Family criticises 'unforgivable' delay in finding soldier's body at Catterick Garrison

The family of a soldier found dead in his barracks three weeks after he was last seen say it is "unforgivable" his body lay undiscovered for so long.
The body of father-of-three Lance Corporal Bernard Mongan, 33, was discovered decomposing in his bedroom at Catterick Garrison on 23 January 2020.
An inquest, held at North Yorkshire Coroners' Court in Northallerton, heard L/Cpl Mongan had "obviously been dead for some time" when he was found, and had last been seen around 27 December.
Doctors were unable to determine a cause of death because of the condition of his body.
The hearing, which started on 2 June, was told of claims L/Cpl Mongan was bullied by senior officers and that the family believed he had taken his own life.
Concluding the inquest, coroner Jon Heath said he was unable to say with sufficient certainty that L/Cpl Mongan had taken his own life and recorded an open conclusion.
Speaking afterwards, L/Cpl Mongan's wife Beth criticised the army's failings.
'I know they've apologised, but it doesn't take away the fact that they've failed him in that front and forever will be unforgivable,' she said.
The inquest heard evidence from former corporal Stephen Timmerman, who lived in the same accommodation block as L/Cpl Mongan, that he was 'downgraded' by superior officers, and that 'bullying would be an understatement'.
After an Army investigation into L/Cpl Mongan's death in 2021, Mrs Mongan said her husband "felt bullied" and was "telling people he was afraid".
The inquest heard L/Cpl Mongan had attempted to kill himself several years earlier when his marriage was breaking down.
In the days before he was last seen in January 2020 he gave away his Nintendo to a friend's son, told another friend he 'had bought pills but not taken them,' and made two donations to a suicide charity.
The two most likely causes of death were self-inflicted poisoning, after barbiturates were found in L/Cpl's system – one of which was bought illegally – or a sudden abnormality of the heart.
A Home Office pathologist told the inquest he could not say which of these was most likely.
Dr Nigel Cooper said: 'I've thought about this long and hard but I just don't think I can, I don't think I have enough positive evidence to go in one direction or the other.'
"He was an amazing dad"
Speaking outside court after the verdict, Mrs Mongan said she was expecting the open conclusion 'mainly due to the army's failure of leaving [L/Cpl Mongan] for so long'.
She said: 'I've come to my own conclusions over the years, it's hard not having it for the kids.
'It's been a rollercoaster.
'He was funny, he would try to make anybody joke, anybody laugh, he had a rather weird but wicked sense of humour. He was an amazing dad.'
Emma Norton, director of the Centre for Military Justice, represented Mrs Mongan outside court.
She said it was "shocking and appalling" that L/Cpl Mongan lay dead for so long.
"That failure has had terrible consequences today because it has meant that the coroner cannot be satisfied as to the medical cause of Bernie's death," she said.
'However, his wife Beth has been in court every single day and has heard and read all of the evidence for herself, and the coroner did find today that Bernie was subjected to treatment and was spoken to in a manner by his chain of command that caused him distress.
'The other word for that in his wife's opinion is bullying."
She added: "It remains the view of his wife that Bernie died by his own hand and that he was in lots of ways very badly let down by the army.'
' We deeply regret and apologise'
The Army said it was taking action to prevent similar cases.
A spokesperson said: "We deeply regret and apologise for the shortfalls in our duty of care towards him, which were clearly unacceptable. We're grateful to HM Coroner for the thorough and diligent examination of the circumstances surrounding his death.
'Bernie's service will not be forgotten, and we owe it to his memory, to his loved ones, and to all who serve to ensure that we consistently and diligently provide the duty of care our people need and deserve.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Leader Live

13 hours ago

• Leader Live

Iran already carrying out ‘wholly unacceptable' actions in UK, Reynolds warns

Jonathan Reynolds said Iranian activity in the UK is already substantial and it would be 'naive' to think it will not escalate. The Business Secretary said 'not a week goes by' without Iran targeting cyber attacks on the UK's critical national infrastructure. Both MI5 and the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) have warned about Iran's activities. The head of MI5, Ken McCallum, said in October that authorities had stopped 20 state-backed plots hatched by Iran in the UK since 2022. He warned of an 'unprecedented pace and scale' of plots posing 'potentially lethal threats' to British citizens and UK residents. The NCSC has warned Iran 'is developing its cyber capabilities and is willing to target the UK to fulfil its disruptive and destructive objectives'. Mr Reynolds told Sky News the risk from Iran in the UK is 'not hypothetical'. He said: 'There is not a week goes by without some sort of Iranian cyber attack on a key part of the UK's critical national infrastructure. There is Iranian activity on the streets of the UK, which is wholly unacceptable. 'It's already at a significant level. I think it would be naive to say that that wouldn't potentially increase. The number of state threat investigations run by MI5 has jumped by 48% in the last year. Countries like Iran use proxies to carry out lethal plots on UK soil – we must act. Those carrying out activity for Iran in the UK must declare it or risk facing up to 5 years in prison. — Home Office (@ukhomeoffice) March 6, 2025 'But again, there's a choice here for Iran: Do they want to continue being an agent of instability in the region and the wider world? Where has that got them? Where has it got the Iranian people? 'There's a better course of action for Iran to take here, and I think they should consider that.' Iran was the first foreign power to be listed on the enhanced tier of the foreign influence registration scheme, aimed at protecting the UK from malign foreign influence. It means anyone who is directed by Iran to carry out activities in the UK must declare it or face five years in prison. The scheme is due to come into force in July. The Home Office will also introduce new laws that will allow the UK to proscribe state-based groups such as Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. In the latest sign of Iran's actions against the UK, it emerged on Saturday that authorities in Cyprus have arrested a Briton alleged to have been carrying out surveillance of the RAF Akrotiri base on the island.

Telegraph

16 hours ago

• Telegraph

Sex predator can stay because home country can't treat his mental illness

A dangerous sexual predator has been allowed to stay in the UK after claiming his home country could not treat his mental illness. An immigration tribunal backed the Bangladeshi man's claims that he should be allowed to stay in the UK despite his convictions for a violent sexual assault on a stranger when he was 17. The Metropolitan Police also provided evidence that he had carried out further sexual offences in the decade since the assault even though he had not been convicted of them. He was also convicted for conspiring to supply 'significant' quantities of heroin as part of a county lines gang. 'High risk of harm to the public' The Home Office argued that he was a sexual predator who was likely to reoffend if he remained free and presented a 'high risk of harm to the public.' A lower tier immigration tribunal, however, accepted expert evidence that he had undergone rehabilitation and could be safely managed in the community. It also agreed that he would face persecution in breach of article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) if returned to Bangladesh, which did not have the facilities to treat his mental illness, and had a reputation for treating those suffering such ill health as outcasts. It ruled the man should be given asylum. However, its decision was overruled by an upper tribunal which concluded it was mistaken in its assessment that the Bangladeshi was not still a sexual predator who posed a threat to the public. It ordered that there should be a re-hearing of the case by a new lower tier tribunal. The case, disclosed in court papers, is the latest example uncovered by The Telegraph where illegal migrants or convicted foreign criminals have been able to remain in the UK or halt their deportations. Ministers are proposing to raise the threshold to make it harder for judges to grant the right to remain based on Article 8 of the ECHR, which protects the right to a family life, and Article 3, which which protects against torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Yvette Cooper, the Home Secretary, has pledged to change the law so that any foreign national convicted of a sex offence will be barred from refugee status in the UK. The tribunals were told that the Bangladeshi had attacked the woman after he offered to walk her to a bus stop, claiming that she was drunk and needed his help. As they walked through a park, he pulled her to the ground, ripped off her bra and started to assault her. He was 17 at the time and handed an 18 month detention and training order at a secure training unit for sexual assault. The judge said the Bangladeshi man had been 'insincere' in his expressions of remorse and failed to recognise his guilt. 'Highly vulnerable' However, the lower tribunal set store on an expert witness who backed his rehabilitation and that he was at low risk of any further sexual offending. This was despite evidence that the expert had been previously heavily criticised over a similar risk assessment. The upper tribunal concluded that he 'posed a high risk of reoffending and a high risk of harm to the public having regard to the particular nature of the offence for which he has been convicted.' It said the victim, who was highly vulnerable, had suffered serious psychological harm which had led to her attempting to commit suicide. The upper tribunal ruled: 'The decision of the First-tier Tribunal involved material errors of law. We set aside the decision and do not preserve any findings of fact. The matter is remitted to the First-tier Tribunal to be reheard before a judge other than the judges who decided the [Bangladeshi's] appeal proceedings.'

Glasgow Times

16 hours ago

• Glasgow Times

Iran already carrying out ‘wholly unacceptable' actions in UK, Reynolds warns

Jonathan Reynolds said Iranian activity in the UK is already substantial and it would be 'naive' to think it will not escalate. The Business Secretary said 'not a week goes by' without Iran targeting cyber attacks on the UK's critical national infrastructure. Both MI5 and the National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) have warned about Iran's activities. The head of MI5, Ken McCallum, said in October that authorities had stopped 20 state-backed plots hatched by Iran in the UK since 2022. He warned of an 'unprecedented pace and scale' of plots posing 'potentially lethal threats' to British citizens and UK residents. The NCSC has warned Iran 'is developing its cyber capabilities and is willing to target the UK to fulfil its disruptive and destructive objectives'. Mr Reynolds told Sky News the risk from Iran in the UK is 'not hypothetical'. He said: 'There is not a week goes by without some sort of Iranian cyber attack on a key part of the UK's critical national infrastructure. There is Iranian activity on the streets of the UK, which is wholly unacceptable. 'It's already at a significant level. I think it would be naive to say that that wouldn't potentially increase. The number of state threat investigations run by MI5 has jumped by 48% in the last year. Countries like Iran use proxies to carry out lethal plots on UK soil – we must act. Those carrying out activity for Iran in the UK must declare it or risk facing up to 5 years in prison. — Home Office (@ukhomeoffice) March 6, 2025 'But again, there's a choice here for Iran: Do they want to continue being an agent of instability in the region and the wider world? Where has that got them? Where has it got the Iranian people? 'There's a better course of action for Iran to take here, and I think they should consider that.' Iran was the first foreign power to be listed on the enhanced tier of the foreign influence registration scheme, aimed at protecting the UK from malign foreign influence. It means anyone who is directed by Iran to carry out activities in the UK must declare it or face five years in prison. The scheme is due to come into force in July. The Home Office will also introduce new laws that will allow the UK to proscribe state-based groups such as Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. In the latest sign of Iran's actions against the UK, it emerged on Saturday that authorities in Cyprus have arrested a Briton alleged to have been carrying out surveillance of the RAF Akrotiri base on the island.