Verifying conflicting accounts of Iran's strike on an Israeli hospital
Conflicting narratives have emerged after an Iranian missile struck an Israeli hospital on Thursday, with Tehran claiming it was targeting military facilities while the Israeli defence minister described the attack as a "war crime."
Israel's Health Ministry said 71 people were wounded after missiles struck the Soroka hospital. A spokesperson for the medical facility said there had been no serious casualties as the part of the hospital that was hit directly had already been evacuated.
Tehran's top diplomat has claimed that the strike "eliminated" two Israeli military targets.
"Our powerful Armed Forces accurately eliminated an Israeli Military Command, Control & Intelligence HQ and another vital target," Iranian foreign minister Abbas Araghchi said on X, adding that the blast "caused superficial damage to a small section" of the hospital.
Euronews' fact-checking team, Euroverify, has analysed videos from the site of the strike and consulted military experts to verify the plausibility of these claims.
Video footage that we've verified shows significant destruction to buildings within the hospital complex, as well as medical workers running to evacuate from the site.
Other photographic evidence analysed by our team suggest hospital buildings were directly impacted by missiles.
We have also geo-located a video that shows the moment the missile hit a hospital building to the north of the Soroka complex, near David Ben Gurion street.
This evidence contradicts the Iranian foreign minister's claims that damage to the site was "superficial' and caused by a "blast wave" from a nearby strike.
Hospitals have special protection under the Geneva Convention, but lose that protection if used to commit 'acts harmful to the enemy', such as launching an attack or storing weapons.
Israel has consistently targeted hospitals in its war in Gaza, claiming they are being used by Hamas militants.
No evidence has yet emerged to suggest the Soroka hospital site was being used by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF).
Dr. Ron Schleifer, an Israeli expert on information warfare, told Euroverify that the IDF does not use hospitals and other public facilities to "hide behind the civilian population."
"A hospital is clearly not a legitimate target, at least in the eyes of the West," Dr Schleifer said, adding that "Israel does not need to hide military installations under hospitals."
Yet, Iran has not alleged the hospital itself was being used for warring purposes, but rather that its missile was targeting two military targets in the hospital's vicinity: a "command and intelligence (IDF C4i) headquarters" and an "army intelligence campus in the Gav-Yam Technology Park."
IDF C4i is the Israeli military's elite technological unit, and was described by the IDF in 2021 as being "responsible for all the contacts, computers and communications of IDF forces on the battlefield."
The exact site of its headquarters is classified information and cannot be verified.
The second site targeted according to Iran was the IDF technology campus at the Gav-Yam Technology park. That campus is located near the site of the strike, around 1.5km to the north-east.
No verified videos have emerged to suggest the IDF campus was struck in the Thursday strike. In fact, verified videos only show impact on the hospital complex itself.
This would suggest that if Iran was aiming at military targets, it missed. Two OSINT experts told Euroverify that their analysis of Iranian strikes on Israel over the past days suggests that Iran lacks precision in hitting its targets.
Early on Friday morning, Israeli public media Kan reported that a fresh attack on Beersheba "targeted a residential neighbourhood," with inital reports suggesting the site of the Gav-Yam Negev park was impacted.
In his post on X, the Iranian foreign minister shared a map that purports to show two Israeli military targets right next to the Soroka hospital.
But the map is fake. The street names and topography do not correspond to the area, and major sites, including the Gav-Yam Negev technology park, are misspelt.
X users have also misleadingly claimed that a video of an Iranian strike hitting the Israeli capital of Tel Aviv on Thursday shows an impact on the Gav-Yam Negev park.
We've verified that the videos in question show a strike on the Ramat Gan neighbourhood in Tel Aviv, and not in the vicinity of the Soroka hospital as the user claims.
Our journalists are continuing to verify footage emerging from the affected area and will update this story with the latest developments.
More countries are evacuating their citizens from the Middle East as the conflict between Israel and Iran rages on, despite international efforts to find a diplomatic solution.
Days of attacks and reprisals by the adversaries have shuttered airspace across the region, severely disrupting commercial flights.
A repatriation flight transporting 69 people from Israel landed in Portugal on Thursday evening, with 48 Portuguese citizens among the passengers.
The Portuguese government announced the temporary closure of its embassy in Tehran this week, alongside ongoing repatriation operations in the Middle East.
In Serbia, 38 people arrived safely in Belgrade on Thursday night, most of whom were Serbian nationals.
They arrived on a special Air Serbia flight from Sharm el-Sheikh, organised by the Serbian government, who said the evacuation of those wishing to leave Israel and Iran would continue.
On Thursday, Serbian Prime Minister Đuro Macut met with Egyptian Foreign Minister Badr Abdelatty in Cairo to discuss the emergency evacuation of more than 2,500 Serbian nationals stranded in Israel.
Meanwhile, in Romania, more than a hundred people arrived in the capital Bucharest on Friday on military transport flights from the Middle East.
The Romanian Ministry of Defence sent the planes to the region after its nationals requested assistance.
The conflict between Israel and Iran erupted on 13 June following Israeli bombings on Iranian military and nuclear facilities, which resulted in the deaths of military leaders, scientists and civilians.
More than 400 EU citizens from countries including Greece, Lithuania, Poland and Slovakia have been evacuated from Israel in flights supported by the European Commission.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
an hour ago
- LeMonde
Despite destruction and death, Israelis widely support war against Iran
Shoshi Arbuz received the alert on her phone just minutes before the explosion. Along with her four children, her husband and their dog, they had just enough time to get down to the shelter beneath their small four-story building – a room just a few square meters in the basement, furnished with plastic chairs and a reinforced door. When the Iranian missile struck less than 100 meters away just after 7 am on Thursday morning in Holon, a southern suburb of Tel Aviv, the ground shook in the basement-turned-shelter. "Everything went black, the shelter filled with dust," said the 40-year-old municipal employee. The building across the street, which took a direct hit, was partially destroyed. About 30 people were rescued from it, including two who were critically injured, according to the city's chief fire officer. The blast destroyed the inside of the family apartment, as well as dozens of others around the impact site. In her partially-destroyed living room, Arbuz repeated that she didn't "want war," but nevertheless firmly supported the Netanyahu government's decision to launch a surprise attack on Iran on June 13, because of the nuclear threat. "Iran wants to destroy us. I understand that if we hadn't attacked, they would have," she explained, echoing the public's deep-seated fears about the dangers posed by the Iranian regime. While Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's policies regarding the hostages held by Hamas in the Gaza Strip since the October 7, 2023 terrorist attack have caused months of anger and incomprehension, the bombing of targets in Iran has, at least for now, been met with wide approval: More than 80% of Jewish Israelis support the strikes, according to a recent poll conducted for the Israel Democracy Institute (IDI).
France 24
an hour ago
- France 24
Supreme Court allows US victim suits against Palestinian authorities
The court issued a unanimous 9-0 decision in a long-running case involving the jurisdiction of US federal courts to hear lawsuits against the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO). Americans killed or injured in attacks in Israel or the West Bank or their relatives have filed a number of suits seeking damages. In one 2015 case, a jury awarded $655 million in damages and interest to US victims of attacks which took place in the early 2000s. Appeals courts had dismissed the suits on jurisdiction grounds. Congress passed a law in 2019 -- the Promoting Security and Justice for Victims of Terrorism Act (PSJVTA) -- that would make the PLO and PA subject to US jurisdiction if they were found to have made payments to the relatives of persons who killed or injured Americans. Two lower courts ruled that the 2019 law was a violation of the due process rights of the Palestinian authorities under the US Constitution but the Supreme Court ruled on Friday to uphold it. "The PSJVTA reasonably ties the assertion of federal jurisdiction over the PLO and PA to conduct that involves the United States and implicates sensitive foreign policy matters within the prerogative of the political branches," Chief Justice John Roberts wrote. The PA announced in February that it would end its system of payments to the families of those killed by Israel or held in Israeli prisons, responding to a long-standing request from Washington. In 2018, during his first term as US president, Donald Trump signed into law rules suspending financial assistance to the PA as long as it continued to pay benefits to Palestinians linked to "terrorist" entities, according to the criteria of the Israeli authorities.
France 24
2 hours ago
- France 24
Drone factories, camouflaged trucks: Iran releases images of Israel's covert operation
The Israeli drones successfully neutralised several of the Islamic Republic's anti-air defences deep inside its territory. What is particularly surprising is that some of these drones were manufactured in covert production facilities deep within Iran. Iranian state TV has broadcast images showing camouflaged lorries and vans that were used to transport the drones, as well as images of the makeshift FPV factories. The Israeli attack on Iran began on June 13. Its first targets were commanders of the Revolutionary Guard Corps, nuclear scientists, and military and nuclear facilities. According to Israeli information, 16 IRGC commanders and 14 nuclear scientists were eliminated by the Israeli army in the first round of attacks on Iran. Eyewitnesses report that from the very first moments, small drones and FPVs were seen or heard in the skies of several Iranian cities, particularly Tehran. Videos released by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) show these small drones attacking Iran's missile systems. Additional footage reveals the drones being launched from inside Iran, demonstrating their use against targets within the country. In response to the widespread use of this tactic by infiltrated Israeli agents on the ground in Iran, the Iranian regime's security forces on June 14 were compelled to publicly urge the people of Iran to stay vigilant and report any suspicious lorries, vans, or activities to the authorities. Images of these lorries and vans, converted to transport FPV drones and discovered by citizens or security forces, were widely shared on social media. State-run television and pro-regime outlets also aired videos showcasing hidden, makeshift drone production facilities discovered near Tehran and Isfahan. In one of the videos, the state TV presenter shows kits for small drones that are ready for production. According to the report, this makeshift facility was located covertly in a three-storey building near Tehran. But were Israeli agents able to establish drone-production sites right under the nose of Iran's intelligence services? 'Most of this system is designed for internal repression' Farzin Nadimi, a research fellow at the Washington Institute and an expert on Iranian weaponry, explains: We have known for many years about the deep infiltration of Israeli assets, almost at every level of the IRGC, the IRGC intelligence service, other intelligence services of Iran, the military and among politicians. In my opinion, the main cause could be corruption. But it's not only that. There is a lot at stake when working with Israel in Iran. With all the risks involved, money can't be the only motivation. When they see how corrupt the system is, they lose respect and loyalty for it, and the higher their rank, the better they understand how corrupt the whole system is. Multiple Iranian officials had issued warnings about the infiltration of Israeli agents within Iran, including at high-ranking levels of the IRGC and the broader power structure. In an unprecedented speech in 2021, Ali Younesi, former intelligence minister of Iran, stated: 'Over the past ten years, the Mossad [Israel's main intelligence agency] has infiltrated several of the regime's structures, to the point that every single Iranian official must now worry for their own life. Any attack is now possible.' On another occasion, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, former president of Iran, claimed in a 2024 interview with CNN Türk: 'The head of Iran's counterintelligence, tasked with finding Mossad operatives, was himself an Israeli agent.' Nadimi continues: On the other hand the Iranian secret services have trained their apparatus for internal security risks. Most of this system is designed for internal repression and internal protests, and they have seen these protests as the more urgent threat than a foreign attack. Nadimi emphasises that he's not surprised that Iranian intelligence services are caught off guard by these drones: In fact, it is not so complicated to smuggle them into Iran. These drones consist of small parts that are easy to smuggle into Iran. Many parts are easy to manufacture in Iran, such as fibreglass parts. The controls and other electronic parts would be easy to smuggle into Iran via the Persian Gulf region, e.g., Dubai and other borders. For a complex mission like this, however, you can't rely entirely on locals and local assets, you need to have agents on the ground. They had planned this for a long time. They claim to have been working on this plan for many years. The Iranian authorities have cut the internet connection since June 18, and claim this has significantly curbed FPV and small drone attacks since then. Nadimi explains: Drone technology has made enormous progress in recent years, particularly in the Russia-Ukraine war. In this war, we have seen drones or FPVs use different types of technologies. We have seen that the Ukrainians use mobile phone networks to guide their drones deep into Russian territory. Thanks to the mobile network, they send information and users can also send them commands. This is quite useful and practical. So these drones could have relied on the 5G, mobile and LTE networks, so a disruption of the network at this level could theoretically have a partial impact on them. This is not the first time Israeli agents have infiltrated Iran in recent years. In July 2024, Israel successfully targeted and killed Ismail Haniyeh, the political leader of Hamas, during a visit to Tehran. He was killed by a precise strike on his room in a protected compound in northern Iran. On November 27, 2020, Israel also succeeded in eliminating Mohsen Fakhrizadeh, the scientist whom Western intelligence agencies and Israel believed to be the mastermind behind "Project Amad", Iran's covert effort to build a nuclear bomb in the early 2000s. He was killed on his way home when he came under fire from a machine gun mounted on a parked truck, which was remotely controlled via satellite.
