FactCheck: False claims about toxins, Vitamin D and ‘cooked' skin in viral claims about suncream
SUMMER HAS BEGUN, meaning soaring temperatures (maybe), shining sun (possibly), and weeks of balmy, good weather (probably not).
It's also a time you'll hear good advice to wear suncream, but an odd chorus of counter advice has taken hold with false and harmful claims that suncreams can be dangerous.
These include incorrect suggestions that sun scream is full of 'toxins', can block vitamin D or cause cancer.
These claims, which have long been espoused online, came to the fore in Ireland recently in reaction to
the appearance
of skincare expert Eavanna Breen on TV to talk about the dangers of sun exposure and the importance of wearing suncream.
'I opened a can of worms,' Breen said in a 19 May Instagram video. 'People saying in the comments that I didn't know what I was talking about. That suncreams are full of toxins and we shouldn't be putting them on our skin.'
Breen is correct. Social media is rife with posts that make false claims about suncream (also called sunscreen), often from accounts that claim to give health advice, can accumulate hundreds of thousands or even millions of views.
Although many of the most popular versions of these posts are not from Ireland their influence has been felt here, particularly in alternative medicine circles.
'It's this rejection of what they need – man made or synthetic – versus what they deem natural,' says David Robert Grimes, a science writer who studies how misinformation spreads. By way of example, he shows why this belief is false: 'Arsenic, Uranium and Ebola are all 'natural'.'
Grimes conducted research for his PhD into UV radiation, which is what can make sunlight so damaging.
'A tan is your body's way of screaming at you 'get me out of the sun'. It is an adaptive response to UV radiation,' he summarises.
'The idea [among those spreading misinformation] is that suncream is made by man, so putting it on your skin is bad, but the sun is natural, therefore it's good,' Grimes said.
He noted that a similar logic is often used by people who go against vaccines; viruses are natural, while vaccines contain ingredients which are synthetic. Nevertheless, the vaccines in use are much less likely to cause you harm than being infected with the live virus.
Grimes also said that many of these outlandish claims often do well because of social media algorithms, which promote them into people's feeds.
People who scroll on social media sites are more likely to click on and react to counterintuitive claims, even if it's to argue against them. On many social media sites, such interactions push those posts higher in the feed so that even more people can see them.
On the flip side, standard advice can struggle to make an impression; even if it is correct, people have heard it all before.
steffyweffy777
/ YouTube
Anti-sunscream claims tend to fall into three main categories: that suncream is toxic; that suncream does more harm than good by blocking vitamin D production; and that there were no skin cancers in the past before suncream was used.
These claims can be dangerous. UV radiation, such as that from the sun or tanning beds, is the main factor for most skin cancers in Ireland.
There were,
on average
, 7,545 cases of Basal cell carcinoma and 1,243 cases of melanoma, both types of skin cancer caused by the sun, diagnosed annually between 2018 and 2022. According to an analysis by the National Cancer Registry, rates of both these cancers are increasing.
If people forego suncream, especially if they do so thinking that the sun's rays must be healthy for them, they are putting themselves at risk needlessly.
Toxins
One of the major claims made against suncream is that it contains toxic ingredients.
'What if slathering toxic, cancer-causing chemicals on our skin in the name of 'protection' was doing more harm than good?' one post we found on Facebook by a skincare company asked.
However, unlike posts by other users that appear to be dispensing odd health advice for social media engagement, the motivation behind that one is clear: it also promotes the company's own suncream, which it says is made from beef fat and 'non-nano zinc'.
(Zinc is a standard sun-blocking ingredient in mineral suncreams. It's what makes them, and other formulas like Sudocreme, white).
Other false claims claiming there are toxins in suncream are not as explicit, but rather implied; they often try to sell 'non-toxic' suncream to a public while amping up the suspicion of 'chemicals', such as those listed on the back of most suncream bottles.
However, as David Robert Grimes points out, even the
chemical description of an apple
can sound sinister when you don't know what the terms mean.
'Unless you're talking about particles of light, everything in our tangible universe is chemical,' he said.
Long lists of exotic-sounding chemicals make up many anti-suncream posts, which warn that these chenmicals can be dangerous.
They often refer to oxybenzone, octinoxate, oxytocinate, octisalate, octocrylene, homosalate, parabens, PUFAs, avobenzone, or nanoparticles.
'If you can't pronounce it, your liver's already struggling,' one of these posts, viewed tens of thousands of times on X, reads.
'These ingredients don't block UV rays. They absorb them. Convert them into heat. Your skin turns into a microwave. Congrats, you're cooked.'
The last part of this claim is partly true, but is misleading in a way that purposely makes the process sound more sinister than it is.
Some sunscreen ingredients do absorb UV rays and
convert them
into tiny amounts of heat, but nowhere near the levels needed to cook or microwave a person's skin.
The heat generated is
negligible
, and is far less damaging than the
DNA mutations
that UV radiation can cause on the skin when they are left unblocked.
Advertisement
Concerns about the chemicals in suncreams are also partly based in fact — some of the ingredients do have potentially negative health effects in high doses, which is why they are regulated.
In order to prevent this from happening, Europe places regulatory limits on them so they are far below any harmful thresholds when they are used in suncream.
'Sunscreens are cosmetic products and as such manufacturers must comply with strict European regulatory standards that include governance on ingredients, safety and labelling,' the Health Products Regulatory Authority (HPRA) told
The Journal.
'The HPRA's role as the competent authority is to ensure cosmetic products on the Irish market are safe for consumers and meet the requirements of the cosmetics regulation.
'When a cosmetic product comes to the Irish market, it undergoes a safety report, including product testing and likely exposure levels.
'Ingredients used in cosmetic products must be safe and must abide by the minimum standards to be met by all cosmetic products placed on the market.'
For sunscreams specifically, this means that only protective UV filters approved for that purpose may be used.
A list of UV filters allowed in cosmetic products, as well as what concentrations and what products they can be used in, is available on the European Commission website
here
.
'The HPRA continuously evaluate the inclusion of cosmetic ingredients at European level and in collaboration with other EU markets, to ensure the highest standards of consumer safety are maintained.
'Consumers should check for a European address on the label. If it is not there, it might indicate that the product has been imported from outside the EU and may not meet European requirements for safety assessment.'
Vitamin D and cancers
A near constant refrain on posts encouraging people to forego suncream is that sunlight is needed to make vitamin D.
'Sunlight increases your body's production of Vitamin D which fights cancer. Sunscreen is full of chemicals that cause cancer,' a post by a self-described 'Naturopath' said on X last July.
To date, the post has accumulated more than 2.4 million views, according to X's analytics.
An identical post by an anti-Covid vaccine account using the exact same wording was also posted last August, and has accumulated a further 3.6 million views on the platform.
Although
research
has looked at whether Vitamin D can prevent cancers, the evidence has been '
mixed
' and there is no credible evidence that skipping sunscreen to boost Vitamin D is worth the well-established risk of
UV-induced skin cancers
.
'We don't have rickets,' David Robert Grimes says. 'That is your bog-standard test for nutritional deficiency.'
While it may seem intuitive that suncream, which blocks the sun's harmful rays, would reduce the amount of Vitamin D produced in the skin,
experiments
have shown that volunteers that used suncream in the sun
maintained
vitamin D production, while
reducing sunburns
.
'Our bodies can still make vitamin D from sunlight even when using suncream,' the HSE told
The Journal
by email.
'The Department of Health recommends vitamin D supplements for everyone. The amount you need depends on your age, skin tone, your situation and the time of year.'
Cancer rates
'We were exposed to the sun for hundreds of thousands of years and were doing just fine until sunscreen was invented in 1938,' a post on X last June said. It was from an account that describes themself as 'the most canceled scientist'.
'Since then, melanoma rates began to skyrocket in the 1950s, yet people blame the sun rather than the toxic chemicals in sunscreen.' The post has been viewed more than 1,800,000 times.
Melanoma is a particularly dangerous form of skin cancer.
Skin cancer diagnoses have increased over the last century, but there is no evidence that sunscreen is responsible. The rise is more accurately explained by much more obvious factors.
'Improved diagnostics, better reporting, and also that we live longer, and we have more time to accumulate that DNA damage that can lead to things like skin cancer,' David Robert Grimes said, listing other reasons why more cases of skin cancer are recorded now than in the past.
Melanomas have been
recorded in history
, including in the writings of Hippocrates, as well as archaeological evidence of melanomas on 2,400-year-old Peruvian mummies.
However, historical statistics on rates of skin cancers are scant. National Cancer Registry Ireland began collecting data on cancer cases in 1994.
'Over 5,000 cases of skin cancer were diagnosed in Ireland in 1994,' a spokesperson for the HSE told
The Journal.
'It can take decades for skin cancer to develop after exposure to UV radiation. Many of those diagnosed with skin cancer in 1994 would have been exposed many years earlier when sunscreen was much less widely used or available.'
The connection between UV rays and skin damage is well established, as is suncream's ability to stop these rays.
Pyro Labs
/ YouTube
Grimes also listed living longer as a reason that more skin cancers are being detected nowadays.
'Cancer is primarily a disease of aging,' Grimes said. 'Most cancers manifest post your 60s, right? There are exceptions, but almost all of them are associated with aging. The damage is done much earlier on, and then decades later, the cancer emerges. You might have got some exposure in your 30s that eventually leads to cancer in your 60s.
'So as we live longer, we get more cancers.'
Ingredients in suncreams are regularly revised in the EU based on the latest science and have strict limits to make sure their use is safe. Many claims about suncream being bad for you are based on incorrect data or faulty reasoning.
Not wearing suncream on sunny days can quickly lead to
visible radiation burns
and genetic damage, which increase the likelihood of cancer developing.
Want to be your own fact-checker? Visit our brand-new
FactCheck Knowledge Bank
for guides and toolkits
The Journal's FactCheck is a signatory to the International Fact-Checking Network's Code of Principles. You can read it
here
. For information on how FactCheck works, what the verdicts mean, and how you can take part, check out our Reader's Guide
here
. You can read about the team of editors and reporters who work on the factchecks
here
.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
It is vital that we surface facts from noise. Articles like this one brings you clarity, transparency and balance so you can make well-informed decisions.
We set up FactCheck in 2016 to proactively expose false or misleading information, but to continue to deliver on this mission we need your support.
Over 5,000 readers like you support us. If you can, please consider setting up a monthly payment or making a once-off donation to keep news free to everyone.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
9 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Kate breaks silence after pulling out of Ascot to share poignant message about kids with ‘serious health conditions'
PRINCESS Kate has spoken out in celebration of the "life-changing work" of children's hospice staff. The Princess of Wales, 43, pulled out of her only appearance at 6 Kate was spotted alongside the family attending Trooping the Colour earlier this week Credit: Getty 6 The princess has slowly been returning to royal duties after going into remission in January Credit: Getty But she returned to work writing a personal message to mark the end of Children's Hospice Week. Kate is Royal Patron of East Anglia Children's Hospices (EACH), and in January this year became the Royal Patron of Tŷ Hafan Children's Hospice in South Wales. In a letter shared in social media she wrote: "No parent expects to hear that their child has a serious health condition that could shorten their life. "Sadly, this is the reality faced by thousands of families across the country, leaving them heart-broken, fearful of the future and often desperately isolated. Royals news "Being able to access the support of one of the UK's 54 children's hospices means they don't have to face that future alone. "As "Lifting spirits through laughter, fun and play, as well as listening, holding, caring and sharing, they support children and families through life, death and beyond. "This Children's Hospice Week, I hope you will join me in celebrating the life-changing work they do and thanking them for the vital care they provide to children and families experiencing the most challenging times." Most read in Royals 6 Her Royal Highness wrote the heartfelt message to mark Children's Hospice Week Credit: Instagram 6 The princess has been Royal Patron of East Anglia's Children's Hospices since 2012 Credit: Instagram This comes after Kate pulled out of her She was listed as arriving in the carriage procession with Prince William, however, moments later, the palace revealed that the mother-of-three had to drop out last minute to continue with her recovery. It is understood that Kate was "disappointed" not to go but has "to find the right balance" on returning to full time duty. Since announcing in January she is in Recent days have seen her attend Trooping the Colour and Order of the Garter, as well as making a visit to V&A East Storehouse last week. However, it is understood that Kate is trying to find the balance as she fully returns to public-facing engagements that have featured an element of flexibility since her cancer diagnosis in March 2024. Prince William was spotted putting on a brave face in his wife's absence, as he drank beer and joked with fellow royals. He was seen greeting others in the grandstand and cheering on horses and jockeys during a sunny day two of racing. Other The national Children's Hospice Week is led by children's palliative care charity Together for Short Lives and the event is dedicated to raising awareness of children's hospice services. Nick Carroll, CEO of Together for Short Lives, said about Kate: "Her ongoing support for Children's Hospice Week over many years has helped to raise much-needed awareness of the life-changing work children's hospices do, every day of the year. "Their extraordinary lifeline care for children with life-limiting and life-threatening illnesses enables families to make the most of their lives together, whether that's for years, months or only hours." 6 Kate stunned at Trooping the Colour this week as her and Charlotte wore matching teal dresses Credit: PA 6 She was also spotted at the annual Order of the Garter Service at St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle Credit: PA
The Journal
2 days ago
- The Journal
Dublin tanning salons 'heavily' promoting products that encourage sunbed use
NEW RESEARCH HAS found that some Dublin tanning salons are 'heavily promoting' products that encourage sunbed use, including accelerators, despite there being a ban on promoting sunbeds themselves. While salons were still compliant with the Sunbeds Act itself, the HSE says the research shows a need for tighter regulations on these related promotions. The study, published by the Institute of Public Health and the HSE National Cancer Control Programme. It examined the marketing practices of two tanning salon operators in Dublin. The Sunbeds Act ensures that no person under 18 years of age can use a sunbed in any premises, and that sunbeds cannot be sold or hired to under-18s. Further restrictions put into place in 2015 banned certain marketing practices in relation to sunbeds, such as making positive health claims about their use. The study found that two operators used marketing strategies that made sunbed use 'sound appealing', and encouraged their use across a range of premises. Advertisement Ireland has one of the highest rates of skin cancer in the world, with more than 11,000 people diagnosed with skin cancer each year. Sunbed use is associated with an increased risk of skin cancer, with the highest risk associated with use in childhood and adolescence, and with using sunbeds frequently. Around 3% of the population are reportedly currently using sunbeds. The study found that words like 'glowing' were used in social media posts related to sunbed use, and that tanning drinks were often promoted as being beneficial health wise as well. Dr Richard Purves from the Institute for Social Marketing and Health at the University of Stirling, which led the research, said that the study showed that while operators are complying with 'the letter of the law', they often incentivise sunbed use by offering free or discounted products. 'Instagram plays a central role, with images of bronzed models, beach scenes, and limited-time promotions designed to attract customers. In-store marketing and special offers on tanning products further encourage sunbed use. Notably, some messaging still hints at unproven health benefits, exposing potential gaps in current regulations,' he added Dr Breeda Neville, specialist in public health medicine with the HSE National Cancer Control Programme said that the marketing strategies being employed by some operators are 'very concerning', especially when it comes to interactive content on instagram aimed at promoting sunbed use. The HSE advises that you should never use a sunbed, as it will increase your risk of skin cancer, and every user is put at risk. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
4 days ago
- Irish Independent
HSE reveals in Cork that over 800 concerns of elder abuse were reported to it in region last year
To mark the day, HSE South West has launched a series of videos and events. The theme of this year's safeguarding awareness campaign is "Loneliness – Connection is Protection." Most older people live independent and active lives. However, loneliness and social isolation leaves older people vulnerable to abuse and risk of exploitation, the health body said. A short series of safeguarding awareness clips can be found on HSE South West's YouTube channel and on social media, focusing on topics such as an introduction to safeguarding and how to recognise abuse, support people to know how to report concerns of abuse and encourage our older population to stay connected. The Safeguarding Team is also visiting several organisations in the region to promote awareness. Cork City Council and Kerry County Council are supporting the campaign by lighting up their buildings purple on June 15, the colour associated with World Elder Abuse Awareness Day. Miriam Tobin, Principal Social Worker with the Safeguarding and Protection Team in HSE South West, said: "There is nothing more lonely or terrifying than feeling unheard. An older person who had a large circle of friends, a fulfilling career, or a wide range of exciting hobbies may feel embarrassed, or may find it difficult, to talk about feeling lonely as they get older. 'The most common issue we are told about is the older person not being listened to. People can experience loneliness if they don't feel understood or valued by the people around them. Stop, take the time to listen properly, and do what you can to help our elders live out their best lives, in safety and comfort. Being there to listen and reassure, creating a safe space to connect, can make the world of difference to how a loved one feels.' Loneliness is not always visible; it can affect people with a network of support around them. Loneliness can lead to an increase in emotional, physical, and financial vulnerability and can result in physical health problems. Abuse can take place in the person's home or in places assumed to be safe such as hospitals, residential homes, or day centres. Abuse can be deliberate, or it can be caused by a lack of knowledge or through neglect. Types of abuse include emotional, physical and sexual abuse, neglect of a person's basic or health needs, and financial and online abuse such as scams or exploitation. Watch out for any signs of elder abuse and know how and when to report it to a professional or service known to you. You can contact the HSE South West Safeguarding Team on 021 4927550 or Freephone 1800 225 500 between 9am-1pm and 2pm-4pm Monday to Friday.
