Saints QB depth chart: How it looks for Derek Carr after New Orleans drafts Tyler Shough
Saints QB depth chart: How it looks for Derek Carr after New Orleans drafts Tyler Shough
Show Caption
Hide Caption
Best NFC 2025 NFL Draft picks
USA TODAY's Tyler Dragon breaks down which teams in the NFC drafted the best this year.
Sports Seriously
The New Orleans Saints, these days, seem to operate on a hope and a prayer.
With no clear path to contention and a salary cap situation that never seems to get better, the Saints are clinging to average rosters with the idea that they'll be anything but when the games kick off. That's a fine idea in the movies, but New Orleans is living the real-life consequences of holding on.
That becomes increasingly clear in the quarterback room.
The Super Bowl win at the end of the 2009 season feels like a distant memory, just like the glory days of the late 2010s. Drew Brees and Michael Thomas aren't walking through that door anytime soon, leaving the Saints as a team stuck in the middle.
They signed Derek Carr to lead the team in the post-Brees years, only to see a diminishing return on their investment.
Now for the first time since 2005, the Saints are operating with a coaching staff that doesn't have Sean Payton's direct influence. Fresh off drafting a quarterback, perhaps New Orleans is readying for a change of direction.
As the quarterback depth chart shows, it's much closer than it seems.
Saints QB depth chart
A shoulder injury for Carr could pave the way for his eventual departure from the bayou. NFL Network's Ian Rapoport previously reported that the injury "has put his availability for 2025 in doubt," and the quarterback was considering surgery to deal with the issue.
Until something happens, however, the 11-year veteran Carr is the engine that powers the Saints offense.
If New Orleans decides to break its four-year lease or Carr opts for surgery, they have a rookie quarterback waiting in the wings.
The Saints drafted Shough in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft, meaning it's only a matter of time before he gets the chance to start. Shough is a seasoned rookie who will turn 26 at the end of September and comes with a whopping seven years of college experience, having made stops at Oregon, Texas Tech and Louisville.
New Orleans won't benefit much from letting him waste away on the bench given his age. That would allow Moore the opportunity to put his stamp on the team.
The remaining duo of Rattler and Haener are also holdovers from the previous Saints' regime. Neither of them figures to be in a position to start, and one of them will almost certainly be off the roster if Carr is able to play.
Rattler is in the better position of the two, but still posted an 0-6 record in his starts while tossing four touchdowns to five interceptions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Bad news for Saints, All-Australian Dog sidelined
St Kilda's Max King has needed more knee surgery, confirming he won't play any AFL this season. The key forward's inability to recover from his pre-season injury has been a disaster for the Saints, who are in the bottom four after Saturday night's fighting loss to Collingwood. Also on Monday, Saints young gun Mattaes Phillipou reportedly is out for several weeks. He was distraught after aggravating a lower-leg injury only minutes before of the start of the Collingwood game and was a late withdrawal. And the Western Bulldogs have lost All-Australian Adam Treloar for six weeks with another calf muscle injury. Treloar was hurt in the first half of Sunday's win over Richmond and coach Luke Beveridge said there was "significant concern" about the midfielder's latest setback. King has not played since round 17 last year, but the Saints had been hopeful he would return before the end of this season. He has already needed two operations on his right knee because of the initial injury during a February practice match. The Saints re-signed King to a six-year deal last season, taking him to 2032. In a statement, the club said Monday's surgery was on damage to the medial aspect of the knee, which had caused "occasional but persistent" pain. The Saints are also adamant they have been baffled by King's ongoing problems. "Max's case has not been simple nor linear, and we've attempted to adequately keep our members and fans up to date while maintaining Max's privacy," said Saints football boss Dave Misson. "We have also been dealing with a medical situation that has often confounded the many medical experts we have consulted. "About 10 days ago, as Max was closing in on a return to football, he felt a clunking in his knee - the same knee that has been causing him trouble throughout this season. "This was as surprising as it was frustrating, as all indications were that Max's most recent arthroscope had addressed this issue." That meant more consultations and scans, leading to Monday's surgery. "We feel the cause of Max's issue has been pinpointed and that damage to the medial aspect of his knee, in certain situations, was impeding his movement and causing pain," Misson said. "The operation aimed to address and repair this issue. It will see Max off-legs for several months, however, will allow him to be ready for the commencement of pre-season." Meanwhile, the AFL website reported Phillipou would be out for several weeks after his plantaris tendon injury flared again before Saturday night's match. Phillipou was a late scratching when he felt sharp pain in his calf while warming up. Injuries have restricted him to only four games this season. Treloar has only played four games in 2025 after last year's All-Australian honours. The Bulldogs confirmed he has a moderate-grade calf strain and ruled him out for six weeks.
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Ryan Clark says Steelers' AFC North rival will win Super Bowl if they stay healthy
If the Ravens stay healthy in the most important positions they should win the whole dang thing! Once a Steeler, always a Steeler — but that mindset hasn't stopped Pittsburgh's former safety Ryan Clark from acknowledging how stacked the Ravens' roster has become. Last Wednesday, mere hours after the Ravens signed two-time All-Pro CB Jaire Alexander to a one-year deal, Clark took to social media to give everyone his Baltimore-related Super Bowl prediction — much to the dismay of his beloved Steelers: "If the Ravens stay healthy in the most important positions, they should win the whole dang thing!" The Ravens' signing of Alexander was the cherry on top of what has been a productive offseason — including the addition of five-time All-Pro WR DeAndre Hopkins and their overall excellent 2025 NFL Draft haul. While Clark will always show his Steelers love, he has been critical of Pittsburgh's acquisition of four-time MVP Aaron Rodgers and is clearly buying into the Ravens' hype this season. For up-to-date Steelers coverage, follow us on X @TheSteelersWire and give our Facebook page a like.
USA Today
2 hours ago
- USA Today
Steelers updated 2026 Super Bowl odds
Parity in the NFL isn't what it used to be. There are some very distinct tiers of teams in the league, and if you aren't in that top tier, it's tough sledding to even make a splash in the playoffs. This is the position the Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves in heading into the 2025 season. Getting into the playoffs is never out of the realm of possibility for the Steelers but it's been a long time since anyone looked at this team as a Super Bowl contender. The Steelers big move of this offseason has been the addition of quarterback Aaro Rodgers. We can debate as to whether or not Rodgers is an upgrade over Russell Wilson but there's no doubt Rodgers is an upgrade over Mason Rudolph. Now that Rodgers and the Packers have signed, let's take a look at the Steelers' Super Bowl odds from around the internet. DraftKings - +4000Fanduel - +4600BetMGM - +4500Bet365 - +4000Caesars - +4000ESPN Bet - +4000Hard Rock - +4000BetRivers - +4500
