No issue with House refusal of Sara Duterte lawyers' papers, says prosecution spokesman
Reginald Tongol (left) and Antonio Bucoy. - Photo from Regie Tongol & Associates Law and Communications Facebook page and video screengrab
MANILA: The House of Representatives' decision not to receive the entry of appearance made by Vice President Sara Duterte's lawyers for the impeachment trial should not result in any issue, prosecution spokesman Antonio Bucoy said.
In his first-ever press briefing held on Tuesday (June 17), Bucoy was asked why the House supposedly refused to receive the entry of appearance sent by the defence counsel on Monday (June 16) afternoon.
Bucoy admitted that he does not know the exact reason, but noted that this should not be an issue, because the phrase 'tender copy refuse to receive' indicates that it was as if the document was received.
'I would like to clarify. I do not know the reason why. But the bottom line is that nobody was hurt, there was no damage. Because when they tendered the service of the entry of appearance, tender means you are constructively served. So, regardless of whether they accept it or not, the purpose was served because it was tendered. So as if you received it,' he explained.
''When it is tendered, the document is left with the chamber. The term 'tender' was used because they did not acknowledge that they had already received it. Nonetheless, like what I said, no harm, no foul. Nobody was hurt here, nobody was aggrieved,' he added.
According to Bucoy, he is not sure whether the recent circumstances surrounding the impeachment proceedings have led to an impediment — which may be a reason why the House did not receive the entry of appearance.
'Now I do not know if there was an impediment or none that's why the entry was not accepted, or what is the exact reason why it was not accepted. But like I said earlier, no harm, no foul because the service […] was tendered so as if it was received. There is no damage,' he added.
On Monday night, Senate impeachment court spokesperson Reginald Tongol confirmed that Duterte's counsel has entered its appearance, with 16 lawyers defending her — including those from the Fortun Narvasa & Salazar law firm.
However, Tongol said that the House was 'indicated in page 3 to have been copy furnished as well today at 3.42pm, but has a note 'Tender Copy refuse to receive.''
Tongol said in an interview with DZMM on Tuesday that the House's refusal to accept the document may delay the impeachment proceedings.
Duterte was impeached last February 5, after 215 lawmakers filed and signed a verified impeachment complaint against her. The articles of impeachment were immediately sent to the Senate as the Article XI, Section 3(4) of the 1987 Constitution states that a trial should proceed forthwith if one-thirds of House members file the complaint.
As one-third of 306 House members is 102, the requirement was fulfilled. However, trial did not start as the articles of impeachment were not sent to the Senate plenary before session adjourned for the election season break.
And when the proceedings were supposed to start last June 3, the Senate eventually approved a motion to remand the articles back to the House, due to alleged constitutional infirmities.
The House prosecution team, however, said that they will defer acceptance of the returned articles, and will file a motion seeking clarification as one of the Senate's requests — a certification from the 20th Congress that they will pursue the impeachment — cannot be complied with now.
Duterte's impeachment was hinged on different issues, like allegations of confidential fund misuse within her offices which were uncovered during the hearing of the House committee on good government and public accountability, and threats to have President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., First Lady Liza Araneta-Marcos, and Romualdez assassinated. - Philippine Daily Inquirer/ANN
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
'No reason for Paetongtarn to resign and dissolve the Parliament', says Thai ruling party
FILE PHOTO: Thailand's Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra speaks during a press conference about tensions following the incident in an undemarcated area on May 28, after a cabinet meeting at the Government House in Bangkok, Thailand, June 10, 2025. -- Photo: REUTERS ISTANBUL (Bernama-Anadolu): Thailand's ruling Pheu Thai Party said on Saturday that Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra will neither resign nor dissolve parliament, rejecting opposition demands following a leaked phone conversation with Cambodia's Senate president; "The Prime Minister has firmly affirmed to us that she will continue to fully carry out her duties in addressing the crises the country is currently facing. "There is no reason to even dissolve the parliament," party Secretary-General Sorawong Thienthong said in a statement posted on Facebook, referring to ongoing tensions with Cambodia. Sorawong said the administration remains focused on using the remainder of its term to advance key policies despite the political fallout from the leaked call. The comments come after a recording of a phone call between Paetongtarn and Cambodian Senate President Hun Sen was posted on the latter's Facebook page. In the call, Paetongtarn is heard criticising Thailand's 2nd Army Region commander over the military's handling of a border dispute that left one Cambodian soldier dead on May 28. Opposition parties and protesters have since called for her resignation and the dissolution of parliament. Thailand's Opposition leader, Natthapong Ruengpanyawut, has demanded a snap election, citing a breach of public trust. In a further escalation, Thai authorities filed a complaint with the Cybercrime Investigation Bureau against Hun Sen, accusing him of threatening national security and stoking bilateral tensions, Thai PBS reported. - Bernama-Anadolu
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
House yet to decide on Gibran impeachment petition
Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka (centre) attends the commemoration of Pancasila Day on June 1 at the Pancasila Building, a historic hall within the Foreign Ministry's compound in Jakarta. Pancasila Day celebrates Indonesia's national ideology based on five principles: Belief in one God, just and civilized humanity, national unity, democracy guided by the wisdom of people's representatives and social justice for all Indonesians. - Photo: AFP JAKARTA: The House of Representatives is still weighing whether to bring a petition to initiate impeachment proceedings against Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka filed by a group of retired Indonesian Military (TNI) generals to a plenary session that would mark the start of the legal process. The decision whether to bring the petition to a plenary session depends on the petition's substance, which will first be reviewed to see whether the aspiration is 'reasonable, rational and has political and legal legitimacy,' according to House Legislation Body (Baleg) deputy chair Ahmad Iman Sukri. 'We leave it to the House leadership. The debate is more political in nature, and political products always have political solutions,' the National Awakening Party (PKB) politician said on Friday (June 20), as quoted by adding that he had not read the retired general's letter. Ahmad made the statement as the House is expected to hold a plenary session on Tuesday to mark the start of its next sitting period. The legislature is currently in recess that will end on Monday. Earlier this month, a group known as the Retired TNI Soldiers Forum sent a letter to call on the leadership of the House and the People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) to begin the legal process of removing Gibran from office. The group argued that Gibran's appointment was tainted by an ethics scandal over a Constitutional Court ruling that lowered the age threshold for candidates. The controversial decision, issued during the administration of Gibran's father, former president Joko 'Jokowi' Widodo, was authored by then-chief justice Anwar Usman, Jokowi's brother-in-law. The justice was later dismissed from the court's top seat for a serious violation of judicial ethics. The group also questioned Gibran's capability to serve as vice president, arguing that the former mayor of Surakarta in Central Java has become a burden to President Prabowo Subianto in carrying out the responsibilities of the state, rather than showing his capacity to assist the President. The forum's secretary Bimo Satrio confirmed the authenticity of the letter and said that former vice president and military general Try Sutrisno had 'given his blessing' for the group to proceed with the petition in late May, despite not having his name appear among the signatories. Several days after the legislative bodies received the retired generals' letter, House Deputy Speaker and Prabowo's Gerindra Party executive Sufmi Dasco Ahmad met with Indonesian Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P) chair Megawati Soekarnoputri in the latter's private residence. Speaking after the meeting, Dasco, who is widely regarded as one of Prabowo's right-hand men, said that he had been sent by the President to deliver a confidential message to Megawati, and he had received a response to relay back to Prabowo in return. With the party's congress that was expected to be the occasion when it would define its political position toward Prabowo's administration, the PDI-P remains as the only de facto opposition party in the legislature, controlling 110 of 580 House seats. - The Jakarta Post/ANN
Borneo Post
11 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Chong urges S'wak govt to prioritise financial aid over mega projects
Chong offers DAP's official magazine, The Rocket during the walkabout. KUCHING (June 22):Democratic Action Party (DAP) Sarawak chairman Chong Chieng Jen has urged the state government to prioritise easing the financial burden on low- and middle-income groups rather than allocating funds for mega projects. The Padungan assemblyman and Stampin MP made this call after receiving feedback from the local community during a walkabout in Gala City and Premier 101 commercial centres here yesterday. Chong said people are struggling financially amid the current economic situation. 'The Sarawak government should focus on how to improve our economy and increase the income sources for our low- and middle-income families. 'This is not the time to give priority to the development of mega projects that involve billions of ringgit,' he said after the event, which also saw him promoting DAP's official magazine, The Rocket. Chong said the DAP is not against the state government implementing development projects, but many of those mega projects 'do not seem to directly benefit the people as in increasing their income'. He cited these projects as the Autonomous Rapid Transit (ART) project, the Second Trunk Road project, and the construction of a Deep-Sea Port and a new Kuching International Airport. He said enormous funds are required to make these projects happen and this does not help the low- and middle-income groups, who are facing financial difficulties. According to him, people worry more about whether these large-scale projects would benefit them directly. 'Not only are these projects going to use up tonnes of taxpayers' money, but they do not help increase the income of most people. Money is never enough as far as most people are concerned,' he said. As such, Chong suggested that the state government shift its focus to developing the manufacturing sector in line with enhancing the state's productivity and increasing job opportunities for locals. He believed that this would directly increase household income in the state as well as bring Sarawak's economic level to new heights. Meanwhile, he thanked all those who had supported the DAP Sarawak by purchasing Rocket, hoping that more people would back the DAP to increase opposition voices in the State Legislative Assembly (DUN). At present, he said there are only two DAP elected representatives in the august House. 'Given this scenario, the checks and balances mechanism is as good as none. The only way to see a healthy democracy is by having more opposition members, especially from the DAP, in the House. 'This helps ensure that the government of the day will not approve budgets and implement projects as they wish,' added Chong.
