OPINION: Bavuma has silenced his doubters, but some of the criticism was fair
It's disrespectful to treat the Proteas Test captain like a child made of glass.
Temba Bavuma led the Proteas to victory in the World Test Championship final against Australia in London last week. Picture: Alex Davidson/ICC/Getty Images
There's a perspective that has emerged from some quarters that Temba Bavuma cannot be criticised. How condescending.
Public figures, including professional athletes, will always be held to account more than the general public. It's a natural byproduct of fame and fortune.
And as the captain of the Proteas cricket team, Bavuma will be a target of criticism, as is the case with any other national skippers or elite sport stars.
According to some, however, Bavuma cannot be treated with the same level of respect as other professional athletes. When we talk about him, we need to put kid gloves on and punch lightly.
Bavuma is not made of glass
After the Proteas returned home this week with the World Test Championship mace, Bavuma's supporters took the opportunity to defend him, including sports minister Gayton McKenzie.
Speaking at a press conference after the team's arrival, McKenzie laid into members of the media who have called out Bavuma in the past when the top-order batter has experienced slumps and not delivered.
And he's not alone. Even some members of the media refuse to criticise Bavuma. They place him in a cushioned box as if he's so fragile that the slightest knock will break him.
McKenzie also claimed this week that those of us who have called out Bavuma in the past cannot praise him now because we previously 'said he was sh**'.
That's completely absurd. To be criticised when you play poorly and lauded when you play well is standard for any elite athlete in any sport. It comes with the territory.
Fair criticism
It would be ridiculous for analysts to simply praise athletes all the time, regardless of their performances, in the hope that one day they will come good. The media needs to be fair, objective and honest.
What Bavuma has achieved as captain of the national Test team over the last couple of years has been phenomenal.
Having gone unbeaten in 10 matches as skipper and leading the SA squad to a historic victory in last week's World Test Championship final (on top of his incredible run of form with the bat) he has earned icon status in South African sport for his recent accomplishments.
But that doesn't change the fact that he hasn't always delivered, especially in limited overs formats, and much of the criticism he's received (or some of it, at the very least) has been deserved, especially after the 2023 World Cup in India where he just didn't perform.
Special immunity
Giving Bavuma special privileges and suggesting he can't be fairly criticised is completely condescending.
He's not a child playing mini-cricket. He's the captain of the national team, and he's only criticised because of the calibre of player he is. It's because of his role in the squad, and his tremendous ability, that we expect as much as we do from him.
To refuse to criticise him is to suggest we don't expect anything from him in the first place. Bavuma deserves more respect than that.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
16 minutes ago
- The South African
Schoolboy move: Grey College lose top star to Paarl Boys' High
Grey College's star loose forward Steven Muller is now a pupil at Paarl Boys' High, following his father's relocation to the Cape due to work commitments. Muller, who already boasts several First XV caps to his name for Grey College, captained the Bloemfontein side's U14A, U15A and U16A teams and was among the leading candidates to skipper the Grey College First XV in 2026. As a result of his departure, the Free State U18 Academy Week team will have to find a replacement for their provincial youth week early next month. Both Grey College and in particular Paarl Boys' High are enjoying tremendous seasons, with both sides in the Top 5 in the 'unofficial' rankings. Muller's transfer will bolster Paarl Boys' already formidable pack of forwards as they head into the business end of the 2025 season. A look at the Springbok history books shows that Grey College have produced 48 Springboks (second most) while Paarl Boys' High boast 26 (sixth most). Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
IOL News
17 minutes ago
- IOL News
Mamelodi Sundowns to showcase Brazilian flair against Borussia Dortmund at Club World Cup
The vibrant colours of the Mamelodi Sundowns kit evoke strong connections to Brazil. Photo: AFP Image: AFP The vibrant colours of Mamelodi Sundowns' kit evoke strong connections to South America's most celebrated footballing nation Brazil, a five-time Fifa World Cup winner. Now, as the South Africans stride onto the global stage at the Club World Cup, this correlation is stronger than ever. Nicknamed the Brazilians, Sundowns are captivated by the shared ethos of flair and passion, and Borussia Dortmund coach Niko Kovac drew parallels between their style of play and that of the Brazilian national team. Kovac came to that conclusion while doing his homework on Sundowns ahead of today's Group F clash. He said: 'They are more to the side of the Brazilian team', underscoring the challenge that awaits Dortmund and the intrigue surrounding Sundowns in this tournament. Grouped in the fiercely competitive Pool F alongside the likes of Bundesliga powerhouses Borussia Dortmund, illustrious Brazilian side Fluminense, and South Korean outfit Ulsan HD, Sundowns are ready to prove that they belong among the elite. Masandawana are stepping into a realm where their fluid passing, inventive movement, and tactical acumen can shine on a worldwide platform. For Sundowns, being likened to Brazil – a country synonymous with football artistry – validates their approach and ambition. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading The team have long been noted for their flair and creativity, distinct qualities that have brought them success in South African football. Sundowns are not just players in a tournament; they are ambassadors of South African football, with the hopes of a continent resting on their shoulders. The world's eyes will be on them as they strive to outshine their formidable opponents. Kovac expressed his enthusiasm for this unique opportunity, highlighting the diverse playing styles of their upcoming opponents. However, his Dortmund squad are ready to face an eclectic mix of playing styles. 'This is something new, a special moment for each of us,' Kovac remarked, underlining the thrill of venturing outside the familiar territory of European football. 'We usually play European teams, and now we're facing three different teams from three different continents. 'It's something new and something nice, to be honest.'
Daily Maverick
36 minutes ago
- Daily Maverick
Proteas' focus shifts focus to white-ball format with next Test a distant dream for fans
White-ball cricket and the 2027 ICC World Cup on home soil are Proteas' new focus. South Africa are officially the best Test cricket side in the world after their five-wicket win over Australia on Saturday, 14 June 2025, in the World Test Championship (WTC) final at Lord's. The nation rejoiced in a victory that was nearly 3o years in the making. Tournament after tournament of heartbreak later, the Proteas finally delivered meaningful silverware to the cabinet. So, when will South Africans get to watch the world champions play the format in front of them again? October 2026 is the answer. That's right — only then. Eighteen months on from their historic victory is when they will play in a Test at home. The opponents will be Australia, in a three-match series. The next time the Proteas run out in white clothes and bowl with a red ball in front of a home crowd, their crowning moment will be a distant memory. South Africa will host eight Test matches in the summer of 2026-27 — two matches against Bangladesh sandwiched in between three-match series against Australia and England. And this summer of 2025-26? Zero. For the first time since readmission, South Africa will not host any Test matches over the course of their summer season. In fact, the Proteas will only host five matches all summer, and they're all in the shortest format: West Indies touring the country for five T20Is in January and February 2026. All about the white ball next South Africa's next few months are littered with white-ball cricket as they look to build for the one-day international (ODI) ICC World Cup at home, staged in 2027. South Africa head to Zimbabwe for a two-match Test series — which doesn't count for the next WTC cycle — before a tri-series T20I tournament in the country, which includes New Zealand. They then travel to Australia and England in August and September for three ODIs and three T20Is in each country. After that they fly over to the subcontinent through the early summer months to take on Pakistan and India, which will each host two Test matches and three ODIs before Pakistan host three T20Is and India host five. With the national team's home summer so sparse, the fourth season of the SA20 will start a few weeks earlier than usual, on Boxing Day, to ensure some cricket content in the period so often associated with Test cricket in the country. It's somewhat ironic that the SA20 is filling this space, and it paints a picture of the changing landscape of the sport. The Proteas' WTC charge was almost derailed because of the first-choice players' contractual obligation to play in the SA20 at the start of 2024, instead of touring New Zealand for a two-match series. Not only did it put South Africa in a position where they had to win seven of their last eight matches to qualify for the final, which they did, it also helped the Black Caps beat the Proteas in a Test series for the first time in the sport's history. Although it looks like a steady overhaul of the shortest format in favour of the longest one, those who still play the red-ball game want to see it maintain its relevance. 'Favourite format' 'It's always been my most important and favourite format,' said Aiden Markram, the WTC final's player of the match. 'Naturally, playing fewer games is not really on us — it's just the cards that get dealt. But it's really important, in my opinion, to keep Test cricket as the number one priority in South Africa. 'We understand all the dynamics that are happening in the cricket world and that's completely fair, but it's more about the young guy coming through — that his main thing is to get a Test match baggy and play Test match cricket for South Africa. 'If we can still do that, it's fine. How long they play for is a different conversation in the world of cricket nowadays. 'But the number one priority should always be to play Test cricket and I've always felt that, believed that. If we can get that back with the younger people coming through, I think we've done well.' South Africa's Test tour to Zimbabwe is littered with talented youngsters. Lhuan-dre Pretorius (19) and Dewald Brevis (22) have lit up T20 tournaments in the past, and they are the two standout young names who are expected to make their debut in South Africa's first match as champions. World Cup in South Africa There was some criticism of the strength of the opposition South Africa faced on their road to the WTC final, as they didn't meet Australia or England prior to the final. Even though England only won half of their WTC fixtures, their reputation as being among the 'Big Three' somehow invalidated South Africa's charge. This time round, in the 2025-27 cycle, South Africa will play England and Australia at home as well as playing India away. 'We play whatever's put in front of us,' Proteas coach Shukri Conrad said. 'There's a lot of things we'd like but we can't get. We just play the cards we're dealt. And it's often not what you've been dealt, but how you play those cards.' ICC World Cup With the influx of white-ball cricket, though, the focus does shift to succeeding at the 2027 ICC World Cup on home soil. So much of South Africa's planning over the past few years has been about winning the tournament, including the hiring of director of national teams and high performance Enoch Nkwe, whose contract runs until the end of it. This WTC win, though warmly welcomed, wasn't part of the long-term planning like the 2027 ICC World Cup is. Conrad has taken over the white-ball sides too, and players such as superstar Kagiso Rabada have had their appetite for success whetted with the victory at Lord's. 'This has obviously given us confidence that we can do it again,' Rabada said. 'I don't know how I would be feeling if the result went the other way around, but let's not think too much about that. 'This gives confidence for the future, and confidence comes from doing good things.' South Africa will hope that the WTC win will inspire Rabada and company to go on and break the nation's World Cup duck as well in 2027, with everything being set up for them to succeed at home. DM
