Founding principles of NHS betrayed by both Labour and SNP
It was fun to be back in the industrial Lanarkshire heartland where I cut my political teeth 40 years ago. It seems like only yesterday I was jousting with the local Labour MP, George (now Lord) Robertson, in the town hall at Young Socialist meetings.
On the doorsteps, then as now, the state of our National Health Service was never far from people's minds. It's not surprising, since the British Medical Association believes the health service is currently facing 'the most severe crisis in its history'.
If so, it's a crisis precipitated by widespread privatisation, chronic underfunding and NHS leaders who do not support its founding principles. Wishaw General and Hairmyres are the NHS Lanarkshire hospitals covering the Hamilton area. Both buildings are owned by commercial companies under the now-notorious Private Finance Initiative.
READ MORE: Quality and quantity of GP appointments have both declined
Their budgets, like six other PFIs in Scotland, have been drained by this arrangement because of the profit-taking inherent to its DNA the profit-taking in the DNA of such arrangements. The controversial model is neither popular nor efficient. History will record for ever more that Labour used these schemes to build six Scottish hospitals and the SNP two more.
Bluntly speaking, this means both parties betrayed the promises they made to protect the NHS's founding principle, established in 1948: that our health services would be free at point of need, publicly owned and run, and guarantee equity of access.
Two reports published last week highlighted the extent of that much-restricted access. First, Audit Scotland reported that one-fifth of all calls to the NHS 24 service last year were abandoned – in other words, 60,000 people gave up waiting for an answer in their doubtless exasperated quest for help.
Adding to that appalling statistic, BMA Scotland calculated that we are now 1800 GPs short in the ambition to return to even pre-Covid levels of primary care provision.
Reinforcing patient dissatisfaction even more, Professor Allyson Pollock, of Newcastle University, sent me her study of elective surgery performance from 1997-2021, which concludes that private medicine is not augmenting the NHS, as successive governments insisted it would.
It is in fact replacing it when it comes to hip and knee surgery, to the detriment of long-suffering patients who can't afford the exorbitant private hospital charges.
Meanwhile, a University of York study on productivity in the NHS revealed that the organisation is now performing 11% below pre-pandemic levels because of the triple whammy of privatisation, chronic underinvestment and staff shortages.
The promise First Minister John Swinney made last week of 100,000 extra GP appointments next year will therefore underwhelm most people experiencing the crisis our NHS is now facing.
The intense frustration patients across Scotland feel at 8am daily attempting to access the medical care from GP surgeries to which they are entitled will be little diminished by such paltry promises.
The provision of social care in Scotland is another demonstrable disgrace.
During the pandemic, then-first minister Nicola Sturgeon acknowledged that the situation was completely unacceptable and repeatedly promised us 'a national care service on a par with the NHS'. Little did we know she intended to diminish the care provided by both!
Today's NHS is unquestionably performing poorer than it was prior to the SNP's first Holyrood victory in 2007. That is something Nationalists must honestly face up to across Scotland.
Meanwhile, back in Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse, people awaiting the vote on June 5 recognise that Reform UK have the wind in their sails after the English local election results.
I fear we could see a sizeable increase in support for them because of the failures of the parties of the 'extreme centre' who have angered people with their insipid managerialism in office.
READ MORE: Andrew Bowie panned over 'contempt for scientific evidence' with climate comments
While I detect no great admiration for the SNP, Geoff Aberdein, the seasoned political strategist and former adviser to Alex Salmond, asked on his podcast recently: 'Where else in the western world is a party in government for almost two decades, and facing a by-election, the favourites to win?'
He has a point. But it says more perhaps about the calibre of the opposition than anything else.
Labour are under more pressure than the SNP to win this contest, yet they are haemorrhaging support under the dull leadership of Keir Starmer and Anas Sarwar.
As we have seen this week, Labour fully intend to embrace the reactionary politics of Reform UK on issues such as immigration, the economy and climate change.
Instead of offering even a mild left-of-centre alternative, they seem to believe Scotland needs more privatisation, inequality and division.
The middle-aged woman I met in Union Street, Larkhall last Saturday weighed up the Scottish Socialist Party's case presented to her, and perhaps summed up the mood in the constituency when she said: 'Right enough. It's time someone else had the chance to show what they can do.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Assisted dying puts price on my head, says disabled peer Lord Kevin Shinkwin as he speaks out against the bill
A DISABLED peer said he fears he would not be alive today if assisted dying was already legal. Lord Kevin Shinkwin said the Terminally Ill Adults Bill 'puts a price on my head' and he would have felt pressure to agree to having a lethal injection over fear of being a burden. 1 The Tory's warning comes as campaigners vow to fight the assisted dying bill in the Lords after MPs narrowly backed it by just 23 votes on Friday. Lord Shinkwin, 54, is a disability rights campaigner who has a severe form of brittle bone disease. He said: 'I am a disabled person. I cost the NHS, over the course of my lifetime, probably several million pounds to keep me alive. 'This Bill would put a price on my head — on the head of so many disabled people.' Asked if he feared he would not be alive today if the assisted dying law was in force, Lord Shinkwin said: 'I think you have hit the nail on the head. "Absolutely. I was in intensive care a few months ago, and had a doctor come over to me when I was extremely vulnerable and said, 'Have you considered assisted dying?', I would have felt under real pressure to do that.' Lord Shinkwin said he and other peers will now amend the Bill so it has greater safeguards. As it is a private member's Bill and not a government initiative, some peers are vowing to try to block it altogether. ASSISTED DYING VOTE What Happens Next? - With the Commons backing the Bill, it now moves to the House of Lords for detailed debate and scrutiny. - Peers can suggest amendments, which would send the Bill back to the Commons — a process known as 'ping pong'. - But because this is a major conscience issue, the unelected Lords are unlikely to block it outright after it passed the elected House. - Supporters hope it will win final approval and receive Royal Assent by October, officially becoming law. - A four-year implementation period will follow, allowing time to establish the new system, including expert panels and regulatory safeguards.
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Eye-watering cost of ADHD handouts in Scotland revealed – and experts warn it'll only get bigger
The next year there was a 28-times increase to almost £14million 'BALLOONING' BENEFITS Eye-watering cost of ADHD handouts in Scotland revealed – and experts warn it'll only get bigger Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) ADHD handouts are set to hit £100million just three years after the payments were introduced. Social Security Scotland handed out £500,000 in 2022, after taking over the benefits. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The cost of ADHD handouts have skyrocketed to £100million in three years Credit: Getty 2 Liz Smith said Scotland's benefits bill is "ballooning out of control" Credit: Alamy The next year there was a 28-times increase to almost £14million. This ballooned again in 2024 to £35million, while this year the figure is predicted to top £50million. And experts warn the bill for sufferers from attention deficit hyperactivity disorder will only get bigger. Scottish Tory social security spokeswoman Liz Smith said: 'Scotland's benefits bill is ballooning out of control. 'While it is essential that adult disability payments support the most vulnerable, it's also essential there is a strong focus on getting as many people as possible back into work.' Scottish Lib Dems leader Alex Cole-Hamilton added: 'The system is broken. We should be spending far more to prevent and treat mental health conditions.' In the past three years, 13,896 adults have applied for ADHD payouts, with 8,204 approved. Those on a standard rate get almost £4,000 a year, while the average claimant has received £8,000 since the system went live. Around two to four per cent of adults have the condition and new Government stats show a surge in benefit applications. Claimants do not need a formal ADHD diagnosis for approval but must have supporting information from medical specialists. New sinister threat issued in ongoing Scotland gang war It emerged this week that firms are offering a 'no-win, no fee' service to help with ADHD claims. John O'Connell, from the TaxPayers' Alliance, said: 'The surge in claims for certain conditions calls into question the whole benefits system itself, which is designed to help people in need. "Politicians must ensure only those genuinely deserving receive support.' But Bill Colley, chair of the ADHD Coalition Scotland, said: 'Awards are made not on the basis of a simple diagnosis but on the severity of symptoms and thus impairment, particularly where ADHD leads to complex mental health difficulties.' Since disability payments launched, SSC paid out £2.9 billion, with £1.2 billion going to new applicants and £1.6 billion to those transferred from the DWP. The Scottish Fiscal Commission recently warned of a cash crisis, predicting ministers will be spending £2.2billion more on benefits than they receive from the UK Government by 2030/31. This would see the total welfare bill balloon to £9.4billion, about 15 per cent of the total Scots budget. A SSS spokesperson said: 'Social security is a human right. We are committed to ensuring eligible people get the support they deserve. 'While a diagnosis is not required to apply, we do need supporting information from a professional such as a doctor or psychologist who knows how the person's condition impacts their daily life.'
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots traitor who lost eye fighting for Putin now pals with paedo US turncoat
The twisted pair enjoyed a meeting in their adopted homeland THE TRAITOR & THE PAEDO Scots traitor who lost eye fighting for Putin now pals with paedo US turncoat Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A SCOTS traitor who lost an eye fighting for Russia is now pals with a US fugitive wanted on paedo photos charges, we can reveal. Ross McElvenny, 26 — pictured for the first time with a patch — shook hands with disgraced American Air Force defector Wilmer Puello-Mota, 28. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Disgraced American Air Force defector Wilmer Puello-Mota Credit: AP 2 Ross McElvenny lost an eye fighting for Vladimir Putin in Ukraine The twisted pair, who signed up for Vladimir Putin's army after its bloody invasion of Ukraine, enjoyed a meeting in their adopted homeland. Next to the sickening social media snap, McElvenny gushed: 'I finally managed to meet Will Puello.' The half-blinded mercenary, from Newton Mearns, near Glasgow, is now a Russian citizen. And he has been travelling the country since leaving hospital after getting surgery on his left eye. Selfies he posted show him in the capital Moscow and also visiting Mamayev Kurgan, a huge memorial commemorating the savage Second World War Battle of Stalingrad, now called Volgograd. McElvenny, who also sustained serious shrapnel injuries after being shelled by Ukrainian forces, had previously shrugged off his plight, saying: 'St happens in conflict.' And the Kremlin squaddie, whose call sign is 'Whisky', insisted he had 'zero regrets'. The Rangers fan added: 'I came here to do what I could to support Russia. I love this country.' We told how McElvenny was hurt in a blast before being fitted with a 'fake eyeball inside what remained of my left eye'. He first hit the headlines last November after it emerged he had been injured while serving in the Donetsk region of Ukraine. Scottish brewer fighting as mercenary for Putin in Russia Previously, he had studied IT at a college in Glasgow after attending Falkland House, a residential school for boys in Fife. We revealed he once had a work experience stint as a schoolboy with the Scottish Government at offices in Atlantic Quay, Glasgow. It was in a placement tailored for pupils with additional support needs. McElvenny told The Scottish Sun on Sunday: 'It was a s**y programme by a school I should have never been in the first place — so they could get some publicity.' He travelled to Russia on a tourist visa last August, then volunteered for Putin's 1099th Motorised Rifle Regiment. The renegade Scot is being probed by cops here and faces prosecution if he returns. We told in December how McElvenny had boasted of becoming 'a citizen of the Russian Federation' after a short ceremony. He called it: 'One of the happiest moments of my life.' His new chum Puello-Mota was in the US Air Force and Massachusetts International Guard before fleeing the sex rap and landing in Russia. The ex-city councillor in Holyoke, Massachusetts, was arrested in nearby Rhode Island in 2020 after cops found explicit images of an underage girl on his phone. He reportedly told officers he thought she was 22, and only later learned she was 17. Puello-Mota was later charged with forgery, counterfeiting and obstructing justice after claiming the seedy snaps were fake. He vanished in January last year, just two days before he was scheduled to answer the charges in a Rhode Island court. US authorities said he boarded a Turkish Airlines flight to Istanbul before disappearing. It is understood the fugitive, who used the call-sign 'Boston', has been fighting as a volunteer mercenary alongside Russian troops in the war with Ukraine. In April last year, footage from propaganda channels showed him signing a military contract. They have spun Puello-Mota's defection as a coup for the Moscow regime.
