner Mike Morath.
Texas is unique in that the state has unilateral authority to require districts to spend funds on this unproven school board training. However, several districts across the United States have also adopted Crabill's governance training — nationally known as Student Outcomes Focused Governance. The effectiveness of this training in these districts is now under scrutiny, too. For example, Seattle Public Schools has spent approximately $300,000 on Student Outcomes Focused Governance and has seen little academic progress.
Texans care about the efficient use of taxpayer dollars, especially when it comes to educating our state's children. Requiring already-cash-strapped districts spend public tax dollars on unproven training with zero evidence of effectiveness is the opposite of efficient. Instead, state interventions should prioritize proven strategies, such as evidence-based professional development for teachers and investments into mental health supports for students.
Rachel S. White is an associate professor, and David DeMatthews is a professor of education, in the Department of Educational Leadership and Policy at the University of Texas.
This article originally appeared on Austin American-Statesman: Required 'Lone Star' training isn't helping school districts | Opinion
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
a day ago
- NBC Sports
Ricky Williams fights effort to ban THC in Texas
Longhorns legend Ricky Williams is bringing a little Texas Fight to the effort to ban THC. As explained by the Texas House and Senate have passed a bill that would ban all consumable hemp-derived products containing THC. Governor Greg Abbott has the measure on his desk, awaiting signature. Williams wants Abbott to veto the bill. 'This plant helped me stay balanced and healthy through the grind of professional football,' Williams said in a press release from Project Champion. 'Now it's helping veterans manage PTSD and families manage pain. These changes in the law don't protect Texans — it punishes them. The people of Texas deserve freedom of choice and don't need the government to tell them what they can and can't put in their body. If we have learned anything from the past decade it has been that.' Lt. Governor Dan Patrick led the effort to push the bill through the Texas legislature. Now, only Abbott stands in the way of the bill becoming the law of the Lone Star State. 'I'm calling on my friend, Greg Abbott, to please veto this bill and stand with the veterans, farmers and families who know there is a better way forward,' Williams said in a video posted on social media. Nationally, views on marijuana and THC have dramatically shifted over the last twenty years. Many states have relaxed their laws in this regard; if Abbott signs the bill, Texas will be taking a big step backward.
Yahoo
2 days ago
- Yahoo
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signs historic $20 billion water investment bill, talks state impact
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott visited Lubbock Wednesday to sign into law the largest generational water investment in state history, addressing a multi-year water crisis and leaving it up to Texans to codify the bill in an election this November. Senate Bill 7 and House Joint Resolution 7 will allocate $20 billion over a 20-year period to offset water infrastructure and development costs through the Texas Water Fund Advisory Committee. Others are reading: Patrick, Perry defend proposed Texas THC ban after smoke shop exploit hemp loophole Authored by State Sen. Charles Perry, R-Lubbock, the bill comes at a much needed time, he said, as nine cities across the state this year have declined development permits, citing lack of supplies as their reason. "Here's what I know,' said Speaker of the House Dustin Burrows, a Lubbock Republican. 'They show up, and they turn on that spigot, the water doesn't come out — those U-Hauls are going to go the absolute opposite direction.' With nearly 1,000 people moving to Texas each day, Abbott said it's important the state's water infrastructure meets the growing population's demand. Story continues after gallery. 'I'll add this: My hometown, Wichita Falls, almost ran out of water a couple of years ago,' Abbott said. 'This is something I got to see occur just a few days away from losing water, and that's where it became a very real understanding. We have communities like that across the state that have this need that has to be addressed.' Perry said irrigated crops in the Panhandle and Rio Grande Valley are the largest areas depleting water resources, and second is municipal use. City water is often pulled from the same sources farmers and ranchers use, Perry said. SB 7 encourages cities to reach a new supply of water further in the ground on the brackish, marine level, creating a more stable water resource for residents and increasing production again for agricultural use. HJR 7, authored by Rep. Cody Harris, R-Palestine, proposes a Texas constitutional amendment that will help fund those long-term water resource projects. While funding has always been available, Executive Director Bobby Bazan with Texas Ground Water Association said funding has never been available in such a large capacity. 'We have an aging infrastructure that is outgrowing its usefulness, timeline, and this money is going to go toward helping improve some of that, making sure, like the governor said, when somebody turns a faucet on, there's going to be water there,' Bazan said. $1 billion will be allocated annually to the Texas Water Fund Advisory Committee over the next 20 years, but Perry said he believes the fund will last far longer than its intended time frame. 'What I know about the legislature is if you prove what you said was going to happen, and it's working, and there's support — it'll be another 10 to 20 years.' The law would not fully go into effect unless Texas voters codify it at the polls - OK'ing the proposal in the upcoming November state constitutional amendments election. What does this mean for Lubbock ? Lake 7, located near Buffalo Springs Lake and 50th Street, is one of many projects Lubbock Mayor Mark McBrayer said SB 7 and HJR 7 will help fund. The proposed lake will be filled with directly reused city water. The water will then go through a treatment plant before it becomes potable water, said Raquel Mullen, customer relations manager with the City of Lubbock. In addition to Lake 7, the bill will help address needs with Lake Meredith and Lake Alan Henry through respective city projects, McBrayer said. 'This bill is going to be very beneficial for Lubbock as well,' McBrayer said. 'We're happy to have it.' McBrayer said he worked with Perry to achieve some of the bill's amendments, such as adding and defining lake-ready projects. 'He took advantage of that, and he saw that need,' McBrayer said of working with Perry. 'He addressed that need in the bill and made some changes, so we're so very happy he worked with us on it.' Perry said just as he met with Lubbock representatives, there was also an effort to meet with all 254 counties in the state to ensure their needs were met. This article originally appeared on Lubbock Avalanche-Journal: Gov. Abbott signs $20 billion water bill, discusses statewide impact
Yahoo
13-06-2025
- Yahoo
Trump DOJ Veteran Aaron Reitz Announces Run For Texas AG
(Texas Scorecard) – Aaron Reitz, a former deputy attorney general under Ken Paxton and recent Trump administration appointee, announced his campaign for the Republican nomination for Texas attorney general. Reitz made the announcement Thursday, a day after resigning as assistant attorney general for legal policy under Pam Bondi in the Department of Justice. He previously served as Paxton's deputy attorney general for legal strategy and as chief of staff to U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz. 'We are in a fight for the soul of Texas, our nation, and Western civilization itself,' said Reitz in a campaign statement. 'This is no time for half-measures or untested cowards.' 'As Attorney General, I'll use every ounce of legal firepower to defend President Trump, crush the radical Left, advance the America and Texas First agenda, and look out for everyday Texans,' he added. Reitz said he would use the office to pursue policies aligned with President Donald Trump's agenda, including increased border security, mass deportations, opposition to progressive prosecutors, and efforts to uncover election fraud. He also pledged to target Big Tech, support law enforcement, and defend constitutional rights. 'I led the fight on virtually every major legal campaign that Texans care about,' said Reitz, referring to his time under Paxton. 'I stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Paxton to challenge the 2020 election when others ran scared.' His campaign announcement included praise from Trump, who described Reitz as 'a true MAGA attorney' and 'a warrior for our Constitution.' Reitz becomes the latest Republican to announce a campaign for attorney general, joining State Sen. Mayes Middleton. The race comes as current Attorney General Ken Paxton is not seeking re-election and is instead running for the U.S. Senate against incumbent Sen. John Cornyn. After Reitz resigned from his federal position yesterday, he was greeted with support from those in the Trump administration, including Attorney General Pam Bondi and FBI Director Kash Patel.
