Edisi Siasat blocked by court order: Lawyer insists Comms Minister spell out crimes of whistleblower site

IN George Orwell's satire, Animal Farm, one tyrannical regime is toppled by a popular revolt, only for it to be replaced by one that is infinitely worse.
This was seemingly the point that lawyer and human rights activist Charles Hector was making with regard to whistleblowers.
He was referring to the action taken against whistleblower sites – Edisi Siasat – whose Telegram channel has been blocked and can no longer be viewed by its 1.18 million followers.
Editor's Note: Apart from Edisi Siasat, another well-known Telegram channel, Edisi Khas, is also facing similar wrath from the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) for allegedly spreading content that could harm public order and erode trust in national institutions.
Hector very pointedly asked what laws did this site break?
The anti-death penalty proponent demanded that Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil and the MCMC to immediately inform Malaysians as to what is happening in detail. This is to avoid confusion.
The legal eagle outlined several pertinent queries:
'What was the alleged crime committed by Edisi Siasat? What post? How was it harmful? Was it fake? Which law exactly did it violate?' he enquired, wondering if it fell afoul of the broadly worded Section 233(1)(a) of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 which many citizens have called to be repealed.
Hector further drew comparisons of Edisi Siasat with that of the restrictions placed on Sarawak Report by Datuk Seri Najib's administration. The latter website had been instrumental in revealing damning details on the 1MDB scandal and drawing public attention to it.
In 2015, the Sarawak Report was blocked in Malaysia with authorities having issued an arrest warrant for its editor/founder Clare Rewcastle Brown for 'threatening parliamentary democracy.'
Pre-0emptive measure
With a number of cases against officials from the previous administration on-going, perhaps there is a fear among Madani officials that they, too. would be subject to such scrutiny should Pakatan Harapan (PH) fall at the next elections.
Hence, they are safeguarding themselves by taking the necessary pre-emptive measures, according to the outspoken lawyer. This includes the dubious blocking of sites and abuse of authority.
'Remember that public officers are responsible to Malaysians and not just the current PM and government,' he reminded civil servants of their duty.
'The fact that (past) PMs and ministers do commit crime and sometimes abuse their power is already clear. Even now, there are pending investigations and on-going trials against past government PMs, ministers, etc.
'After GE16 –if and when PMX Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's's Madani government is ousted – it is possible we will see cases being commenced against ministers of this current government.' – June 20, 2025

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Barnama

6 hours ago

• Barnama

AGC Rejects Claims Of 'Flawed Prosecution' After Najib's DNAA In Second SRC Case

KUALA LUMPUR, June 20 (Bernama) -- The Attorney General's Chambers (AGC) has dismissed as baseless allegations that it carried out a 'flawed prosecution' in the second SRC International Sdn Bhd case involving Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak. In a statement, the AGC reiterated its firm commitment to upholding the rule of law and stated that it would continue to fulfill its responsibilities under the Federal Constitution with integrity, fairness and respect for the judicial process. However, the AGC acknowledged the decision by High Court Judge K Muniandy to grant Najib a discharge not amounting to an acquittal (DNAA) on three charges of money laundering involving RM27 million in funds from the company. 'The case was registered in the High Court on Feb 7, 2019, and scheduled for trial on five occasions: June 2020, July to August 2021, March to April 2022, September 2024 and April to May 2025. 'However, all trial dates were postponed due to the Movement Control Order caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, requests by the defence, or applications by the prosecution itself,' the statement read. According to the statement, the prosecution's requests for postponement were due to the ongoing trial of the first SRC case, which proceeded at the High Court, Court of Appeal and Federal Court until its completion on March 31, 2023. At the same time, the trial proceedings for the 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) case had also begun while the first SRC case was still ongoing. 'Both cases involved overlapping material documents required for the second SRC trial. 'As these documents were critical to the second SRC case, the prosecution had no choice but to wait until they were available, which was until the 1MDB trial proceedings were completed. 'It must be emphasised that the material documents are available but are currently being used as evidence in the ongoing 1MDB trial,' the AGC said.

The Star

7 hours ago

• The Star

Asean news headlines as at 10pm on Friday (June 20)

Malaysia * Najib's DNAA: Material documents unavailable because held up in 1MDB trial, says AGC * Najib freed in RM27mil SRC trial but not cleared * PM: Najib's DNAA solely a judicial matter * 'Economy grew better than expected', PM defends reforms * Iran evacuation: Wisma Putra finalising efforts, M'sians to leave Iran today * Meru shooting: 46-year-old man found dead in 4WD, cops seeking public help for info * SST on commercial rental will impact retail sector, says MRCA * Bernama chairman Wong Chun Wai named national journalism laureate * Malaysia's trade remains on growth trend in May * MasterChef finalist, ex-husband jailed 34 years for maid's murder * UM climbs to 58th place * Malaysia proposes Asean Institute * Selangor Ruler: Stop using the term 'Sisters in Islam' * SIS wins appeal against fatwa * PM: JS-SEZ stands out globally due to trust and stability * Sabah minister in the crosshairs * RON95 price will not be raised, assures Anwar * Nationwide clampdown begins on illegal tourism players * Tariff talks on track, says Anwar * Govt committed to reducing national deficit, says PM * JPJ to audit 500 bus and lorry operators from June 23 in special ops * Mohd Khalid Ismail appointed as new IGP * New IGP to leverage AI in modernising police force * Hamzah Zainudin's mother-in-law dies in house fire * Woman survives fall from seventh floor of Ipoh apartment * Pearly says the ball is in BAM's court * No more imported food at official events, PM tells civil service * 'Queen of Dangdut' Zaleha Hamid passes away at 70 * Malaysian women archers stun India to strike gold at Asian Cup * Herry challenges Aaron-Wooi Yik to reach world No. 1 before world meet * Malaysia shine with four golds in SEA karate meet Singapore * Passenger sues SIA after allergic reaction, claims served meal containing shrimp despite warning crew * Jail for cop who told woman he could help with her drug case if she had sex with him * S'poreans can test for genetic condition causing high cholesterol levels under new programme * Singaporean radio DJ Glenn Ong says he was 'unhappily married' in Instagram post on weight loss * Seah Kian Peng to be nominated again as Speaker of Singapore Parliament; Indranee Rajah will remain Leader of the House * Fire breaks out on oil tanker anchored in eastern Singapore; no injuries reported * One ticket wins S$12.3mil Toto jackpot draw * Siti Nurhaliza to debut new song at Singapore concert Thailand * Thai PM faces call to step down to avert coalition revolt * People's Party rules out forming government with Anutin as PM * Thai PM visits troops as rivals plan new protests for her outster * Love-seeking Thai women visit breast-shaped island, offering bras as thanks if wishes granted * Thai defence minister dodges question on blacklisting Hun Sen, urges unity and political stability * Thailand's economy teeters as political turmoil threatens recovery efforts * Thai PM to meet army commander to defuse political crisis * Thailand's 'Yellow Shirts' return to streets, demand PM quit * Thailand credits prey releases for 'extraordinary' tiger recovery Indonesia * Chinese tourist drowns off Indonesia's pink beach after skipping life jacket to pose for camera * Indonesia mobilises cross-border efforts to combat malaria in Papua * Uncooked rice, ultra-processed food included in free meals programme * Tiny homes for young urbanites draw criticism over livability * This indeed a grand outing: two icons, one song - local legend Misha Omar and Indonesian star Melly Goeslaw unite for 'Break' Superman fans dressed in costumes posing during an event as part of the first stop of the Superman World Tour in Pasig city, Philippines on Thursday June 19, 2025. - AP Philippines * Public transportation will be better by the end of 2025, says Marcos * 'Wait and see,' says Philippine palace to fugitive Harry Roque's 'come and get me' taunt * Philippine Navy seizes US$175mil meth haul at sea * Soldier, three rebel suspects killed in southern Philippine clash Vietnam * Vietnam to appoint leaders for newly-merged localities * PM orders urgent action to prepare for storm season * Vietnam's war-themed coffee chain: Where hipsters meet Vietcong * Vietnam's top leader plans US trip as tariff deadline looms * Vietnam, US hold negotiations on new trade deal, ministry says Cambodia * Cambodia continues efforts to establish a Legacy Institution for genocide prevention, education * Hun Manet urges Malaysia, Cambodia to bolster tourism synergy * Cambodian cookbook wins award in Portugal Myanmar * Covid-19 cases rise to 52 this week, highest in Mon State * Authorities take action after video of student being assaulted in southwestern Myanmar goes viral on social media * Myanmar junta battles guerillas for control of jade hub Laos * Laos strives to develop strong tourism growth * Health ministry inks deal with S. Korea to build new medical university Brunei * Brunei cracks down on int'l drug cartel * Brunei temporarily closes embassy in Teheran * Brunei team brings glory in SEAKF meet Anti-Israel protesters holding placards as they demonstrate against the ongoing conflict between Israel and Iran near the Israeli Embassy in Tokyo on June 20, 2025. - AFP Aseanplus * China condemns British warship's 'troublemaking' Taiwan Strait transit * South Korea's Cabinet approves universal cash grant amid controversy * 87 Japanese nationals, family members evacuated from Iran, Israel * Leaders of China, New Zealand discuss trade, Pacific security * Ramos-Horta: Timor-Leste ready to contribute to regional stability * South Korea says SK and Amazon to invest $5 billion in country's biggest data centre * 'Cyborg' Chinese woman with rare disorder lives on feeding tube, stays optimistic * New S. Korean President's call for public to suggest Cabinet members 'more than a populist move' * Australian trial says tech for social media teen ban can work * S. Korean taxi driver under fire for sexually harassing Thai tourist * N. Korea flag disrupts S. Korea church livestream in 'hacking incident' * Monsters and memes: Labubu dolls ride China soft-power wave * billionaire's viral stunt reignites China's food-delivery feud * Rice prices double in Japan as inflation accelerates * Where is Trump's 'all-American' phone made? Analysts point to Asia * Japan's core inflation hits 2-year high, keeps rate-hike bets alive * Hong Kong singer Tommy Yuen arrested for allegedly stealing snacks worth HK$140 * Star singer Hael Husaini overjoyed as tickets for solo concert almost sold out; celebrates by inviting more 'friends' on stage for big show * Ju Hak-nyeon, formerly of K-pop boy band The Boyz, denies paying for sex * Stephen Chow cuddles up to Carina Lau in new photo; fans think a movie collaboration is in the works

Malaysiakini

8 hours ago

• Malaysiakini

MCMC's phone data grab is not harmless

COMMENT | In 2018 and again in 2022, Malaysians voted for reform, demanding greater transparency, democratic rights, and a government that listens. That is why the public backlash to recent revelations about the MCMC mobile data request has been swift and entirely justified. According to local and international media reports, such as The Edge and South China Morning Post, MCMC issued directives to five major telcos requesting mobile phone metadata for the first quarter of 2025. The fields listed include anonymised user IDs (MSISDN), precise date and time stamps, base station identifiers, GPS coordinates, data type (calls or internet), service type (2G - 5G) and mobile country code. On paper, names or identity card (IC) numbers were excluded, but in practice, metadata is never truly anonymous.