Gun dealer to judge: Don't punish me for keeping shank in violent MDC Brooklyn jail
A gun trafficker says he shouldn't get a longer sentence after being caught with a makeshift weapon in his cell at MDC Brooklyn – because the federal lockup is so violent he needs it for protection.
Federal prosecutors want Raymond Minaya, 29, to spend more than 15 years behind bars for his role in a gun-dealing ring — six years more than the ring's leader received — in part because of the sharpened metal rod and cell phones found stashed in his jail cell last year.
Minaya's lawyers essentially called the contraband a necessary reality in MDC Brooklyn, pointing out that guards found the weapon last November, just a few months after a string of violent attacks and two murders at the troubled Sunset Park lockup.
'Possessing an object to protect himself against the well-documented dangers of the MDC cannot fairly be said to be evidence that Mr. Minaya has not accepted responsibility for his conduct or withdrawn from criminal activity,' wrote Jeffrey Dahlberg and Mia Eisner-Grynberg of the Federal Defenders on Wednesday.
'Mr. Minaya did not use or threaten to use the object, nor was he ever seen brandishing it; it was merely inside his cell, arguably as a deterrent to others or as emergency protection given the recent violent incidents there.'
And the cell phones, they argue, can be the only way to reach family members due to the frequent lockdowns at the jail.
Several federal judges — including Brooklyn Federal Court Judge William Kuntz, who's scheduled to sentence Minaya on Tuesday — have railed against the notorious conditions at MDC Brooklyn and have shaved months or years off some defendants' sentences to account for the conditions inside. The jail currently houses Sean 'Diddy' Combs and alleged CEO-killer Luigi Mangione.
Prosecutors have a different perspective on Minaya's motives: the Gorilla Stone Bloods member has a long history of violence and rule-breaking behind bars when he served time in state prison, including three separate assaults on inmates, they argue.
'The government expects that the defendant, like many other MDC inmates, will use those conditions as a reason for this court to impose a lesser sentence,' prosecutors wrote in a letter to Brooklyn Federal Court William Kuntz. 'But he cannot simultaneously contribute to the dangerous conditions at the MDC and then claim them as a reason he should be granted leniency.'
Photos on his contraband phone show bags of pot and him smoking on a video call with other inmates, prosecutors note.
'Additional images appear possibly related to a contraband smuggling scheme, including images of pellets, money transfers, and dried leafy substances,' federal prosecutors wrote in a Tuesday filing.
Minaya and three other men were busted in 2023 on charges they sold more than 50 firearms to an undercover cop in Brooklyn, making the sales in a crowded waterfront park and on a playground.
Minaya sold 12 of those guns personally, including one weapon used in a 2021 shooting at a Bedford-Stuyvesant family day celebration that left eight people wounded.
All four suspects took plea deals last year. The ringleader, David McCann, was sentenced to nine years, while accomplice Tajhai Jones got just over eight years. The remaining defendant, Calvin Tabron, awaits sentencing.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
New York's Prisons Were in Crisis. Did Hochul Do Enough to Fix Them?
In response to crises inside New York State's prisons, Gov. Kathy Hochul said this winter that swift action in Albany would hold corrections officers accountable and keep inmates safer. In the legislative session that ended Wednesday, the governor directed $400 million to increase camera coverage in prisons. She replaced the head of the prison where an inmate had been savagely beaten to death and ordered reviews of 'safety gaps' in several lockups and assessments of their operating cultures. But she has not committed to signing a package of bills meant to increase prison oversight that originated with reform-minded lawmakers. Criminal justice advocates and some legislators were also left disappointed that she has not championed measures that would increase the chances for inmates to gain early release and make it easier to discipline officers. They accuse Ms. Hochul of prioritizing expedient and incremental policies to court moderate voters as she gears up for re-election next year. 'As public servants, we have to lead with a great deal of courage and moral clarity,' Emily Gallagher, a Democratic assemblywoman who represents parts of North Brooklyn, said of the governor. 'There is a tension between good policy that protects all residents of New York State,' added Ms. Gallagher, who has been endorsed by the Democratic Socialists of America and supported the prison bills. 'And the fear of this right-wing political moment that we're in.' Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Police say a man opened fire outside a church before staff fatally shot him, averting mass shooting
A man who opened fire outside a Michigan church filled with worshippers on Sunday was struck by a vehicle and then fatally shot by security staff who averted a potential mass shooting, police said.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Former Ohio State football star Kirk Barton facing charge in deadly car crash
An image collage containing 2 images, Image 1 shows Ohio State football player Kirk Barton wearing jersey #74, Image 2 shows Mugshot of Kirk Barton An ex-Ohio State lineman was charged with aggravated vehicular homicide following a fatal car crash on Saturday. Kirk Barton was driving a Ford F150 Raptor at what local authorities deemed as a 'high rate of speed' when it struck a Lexus in Dublin, Ohio, at roughly 2:56 a.m. ET, according to a press release from the city. Advertisement Ethan Wence Perry, 24, was the driver of the Lexus and died at the scene, per the city. Police stated that Barton apparently had 'glassy, bloodshot eyes and a blank stare,' per Fox 28 Columbus. Kirk Barton pictured in a mugshot on June 21, 2025. Delaware County Sheriffs Office Barton, who 'sustained non-life-threatening injuries,' was released from Riverside Methodist Hospital and was taken into Dublin Police Department custody before being transported to Franklin County Jail. According to court documents viewed by The Post, local authorities plan to charge Barton with one count of aggravated vehicular homicide. Records indicate that Barton is expected to appear in court on Monday. Offensive tackle Kirk Barton of Ohio State prepares prior to action between the Ohio State Buckeyes and Illinois Fighting Illini at Memorial Stadium in Champaign, Illinois on November 4, 2006. WireImage Barton was previously charged with felony assault of a deputy in 2018. Advertisement Court records also show that Barton has had a history of traffic offenses, per The Columbus Dispatch. The 40-year-old worked for Buckeye Scoop, a media outlet covering Ohio State athletics, which released a statement on X on Saturday. Kirk Barton of the Chicago Bears poses for his 2008 NFL headshot at photo day in Chicago, Illinois. Getty Images 'We just learned of the devastating news regarding Kirk's involvement in a fatal incident,' the statement read. 'We are heartbroken for the victim and their loved ones. This is a tragedy. At this time, we are gathering information and will have more to say when appropriate.' Barton started at right tackle for Ohio State from 2003-07, and was team captain during his senior season, when he earned first-team All-American honors. The Bears drafted Barton in the seventh round of the 2008 NFL Draft, but released him after he appeared in just one game that season.
