Sulphur-cleaning device in coal plants not necessary: Central scientific committee

A high-powered committee of experts, chaired by Principal Scientific Advisor (PSA) Ajay Sood, has recommended that India do away with a decade-long policy of mandating equipment, called Flu Gas Desulphurisation (FGD) units, in all coal-fired thermal power plants (TPPs), according to documents perused by The Hindu.
These FGD units are required to be retro-fitted in TPPs to cut harmful sulphur dioxide (SO2) emissions. While 92% of India's 600 TPPs have not yet installed FGD units, the recommendation would exempt about 80% of them from needing to install such equipment.
The limited number of vendors capable of installing such equipment in India, the high installation costs, the potential rise in electricity bills, and disruptions due to the COVID-19 pandemic have been some of the reasons historically cited by the Power Ministry, the overseer of India's TPPs, for plants' inability to adhere to previous deadlines. In theory, the costs of non-compliance could run to crores of rupees in fines, though these have not materialised thanks to deadline extensions.
'FGD not necessary'
However, this was the first time that multiple arms of the government congregated to deliberate on whether FGDs were required in the first place. Their verdict draws on three reports by the CSIR-NEERI, the National Institute of Advanced Studies, and the Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi. The lead scientists of these three institutions – each 'supported' by different arms of the government – were at the meeting on April 23, along with representatives from the Office of the PSA, the Union Power Ministry, and the NITI Ayog. They were all largely unanimous that FGD 'was not necessary.'
The guiding principles informing the committee's recommendation are that: SO2 levels in ambient air across the country are around 10-20 micrograms/cubic metre, well below India's air quality norms of 80; Indian coal is low in sulphur; SO2 levels in cities near plants with operational FGD units do not differ significantly from those without these units, and all of these were anyway well below permissible levels.
The committee opined that concerns about sulphates – a potential by-product when SO2 emissions reach certain atmospheric levels, thus forming particulate matter (PM) – are unfounded. They cited an analysis of 5,792 PM samples across the country, which found 'low elemental sulphur' content (max 8 micrograms/m3 after outlier removal) which was deemed 'insignificant — for considering PM removal as a benefit of FGD.'
FGDs may worsen carbon emissions
One argument mentioned in the report was that using FGDs might result in additional carbon dioxide emissions and accentuate global warming. 'Installing FGDs in all TPPs by 2030 will increase the Auxiliary Power Consumption (APC) of the TPPs, thereby adding approximately 69 million tons of CO2 emissions to the atmosphere (2025-30) while reducing SO2 emissions by —17 million tons. Adding more long-lived CO2 emissions while removing short-lived SO2 emissions by installing FGDs indiscriminately in all TPPs in India despite the low Sulphur content of Indian coal will enhance global warming.'
On the other hand, given that burning coal is India's primary source of electricity, India's annual SO2 emissions has risen from 4,000 kilotonnes in 2010 to 6,000 kilotonnes in 2022. By comparison, Indonesia, a source of imported coal to India has averaged about 2,000 kt in the same period, according to data from the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air (CREA), a Helsinki-based think tank. This is when India's emission standards, at 100 micrograms/m3 (thus requiring FGD), is lower than Indonesia's 800.
Environment Ministry 'studying' order
Those who attended the meeting included the Secretary, Minister of Power and three other senior officials; Secretary, Environment and Forests and two other officials; four officials of the Office of the PSA; representatives of the NITI Ayog, Central Electricity Authority (the power regulator), Central Pollution Control Board, and academicians.
A detailed questionnaire to the Power Ministry was unanswered until press time. Tanmay Kumar, Secretary, Environment Ministry, told The Hindu that his Ministry was 'studying' the order.
India has 180 coal-fired thermal power plants, each of them with multiple units. The 600 TPPs, depending on their size, age, proximity to densely populous cities, and background pollution levels, were given different timelines by the Environment Ministry to comply with the FGD installation requirements. Deadlines have been shifted three times, with the most recent extension coming on Dec 31, 2024.
Major population centres
The committee, according to the minutes of the meeting seen by The Hindu, will 'recommend' to the Power and Environment Ministers that only power plants located within a 10-km radius of the National Capital Region and other cities with a million-plus population be required to install FGDs. These are called Category A plants. There are 66 such plants, and only 14 of them have installed FGDs. Currently, all these plants are required to comply by 2027.
Plants within a 10-km radius of 'Critically Polluted Cities' or 'Non Attainment Cities', called Category B plants, would be eligible for exemption on a 'case by case' basis, on a joint review by the Central Electricity Authority or Central Pollution Control Board. There are 72 such plants, with only four having installed FGD. These plants currently have a deadline of 2028.
The remaining 462 plants all come under Category C, of which 32 have installed FGDs. These plants have been given a 2029 deadline, but the committee has now recommended that Category C plants be exempted completely, along with some units in Categories A and B which were set up at least 20 years ago.
'Will not affect public health'
'The key common point in these studies is that fitment of FGDs in all TPPs in India is not necessary to comply with the NAAQ (National Ambient Air Quality) standards whose compliance is essential to safeguard public health. While all TPPs must comply with the December 2015 stack emission standards for PM pollution and freshwater consumption, the SO2 stack emission standards can be relaxed to ensure that they are in conformance with the NAAQ standards which are notified by CPCB, keeping in mind the human health and other aspects. This way, TPPs may be able to comply with these standards without fitting FGDs. Since the existing NAAQ standards (for ambient SO2) must be complied with, this change will not affect human health in India,' the committee concludes.
Currently, State governments or affiliated companies run a majority of the Category A TPPs, whereas private authorities hold the highest share in Categories B and C.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Time of India

18 minutes ago

• Time of India

‘Yoga paves the way for welfare of the world and discipline of the body'

Bhopal: To observe International Yoga Day , the BJP organised yoga functions at the division and booth levels across the state. At the state party headquarters, the yoga function was headed by BJP national co-organisational general secretary Shivprakash, chief minister Mohan Yadav, BJP state president Vishnudutt Sharma, and state party organisational general secretary Hitanand Sharma. Office-bearers and party workers performed yoga in the early morning hours. Addressing the workers, Shivprakash said that yoga is not just a physical exercise, but an art of living. "Samatvam Yoga Uchyate" means that the essence of yoga is equanimity; to see every person and situation of the world with an equal perspective. This equanimity brings balance and stability in life. "Those with a liberal outlook consider the entire world as their family. This is the basic thought of Indian culture, to rise above conflict, exploitation, and war and move towards the welfare of all. Yoga paves the way for the welfare of the world along with the discipline of the body," the BJP national co-organisational general secretary said. CM Mohan Yadav said that yoga is such a divine state when consciousness and supreme consciousness meet. Every living being has the opportunity to achieve this state of mind. Yoga is an invaluable gift of Sanatan Hindu religion and culture to the entire humanity. "Due to the tireless efforts of PM Modi, UNGA declared June 21 as International Yoga Day," he said. "It also supported the fact that yoga provides a holistic approach to health and well-being along with establishing a balance between all aspects of life. He ushered in a new era of holistic health revolution across the world. Today, the entire global community is expressing gratitude to Prime Minister Modi. We are celebrating the 11th International Yoga Day. It is dedicated to the theme of Yoga for One Earth, One Health," Yadav said.

Indian Express

21 minutes ago

• Indian Express

Ahmedabad crash: At least 20 on-ground deaths confirmed; 247 DNA matches complete, 232 bodies handed over

While the exact death toll of June 12 Air India plane crash is still not clear, it has emerged that at least 20 people may have been killed on the ground when the aircraft slammed into a Medical College hostel in Ahmedabad's Meghaninagar, The Indian Express has learnt. By 6 pm on Saturday, the process of matching a total of 247 DNA samples of the victims with their living family members had been completed, said officials at the Ahmedabad Civil Hospital. These included 238 people who were on board the ill-fated Boeing aircraft, the officials added. As many as 241 out of the 242 passengers who boarded the plane lost their lives in the tragedy. Meanwhile, the process of DNA analysis of samples taken from the bodies of victims with those of their living relatives is still underway, almost 10 days after the crash. Of the 247 DNA matches, 232 bodies have been handed over to the families. Out of the remaining 15 identified bodies, three families are awaiting the remains of their other family members since more than one of their kin perished in the crash. Six bodies are ready to be handed over while scheduling with families is underway to hand over the mortal remains of another six passengers. The Indian Express has learnt that of the 247 bodies identified through DNA as of Saturday evening, 175 were Indian, 52 British, seven Portuguese, one Canadian, and 12 non-passengers. Dr Rakesh Joshi, Medical Superintendent of Ahmedabad Civil Hospital, confirmed that of the 12 non-passengers whose bodies had been handed over to families, nine had died on the spot and their identification had to be carried out through DNA analysis. Three of the victims were admitted to the hospital in a critical state and succumbed to their injuries later. On bodies that could be identified without the need for DNA profiling, Dr Joshi said, 'We had handed over eight such bodies to their families. In these cases, the need for DNA profiling did not arise because their bodies were identifiable.' All these eight persons were those who had died on the ground, bringing the total number of casualties in the Atulyam hostels of B J Medical College and those on the road to 20. This also takes the estimated death toll to 261 persons, including 241 airline passengers. Resampling needed in some cases Meanwhile, The Indian Express has learnt that some families had to give additional DNA samples. This is because initial blood samples were taken from distant relatives, which may have not been enough to prove a blood relation, people in the know of the matter said. There could be other problems with the blood samples during the DNA profiling process, they added. Dr Joshi said, 'We have done resampling for some families. In cases where a delay was taking place, we asked for additional samples from families. The most effective blood samples to match are between a parent and a child. But in the earlier phase of the tragedy, immediate family may not have been available. Since they came later, we took additional samples from them. In some cases, we were about to take additional samples but before that, we received the news that the body had been identified.'

First Post

34 minutes ago

• First Post

FATF links dual-use equipment seized by India to Pakistan's missile programme

A dual use equipment seized by India from a Pakistan bound merchant vessel in 2020 is linked to Islamabad's National Development Complex that is involved in the country's missile development programme, a new report by the Financial Action Task Force has said. read more India's 2020 seizure of Pakistan-bound dual-use equipment has been linked to Islamabad's missile development programme, according to a new report by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF). The equipment, intercepted from a merchant vessel is associated with Pakistan's National Development Complex, a key entity involved in the country's missile development. FATF, the global financial watchdog, referenced the case in its latest report, which outlines risks and vulnerabilities in the international financial and trade systems. The incident was cited under a section highlighting the misuse of the maritime and shipping sectors to move sensitive goods, including dual-use items that can be repurposed for weapons programmes. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'In 2020, Indian custom authorities seized an Asian-flagged ship bound for Pakistan. During an investigation, Indian authorities confirmed that documents mis-declared the shipment's dual-use items,' the FATF report said. 'Indian investigators certified the items for shipment to be 'Autoclaves', which are used for sensitive high energy materials and for insulation and chemical coating of missile motors,' the report said. It said these sensitive items are included in dual-use export control lists of the Missile Technology Control Regime (MTCR). The bill of lading of the seized cargo provided evidence of the 'link between the importer and the National Development Complex, which is involved in the development of long-range ballistic missiles,' it said. The export of equipment such as the autoclaves without formal approval from various authorities is a violation of existing law, the FATF said. Pakistan's National Development Complex (NDC) has played a crucial role in the development of Pakistan's missile programme. India had seized the dual-use equipment from merchant vessel Da Cui Yun at Kandla port in Gujarat on February 3, 2020. The Indian customs authorities had stopped the vessel for wrongly declaring an autoclave, which can be used in construction of missiles, as an 'industrial dryer'. The report said that significant vulnerabilities remain across the global financial system in countering the financing of weapons of mass destruction (WMD). STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD 'Despite the grave threat posed by proliferation financing (PF), only 16 per cent of countries assessed by the FATF and its global network have demonstrated high or substantial effectiveness' in a process that evaluates the implementation of targeted financial sanctions under the United Nations Security Council resolutions on proliferation. The report said that unless the public and private sectors urgently bolster technical compliance and effectiveness, those seeking to finance WMD proliferation will continue to exploit weaknesses in existing controls. The report provided a detailed analysis of the evolving methods and techniques used to evade PF-related sanctions. 'Illicit actors are employing increasingly sophisticated methods to evade sanctions and circumvent export controls,' it said. With inputs from agencies