SA accused of dumping 'non-premium' citrus in India
Citrus varieties like Nadorcott mandarins and Forelle pears have been singled out by Indian fruit importers as being in surplus and weakening product reputation.
The issue came to a head last year when an estimated 50 to 60 container loads of small-sized Nadorcott mandarins arrived in a short time span.
This triggered a price crash to just USD $5–6 (R88–R106*) per box. The surplus in turn affected the opening of the 2025 season for Nova mandarins, which entered the market at 30% less than the previous year's value.
Importers argue that South African exporters are shipping volumes without proper planning and without regard for India's demand cycles or size preferences.
In the case of mandarins, the late arrival of large, unwanted sizes and excess volumes has led to a growing perception of South African fruit as low quality or 'non-premium.'
The situation is just as troubling in the pear segment. Usually a premium variety, Forelle pears have been so heavily oversupplied from South Africa that prices have fallen 40–50% year-on-year.
Indian stakeholders claim this is part of a recurring pattern where South African companies treat India as a 'dumping ground' for their excess produce.
'This aggressive export strategy may benefit short-term clearance but comes at a cost to both growers and long-term trade relationships,' a leading importer told FreshPlaza .
'The burden of these losses is ultimately borne by South African growers, and it makes Indian importers extremely cautious when engaging with RSA suppliers.'
Meanwhile, the proposed new 30% tariff on South African citrus exports to the USA could disrupt emerging markets even further.
Boitshoko Ntshabele, CEO of the Citrus Growers Association (CGA), insists that South Africa already pays hefty export duties to Asia.
'The US volumes cannot be easily absorbed elsewhere at such short notice,' explained Ntshabele. 'Also, we already face very steep tariffs with exports to promising markets like India and China.'
* USD – ZAR exchange rate as of 12/06/2025
Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1.
Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
6 minutes ago
- The Star
Black Economic Empowerment: Has BEE failed South Africa's poor
Thabo Makwakwa | Published 1 week ago The debate surrounding the effectiveness of Black Economic Empowerment (BEE) in South Africa has intensified in recent months, with critics pointing to its shortcomings in achieving its core objectives. BEE is a government policy enacted in 2003 to increase economic participation by black South Africans. It seeks to transform the economy by promoting black ownership of companies, increasing black representation in management and boardrooms, and fostering entrepreneurship among historically disadvantaged communities. Although its objectives are widely supported, the policy's success has been scrutinised. In a detailed analysis published in the St Andrews Law Review on May 24, 2023, James Vandrau argued that BEE has failed to reconcile social inequalities in South Africa. He pointed out that resistance from the white business community has hampered the policy's effectiveness. 'This demographic has largely opposed the changes instigated by BEE, leading to a considerable backlash against the program,' Vandrau noted. According to a 2006 survey, approximately one-fifth of South African companies had no plans to implement black empowerment initiatives. The slow pace of progress prompted the Presidential Black Business Working Group to call for more stringent measures, with the ANC acknowledging that more aggressive interventions were necessary to meet BEE targets. This frustration has led many black entrepreneurs to advocate for faster economic de-racialisation. One of the most persistent criticisms of BEE is that it has been undermined by corruption and nepotism. Critics argue that a privileged few have benefited disproportionately at the expense of the wider black community. Gelb & Black (2004) highlighted how unissued equity was transferred from white-owned companies to a select group of 'tenderpreneurs'—black businesspeople often with high political profiles but limited business experience—resulting in a form of enrichment rather than broad-based empowerment. Furthermore, the representation of black individuals in senior management and boardrooms remains disappointingly low. The Black Business Executive Circle report of October 2005 revealed that only five of the top 200 companies on the Johannesburg Securities Exchange (JSE) had black ownership exceeding 51%. Only 32 companies had black ownership above 25%, collectively accounting for less than 2% of the JSE's market capitalisation. In an opinion piece published in The Star three months ago, Professor Bheki Mngomezulu, Director of the Centre for the Advancement of Non-Racialism and Democracy at Nelson Mandela University, acknowledged that BEE was a noble idea but emphasised that corruption has derailed its progress. 'The process should start with politicians who have corrupted the system and then move to businesses that have exploited loopholes to serve self-interests,' Mngomezulu wrote. 'Unless these corrupt practices are addressed, BEE will hinder economic growth and exclude those it was meant to benefit.' Weighing in, Dr. Khwezi Mabasa, a sociology lecturer at the University of Pretoria and an economic policy analyst, emphasised the need for a broader approach. Speaking to IOL, Mabasa highlighted that current legislation and initiatives, such as the broad-based black economic empowerment codes (B-BBEE), must be complemented by efforts outside the stock exchange, including supporting small and medium enterprises, entrepreneurship, and local economic development. 'We need to look beyond listed companies,' Mabasa explained. 'Most businesses are unlisted, and we must focus on fostering local ventures, job skills development, and access to affordable financing for black entrepreneurs. 'Transformation should also prioritise building sustainable local economies, especially in townships, rather than relying solely on high-profile corporate ownership.' Without these reforms, Mabasa argued that South Africa risks perpetuating the inequalities that the BEE was designed to eradicate. [email protected] IOL Politics
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Artisans of Mzansi 2025: Entries open to empower South African trade businesses
Allan Gray Makers has officially opened entries for Artisans of Mzansi 2025, a national campaign designed to recognise and empower South Africa's most outstanding artisan entrepreneurs. The initiative seeks to challenge negative perceptions around technical trades, inspire young people to pursue artisanal careers and accelerate the growth of small and medium businesses in the sector. Despite the National Development Plan's target of producing 30 000 qualified artisans annually by 2030, South Africa produces only 15 000. ALSO READ: Kaalfontein school excels in entrepreneurial skills A key barrier is the stigma around Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) colleges and trade careers, discouraging young people from entering this critical industry. Artisans of Mzansi aims to change this narrative by profiling successful artisan entrepreneurs as role models, demonstrating the viability and dignity of careers in plumbing, electrical work, construction, carpentry, and related trades. 'South Africa's artisan economy is a powerhouse of untapped potential. Through Artisans of Mzansi, we celebrate skilled tradespeople and rewrite the story of what it means to be an artisan. 'These entrepreneurs are job creators, innovators, and nation-builders. By showcasing their success, we hope to inspire a new generation to see the trades as a first-choice career path,' said Seth Mulli, programme director of Allan Gray Makers. Artisans of Mzansi will identify and reward exceptional artisans and trade businesses through a competitive process. Winners will receive cash prizes and a year of business advisory support to scale their enterprises. ALSO READ: Local skills centre leads youngsters to a brighter future To enter, artisans must: • Be a qualified artisan (with a trade test). • Be the owner or 50% partner in a formalised trade business (plumbing, electrical, or construction). • Be a South African citizen or permanent resident, aged 50 or younger in 2025. • Ensure their business operates ethically and complies with industry standards. Micro businesses earning between R0 and R1m in revenue can win R50 000 while small businesses earning between R1m and R5m stand a chance of winning R100 000. Medium-sized businesses earning over R5m can win R50 000. Interested artisans can submit their applications online by June 30. Shortlisted candidates will undergo interviews and pitch presentations before the organisers announce the winners. For more information and to apply, visit At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading! Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App Stay in the know. Download the Caxton Local News Network App here
Eyewitness News
5 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
LISTEN: The Money Show highlights – Beauty on TApp CEO Mathebe Ngwenya and wheelchair tennis star Kgothatso Montjane
On this week's episode of 'The Best Bits of The Money Show', Mathebe Ngwenya shares her remarkable journey of founding Beauty on TApp, highlighting the courage, resilience, and deep passion that fueled her mission. Warren Ingram, financial advisor and Co-Founder of Galileo Capital, discusses the importance of being prepared for unexpected financial emergencies. Stephen interviews inspiring South African wheelchair tennis star Kgothatso Montjane. Consumer expert Wendy Knowler explores how technology has revolutionised everyday communication and convenience, and asks whether companies are leaning too heavily on bots and automated responses.
