Streaming services and a cost of doing business
Opinion
The battle between Canadian media and the streaming services of the world goes on.
The latest front of that conflict is playing out at the Federal Court of Appeal in Toronto, which is hearing consolidated appeals by several streamers over efforts by the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) to force those streamers to fund Canadian content.
There is certainly a case to be made that they should. Too often, web-based outlets are overlooked on the regulation front, as regulators or lawmakers may struggle to understand how to fit them into current moulds.
FILE
The online social-media pages of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC).
But the logic is simple: if a streamer functions as a broadcaster, and if its library is being broadcast to Canadian users, then it must adhere to Canadian expectations regarding contributing to that content and giving it the designated amount of playtime.
Apple, Amazon and Spotify are fighting the CRTC's order, which requires streamers with Canadian revenues over $25 million (and that are not affiliated with a Canadian broadcaster) to pay five per cent of that revenue toward funding a broad range of Canadian content, including local TV news.
It is not unfair to expect streaming services to customize its dealings country-by-country in this fashion — they already do it.
For example, Netflix's library of available titles is different in Canada than it is in the U.S., and further abroad, depending on what they have streaming licences for, and what they believe will appeal to each market. They are already making efforts to appeal to the Canadian market in their content-curation decisions, as do other streamers. Therefore, they can be expected to follow CanCon rules the same way every traditional broadcaster has done.
But, speaking of Netflix, the CRTC is also at risk of overplaying its hand.
According to the Canadian Press, one of the parties fighting the CRTC order is Motion Picture Association-Canada, which represents Netflix and Paramount.
Tuesdays
A weekly look at politics close to home and around the world.
They are challenging the CRTC order respective to contributing to local news, and there they have a point. While Spotify — which hosts many news and other current-events-related podcasts — has a stake in the news game, Netflix and Paramount aren't really in that business, so it's a weak argument to claim they should be funding it.
That said, there are weak arguments to be found on both sides: Apple is claiming the five per cent is not equitable, comparing itself to radio stations, which must pay only 0.5 per cent. That claim is a little rich, though not as rich as Apple; radio stations, at least the traditional, terrestrial kind, only has a fraction of the reach and revenue-generating power as Apple does, so it's fair enough at a glance that the larger entity pay more of a share, given its greater exposure. (On this point, the Canadian Press's coverage points out that the CRTC 'requires large English-language broadcasters to contribute 30 per cent of revenues to Canadian programming,' far more than is expected currently of streamers.)
The streamers appealing to the court have submitted a lengthy list of reasons why they shouldn't have to pay. That is to be expected. It suits streamers to maintain the idea that they are not the same as traditional broadcasters and so should get to operate under a separate set of rules, preferably ones beneficial to their bottom line.
That's why the CRTC's order is, while flawed, important. It is the commission's role, in part, to ensure purveyors of audio-visual media in Canada — on all platforms — meet their obligations to support Canadian content.
It's just the cost of doing business.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canada Standard
5 hours ago
- Canada Standard
Indian delegation in Ireland to attend 40th anniversary memorial of Kanishka bombing
Dublin [Ireland], June 23 (ANI): A high-level Indian delegation led by Union Housing and Urban Affairs Minister Hardeep Singh Puri along with BJP National General Secretary Tarun Chugh, and representatives from five states, has arrived in Ireland, to participate in the 40th anniversary memorial of the Air India Kanishka bombing. The commemoration will take place at the Ahakista Memorial in Cork on Sunday. The delegation includes prominent elected representatives, including Arvinder Singh Lovely (Delhi MLA), Baldev Singh Aulakh (Minister from Uttar Pradesh), Gurveer Singh Brar (MLA from Rajasthan), Trilok Singh Cheema (MLA from Uttarakhand), and Narinder Singh Raina (MLA from Jammu and Kashmir). The solemn memorial service will be attended by Ireland's Prime Minister, Micheal Martin, Canada's Minister of Public Safety, Gary Anandasangaree, and several other international dignitaries. This event not only commemorates the 329 innocent victims of the 1985 terror attack but also reinforces the global commitment against terrorism. In a post on X, Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri said, 'On the way from Heathrow to dastardly mid air bombing of Air India Kanishka Flight 182 in 1985 which claimed 329 innocent lives off the Irish Coast remains one of the most inhuman acts of terror in aviation history.I was able to pay tribute to the victims at the Kanishka Memorial at Humber Bay Park in Toronto in September 2019 where I also met family members of several victims who had shared their pain and suffering.' 'On Monday, 23 June 2025, I will lead an Indian delegation comprising senior Punjab leader Sh@tarunchughbjpJi, legislators from several states Sdr@ArvinderLovelyJi, Sdr@BaldevAulakhJi, Sdr@GurveerBrarJi and Sdr Trilok Singh Cheema Ji, to join the Irish Prime Minister HE@MichealMartinTD, Canadian Minister of Public Safety HE Gary Anandasangaree@gary_srpand others, to pay homage to the victims at an event at the Ahakista Memorial in Cork, Ireland in a solemn moment of remembrance and unity, on the 40th anniversary of the reprehensible Kanishka Bombing,' he added. Speaking ahead of the ceremony, BJP National General Secretary Tarun Chugh said, 'The Kanishka bombing was a painful reminder of the brutal face of terrorism, which claimed innocent lives across nations. As I stand on Irish soil, I pay my heartfelt tribute to those who perished, and reaffirm our resolve to unite against terror in all its forms.' (ANI)
Canada News.Net
6 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
Canada warns of retaliation without Trump agreement
OTTAWA, Canada: Canada may boost its counter-tariffs on steel and aluminum imported from the U.S. if a comprehensive trade agreement with President Donald Trump is not finalized within the next 30 days, Prime Minister Mark Carney announced this week. Earlier this month, Trump raised import duties on these metals from 25 percent to 50 percent, prompting the industry to call for Canada to respond officially. This decision could negatively impact Canada, the largest supplier of steel and aluminum to the U.S. Carney stated that he had reached a mutual agreement with Trump to aim for a new economic and security deal by July 21. He emphasized that, based on the progress achieved in the trade negotiations, Canada would modify its existing counter-tariffs on U.S. steel and aluminum products by that date. While Carney did not immediately respond to Trump's recent tariff increase, he expressed the desire to see advancements in talks focused on establishing a stronger economic and security alliance. Earlier this year, on March 13, Canada enacted 25 percent retaliatory tariffs on steel products worth C$12.6 billion and aluminum products worth C$3 billion. Furthermore, Canada is introducing new procurement policies that allow Canadian producers and trading partners with tariff-free access to compete for federal contracts involving steel and aluminum. Carney also indicated that Canada intends to create new tariff-rate quotas equal to 100 percent of 2024 levels for steel imported from nations without free trade agreements, aiming to stabilize the domestic market and prevent detrimental trade shifts. Approximately 90 percent of Canada's steel and aluminum exports go to the U.S., while Canada consumes about 20 percent of U.S. steel exports and 50 percent of U.S. aluminum exports, according to the Royal Bank of Canada, underscoring the importance of this trade relationship. Under Carney's leadership, Canada is advancing numerous infrastructure projects, including those related to defense and housing, which will significantly increase the demand for steel and aluminum. "We are committed to supporting the industry by prioritizing Canadian steel and aluminum in federal projects," Carney stated during a press conference.
Canada News.Net
6 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
Indian delegation in Ireland to attend 40th anniversary memorial of Kanishka bombing
Dublin [Ireland], June 23 (ANI): A high-level Indian delegation led by Union Housing and Urban Affairs Minister Hardeep Singh Puri along with BJP National General Secretary Tarun Chugh, and representatives from five states, has arrived in Ireland, to participate in the 40th anniversary memorial of the Air India Kanishka bombing. The commemoration will take place at the Ahakista Memorial in Cork on Sunday. The delegation includes prominent elected representatives, including Arvinder Singh Lovely (Delhi MLA), Baldev Singh Aulakh (Minister from Uttar Pradesh), Gurveer Singh Brar (MLA from Rajasthan), Trilok Singh Cheema (MLA from Uttarakhand), and Narinder Singh Raina (MLA from Jammu and Kashmir). The solemn memorial service will be attended by Ireland's Prime Minister, Micheal Martin, Canada's Minister of Public Safety, Gary Anandasangaree, and several other international dignitaries. This event not only commemorates the 329 innocent victims of the 1985 terror attack but also reinforces the global commitment against terrorism. In a post on X, Union Minister Hardeep Singh Puri said, 'On the way from Heathrow to dastardly mid air bombing of Air India Kanishka Flight 182 in 1985 which claimed 329 innocent lives off the Irish Coast remains one of the most inhuman acts of terror in aviation history.I was able to pay tribute to the victims at the Kanishka Memorial at Humber Bay Park in Toronto in September 2019 where I also met family members of several victims who had shared their pain and suffering.' 'On Monday, 23 June 2025, I will lead an Indian delegation comprising senior Punjab leader Sh@tarunchughbjpJi, legislators from several states Sdr@ArvinderLovelyJi, Sdr@BaldevAulakhJi, Sdr@GurveerBrarJi and Sdr Trilok Singh Cheema Ji, to join the Irish Prime Minister HE@MichealMartinTD, Canadian Minister of Public Safety HE Gary Anandasangaree@gary_srpand others, to pay homage to the victims at an event at the Ahakista Memorial in Cork, Ireland in a solemn moment of remembrance and unity, on the 40th anniversary of the reprehensible Kanishka Bombing,' he added. Speaking ahead of the ceremony, BJP National General Secretary Tarun Chugh said, 'The Kanishka bombing was a painful reminder of the brutal face of terrorism, which claimed innocent lives across nations. As I stand on Irish soil, I pay my heartfelt tribute to those who perished, and reaffirm our resolve to unite against terror in all its forms.' (ANI)
