The Irish Independent's View: New housing excuses sound remarkably similar to the old ones

The minister talked up returning vacant properties to the market and the potential for social housing and rental accommodation. Strategies will include streamlining the planning process, strategic use of land, funds for local authorities and more specific schemes. Construction levies and taxation will also be looked at.
To understand the issue better from the inside out, and then to put measures in place that are practical and action-orientated, the minister was meeting with a wide variety of stakeholders.
He also acknowledged that things will probably get worse before they get better.
If this all sounds remarkably familiar, it's because this account of an interview by the housing minister is almost a decade old. This time nine years ago, the housing minister Simon Coveney was building up towards his big announcement of an action plan for housing. 'Rebuilding Ireland' was published in the summer of 2016 – complete with the commitment to end homelessness.
Browne's overhaul of Rent Pressure Zones will arguably make the cost of rent worse
Fast forward nine years and the current occupant of the Custom House, James Browne, is talking in strikingly similar terms about the imperative to increase supply. Browne's overhaul of Rent Pressure Zones will arguably make the cost of rent worse, initially, in order to increase the supply in the longer run, thereby making things better. But the minister doesn't appear to have the political wit to acknowledge there are immediate downsides to his plans.
The impact of the lack of supply in the market is illustrated today in the Irish Independent/REA Average House Price Index. The survey shows asking prices still rising as buyers become desperate to get a home they can call their own. This summer, the minister will also launch an action plan for housing – the latest iteration of a running theme for a decade.
Emerging from the ashes of the Celtic Tiger crash, successive governments of similar hues have failed to sufficiently increase the output of housing to anywhere near the levels required. A record 93,419 houses and apartments were built in 2006 – the highest rate in Europe. Nowadays we seem to be lucky if we break the 30,000 mark. Even the Government's bluff figure of 40,000 is well below that of a generation ago.
Whatever bells-and-whistles plan is launched this time will doubtless try to suggest that the initiatives identified are new and therefore deserving of time to bed in and deliver results. It's a hard sell at this stage as the housing excuses wear thin for this Coalition. It is simply not credible to ask the public to ignore what has gone before simply because there is a new minister appointed in a newly formed government.
Meet the new boss, he sounds remarkably similar to the old boss. Clear, coherent and credible policies will get a better reception than being told it will be different this time around.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Journal

36 minutes ago

• The Journal

Government survey finds majority of the public think it's doing a bad job on climate

THE LATEST 'CLIMATE Conversations' survey by the government has found that the public believe that the government is seriously underperforming in its climate action. This survey is the fourth report of its kind. It gathered its responses through an online public consultation between May and September 2024. It claims to 'provide critical insights into Irish citizens' attitudes, understanding, and involvement in climate action'. One section of the report, titled 'Perceptions of the Government's Performance [on climate]', summarised its respondents' attitudes to Government's climate performance as so: 'Their performance was generally negatively perceived across all areas, especially in terms of 'having a clear plan in place for getting Government, businesses and people to work together', and in 'Giving citizens a say in climate policy'. 'Supporting individuals and communities to take climate action' was also one of the more poorly rated areas.' Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications Department of the Environment, Climate and Communications Just over one in seven people who responded to the survey believed that the Government is delivering a clear climate action plan. Advertisement The report noted that those that had responded to the online consultation are generally more engaged with the topic of climate change than the general public, and stated 'this is worth remembering' in regards to assessing responses from the cohort in which 76% of the respondents expressed that they felt that they themselves could do more to address climate change, an increase in the previous iterations of the survey. It said that frustration is the dominant emotion felt by the Irish public regarding climate change, followed by worry and powerlessness. Frustration was recorded by 67% of the 1,9,49 respondents (about 1,306 people), worry by 54% (about 1,052 people), and powerlessness by 51% (994 people). Respondents decided that in their view, reducing the number of flights, retrofitting, and the installation of solar panels/wind turbines would have the greatest impact on reducing carbon emissions. However, the department said that there was a misperception and that Ireland's lagging behind on the adoption of electric vehicles was not viewed correctly in this context. Other key findings within the report included the persisting of 'misconceptions' about actions that most effectively reduce carbon emissions. It said that 'many respondents' underestimate the benefits of adopting the use of an electric vehicle. The report recommends establishing community climate hubs, addressing misperceptions about electric vehicles, and enhancing cross-government collaboration on climate initiatives. Minister Darragh O'Brien said that the report 'provides us with a great understanding of the issues that our citizens and communities really care about when it comes to climate action'. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal

Irish Examiner

2 hours ago

• Irish Examiner

Three Irish citizens evacuated from Iran in wake of US airstrikes

Three Irish citizens have been evacuated from Iran, Tánaiste Simon Harris has confirmed. Mr Harris confirmed the evacuation of the citizens took place overnight. 'I am pleased to confirm that three Irish citizens and their dependents were assisted to depart Iran overnight and will now travel home,' Mr Harris said. 'I want to extend our gratitude to our European friends and partners for their excellent support.' It comes after 15 Irish citizens were evacuated from Israel on Sunday, with the Government expecting them to arrive back in Ireland in the coming days. Mr Harris has urged any other Irish citizens remaining in Iran to register with Department of Foreign Affairs staff. 'Throughout this crisis, the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade and our Embassies have remained in regular contact with Irish citizens in the region,' he said. 'We have worked closely with our EU and other partners to exchange information and coordinate our consular response to the situation.'

Irish Independent

3 hours ago

• Irish Independent

TD warns GP services across Wicklow ‘at breaking point'

In 2023, Social Democrats TD for Wicklow Jennifer Whitmore conducted a survey of GP services across the county and the stark figures pointed to an emerging crisis, as she warned that communities across Wicklow were being left without access to basic healthcare. Speaking to the Tánaiste, Simon Harris, in the Dáil on Thursday, June 19, Deputy Whitmore challenged the Government's failure to introduce salaried GPs, a key reform promised in the Programme for Government. She also highlighted the results of a new report that showed the need for at least 940 GPs over the coming 15 years in order to meet the demand that exists nationally. 'GP services are at breaking point,' she said. 'They are over-subscribed, under-staffed, and struggling to remain open. It is now standard to wait two or even three weeks for an appointment. That is simply not good enough. 'In 2023, I conducted a survey of GP practices across Wicklow. The results were stark; the vast majority were not accepting new patients. This is a clear sign that the system is under enormous strain and cannot meet the needs of our growing population,' Deputy Whitmore continued. 'Six in 10 GPs nationwide are not taking new patients, one in four GPs are over the age of 60 and set to retire within the next decade, and up to 30pc of newly trained GPs are emigrating. All the while, the population of Ireland is growing rapidly and outpacing GP availability. 'This is a ticking time bomb and it's about to go off. We are not meeting the demands of our communities. The Government is sleepwalking into a healthcare disaster,' she warned. Deputy Whitmore criticised the delay in publishing the long-promised Strategic Review of General Practice, which began in April 2023 and remains incomplete more than two years later. 'We don't need another review to tell us what is blindingly obvious; we need more GPs, and we need them now. The Government has been far too slow to act, and the consequences are becoming insurmountable. 'We need to see the immediate rollout of salaried GPs, because the current model is deterring young doctors from entering general practice. Many young GPs want to focus on medicine, not on running a business. Salaried GP roles would remove the financial and administrative burdens, restore work-life balance, and allow the HSE to directly address GP blackspots like those in Blessington and across Wicklow. 'GPs are crying out for support and patients are crying out for healthcare. It's time for the Government to stop talking and start acting,' Deputy Whitmore concluded. The Tániaste conceded it was 'a real challenge in lots of communities' and replied that the annual intake to the GP training scheme had increased by approximately 80pc between 2019 and 2024. He said there has also been increased investment in general practice and pointed to one of the positive developments in the constituency, which was the roll-out of the out-of-hours GP service in Loughlinstown. "That service that did not exist five or six years ago," he said. Deputy Harris said some 118 GPs have chosen to come to Ireland and there are plans to get the number up to 250. 'Let me be clear that I am aware of – and am not in any way disputing – the huge challenges that exist in terms of capacity. People are waiting too long too see a GP. There is a need to ramp up capacity in general practice further, not just the number of doctors but also the number of support staff,' he said.