Sullivan County Sheriff's Office sued for wrongful death related to 2024 BRMC incident
GREENEVILLE, Tenn. (WJHL) — The widow and family members of a man who died days after an 'active shooter' incident at Bristol Regional Medical Center in May 2024 have sued the Sullivan County Sheriff's Office and multiple officers in federal court.
The 26-count suit alleges that officers mistook a mental health crisis for a drug-induced high and escalated their force against Matthew Stoddard in an initial encounter on May 21, 2024. As previously reported by News Channel 11, the married father of three from the Chattanooga area had taken his family away from their home, and they'd stopped and entered a home in Sullivan County without invitation to ask for directions.
The owners arrived and called 911, and eventually deputies arrested and handcuffed Stoddard.
Deputies took Stoddard to the Sullivan County Jail that night, and soon after transported him to BRMC. The next night, a sheriff's office report claimed, he tried to take an officer's weapon at the hospital. In the struggle that ensued and involved multiple deputies, Stoddard lost consciousness and never regained full awareness before dying at a Chattanooga medical facility on July 13.
PREVIOUS: Man involved in Bristol hospital shooting died weeks later; family seeks answers
The lawsuit claims wrongful death, outrageous conduct and intentional infliction of emotional distress, assault and battery and a host of other counts, including excessive force that violated multiple constitutional rights.
The suit points to what it says were four separate violations of Stoddard's Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights:
That deputies engaged in 'excessive tightening, tugging and jerking of Mr. Stoddard's handcuffs and ankle shackles which caused Mr. Stoddard to suffer from open wounds at the cites [sic] of his upper and lower extremities.'
That they mistreated a mentally disturbed Stoddard while he was in the back seat of a patrol car being taken to the jail, what the suit calls 'psychological torture' that also involved 'freezing out' by rolling the windows down at a high speed.
Treatment on arrival at the jail alleged to include punching, kicking, striking with fists, using shock devices and otherwise beating up Stoddard 'while he was handcuffed, held down, shackled, and in a restraint chair.'
The final alleged violation occurred at BRMC. A Sullivan County officer is alleged to have entered Stoddard's room, where two security guards were restraining him.
It claims the officer 'placed his knee on the upper back of Mr. Stoddard while attempting to secure Mr. Stoddard's arm' and that the pressure applied 'caused Mr. Stoddard to asphyxiate and die.'
According to the lawsuit, an autopsy report conducted by Emily Cook of the Jenkins Forensic Center said among the pathological diagnoses was 'complications of sudden cardiac arrest and anoxic brain injury in the setting of police restraint.'
That report, according to the lawsuit, determined Stoddard's death was caused by 'complications of sudden cardiac arrest and anoxic brain injury in the setting of police restraint, hypertensive cardiovascular disease, and morbid obesity.' The lawsuit says the autopsy found the manner of death as homicide and that it 'identified that Mr. Stoddard became unresponsive after officers were attempting to restrain him while prone.'
Attorneys for the family include local lawyers Corey Shipley and Christopher Rogers, as well as Atlanta-based Eric Hertz. They offered the following statement:
'We chose to represent the Stoddards because this is a deeply troubling situation with a tragic outcome. Allegations of misconduct by law enforcement must always be taken seriously. When someone is found legally responsible for causing harm to another, they should be held accountable — regardless of their position or status in society.
'A society is ultimately judged by how the powerful treat the vulnerable. Everyone, no matter the circumstances, is entitled to the protection of their constitutional rights. The purpose of this lawsuit is to ensure that our clients' constitutional rights are upheld and that accountability is pursued where it is due.'
The suit was just filed Wednesday. Sullivan County Attorney Dan Street said he had no comment on the suit, but added that 'Sullivan County will defend itself and its officers.'
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
9 minutes ago
- CBS News
Teen boy killed in fiery multi-vehicle crash in Pompano Beach, 5 others hospitalized, BSO says
A teenage boy is dead and five people were hospitalized after a fiery crash involving multiple vehicles in Pompano Beach on Friday night, authorities said. Just before 8 p.m., the Broward County Sheriff's Office responded to a multi-vehicle crash and car fire near 200 West Copans Rd. According to investigators, the preliminary investigation revealed that a 2019 Mercedes-Benz CLA 250, which a 16-year-old boy drove with a 17-year-old female passenger and three 17-year-old male passengers, was traveling west on West Copans Road and approaching Leisure Boulevard. Meanwhile, a 2021 Toyota Sienna, driven by an 82-year-old man, was traveling south on Leisure and approaching West Copans. BSO detectives said that at some point, the Sienna turned left when it collided with the Mercedes. The collision caused the teenage boy to lose control of his car, which rolled onto its roof as it slid southwest across the road and into eastbound traffic, colliding with a 2015 Lexus RX 350. Also, BSO said a 2021 Toyota RAV4 was traveling east on West Copans and was struck by debris as the Mercedes slid by. BSO deputies at the scene began life-saving measures until Pompano Beach Fire Rescue arrived and took all the Mercedes' occupants and the Lexus' driver to the hospital for treatment. However, the 16-year-old boy died at the scene, BSO said. BSO said the Sienna and RAV4 drivers were not injured and remained at the scene and cooperated with investigators. According to BSO, detectives said excessive speed may have been a contributing factor, but the circumstances surrounding the crash remain under investigation.
CBS News
9 minutes ago
- CBS News
The sculptures worth $2.1 million stolen from Anaheim warehouse have been found
A pair of sculptures that were taken from a warehouse in Anaheim last week have been recovered, according to authorities. The Anaheim Police Department confirmed that the sculptures, worth an estimated $2.1 million combined, were found Friday night. They were found in a trailer in a driveway after community members tipped police off to the location. Masterpiece Publishing Created by Sir Daniel Winn, the two pieces of artwork went missing sometime before June 9, police said. They each stand higher than eight feet tall and weigh thousands of pounds. Police said it's possible that forklifts were used to steal the sculptures due to their weight. As of Saturday, there's no word on any potential suspects in the alleged burglary. No arrests have been made, police said.
CBS News
9 minutes ago
- CBS News
Colorado dentist sentenced to over three years in prison for multi-million dollar tax evasion scheme
A dentist in northern Colorado was sentenced to over 3 years in prison this week for concealing millions in an illegal tax shelter. According to authorities, Ryan Ulibarri, who owned and operated Ulibarri Family Dentistry in Fort Collins, purchased an abusive-trust tax shelter in 2016. Ulibarri used the tax shelter to conceal income and create false tax deductions through trusts and a foundation that he created and controlled. The Department of Justice said Ulibarri signed trust instruments that named him as a trustee of three trusts and a foundation, and then opened bank accounts in the name of each. Authorities said he recruited friends to falsely sign the trust instruments as the creators of the trusts in order to hide the fact that he created them. Despite being warned by attorneys and CPAs that a trust in Colorado can't own a dental practice, he transferred the majority ownership of his dental practice to his business trust. Through the tax shelter, Ulibarri concealed over $5 million in income from his dental practice from the IRS and evaded paying more than $1.6 million in federal and state income taxes owed on it. Authorities said he transferred the income into the various trust and foundation accounts to make it appear the money didn't belong to him, then used those funds to pay for personal expenses, including his mortgage, credit card bills, boats, luxury vacations and professional baseball season tickets. Ulibarri also filed false tax returns for himself, his practice, the trusts and the foundation with fraudulent deductions. The DoJ said he disguised personal living expenses as trust expenses and charitable donations. On Wednesday, Ulibarri was sentenced to 41 months in prison for tax evasion. He was also ordered to serve three years of supervised release and to pay a $150,000 fine. Ulibarri must pay $1,449,121 in restitution to the IRS and $166,966 in restitution to the Colorado Department of Revenue as well.
