How Democrats Are Meeting (and Missing) the Moment
Jun 19, 2025 7:00 AM After the shootings of lawmakers in Minnesota, the weekend's "No Kings" protests, and elected officials being placed in handcuffs, Democrats are searching for the path forward. Photo-illustration: WIRED Staff; Getty Images
'Well,' a senior Democratic strategist tells me, 'my wife and I are having a fight about me going back to the field in the midterms.'
'I would be lying if I said these aren't conversations I've been having with my family every day,' shared a Democratic candidate in a high-profile battleground state midterms race.
In a matter of days, the truly unthinkable occurred: On Thursday last week, Senator Alex Padilla of California was forcibly removed from a news conference and handcuffed by officials wearing FBI-identifying clothing when he tried to question Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem on immigration raids in Los Angeles. On Saturday, Melissa Hortman, a Democratic Minnesota state representative, and her husband, Mark Hortman, were shot and killed. State senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette Hoffman were also shot. On Tuesday, New York City Comptroller and Democratic mayoral candidate Brad Lander was violently arrested after accompanying an immigrant from a court appointment.
Not to mention the fact that an estimated 4 to 6 million people attended 'No Kings' protests this past weekend against President Donald Trump's administration.
How should Democrats be approaching this chaotic and, at times, violent moment? From lawmakers and candidates all the way down to the staff who fuel their operations, a series of events over the past week have made national Democrats reconsider their strategy. Following the shootings of the state lawmakers in Minnesota, a weekend of nationwide protests, and Democratic lawmakers in handcuffs, Democrats are trying to figure out what meeting the Trump moment really means for an out-of-power coalition that's already under fire from constituents for ostensibly rolling over. And for a number of lawmakers and strategists, that answer isn't so simple.
'I think that the hard reality is, a lot of Democrats and a lot of people say, like, why aren't we doing something?' David Axelrod, former President Barack Obama's chief strategist from his 2008 and 2012 campaigns, tells WIRED. 'Well, there are a limited number of ways in a democracy to do something, short of revolution—which I'm not advocating. You win elections, you go to court.'
He says Padilla was in the right but that Democrats should exercise caution and not play into the White House's hands by rushing to get arrested or associating themselves too closely with protests that are unpredictable and prone to producing images of disorder. (Padilla's office did not return a request for comment.)
Some laws of political gravity, Axelrod argues, still apply: 'As a general rule, don't do what your opponent wants.'
The issue isn't just optics though, but expectation. 'I think the last thing Dems want to do is look unhinged or out of control,' a GOP strategist tells me. Right-wing media, certainly, has had a field day: a Fox News prime time segment from Jesse Watters on Tuesday night painted Democratic protesters as hysterical and ineffective.
But Democratic voters might just want a strong, 'unhinged' response. 'Democrats are crying out for [a] fight,' the senior Democratic strategist tells me. 'They are crying out for someone who seems like they're fighting.'
Democrats have been deeply pessimistic about the future of their own party, according to polling, despite a recent rebound for the party brand in the generic ballot against Republicans, where they now lead by 2 points, their best performance since last August, according to YouGov's latest survey.
Pennsylvania state representative Malcolm Kenyatta—a newly elected vice chair of the Democratic National Committee since David Hogg stepped down—tells WIRED optics should not be the primary consideration when it comes to whether lawmakers with oversight abilities should consider risking the chance of an arrest.
'Listen, I think we have a responsibility to do our fuckin' job,' says Kenyatta, the grandson of civil rights leader Muhammad Kenyatta. 'And what Senator Padilla was doing was his job.'
House Speaker Hakeem Jeffries of New York has often used the baseball analogy of not swinging at every pitch to explain how he thinks Democrats should respond to President Trump's deluge of executive actions and outlandish statements.
For emerging leaders in the party like Kenyatta, the state of play has moved beyond that point.
'Things don't become less important because a lot of them are happening,' Kenyatta says. 'I don't think we have the luxury of ignoring any of the things he does that are going to make life worse for people.'
Lander, who was detained outside of an immigration court hearing in New York City on Tuesday, took that exact type of risk. For the senior Democratic strategist fighting with his wife—who requested anonymity to avoid entangling other clients, and their spouse—Lander showed fellow Democrats how it should be done. (A representative for Lander did not return a request for comment.)
'Yes, this is exactly what people should be doing,' they say. 'There are people who are going to say this whole thing is gimmicky, and I get that. Put some fucking skin in the game. We've gotta draw attention to it somehow—look at all of those cameras they had to arrest him in front of.'
But there are also very real security considerations. The battleground state candidate, who also requested anonymity to discuss sensitive security conversations, said the increased security posture lawmakers are dealing with has only made it harder to be as up close with voters, as regularly, in as many places.
'It's this ugly reality where you have to look out for your safety. It is going to rob people of access to their elected officials and candidates,' they say.
This has happened already: Representative Hillary Scholten of Michigan postponed a Monday town hall in Muskegon after her name ended up on the alleged Minnesota shooter's list of lawmakers to target. (Scholten's office did not return a request for comment.)
Even so, the Democratic candidate wants their constituents to know they're not alone, and they have every right to be angry.
"I am as angry as you are about our government and our elected officials,' they say. 'I'm doing the hard thing. I'm putting my name on a ballot. I'm being vulnerable. I'm asking for people to support me, which is a fuck-ton harder than buying a gun and going and threatening people." The Chatroom
Who stands out to you as a lawmaker or candidate meeting the moment?
Leave a comment on the site or send your thoughts to mail@wired.com. WIRED Reads
Want more? Subscribe now for unlimited access to WIRED. What Else We're Reading
🔗 Inside the Clashes Between Trump and Gabbard: Tulsi Gabbard is in a bind after more than two decades of pushing for an end to forever wars, and a rogue 3-minute video she recently released didn't help. (Politico)
🔗 Comptroller Brad Lander Arrested by Masked Federal Agents While Escorting Immigrant from Court: A comprehensive write-up of how Brad Lander's arrest went down, from an excellent local outlet in New York. (Hell Gate)
🔗 Bid to Protect Lawmakers' Data Gains Momentum: The Minnesota shooter's alleged use of data brokers has revived a bill in Congress that would allow lawmakers to remove personal data from the internet. (Semafor) The Download
Our flagship show Uncanny Valley dives into some of the strange and disturbing hallucinations from AI chatbots around the Los Angeles protests—the same ones that would come up blank when users asked for information about the 2024 election. Listen now.
Thanks again for subscribing. You can find me on Bluesky or on Signal at Leak2Lahut.26.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Police arrest 16-year-old in connection to shooting near Lincoln High School
Police arrested a 16-year-old Thursday in connection to a shooting that injured another teenager near Lincoln High School earlier in the week. Officers booked the suspect into the Remann Hall Juvenile Detention Facility on suspicion of first-degree assault, unlawful gun possession, and possession of a weapon on school grounds, Tacoma Police said in a news release Thursday evening. The shooting happened after school, about 2:45 p.m., on June 17 in the 700 block of South 37th Street, The News Tribune reported. Police said the boy who was shot, also a 16-year-old, was hospitalized with injuries that were not life-threatening. 'Police identified the location of the shooting, interviewed witnesses, and obtained video surveillance as part of the investigation,' the news release said. Investigators said they found the gun and that there are no other suspects. There was a four-vehicle wreck nearby shortly after the shooting, The News Tribune reported, including a police vehicle on the way to the scene and a school bus that wasn't carrying any students.
Fox News
22 minutes ago
- Fox News
Democrats won't allow law enforcement officers to 'do their jobs,' ICE official laments
All times eastern FOX News Radio Live Channel Coverage WATCH LIVE: Former President Biden attends Juneteenth event at Reedy Chapel Church in Texas
CBS News
23 minutes ago
- CBS News
On Juneteenth, President Trump says America has "too many non-working holidays"
President Trump appeared to mark Juneteenth on Thursday with a Truth Social post arguing the United States has "too many non-working holidays." "It is costing our Country $BILLIONS OF DOLLARS to keep all of these businesses closed. The workers don't want it either! Soon we'll end up having a holiday for every … working day of the year," Mr. Trump wrote. "It must change if we are going to, MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!" The post did not explicitly mention Juneteenth. CBS News has reached out to the White House for comment. The holiday commemorates the end of slavery in the U.S. after the Civil War — specifically, the day in 1865 when Union soldiers arrived in Galveston, Texas, and belatedly announced that enslaved people were freed. Juneteenth has been a federal holiday since 2021. Federal and state government offices are generally closed as a result, along with banks and stock exchanges, but private businesses aren't required to close for Juneteenth or any other holiday, and many retail establishments remain open. When asked earlier Thursday if the president planned to commemorate Juneteenth, White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters: "I'm not tracking his signature on a proclamation today. I know this is a federal holiday. I want to thank all of you for showing up to work. We are certainly here. We're working 24/7 right now." Mr. Trump honored Juneteenth during his first term, including in 2017, when he called it "a historic day recognizing the end of slavery." He issued similar messages in 2018 and 2019, and in 2020, he said during an interview that he "made Juneteenth very famous" — referring to his decision not to hold a campaign rally in Oklahoma on the holiday. "It's actually an important event, an important time. But nobody had ever heard of it," Mr. Trump said in a 2020 interview with The Wall Street Journal. Former President Joe Biden signed a bill making Juneteenth an official federal holiday in 2021, after the measure passed both houses of Congress with overwhelming bipartisan margins. One longtime backer of the holiday is Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas.
