SIS Forum appeal not concerned with substantive beliefs, doctrine of Islamic faith, says Federal Court
Published on: Saturday, June 21, 2025
Published on: Sat, Jun 21, 2025
By: Bernama Text Size: PUTRAJAYA: The appeal by Sisters in Islam (SIS) Forum (Malaysia) does not concern the substantive beliefs in the religion of Islam, its mandates or doctrines relating to the Islamic faith but relates to the exercise of legal powers by certain state authorities, says the Federal Court in its judgment. Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat said the challenge only concerned the review of the Selangor State Fatwa Committee, the Selangor Islamic Religious Council (MAIS) and the Selangor government's exercise of certain powers under the law, which is distinct from the substance and contents of their decisions. 'While it concerns a certain fatwa (religious edict), the case has neither to do with the substantive beliefs held in the religion of Islam nor does it have anything to do with the administration of the substantive aspects of the religion of Islam,' she said in the 40-page majority judgment. The top judge said in all civilised democracies with independent judiciaries, it is routine for the executive's decisions to be subjected to judicial review and in most cases, the subject matter of the exercise of discretion in the plaint is not the main issue rather the manner in which the decision was made. On Thursday, the Federal Court bench, in a 3-1 majority ruling, held that the 2014 fatwa issued by the Selangor State Fatwa Committee and gazetted by the Selangor state government is valid, but only insofar as it applies to individuals, not companies. The court ruled that a fatwa cannot be imposed on an organisation like SIS Forum as it is not capable of professing a religion.
Advertisement The ruling partially allowed the appeal by SIS Forum and its co-founder Zainah Mahfoozah Anwar to quash the 2014 fatwa, which had declared the group as deviating from Islamic teachings. In the written judgment released on the judiciary's website, Justice Tengku Maimun explained that the Selangor state government and the religious bodies are part of the executive branch and are empowered by the Federal Constitution and laws passed by the Selangor State Legislative Assembly (SLA). 'The fact that they deal with matters pertaining to Islamic faith, dogma and doctrine – are beside the point and these matters are, in any event, not within our purview (of the Civil Court),' she said. Justice Tengku Maimun said that under Article 121 (1A) of the Federal Constitution, the Shariah Courts have exclusive jurisdiction over matters within their scope. However, if the Shariah Courts act beyond their jurisdiction, they remain subject to judicial review by the Superior Courts. She reiterated that SIS Forum's legal challenge did not question the contents of the fatwa but the way it affected them. This, she said, involved constitutional importance and administrative law, which is for the Superior Courts to determine. The Chief Justice also reminded all judges that judgments of the Federal Court, unless overruled by a later decision of the same court, are binding and failure to abide by them is an affront to the administration of the justice system. In the judgment, Tengku Maimun also said a fatwa, once gazetted, carries the force of law and is not mere suggestion, and it is binding on all Muslims in the state and the Shariah Courts. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available.
Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Trump says US ‘obliterated' Iran nuclear sites, threatens more
WASHINGTON: President Donald Trump said US air strikes on Sunday had 'completely and totally obliterated' Iran's main nuclear enrichment facilities, and warned of more attacks to come if Tehran does not seek peace. In a televised address to the nation from the White House after the United States joined Israel's air campaign against Tehran, Trump called the US attacks a 'spectacular military success.' Trump had earlier stunned the world by announcing on social media that US aircraft had struck Iran's Fordo nuclear enrichment plant, plus the Natanz and Isfahan facilities. But the fresh US military entanglement comes despite Trump's promises to avoid another 'forever war' in the Middle East -- Iran has vowed to retaliate against US forces in the region if Washington got involved. 'Iran's key nuclear enrichment facilities have been completely and totally obliterated. Iran the bully of the Middle East must now make peace,' said Trump. 'If they do not, future attacks will be far greater, and a lot easier,' added Trump, who was flanked by Vice President JD Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Secretary of State Marco Rubio for his address on Saturday evening for US audiences. Trump said earlier on his Truth Social site that a 'full payload of BOMBS' was dropped on the underground facility at Fordo, describing it as the 'primary site.' Trump added that 'all planes are safely on their way home. Congratulations to our great American Warriors.' 'Heads up' Earlier Saturday there were reports that US B-2 bombers -- which carry so-called 'bunker buster' bombs -- were headed out of the United States across the Pacific. Trump did not say what kind of US planes or munitions were involved. Iranian media confirmed that part of the Fordo plant as well as the Isfahan and Natanz nuclear sites were attacked. Trump spoke to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu after the attacks, while the United States also gave key ally Israel a 'heads up' before the strikes, a senior White House official told AFP. Netanyahu congratulated Trump on the strikes, saying that 'America has been truly unsurpassed.' Trump had said on Thursday that he would decide 'within two weeks' whether to join Israel's campaign -- but the decision came far sooner. The US president had also stepped up his rhetoric against Iran in recent days, repeating his insistence that it could never have a nuclear weapon. Israel and Iran have traded wave after wave of devastating strikes since Israel launched its aerial campaign on June 13, saying Tehran was on the verge of developing a nuclear weapon. Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian had warned earlier Saturday of a 'more devastating' retaliation should Israel's nine-day bombing campaign continue, saying the Islamic republic would not halt its nuclear program 'under any circumstances.' On Saturday, Israel said it had attacked Isfahan for a second time, with the UN nuclear watchdog reporting that a centrifuge manufacturing workshop had been hit. Iran's Revolutionary Guard meanwhile announced early Sunday that 'suicide drones' had been launched against 'strategic targets' across Israel. Iran denies seeking an atomic bomb, and on Saturday Pezeshkian said its right to pursue a civilian nuclear program 'cannot be taken away... by threats or war.' Huthi threat Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi was in Istanbul on Saturday for a meeting of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation to discuss the conflict. Top diplomats from Britain, France and Germany had met Araghchi in Geneva on Friday and urged him to resume nuclear talks with the United States that had been derailed by the war. Iran's Huthi allies in Yemen on Saturday threatened to resume their attacks on US vessels in the Red Sea if Washington joined the war, despite a recent ceasefire agreement. The US-based Human Rights Activists News Agency said Friday that, based on its sources and media reports, at least 657 people had been killed in Iran, including 263 civilians. Iran's health ministry on Saturday gave a toll of more than 400 people killed in the Israeli strikes. Iran's retaliatory strikes have killed at least 25 people in Israel, according to official figures. Leading US Democrat Hakeem Jeffries said Trump risked US 'entanglement in a potentially disastrous war in the Middle East,' while the Israeli army raised its alert level, permitting only essential activities until further notice.
Malaysiakini
2 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Ramasamy urges opposition unity to liberate judiciary, backs PN's push
Urimai chairperson P Ramasamy has urged the opposition to unite and spearhead meaningful reforms to free and democratise the nation's judiciary. He also threw his support behind Perikatan Nasional chief whip Takiyuddin Hassan's call to amend Article 121 of the Federal Constitution, aimed at restoring the crucial separation of powers between the judiciary, legislature, and executive. 'Institutional reforms such as...
Borneo Post
2 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Trump says US 'obliterated' Iran nuclear sites, threatens more
Trump addresses the nation, alongside Vance (left), Rubio (second right) an Hegseth from the White House in Washington, DC on June 21, 2025, following the announcement that the US bombed nuclear sites in Iran. – AFP photo WASHINGTON (June 22): President Donald Trump said US air strikes on Sunday had 'completely and totally obliterated' Iran's main nuclear enrichment facilities, and warned of more attacks to come if Tehran does not seek peace. In a televised address to the nation from the White House after the United States joined Israel's air campaign against Tehran, Trump called the US attacks a 'spectacular military success.' Trump had earlier stunned the world by announcing on social media that US aircraft had struck Iran's Fordo nuclear enrichment plant, plus the Natanz and Isfahan facilities. But the fresh US military entanglement comes despite Trump's promises to avoid another 'forever war' in the Middle East — Iran has vowed to retaliate against US forces in the region if Washington got involved. 'Iran's key nuclear enrichment facilities have been completely and totally obliterated. Iran the bully of the Middle East must now make peace,' said Trump. 'If they do not, future attacks will be far greater, and a lot easier,' added Trump, who was flanked by Vice President JD Vance, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Secretary of State Marco Rubio for his address on Saturday evening for US audiences. Trump said earlier on his Truth Social site that a 'full payload of BOMBS' was dropped on the underground facility at Fordo, describing it as the 'primary site.' Trump added that 'all planes are safely on their way home. Congratulations to our great American Warriors.' – 'Heads up' – Earlier Saturday there were reports that US B-2 bombers — which carry so-called 'bunker buster' bombs — were headed out of the United States across the Pacific. Trump did not say what kind of US planes or munitions were involved. Iranian media confirmed that part of the Fordo plant as well as the Isfahan and Natanz nuclear sites were attacked. Trump spoke to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu after the attacks, while the United States also gave key ally Israel a 'heads up' before the strikes, a senior White House official told AFP. Netanyahu congratulated Trump on the strikes, saying that 'America has been truly unsurpassed.' Trump had said on Thursday that he would decide 'within two weeks' whether to join Israel's campaign — but the decision came far sooner. The US president had also stepped up his rhetoric against Iran in recent days, repeating his insistence that it could never have a nuclear weapon. Israel and Iran have traded wave after wave of devastating strikes since Israel launched its aerial campaign on June 13, saying Tehran was on the verge of developing a nuclear weapon. Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian had warned earlier Saturday of a 'more devastating' retaliation should Israel's nine-day bombing campaign continue, saying the Islamic republic would not halt its nuclear program 'under any circumstances.' On Saturday, Israel said it had attacked Isfahan for a second time, with the UN nuclear watchdog reporting that a centrifuge manufacturing workshop had been hit. Iran's Revolutionary Guard meanwhile announced early Sunday that 'suicide drones' had been launched against 'strategic targets' across Israel. Iran denies seeking an atomic bomb, and on Saturday Pezeshkian said its right to pursue a civilian nuclear program 'cannot be taken away… by threats or war.' – Huthi threat – Iranian Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi was in Istanbul on Saturday for a meeting of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation to discuss the conflict. Top diplomats from Britain, France and Germany had met Araghchi in Geneva on Friday and urged him to resume nuclear talks with the United States that had been derailed by the war. Iran's Huthi allies in Yemen on Saturday threatened to resume their attacks on US vessels in the Red Sea if Washington joined the war, despite a recent ceasefire agreement. The US-based Human Rights Activists News Agency said Friday that, based on its sources and media reports, at least 657 people had been killed in Iran, including 263 civilians. Iran's health ministry on Saturday gave a toll of more than 400 people killed in the Israeli strikes. Iran's retaliatory strikes have killed at least 25 people in Israel, according to official figures. Leading US Democrat Hakeem Jeffries said Trump risked US 'entanglement in a potentially disastrous war in the Middle East,' while the Israeli army raised its alert level, permitting only essential activities until further notice. donald trump Iran nuclear. facilities US air strikes
