The end of the Vietnam War was also a turning point for protest songs
NEW YORK (AP) — Out of the many Vietnam War protests she performed at in the 1960s and 1970s, Judy Collins can never forget one in Washington, D.C., where she stood before thousands and sang Bob Dylan's 'Masters of War.'
'It was just me, and Bruce Langhorne playing the guitar, for this huge event. ... And everybody knows the words and very quickly they all start singing along,' she says, remembering the 'amazing' spirit of those rallies. 'It does trigger something in the brain to hear those songs. They make you say, 'I must be able to contribute something.'"
The end of the Vietnam War, 50 years ago, also helped wind down an extraordinary era of protest music.
For Collins and such contemporaries as Joan Baez, Pete Seeger and Peter, Paul and Mary, bringing the troops home was a mission that carried them around the country, and the world. The journey was shared with like-minded audiences who joined in on 'Masters of War,' 'Give Peace a Chance,' 'Blowin' in the Wind' and other standards — as if to say the songs belonged as much to the movement as they did to the singer.
The causes have endured, and proliferated: arms control and apartheid, women's rights and globalization, climate change and police violence. And protest songs have been written for them, from Kendrick Lamar's 'Alright' to Steve Van Zandt's 'Sun City.' But few, if any, have entered the collective cultural memory like the music of decades ago: Protest songs are as common as ever, protest anthems are rare.
'These days you have all these genres and all of these identities, and things are more decentralized,' says Ginny Suss, who helped organize the 2017 Women's March in Washington and helped found the Resistance Revival Chorus, a collective of dozens of singers who specialize in protest music.
Ronald Eyerman, a professor of sociology at Yale University and co-author of the 1998 book 'Youth and Social Movements,' says that it's been a long time since a song like 'We Shall Overcome' has emerged, one so universal in its message that it can be adapted to any number of issues. 'Protest songs tend to be very specific to an issue and a time and place,' he observes, adding that he can't think of 'any anthem related to mobilization about climate change or gay rights.'
The rise of protest songs
The rise of protest music in the 1960s fits into the greater narrative of the post-World War II era. Growing prosperity and young technologies such as television and transistor radios helped give the emerging 'baby boom' generation an unprecedented sense of autonomy and common experience, and the Vietnam War and Civil Rights movements united millions across race and class and geography.
Eyerman notes that the military draft, which ended in the early 1970s, made Vietnam more than just a moral issue for Americans, but one with a 'personal, self-interested dimension.' And rock and folk music helped forge a soundtrack of easy melodies and memorable, resonant phrases for an explosive historical moment.
'There was just an incredible intensity of feeling about the political situation,' says Dorian Lynskey, author of '33 Revolutions Per Minute: A History of Protest Songs,' published in 2011. 'A lot of people expected an imminent revolution.'
Protest songs in the '60s and '70s weren't only heard at protest rallies: From 'Blowin' in the Wind' to 'People Get Ready' to 'Ohio,' they also placed high on the Billboard charts.
The current state of protest music
Bill Werde, former editorial director of Billboard and director of Syracuse University's music business school, the Bandier Program, says protest music still exists in the U.S., but he isn't sure the appetite exists for them as mainstream hits.
He points out that there is a lot of protest music happening outside of the U.S., like that of the popular Iranian singer Mehdi Yarrahi, who shared a song titled 'Roosarito,' Farsi for 'Your Headscarf,' urging women to remove their mandatory headscarves. He was flogged by Iranian officials over a conviction for possessing and consuming alcohol. Or the Indonesian post-punk band Sukatani's anti-corruption anthem 'Bayar Bayar Bayar" ('Pay Pay Pay').
'It has led to this nationwide call for greater freedom of expression under an increasingly authoritative regime there,' he says of Sukatani's song. 'This may be hard for some folks to understand or to accept, but I think one of the simple realities may just be that things aren't bad enough here in America for people to really feel that urgency, when you compare America to places like that.'
Puerto Rican rapper and filmmaker Residente, known for releasing socially conscious music on topics including war, colonization, socioeconomic inequality, climate change and beyond, disagrees. He says that there are contemporary protest songs — you just have to know where to look. For example: Bad Bunny's 'Lo Que Le Pasó A Hawaii," 'What Happened to Hawaii' in English, a song that ties the U.S. colonization of Hawaii to the Puerto Rican fight for independence.
Last year, Residente released 'Bajo los Escombros,' ("Under the Rubble") with Palestinian artist Amal Murkus, dedicated to the children killed by the war in Gaza. 'There are not many songs talking about it,' he says.
Eyerman wonders if the recent mass demonstrations against Donald Trump will 'grow into a national force,' with a 'distinctive protest anthem.'
A divided country
Like the 1960s and 1970s, the country is deeply divided, politically and socially. But Werde otherwise sees a more limited landscape for protest music. He cites the increased consolidation of the music industry and demise of legacy media outlets, which means 'today's hits are smaller than they used to be' and there are fewer opportunities for protest songs to become full-on anthems. The only way that happens is if 'things reach a certain point … like with George Floyd and Black Lives Matter.'
Songs played around that time included Lamar's 'Alright,' Childish Gambino's 'This Is America' and Beyoncé's 'Freedom," which came out before Floyd's murder in 2020.
Often, protest songs become anthems because of their reception.
Oliver Anthony's 'Rich Men North of Richmond" is an example, a song with no explicit ties to any political party that became an anthem for Republicans in 2023. 'It's all about the plight of the working man,' Werde says. 'It shows you how music can really be manipulative at times and how a lot of politics is all about like marketing an idea whether it's true or not.'
A possible reason for the reluctance to produce protest songs may be simply that in 2025, "artists, like most corporations, really want to be left out of the political discussion these days because it's just too risky to their bottom line,' he says.
His most mainstream example of pop music protest is Lamar's Super Bowl halftime show, with its nod to Gil Scott-Heron's early '70s anthem 'The Revolution Will Not Be Televised' and its indirect symbolism, delivered in a way that Werde says corporate sponsors had to agree to, and that wouldn't 'leave an enormous part of that audience feeling deeply offended.'
Residente says that when he started his career in the early 2000s, performing political music had real-life consequences: He was banned from playing in Puerto Rico for four years; once, in Venezuela, he was shot at. 'To be censored in your own country is horrible,' he recalls. Nowadays, he is still political in his music but has noticed stateside artists tend not to be.
'I hope that in the United States there will be more (political songs),' he says. 'It's weird. Maybe they're very concentrated on the business.
'Not every artist is going to talk about social awareness,' he adds. He says he hopes there will be more activist groups in the U.S., like Rage Against the Machine or System of A Down.
History reinvented
What were once protest songs have since been stripped of their original context and repurposed for antithetical ends. Creedence Clearwater Revival's anti-Vietnam War anthem, 'Fortunate Son,' was featured at Trump rallies — over the objections of songwriter John Fogerty — and used in a Wrangler commercial decades after its initial release. Dylan's 'Blowin' in the Wind' was the soundtrack to a Budweiser commercial aired during the Super Bowl in 2019. Green Day's anti-George W. Bush hit 'American Idiot' has been used by conservatives on TikTok.
'Things live on a fragmented level like never before,' Werde says. Music discovery happens on TikTok, presented without any context. Gen Z has discovered the Irish band the Cranberries, but when 'Zombie' plays, they don't necessarily know the history of the Troubles that the song was written about.
Collins, however, says her audiences seem as engaged as ever. Now 85, she still gives some 100 shows a year and still features 'Where Have all the Other Flowers Gone' and others in the protest canon, along with such newer works as her own 'Dreamers,' about immigrants in the U.S.
'When I sing 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone' ... everyone sings it, everyone knows it. I'm kind of astonished when that happens,' she says. 'They're not just protest songs. They're songs of life and the journey of life, things you're up against."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
5 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Bassist Carol Kaye tells AP she's declining Rock & Roll Hall of Fame induction, 'Permanently'
NEW YORK (AP) — Carol Kaye, a prolific and revered bassist who played on thousands of songs in the 1960s including hits by the Beach Boys, Simon & Garfunkel and Barbra Streisand, told The Associated Press on Friday that she wants no part of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. 'I've declined the rrhof. Permanently," the 90-year-old Kaye said in an email to the AP. She said she has sent a letter to the Hall saying the same thing. Her remarks come two days after a Facebook post — since deleted — in which she said 'NO I won't be there. I am declining the RRHOF awards show.' Kaye was set to be inducted in November in a class that also includes Joe Cocker, Chubby Checker and Cyndi Lauper. She said in her deleted post that she was 'turning it down because it wasn't something that reflects the work that Studio Musicians do and did in the golden era of the 1960s Recording Hits.' Kaye's credits include the bass lines on Simon & Garfunkel's 'Homeward Bound,' the Beach Boys' 'Good Vibrations' and the Monkees' 'I'm a Believer." Along with drummer Hal Blaine and guitarist Tommy Tedesco, she was part of a core of heavily used studio musicians that Blaine later dubbed 'The Wrecking Crew.' 'I was never a 'wrecker' at all,' she wrote, "that's a terrible insulting name.' Kaye's inductee page on the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame website makes no mention of the moniker. Hall representatives had no immediate comment. Many artists have been inducted in their absence or after their death, and in 2006 the Sex Pistols became Hall of Famers despite rejecting their induction. In 2022, Dolly Parton initially declined her induction, saying someone more associated with rock 'n' roll should get the honor. But she was convinced to change her mind and embrace the honor. ___ Dalton reported from Los Angeles.
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Noted Machine Gun Kelly Fan Bob Dylan Narrated MGK's New Album Trailer
In the spiritual sequel to his legendary 2004 Victoria's Secret commercial, Bob Dylan has provided narration for a new trailer announcing Machine Gun Kelly's next album, Lost Americana. 'Lost Americana is a personal excavation of the American dream — a journey to find what's been lost,' Dylan drawls in the short clip. He goes on to describe the album as 'a love letter to those who seek to rediscover' and 'a sonic map of forgotten places, a tribute to the spirit of reinvention, and a quest to reclaim the essence of American freedom.' More from Rolling Stone Joan Baez on America Under Trump: 'It Feels Like Torn Fabric' Troubadour Eric Andersen on New Album and Why 'A Complete Unknown' Was a Tad 'Sugarcoated' It's the Perfect Time For a Pulp Reunion Dylan's narration is accompanied by a montage of home movie footage of MGK and friends, including some shots of the musician riding a motorcycle decked out in a custom Lost Americana biker jacket. There's a snippet of music, too, at the end of the clip, a wild synth arpeggio that jumps out after Dylan says: 'From the gold neon diners to the rumble of the motorcycles, this is music that celebrates the beauty found in the in-between spaces. Where the past is reimagined and the future is forged on your own terms.' Along with sharing the trailer, MGK said Lost Americana would arrive Aug. 8. The album will be his first in three years, following 2022's Mainstream Sellout. MGK has yet to reveal the full track list for Lost Americana, but the album will feature his recent single, 'Cliché.' 'Cliché' is actually one of several songs MGK has dropped this year, along with 'Your Name Forever,' 'Come Pick Me Up,' and a cover of the Goo Goo Dolls' 'Iris' with Julia Wolf. It's unclear if any of these songs will also appear on the album. As for Dylan's involvement in the trailer, it comes after the legendary singer-songwriter posted, seemingly out of nowhere, a video of MGK rapping on his Instagram earlier this year. Even MGK was astounded, revealing he learned of Dylan's post while discussing with friends some of his concerns and reservations about his next album. 'Just the originator of doing everything opposite of what people wanted him to do, randomly posting a video of me back in the day rapping in a vinyl shop,' MGK said. 'I'm just like, 'What the fuck?' Just trust the signs, man. That was so cool. I'm so grateful.' For those looking for some insight into the ever-mysterious movements of Dylan's taste and artistic predilections, who crave some explanation for how he even became aware of Machine Gun Kelly in the first place, Dylan scholar Ray Padgett shared a theory on Bluesky that is as hilarious as it is believable. 'All because the dude has the same name as an old gangster Bob was googling. What a ride,' Padgett wrote. Best of Rolling Stone Sly and the Family Stone: 20 Essential Songs The 50 Greatest Eminem Songs All 274 of Taylor Swift's Songs, Ranked
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Troubadour Eric Andersen on New Album and Why ‘A Complete Unknown' Was a Tad ‘Sugarcoated'
It's taken a few months, since he lives in the Netherlands, but Eric Andersen finally found time to watch A Complete Unknown. And the troubadour legend, who haunted those same Village clubs during that same time, was…a bit underwhelmed. 'It seemed a little sugarcoated,' he says. 'It was a little two-dimensional. But I found it quite amusing and quite entertaining. I was looking at it more like a cinematic situation than something I knew. I was watching a movie. So, I enjoyed it from that standpoint.' More from Rolling Stone It's the Perfect Time For a Pulp Reunion Watch Bob Dylan Perform a Stunning 'All Along the Watchtower' With Billy Strings Watch Bob Dylan's Shocking Cover of Ricky Nelson's 'Garden Party' Then again, Andersen has a right to critique. At this point, many of the songwriters and musicians from that hallowed Greenwich Village scene have either died (mostly recently Peter Yarrow) or retired from touring (like Tom Paxton last year). Only a handful of those who helped make the Village a musical hotbed are still out performing and even making new albums — Bob Dylan, of course, along with Judy Collins, Carolyn Hester, Noel Paul Stookey, and very few others. Andersen, who turned 82 this year, is also still on that list. Although he's never had a Top 40 hit, the American-born songwriter has written a handful of songs that are part of that new American folk songbook — 'Violets of Dawn,' 'Thirsty Boots' — and albums like 1972's Blue River are considered high-water marks of the genre. His impact was especially felt on the recent tribute album Songpoet: Songs of Eric Andersen, which includes renditions of his songs by Dylan, Linda Ronstadt, Mary Chapin Carpenter, Amy Helm, Lenny Kaye, Dom Flemons, Willie Nile, the duo of Larry Campbell and Teresa Williams, and the late Rick Danko (who formed a band with Andersen shortly before his death). In the last few decades, Andersen, who moved to Norway for a period and then relocated to Amsterdam 20 years ago, has occasionally returned to the U.S. for shows. In those years, he's made albums based on the words of Lord Byron, Albert Camus and German writer Heinrich Böll; released a collection of his own spoken-word pieces; saluted his peers with recordings of Village covers (The Street Was Always There); and cut a full-album, live-recreation of Blue River. But last month, he finally rolled out his first new set of songs, Dance of Love and Death, in over 20 years. With its ruminative ballads and rhythms, the album is very much of a piece with the territory Andersen began carving out for himself when he arrived in New York in the Sixties. Like Dylan, he was championed by New York Times music critic Robert Shelton, which also helped Andersen land a record deal. With songs like 'Close the Door Lightly When You Go' and 'Come to My Bedside,' Andersen injected an air of mystery and sensuality into the scene. He befriended the likes of Paxton, Collins, and the late Phil Ochs and witnessed an increasingly isolated Dylan spar with his peers at the Kettle of Fish bar. He was so ingrained in that world that, he says, he missed Dylan's historic Newport 1965 show because he was booked into the Gaslight Café, one of the essential Village venues. Talking about the way that community has been recreated in films, Andersen feels that another recent movie rings a bit more true than A Complete Unknown. '[Inside] Llewyn Davis was much more of the scene that I remember,' he says. 'Even to the point where I went up to Vanguard Records to get some money, and the guy actually handed me a $20 bill. I was living on the Lower East Side cooking for junkies and I needed the money to go to the vegetable market to buy stuff for them. I was walking back home, and I just stopped at the Vanguard offices. There's a scene identical to that in Llewyn Davis. It couldn't have come from me, but the vibe, the scene, and the lighting was more realistic than the other film.' Along with many of his peers at the time, Andersen isn't a character in A Complete Unknown, although he took heart in Ochs' 'There But for Fortune' heard in one of Monica Barbaro's Joan Baez performance scenes. 'That was really beautiful,' he says. 'That came out being the best song in the film, which is hard to believe, because there are so many great songs. What was a little bit tragic was that Bob was such a word guy. He can talk. Not chatty, but he said things, you know. Usually talking about writing and stuff like that. None of that seemed to come through. But you can't do much in a movie. You got to gloss things over.' Whether it's the result of those movies or a degree of rediscovery, Andersen has felt more openness to his style and that era than he has in a while. 'I remember playing a couple of shows in Boston, when parents took their kids,' he says. 'And they were the ones who came up to talk to me. Maybe it blew their minds that somebody could stand up there and sing songs about things they think about. Maybe there's some kind of deprivation going on in terms of their musical world. I don't know. But even though their parents dragged them to this show, they were the ones who got it, which was funny.' Starting during that period and continuing over the decades, Andersen very much lived the life of the wandering, nomadic poet-writer. He was featured in an early Andy Warhol film, appeared on Johnny Cash's TV variety show, wrote songs about his close relationships with Janis Joplin ('Pearl's Goodtime Blues') and Patti Smith ('Wild Crow Blues'), and asked Joni Mitchell to be the godmother to his daughter. He's also had his share of disappointments: signing with Beatles manager Brian Epstein right before Epstein's death and having the tapes for his all-important follow-up to Blue River lost. (They were finally discovered and released, but 20 years later.) Over its 17 songs, Dance of Love and Death reflects on some of those past times, most movingly in 'Every Once in a While,' about his wife Debbie Green, who died in 2017. 'Were you jealous of my future? Was I jealous of your past?' he sings. 'Yeah, that was about her,' Andersen says. 'I think everybody has a situation where you think about somebody every once in a while and that person comes back, and I just sat down and that song poured out.' The album also has moments of harrowing storytelling ('River Spree [Berlin],' about a junkie), relative lightheartedness ('After This Life'), and his signature deep-voiced intimate romanticism (the title song). Although Andersen isn't known as a topical songwriter, he also ventured into that topic with the climate change-inspired 'Season in Crime (Crime Scene),' spurred on by a California tour with violinist and Dylan alumnus Scarlet Rivera. 'She was living in Topanga Canyon and her house was going to burn down,' he says. 'We were talking about sparks and embers in the air. It started to write itself. It doesn't take much to start a song.' Thanks to producer Steve Addabbo and contributing musicians like Kaye and Dylan bassist Tony Garnier, the music is a mix of chamber-folk beauty and galloping rock & roll. In early September, Andersen will return to the States for a month of shows on the East Coast. He's read or heard about international musicians who've supposedly had their visas revoked or have had to deal with profit-depleting tariffs when they arrive. 'So far, it's full steam ahead,' says Andersen, who has American and Dutch passports. 'But things are evolving very rapidly. Everybody's on edge. I want to come over with my guitar and maybe they'll say, 'Well, you know ….,' because I'm a resident overseas. It'll be interesting.' About any unlikely detainment, he jokes, 'If I have one call to make, it'll be to you.' Best of Rolling Stone The 50 Greatest Eminem Songs All 274 of Taylor Swift's Songs, Ranked The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time
