Scottish fishing body accuses David Attenborough of 'propaganda'

The Scottish Fishermen's Federation (SFF) have issued a statement claiming that Attenborough's latest cinematic offering for National Geographic, Ocean, is a 'full panoply of Hollywood tear-jerk techniques'.
Co-produced by two Bristol-based companies, Silverback Films and Open Planet Studios, the cinema-length film documents how the state of the world's oceans and our understanding of how they function have changed over the course of Attenborough's lifetime.
The natural historian and broadcaster described Ocean as one of the most important films of his career, as the launch coincided with his 99th birthday last month.
READ MORE: Scottish council issues statement amid row over whether Union flag is 'sectarian'
However, despite the film being widely well-received, the narrative of the world's oceans being at a crossroads with 'destructive' fishing techniques has triggered condemnation from SFF.
A statement from the Aberdeen-based federation said: 'Once again, the fishing industry is in the position of defending its legitimate business activity in the face of a fresh onslaught from environmental non-governmental organisations (NGOs) designed to influence delegates to the UN Ocean Conference in Nice, France, from June 9-13.
'The spearhead this time is a film, Ocean, made by Silverback and narrated by Sir David Attenborough.
'Despite being voiced by someone who is regarded as a national treasure, and whose former association with the BBC means he is almost universally perceived as being impartial and unbiased, the film is a work of anti-fishing propaganda that wholly blames the industry for the poor state of the planet's oceans.
(Image: PA)
'Astonishingly, it singles out fishing from every other form of human impact on our seas.
'It also omits to mention the necessity of protein-rich, healthy food to feed the planet, and fishing's relatively low impact on greenhouse gas emissions, compared with other modes of food production.'
SFF added: 'Deploying the full panoply of Hollywood tear-jerk techniques, from beautiful imagery to, by turns, uplifting and depressing music, and additional narration by individuals who give an unchallenged, one-sided perspective on a variety of case studies from around the world, it has been carefully crafted to damage the industry.'
The industry body went on to say that fishermen have made 'huge changes' over the last 30 years to ensure fish stock levels are 'sustainable for the future'.
They went on to say that the industry is 'very heavily regulated' and that their focus is to work with governments in a bid to find a balance between conservation and sustainable harvesting.
SFF added that island communities depend on seafood to provide jobs and income and that the industry is committed to making industry sustainable for future generations to come.
The statement concluded: 'The unbalanced and unfair light shone on fishing in Ocean does a huge disservice to the skilled, knowledgeable and responsible men and women who make up our industry and, sadly, is a wasted opportunity to inform the public.'
Ocean contains some of the most graphic footage of the damage that bottom trawling, a common fishing practice around the world, can do to the seabed.
According to Attenborough, the film is a vivid example of how industrial fishing can drain the life from the world's oceans.
Footage from the film shows how the chain that the trawlers drag behind them scours the seafloor, forcing the creatures it disturbs into the net behind.
They are often seeking a single species: more than three-quarters of what they catch may be discarded.
A statement from Silverback Films and Open Planet Studios said the film emphasises the importance of supporting fishing communities and highlights that one of the 'standout lines' is that the goal of healthy fisheries and conservation is the same.
The statements read: 'Throughout this film, we make clear this is not anti-fishing.
'One of the standout lines from the film is that 'the goal of healthy fisheries and conservation are the same: more fish, more abundance'.
'The film emphasises the importance of supporting fishing communities and the three billion people worldwide who depend on fish for food and livelihoods.'
The statement added: 'If we allow marine environments to recover, fisheries will recover too.
'In the film, we cite the scientific recommendation of protecting 30% of our seas and, crucially, this is not suggesting we stop fishing altogether.
'Certain types of fishing methods are particularly damaging, but there is no reason why we cannot continue to fish if we also govern the ocean more responsibly.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Scottish Sun

24 minutes ago

• Scottish Sun

Tyson Fury drinks with locals in Scots bar and visits historic castle during road trip

The former world heavyweight champion dropped by Carbisdale Castle in the Highlands GYPSY KING ON TOUR Tyson Fury drinks with locals in Scots bar and visits historic castle during road trip Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) TYSON Fury has been spotted drinking with locals in a bar and visited a historic castle during his Scottish road trip. The boxing icon, 36, visited north of the border for Netflix's At Home With The Furys. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 Tyson Fury has been enjoying travelling around Scotland with his family Credit: Tyson Fury/Instagram 5 The former world heavyweight champ visited the Claymore Bar in Grantown-on-Spey Credit: Claymore Bar/Facebook 5 He posed with delighted locals as he downed pints in the Moray boozer Credit: Tyson Fury/Instagram 5 The boxing hero also visited John o' Groats, the northernmost point of mainland Britain Credit: Tyson Fury/Instagram The former world heavyweight champion dropped by Carbisdale Castle in the Highlands. He was shown around the grounds of the 118-year-old country pile and told of the work that had gone into transforming it into a luxury home. But owner Samantha Kane was unable to welcome the Gypsy King as she attending Royal Ascot in Berkshire. She said: "World-famous heavyweight boxer Tyson Fury made an unexpected visit to Carbisdale Castle while I was at Ascot yesterday and was greeted by Sarah and Michael, who showed him around the Castle and what was achieved in bringing Carbisdale to its former glory. 'He was very impressed indeed. Thank you Tyson for your visit.' Earlier this week, Fury was spotted strutting topless around Grantown-on-Spey in Moray wearing a red tartan kilt and matching tie. The 9ft 9ins star got fitted out at a kiltmaker in the small town and chatted with locals. He also enjoyed a drink in the Claymore Bar where he downed Guinness and posed for photos with staff. The ex-boxer has also visited Wick and John O'Groats in the Caithness region. He is visiting with his wife, Paris, children and film crew as he makes the second season of At Home With The Fury's. Boxing icon Tyson Fury spotted posing topless in Scots town as he chats with locals He happily posed for photos with fans, including Cromdale FC manager Stuart Dunbar, who jokingly tried to sign him up. Ms Kane is the only person in Britain to have changed gender three times. Born in Iraq as a man, named Sam Hashimi, she had surgery in 1997 to become Samantha, before a second operation in 2004 when she changed her name to Charles Kane and then a third surgery to become Samantha again in 2018. The barrister and business tycoon spearheaded a Saudi bid to buy Sheffield United Football Club in 2000. She called herself Lady Carbisdale after buying the dilapidated 19-bedroom clifftop castle, near Ardgay, in 2022. Fury retired in January, eight months after suffering the only defeat of his career at the time when he lost to Oleksandr Usyk by split decision. During a rematch last December, the Ukrainian won by unanimous decision. 5 The Gypsy King donned a kilt and matching tartan tie in Grantown-on-Spey Credit: Tyson Fury/Instagram Keep up to date with ALL the latest news and transfers at the Scottish Sun football page

Daily Mirror

an hour ago

• Daily Mirror

King Charles' sweet frozen-in-time tribute to loved one who died decades ago

When one of King Charles's loved ones passed away over two decades ago, he was left totally bereft, experts have revealed in a new documentary - and he was so heartbroken he has kept several tributes to them in one of his royal homes King Charles has a seriously sentimental side - and this heartbreaking tribute to a lost loved one proves just how deep it runs. More than 20 years ago, Charles lost someone who had been incredibly important to him, and experts have revealed that to this day, he has kept a few key aspects of their belongings in his home in exactly the same place - as if they might walk back in the door any moment now. ‌ The revelation came in the new Channel 5 documentary, Birkhall: The King's Secret Sanctuary, which details the monarch's relationship with one of his absolutely favourite residences. ‌ Birkhall is positioned very near the Royal Family's famous Balmoral estate, where they gather every summer and spend weeks engaged in countryside pursuits like fishing and picnics, in the privacy afforded to them by the Scottish countryside. The nearby Birkhall is a much more modest home compared to the grandeur of Balmoral, and since his childhood, it is said by the experts to have been one of Charles's favourite places to spend time - in part because of who it previously belonged to, his beloved grandmother, the Queen Mother. "For Charles, she was this haven of security and affection, and laughter and love," explained former BBC royal correspondent Jennie Bond. The expert continued that during Charles's unhappy school years in the north of Scotland, his grandmother's home of Birkhall, and the warm relationship they shared, offered the young prince some welcome respite. "When he was at Gordonstoun school in the north of Scotland, he would, whenever he could, take the two-hour journey to Birkhall to be with his beloved granny." When the Queen Mother died in 2002 at her home of Royal Lodge, Windsor - at the ripe old age of 101 - the Scottish retreat of Birkhall went to Charles, who was left utterly bereft at the loss. ‌ "For Charles, the loss of his grandmother was absolutely devastating," explained Jennie, but after taking over the property, he started undertaking essential refurbishments, updating the heating systems, and redecorating much of the place with the help of his now-wife Camilla. However, Charles made sure that the Queen Mother's presence is still felt in the house, "Her coats are still hanging up, on the is really sweet," revealed expert Afua Hagan. This heartbreaking nod to his grandmother in his favourite home is not the only way he has paid tribute to the Queen Mother, the expert also revealed that he has kept the barometer she used to use to check the weather hanging up. ‌ The Queen Mother was also a huge fan of clocks, the experts revealed, and used to have eight in the dining room alone - all set to "slightly different times" so they would chime out of sync with one another. The Queen Mother's guests were said to have been sent round the bend by this - but this reaction was something the quirky royal "thoroughly enjoyed". ‌ Charles has kept her clocks hanging up, it is revealed in the documentary, "He kept all eight of those grandfather clocks in the dining room," Afua explained, "but he set them all to the same time, so it didn't drive everybody as bonkers as it had done before." A royal author has previously claimed that the Queen Mother was actually "more of a mother" to her grandson than the late Queen Elizabeth herself - putting this down to the former monarch's gruelling schedule as head of state. "In some ways, the Queen Mother was a mother figure to Charles just because the Queen became Queen when Charles was so young. There were a lot of tours of the Commonwealth and every time the Queen had to go away, Prince Charles stayed with the Queen Mother," Gareth Russell, who has written a biography of the Queen Mother explained to People magazine. "They had a great sense of humour, and she always encouraged him." Birkhall: The King's Secret Sanctuary, airs Saturday 21 June at 7.30pm on Channel 5.

Scotsman

3 hours ago

• Scotsman

The Royal Highland Show 2025 in pictures

It's that time of year again - the Royal Highland Show is back, running from Thursday to Sunday. The country's biggest agricultural show, it will see almost 200,000 visitors pass through the gates, and more than 4,000 farm animals are brought to the arena. Hundreds of businesses have filled up the grounds, selling everything from agricultural machinery, clothing and motor vehicles to Scottish food and drink. Here are 18 images from this year's RHS. 1 . Say cheese The judging continues on day three of the show. The RHS sees over 190,000 visitors each year. | Lisa Ferguson Photo Sales 2 . Very grand What a grand and proud face. Over 6,000 animals are shown at the Royal Highland Centre over duration of the show. | Lisa Ferguson Photo Sales 3 . Trio of sheep The animal's are brought out in front of the judges to face inspection and a range of livestock is exhibited at the show each year. | Lisa Ferguson Photo Sales 4 . Another one for the judges Another proud animal! The show has been taking place at Ingliston since 1822. | Lisa Ferguson Photo Sales