Bishop and Colman's mustard heir's wife face discipline on safeguarding failings

Retired former Bishop of Durham Paul Butler is among those who could be banned from ministry as a result of investigations following the Makin review – but former archbishop of Canterbury George Carey will not face any action.
The report, published last year, concluded that abuse carried out for decades by Christian camp leader John Smyth was known about and not acted upon by various people within the Church.
While the review led to the eventual resignation of Mr Welby as the most recent Archbishop of Canterbury, the Church's national safeguarding team (NST) undertook to look at all clergy criticised within the report.
In an update on Thursday, the Church said Bishop Paul and six others are to face disciplinary proceedings under the Clergy Discipline Measure (CDM).
CDM outcomes can range from a conditional discharge where no penalty is imposed, to removal from office, resignation by consent and a lifetime ban from ministry.
While a new process, replacing the CDM, was approved by the Church's parliament earlier this month to include defrocking, it is not thought this will be in place in time for these cases.
Lord Carey, who was named in the Makin report, had been one of 10 clergy revealed in February as facing possible action.
But the NST has confirmed 89-year-old Lord Carey, Reverend Paul Perkin and Reverend Hugh Palmer will face no further action.
As there is a 12-month time limit on cases being brought, the NST had to ask for permission of the President of the Tribunals to bring a CDM 'out of time'.
Permission was granted in only seven of the 10 cases and the NST said it 'entirely respects' the decision from the 'independent judicial process'.
Others named as facing CDMs include Reverend Sue Colman – the wife of the Colman's mustard heir Sir Jamie Colman.
The Makin report concluded Mrs Colman, associate minister at St Leonard's Church in Oakley, near Basingstoke in Hampshire, was aware of Smyth's abuse before being ordained and noted that she and her husband visited Smyth in Africa in the 1990s and funded the Smyths through a personal trust.
Around a week after the Makin report was published, the Diocese of Winchester said Mrs Colman had been asked to 'step back from all ministerial duties'.
The rest facing possible disciplinary action are Reverend Roger Combes, Reverend Andrew Cornes, Reverend Tim Hastie-Smith, Reverend Nick Stott and Reverend John Woolmer.
The NST said it will make no further comment on the cases while CDM proceedings are under way and no timeline has been given for when they might conclude.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

The Sun

8 hours ago

• The Sun

At least one injured after gunman ‘drove truck into church and opened fire' before being killed by heroic security guard

AT least one person has been injured after a gunman reportedly drove a truck into a church and opened fire. A heroic security guard at the church in Wayne, Michigan, took quick action and shot the suspect, police have said. 5 5 Cops confirmed the suspected gunman was dead by the time they arrived on scene. Deputy Chief Finley Carter III told The U.S. Sun that the suspect is a 31-year-old male. The shooting is reported to have taken place around 11:15 am local time at Crosspointe Community Church. A Sunday service began there just minutes before at 10:45 am. According to a police source, the male gunman drove his truck into the church and opened fire, per ABC News affiliate WXYZ. Multiple people have been injured, but the severity of these injuries is not yet known, the sources told the outlet. Cops confirmed that one person was shot in the leg but gave no further details. Locals have been told to avoid the area as the investigation continues. "The Wayne Police Department responded to an active shooter at Crosspointe Church in Wayne this morning," the City of Wayne, Michigan Police Department wrote on Facebook. "Upon arrival, officers determined that a security guard for the church shot and killed the suspect. "One victim was shot in the leg. Please avoid the area. "Officers are still actively investigating." 'SAVED THE DAY' In response to the statement, locals praised the heroic security guard who took out the active shooter, claiming they heard "at least 100 rounds of gunfire". "That security guard saved the day," local Ethan Wagemann wrote in the comments. "I heard it all sounded like it was right outside. Sounded like at least 100 rounds of machine gun fire. "After I heard what sounded maybe 3 handgun shots there was no more machine gun fire." "Prayers to the Security Guard. He should get a Key to the City for his bravery and for possibly saving countless other lives," another said. A third added that the police response "was phenomenal". Westland City Councilwoman Melissa Sampey thanked officers assisting in the investigation and urged people to "pray for all involved". The U.S. Sun has reached out to the Wayne Police Department for updates. Deputy Chief Carter confirmed that multiple agencies are on scene. 5 5 .

Daily Mail​

9 hours ago

• Daily Mail​

BREAKING NEWS Active shooter drives truck into church and opens fire on congregation in Michigan

An active shooter was killed after driving their car into a church and opening fire on a congregation in Michigan on Saturday. The shooter was shot and killed by a security guard for the Crosspointe Church in Wayne, the Michigan Police Department confirmed. At least one other victim was shot and injured in the leg. Officers are actively investigating the scene and have urged residents to stay away from the area. This is a breaking news story.

Spectator

20 hours ago

• Spectator

Why conservatives should embrace their Christian heritage

The heydays of Christian influence over European politics may seem long gone. In the UK, after the most recent general election, four-tenths of all MPs took secular affirmations – up from less than a quarter in 2019 – while in Europe, parties with explicitly Christian foundations often seem embarrassed about their religious heritage as they tumble down the polls. Yet Christians have not stopped turning up for those parties. To play to its strengths and resolve its identity crisis, the centre-right should embrace its Christian inheritance. By returning to this Christian inheritance, the centre-right can offer a vision that is compelling to all and re-establish its dominance Even as the centre-right shies away from invoking its Christian credentials, it continues to rally Christian voters around its banner. In the UK, according to the most recent wave of the British Election Study, Christian voters were 33 per cent more likely to vote Conservative, compared to only 15 per cent of non-Christians. In Germany, too, churchgoing Christians are more than twice as likely to vote for the CDU/CSU Union than the non-religious. Even in the notoriously secular France, Catholics disproportionately turn up for the centre-right, with 19 per cent of Catholics – and 29 per cent of regular churchgoers – voting for the centre-right UDC at the 2022 legislative election, where the UDC received only 14 per cent of the overall vote. This reflects a long-standing trend. A recent report by Bright Blue and the Konrad Adenauer Foundation argued that religiosity has been a core component of European centre-right's history as they dominated European politics over the course of the twentieth century. Since 1949, the CDU held the chancellorship for 49 years – 26 more than its main rival, the SPD – during which time its policy platform was largely dictated by Catholic social thought, emphasising the value of family and the importance of social cohesion. In Ireland, up until recent years, both Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael upheld a staunchly Catholic outlook on social policy as they maintained a stranglehold over Irish politics; their Catholicism waned only as their combined vote share began to tumble, but this abandonment of their roots has proven a poor recipe for electoral success. Even in the UK, where Christianity was not as explicit a part of Conservative Party philosophy, the Church of England is not described as 'the Conservative Party at prayer' without reason. This is not merely because Christians vote right-wing. A 2023 paper titled From the Death of God to the Rise of Hitler found that a key predictor for whether you joined the Nazi Party or not was whether you had a Christian first name. If your name was common on churches – think St George or St Martin in England – you were far less likely to do so. The values of the centre-right deeply reflect their Christian heritage, while far-right politics instead often offers a secularised version of religion; one where politics, rather than God, is the source of meaning, and the party takes on the role of the church. For the centre-right to succeed in the future, it should play to its strengths and embrace its Christian inheritance. First, by doing so, it would be playing into a renewed uptick in church attendance and religiosity. Between 2018 and 2024, church attendance in the UK has increased by 50 per cent, including by 300 per cent among the 18-to-24s. In France, as of 2025, the annual number of baptisms is the highest since records began 20 years ago. But second, and more importantly, the values that have allowed the centre-right to be successful are the values it inherits from Christianity: love of country, caring for your family and rewarding contribution. The late Pope Saint John Paul II, in Memory and Identity – the very last book he published before his death – wrote that 'patriotism … is covered by the fourth commandment, which obliges us to honour our father and mother…the patria truly resembles a mother…Patriotism, in other words, leads to a properly ordered social love.' The centre-right alone can provide a vision of country that represents a love of your closest neighbour rather than shutting off from the world, as some right-wing populists would prefer. On rewarding contribution, too, it is largely thanks to its Christian heritage that the centre-right believes that people should take responsibility for their actions – that we have free will and are accountable for our actions and should be rewarded or punished accordingly. Here, it has clashed with those on the left who see hard work or good character as the mere consequences of socio-economic factors and nothing that anybody deserves praise or blame for. Those beliefs – in country, family and contribution – are persuasive to all Europeans, not just Christians. By returning to this Christian inheritance, the centre-right can offer a vision that is compelling to all and re-establish its former dominance.