Worst NIMBY suburbs: Sydney areas choking housing supply
Chronic opposition to new housing in prime western suburbs has strangled attempts to supply Sydney with the vital homes needed to meet surging population growth.
Alarming new analysis has revealed multiple, large Harbour City enclaves where fewer than 20 new homes were built over the past two years, with local housing supply growing by less than a per cent.
There were 78 suburb areas identified as having 'minimal to negligible' housing growth due to low dwelling approval rates, according to the SuburbTrends and MCG Quantity Surveyors data.
The low approval rates were 'indicative of local opposition or restrictive zoning practices', the research revealed.
It comes as NSW continues to fall behind housing targets, with the state well short of the 377,000 homes needed to be built to meet the National Housing Accord target of 1.2 million new homes by 2029.
Sydney areas with the least new housing approvals tended to be established suburbs dominated by low density, single-level homes. Less than a third of the homes in these suburbs were units or townhouses when the last census was taken in 2021.
These suburbs often had space to grow and much of the community opposition to the new homes has been on density grounds.
Council areas where lower volumes of housing were being approved covered much of the north shore and the inner west, along with parts of the Hills District.
But individual suburbs flagged as some of the worst perpetrators of NIMBYism (Not In My Back Yard) were in Sydney's outer west – where there is generally space for new housing developments.
They included Glenmore Park in Sydney's outer west, along with Harrington Park, Londonderry and Bligh Park.
Other pockets with particularly low housing approvals were Menai, Illawong and Alfords Point in the Sutherland Shire and Cromer, on the northern beaches. The research excluded suburbs with less than 1500 dwellings.
Low development in these areas was 'placing significant pressure on existing housing stock and exacerbating local affordability issues', the SuburbTrends and MCG research revealed.
MCG Quantity Surveyors director Mike Mortlock said low approvals in many areas painted a 'clear picture of entrenched resistance to new housing'.
'Places like Glenmore Park, Illawong and Cromer are emblematic of the challenge: low-density communities, often with strong local identities, where planning inertia and local opposition continue to choke supply,' Mr Mortlock said.
Many of the areas with the lowest housing approvals could benefit from densification, he added.
'What's striking is that several of these areas, such as Springwood and Wentworth Falls, offer the very lifestyle benefits that would make them ideal candidates for moderate densification. Yet we see barely a trickle of approvals,' Mr Mortlock said.
'These are the suburbs where policy needs to evolve from rhetoric to implementation, because the mismatch between demand and local supply is only widening.'
Regentville, Windsor and Yarramundi were also flagged as low development suburbs, although these suburbs had strict flood control or bush fire zones that limited where new housing could be built.
Regional towns within SA4 areas such as Newcastle, Wollongong, and The Central Coast also reflect strong opposition or restrictive planning policies, according to the research.
This has limited new housing growth in these areas despite them being critical to relieving housing pressures in metropolitan Sydney.
Housing Industry Association economist Tim Reardon said a 'perfect failure' in the town planning system had allowed NIMBY tendencies to flourish in certain councils.
'Town planners get no reward for approving a development and face risks if they do approve a development,' he said.
Mr Reardon added that councils were often overly concerned with how new developments would influence voter decisions at local elections, thinking approvals would turn ratepayers against them.
'The areas where there is stronger resistance to new development tend to be older suburbs. We need to strike a balance between preserving these areas and supplying new housing.
'The solution is to take development approvals out of the hands of local councils and let state governments handle it while councils focus purely on town planning.'
Mr Reardon explained that a change in homeowner attitudes would also help.
'Opposition from rate payers to higher density developments is often with the view that it will devalue the existing homes and stretch amenities but new developments often deliver the opposite.
'Well-designed developments will often bring better amenities and services and make areas more desirable.'
Real estate entrepreneur Peter Diamantidis built a house in Glenmore Park back in the early 2010s and said the current planning system was unrecognisable compared to when he built.
'Most of the area was built about 30 years ago and they staggered land releases over a few years but now it's really slow,' he said.
'There is a lot of land around there but it is not as easy to build.
'The problem with a lot of areas like this is that they are really poorly planned. A whole lot of promises were made about what kind of services would be built in the area but they often haven't done that.
'There are a few suburbs that are like Glenmore Park. They have to be better serviced before they can be developed further. Right now, the infrastructure is coming in last.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Canberra Times
2 days ago
- Canberra Times
Do you have $3 million in super? Me neither. These changes will actually help you
Do you have $3 million in super? Me neither. It is estimated that the changes will only impact a tiny fraction of the Australian population, around 80,000 people. That's fewer people than can fit in the MCG. In fact, 99.5 per cent of Australians currently do not have more than $3 million in super. According to ATO data, the average super balance is a mere $182,000 for men and $146,000 for women. Greg Jericho, chief economist at the Australia Institute, crunched the numbers and found that around 97 per cent of people currently in the labour force will never have $3 million in superannuation, no matter how hard they work for their entire lives. Even if a young person works their entire life on the full-time average wage, with no time out of the workforce for kids or illness, they will never accumulate $3 million in super. Not surprising when you consider the median super balance for women aged 60-64 is less than $160,000, meaning half of Australian women have less super than that (half of Australian men the same age have just $211,996 or less).
News.com.au
2 days ago
- News.com.au
Dan Andrews' ‘ghost' home legacy revealed as apartment towers stall
Thousands of Melbourne apartments have been abandoned or heavily delayed in a blow to the Victorian government's hopes to build its way out of a housing crisis. Families who have been waiting years for their next home are now having contracts torn up as the state's development woes worsen. Surging building costs and Daniel Andrews-era policy decisions have combined to turn huge numbers of the state's apartment pipeline into 'phantom approvals', with Victoria now ranked as one of the worst places to build units. Packer's $100m play to live longer Australian Bureau of Statistics data analysis shows one in six apartments approved for construction around the nation have still not been commenced two years later, with experts warning it is significantly worse in Victoria. By contrast more than 95 per cent of houses approved are built, as are similar numbers of townhouses. MCG Quantity Surveyors research shows that home completions in Victoria are on track to reach about 56,000 in 2025, which is 10,000 (15 per cent) below the state's peak of 66,000 in 2017. It is significantly short of the 76,000 annual home build target to meet obligations under the National Housing Accord's 1.2 million home target by 2029, and even worse when contrasted with the state government's own 80,000 homes a year goal for the next decade. MCG Quantity Surveyors director Mike Mortlock said the data showed far fewer homes were being built than officials citing approvals data were claiming. 'We need unit construction to be outperforming targets. The reality is the opposite,' Mr Mortlock said. Their figures show Melbourne's south east has a less than two month supply of new apartments, while there is just over three months' supply headed to the Mornington Peninsula, followed by the city's inner east where there is an about four-month supply of units. Mr Mortlock said there were multiple 'headwinds' to unit construction that were not as prevalent only a few years ago, a key one was that 'governments at all levels have become drunk on property taxes'. Housing Association Industry chief economist Tim Reardon said many of the multi-unit projects approved in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane and other big city markets were 'phantom approvals'. 'For apartment building to increase meaningfully, we would need to wait for established units to become so scarce that the prices would catch up with those for new units,' Mr Reardon said. 'It could take years.' He noted that a key contributor to phantom approvals issue was increased taxes on foreign investment into new housing projects, with Daniel Andrews the first premier to increase stamp duty on internationals in 2015. 'These taxes are the goose that killed the golden egg,' Mr Reardon said. 'It's one of the worst housing policy own goals. Removing the taxes would see significant increases in the homes getting built.' A number of major Victorian projects have suffered as a result of international investment taxation as well as rising building costs. Buyers who have splashed as much as $35m on homes in 2022 for what was planned to be Australia's tallest skyscraper, STHBNK By Beulah, are now in limbo after the project manager BSSPV Pty Ltd was placed in voluntary administration in February. While it has since exited administration, the site is still waiting on the outcome of an expressions of interest with developer Beulah International looking to either sell the site or establish a joint venture for its continued development. Aspects of the Malt District redevelopment of the Nylex Clock site in Cremorne also remain undeveloped, years after its developer, Caydon, collapsed. In Alphington, Glenvill's YarraBend stopped sales for a development titled the Glass House as the cost of building soared, and while most buyers took back their deposit in the years that followed the building's launch to sales in 2022, one couple finally had their contract torn up in March this year. 'We stopped sales when we found out where building prices were headed,' said Glenvill sales and marketing director Sam Tucker. Mr Tucker added that the Glass House was being redesigned and going back through council planning and would be included as part of its Boiler House complex, with apartment sizes and formats to be revised – including the removal of most one-bedroom offerings which had become far more difficult to sell with prices touching on $700,000 due to building cost increases. Glenvill have been able to continue with other developments within the wider YarraBend infill project and a separate complex with close to 200 homes is due to reach settlement in the near future. Conveyancer Andrew Curtis worked with a number of buyers affected by the project's cancellation and said he was seeing a rise in the number of people buying off-the-plan apartments only to have their contract rescinded years later. 'The vast majority of developers, you don't run into these sort of problems; and a lot of this was impacted by Covid,' Mr Curtis said. 'But the issue is becoming more common. 'And it is going to get worse. The building costs are still ridiculous and that's still causing a lot of issues for builders in the industry.' In many instances, the conveyancer said stalled or abandoned developments would likely have gone ahead if not for the Daniel Andrews-era policy increase to stamp duty for international investors. 'One of the reasons these projects are running into trouble is that they aren't selling to offshore investors,' Mr Curtis said. Charter Keck Cramer national executive director of research Richard Temlett said building costs had increased by 30-50 per cent, adding hundreds of thousands of dollars to the cost of many projects, with the state's tax regime also a major factor in development woes. 'Rather than tax at 5 per cent and nothing gets built, if they taxed at 2.5 per cent and 10 times the number of homes get built, they would at lease get some revenue,' Mr Temlett said. 'Melbourne is the weakest apartment market right now, because of the loss of overseas revenue. And that's one of the biggest missteps the government has made and we are now seeing it. 'It's all things lingering from the Andrews era.' He noted buyers looking for certainty in the apartment sector could still look for well-funded groups and those with a listing on the Australian Stock Exchange as a way to find groups more likely to be able to proceed with projects in a timely way. Australian Property Development Association president Alex Huang said Victoria had become 'probably one of the worst places that a developer can pick to launch a project'. Over the past year he said he was hearing of contracts being torn up 'more and more frequently', estimating 100s of would have been rescinded, though he was optimistic falling interest rates would help to improve the situation for the sector in the year ahead.
Herald Sun
3 days ago
- Herald Sun
Waverley Park: AFL likely to snap up historic Hawks' home
Waverley Park in Mulgrave. Melbourne's historic Waverley Park may not be lost to football, with the AFL firmly in the race to purchase the venue from Hawthorn. It would be the league's second major piece of infrastructure, following their purchase of Marvel Stadium in Docklands for more than $30m in 2016. Expressions of interest for the property closed on April 3, and a deal is expected to be finalised within a matter of days. RELATED: Ex-Tiger star Kayne Pettifer and mate set to farewell Bungalow Beer Garden Actor Shane Jacobson reveals plans after buying country Vic pub Fairfield: Developer splashes $50m on Heidelberg Rd site Industry sources have indicated the property had attracted significant interest, but the AFL was the frontrunner. They also confirmed the sales price would likely fall in the $10m to $20m range. Hawthorn purchased the ground for just $1 in 2006, with the club set to cash in big-time on any sale. Commercial real estate agency Colliers' director Ben Baines, Victorian chief executive Rob Joyes and executive Lucas Soccio, who have the listing, declined to comment. The Goodlife Gym at Waverley Park generates $600,000 in annual rental income. The offering includes the Hawks' soon-to-be former training and administrative headquarters set within the within the Sir Kenneth Luke Stand, with the club set to move to a purpose-built new Dingley Village site this year. Features of Waverley Park include a full-size MCG-specification oval on the title, a gym, 25m-long heated indoor pool, running track, medical treatment rooms and 48 basement car spaces. But the listing does not include the famous oval that hosted more than 730 AFL and VFL games, including the 1991 AFL grand final. Jack Ginnivan kicks during a Hawks training session at Waverley Park on March 18, 2025. Picture:. While the venue once had a capacity of 72,000 people, much of the stadium has since been demolished and is now surrounded by a housing estate. The AFL said only on Friday night that it was always looking for more facilities to accommodate the growth of the game. 'The AFL has targeted having 10 million attendees at AFL/AFLW games, events or festivals, two million AFL club members and one million participants and in order to achieve the target for participation we need two ovals a week every week for the next five years,' AFL spokesman Jay Allen said. 'We are always looking for ovals, either already in the system that we can continue to use for football, or new greenfield developments so we can continue to expand the space we need to accommodate the strong national growth in people playing our game.' Footballers Jason Dunstall and Dermott Brereton with the Premiership Cup from the 1991 Grand Final match between Hawthorn and West Coast at Waverley Park. Picture: Darren Tindale. Former footballer John Rombotis debuted at Waverley Park for Fitzroy in 1995, and had one of his best games in the AFL with Port Adelaide at the ground in 1997. Rombotis, now a real estate agent, said it was good to see the AFL taking an interest in the old ground – and noted that a purchase price under $20m would be just a fraction of what they were making at Marvel Stadium each year. Waverley Park also hosted the 2000 VFA/VFL premiership match, the last official game played there, and a KISS concert in the 1980s. – additional reporting by Chris Cavanagh and David Bonaddio Sign up to the Herald Sun Weekly Real Estate Update. Click here to get the latest Victorian property market news delivered direct to your inbox. MORE: Swans icon's family farewells Melbourne home after 115 years Albert Park: Essendon's Andrew McGrath's $2m+ deal Bodybuilder Sergio Taranto lists Lysterfield mansion
