Phillies Trade Idea Sends Nick Castellanos to Blue Jays After Benching
Phillies Trade Idea Sends Nick Castellanos to Blue Jays After Benching originally appeared on Athlon Sports.
If the Rafael Devers-Boston Red Sox stunner taught us anything, it's that any feud can lead to an unexpected trade.
Advertisement
Devers refused to switch positions and battled management, eventually leading to the Red Sox sending him to the San Francisco Giants for two pitchers and two prospects. We'll see whether or not the Philadelphia Phillies have a similar problem on their hands with All-Star right fielder Nick Castellanos.
Phillies manager Rob Thomson benched Castellanos on Tuesday, citing a negative comment the 33-year-old veteran made during Monday's 5-2 victory over the Miami Marlins. Castellanos evidently disagreed with Thomson's decision to pull him in the eighth inning for defensive reasons.
Could Castellanos' benching, even if it's only for one night, eventually lead to a trade? The Blue Jays should be asking themselves that exact question, and they should be ready to pounce if the Phillies are willing to talk.
Philadelphia Phillies right fielder Nick CastellanosRon Chenoy-Imagn Images
Castellanos has a season and a half remaining on the five-year, $100 million contract he signed after the 2020 season. He's admittedly been relatively average thus far, hitting .278 with seven home runs, 36 RBI, 17 doubles, and a .746 OPS.
Advertisement
Those numbers are all in line with last year's, though his bWAR has plummeted from 0.8 to -0.5.
However, Castellanos offers durability, and he'd undoubtedly be an upgrade in left field over rookie Alan Roden. Unfortunately for the Blue Jays, they're likely stuck with Anthony Santander and his .577 OPS at DH, given that he's in the first season of a five-year, $92.5 million contract.
Castellanos should come relatively cheap, and the Blue Jays are in an excellent position to make a playoff run. Toronto entered Tuesday at 38-33, holding the AL's second Wild Card berth and only four games out of first in the AL East.
Advertisement
As for the Phillies, ditching Castellanos could eventually pave the way for another outfield-related trade. Boston Red Sox star Jarren Duran has been linked to the Phillies in recent weeks, and Chicago White Sox veteran Luis Robert Jr. remains available.
The Devers-Red Sox feud arguably began with a position change. Might we eventually look back at a mid-game benching involving two NL East teams as the start of an eventual Blue Jays title run?
Related: MLB Makes Bryce Harper Announcement After Injury Update
Related: Phillies Share Bryce Harper Injury Update Amid Trade Rumors
This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 17, 2025, where it first appeared.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
JT Realmuto, Nick Castellanos accomplish an insane base running feat vs. Mets
The post JT Realmuto, Nick Castellanos accomplish an insane base running feat vs. Mets appeared first on ClutchPoints. The Philadelphia Phillies opened a critical three-game series against the New York Mets Friday with first place in the NL East on the line. The teams were tied with identical 45-30 records at the start of the day. But the Phillies scored a big victory over New York, powered in part by Nick Castellanos, who's played with renewed energy after being benched by manager Rob Thomson earlier this week. And the veteran right fielder teamed up with J.T. Realmuto to pull off a wild base running feat. With the score tied 2-2 entering the bottom of the seventh inning, the Phillies broke the game open, batting around and scoring six runs. But the final two runs of the inning were a sight to behold. Second baseman Bryson Stott came up with the bases loaded and delivered a three-run double off the wall in left. Alec Bohm easily scored from third. But Realmuto showed off some serious speed, scoring from first and nearly passing Castellanos, who was heading home from second. Realmuto was right behind Castellanos as the pair rounded third and approached home plate. They then both slid and beat the tag, almost simultaneously adding two runs to the scoreboard and putting the Phillies up 8-2. Castellanos added a two-run homer in the eighth inning to put Philadelphia up 10-2. He hammered a 96 mph four-seamer from Justin Garza 428 feet to center for his eighth bomb of the season. The deep shot capped off a three-hit, three-RBI game for the two-time All-Star, as Castellanos has responded to his benching with clutch performances. Earlier in the month, Castellanos made his 231st consecutive start for the Phillies. The iron man feat gave him the longest streak for the franchise since Pete Rose nearly 40 years ago. Unfortunately, some choice words for Thomson led to the 13th-year veteran getting benched, which ended his consecutive games played streak. Still, Castellanos and the Phillies are playing with renewed purpose of late. A slump at the beginning of June allowed the Mets to take over first place in the NL East as the Phillies lost nine of 10 games. However, since then, the team has turned things around. Philadelphia has now won three straight games and nine of the last 11. With the victory over the Mets Friday, the Phillies recaptured sole possession of first place in the division. Related: Phillies' Bryce Harper takes key step in injury rehab Related: Phillies' Nick Castellanos breaks silence after recent benching
New York Times
42 minutes ago
- New York Times
Brandon Marsh is ‘locked in right now' for the Phillies: ‘It's the best feeling'
PHILADELPHIA — Moments before the Philadelphia Phillies scored two runs in a straight-from-a-movie play at the plate, Trea Turner found Brandon Marsh in the dugout. He had forgotten to tell him something earlier in the week. The six-run inning in a win that catapulted Philadelphia back to first place will be remembered for J.T. Realmuto drafting Nick Castellanos as they scampered home together and scored in succession like synchronized swimmers, but Marsh started the whole thing. Advertisement He saw a 2-2 fastball down the middle at 98 mph, and he was a little late. But he drove it to the opposite field for a double, his third hit of the night, to begin the seventh inning. Marsh wasn't there long; Turner doubled to score him. The Phillies soon cruised to a 10-2 win over the New York Mets. That's the two for one special — Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) June 21, 2025 As they piled on the runs, Turner remembered what he had wanted to tell Marsh. 'I meant to tell you this the other day, but just keep doing what you're doing,' Turner said. 'You look really good. At-bats have been unbelievable.' Now, after the fact, Turner shook his head. 'I mean,' he said, 'you look up and he's hitting .250 with a .350 on-base, and I'm like, 'Oh, my God.'' It's jarring, considering where Marsh was recently. He slogged through a hitless streak of 31 at-bats in April. He was hurt, then unremarkable to begin May. His playing time was sporadic. His play in center field was (and still is) not as good as the Phillies expected. Still, he's giving them something. It is all the Phillies have ever wanted from whoever is playing in center field, a position that often feels as if it's cursed for this franchise. But in June, Phillies center fielders have a .788 OPS. Most of that is Marsh. He is hitting .400/.450/.543 in 40 plate appearances. A small sample. Since the beginning of May, it's .333/.400/.440 in 95 plate appearances. He has not always hit for power, but he's doing something. Turner, as the leadoff hitter, has a good view from the on-deck circle whenever Marsh is batting. 'He's hitting the ball the other way really, really well,' Turner said. 'He hit some balls in Miami that he got out on. I mean, like, man, they're such good swings. Just feels so consistent. He takes his walks. He's still pulling the ball at times, too. It looks really good right now. I think that makes a huge difference, especially in the nine-hole, and getting on base for whoever's after him. I think it's big.' Advertisement The Phillies have outfield decisions to make in the next 40 days; all indications are the club will be most aggressive in pursuing bullpen depth. It could shop again for a capable right-handed platoon bat, but center field is such a barren position across the sport. The Phillies' best chance — just as it was in 2023 and 2024 — is from within. They held firm on their center fielders, Marsh and Johan Rojas, at both trade deadlines. If Marsh keeps producing, they'll probably do that again this season. 'He's locked in right now,' Phillies manager Rob Thomson said. It wasn't just the double that sparked the seventh-inning rally. Marsh batted in the fourth inning with two outs and runners on first and third. The Phillies had just taken the lead, and New York went to its only lefty reliever, José Castillo, to face Marsh. Marsh fell behind 0-2. He poked a slider below the strike zone into shallow left field for a run-scoring single. It was his first 0-2 hit against a lefty since April 2, 2024. Marsh reached first base and looked to the sky. The previous day in Miami, Marsh had gone 0-for-3 with three hard-hit outs. One went 375 feet, another 365 feet. Nothing. 'I was just like, 'OK, I feel a bloop coming here pretty soon,'' Marsh said. 'And that was just like the thank you to the baseball gods.' He was rewarded. 'Don't press too much and blow up over three good at-bats when you get nothing to show for it,' Marsh said. 'Kept the head up and smiled all the way back here to Philly today.' That mindset, Turner said, is something Marsh deserves praise for following. There will be more ups and downs in the summertime, but Marsh went through some of the lowest lows he's had in the majors to begin the season. It never really felt like he had emerged from it until the last few weeks when he became pickier at the plate. The walks came, and then he started using the opposite field. His best friend on the team, Alec Bohm, has emerged from a similar slow beginning to the season. Advertisement 'I don't know enough credit is given to him and Bohm from where they were two months ago,' Turner said, 'and how much everyone hated them and wanted them out of here to how good they've been.' It's why Turner wanted to deliver his message to Marsh in the dugout. 'That's encouraging, you know?' Marsh said. 'That's really cool, someone like that, who players like myself look up to, saying something like that's pretty cool.' There was something almost cathartic about the seventh inning. It does not atone for how the Mets brushed aside the Phillies in last October's National League Division Series. But erasing a five-game deficit in the standings over 10 days counts for something. The ballpark was filled. It was muggy. Realmuto slapped Castellanos on the butt after the home-plate umpire issued a rare double-safe signal. Everyone laughed about the play. They had fun. Especially Marsh. 'It's awesome,' he said. 'It's the best feeling, especially against a good team like that in the division. We're just going to keep feeding off each other, and that's what we did. We needed it.'
New York Times
42 minutes ago
- New York Times
Mets drop from first as losing streak reaches 7: ‘This is not good'
PHILADELPHIA — The sting of a seventh straight loss lingered in a quiet New York Mets clubhouse as Francisco Lindor tried to explain a poor stretch and his role navigating the ugly streak as a team leader. Lindor, the star shortstop who doubles as something of a de facto captain, typically offers appropriate perspective for good times and bad. Advertisement The most obvious example happened last year when Lindor called a players meeting with the Mets' season on the brink. Things were different back then, in late May 2024. The Mets were below .500. The alarm bells went off early. They had to — a season needed saving. After falling 10-2 to the Philadelphia Phillies on Friday night, Lindor indicated the Mets aren't quite there this time. But the Phillies claimed first place in the National League East from the Mets for the first time since May 30. And the Mets matched their longest losing streak since they lost seven in a row June 2-9, 2023. 'It's gotta happen organically,' Lindor said. 'We all have a sense of urgency. We're all trying to do whatever it takes to win.' By 'organically,' Lindor said he means a conversation among players grows into something like, 'All right, yeah, let's talk about this.' 'It's not about slamming things,' Lindor said. 'It's nothing like that.' Such an approach doesn't mean the concern level is low. Things are more nuanced than that. The Mets (45-31) spent two-plus months looking like one of baseball's best teams. Over the past week, however, other teams aren't just beating the Mets; they are thoroughly outplaying them. 'This is not good,' Lindor said. 'This is not good at all. But it's adversity that we're going to have to go through at some point of the year. It's just, we want to get away from it as fast as we can. It's a tough moment in the season.' The challenging part for the Mets is that their problems continue to pile up. In a twist, it wasn't their starting pitching, which recently nosedived, that let them down this time. Over their last six games heading into Friday, the rotation sported a 6.04 ERA, worst in the NL in that span. Though Sean Manaea's rehab outing Friday with Triple-A Syracuse offered hope (5 1/3 innings, one run), the Mets are also down Kodai Senga and Tylor Megill, with Frankie Montas set for a return Tuesday after poor results throughout his rehab assignment. Friday, New York turned to spot starter Blade Tidwell, who lasted just 3 2/3 innings but limited hard contact and surrendered just two runs. Advertisement No, instead of the starting pitching, it was everything else that went awry. The offense, which has produced just seven runs in five games, continued to struggle. Though Phillies ace Zack Wheeler didn't allow a run, the Mets at least pushed him to 98 pitches through five innings, forcing him out of the game. Pete Alonso and Jeff McNeil then hit back-to-back home runs off Taijuan Walker in the sixth inning, but the Mets stopped producing from there. JEFF GOES BACK-TO-BACK! — New York Mets (@Mets) June 21, 2025 The lineup needs to carry the team. But as a whole, it chases too often lately and fails to produce with runners in scoring position. The Mets' young players, such as Brett Baty, Ronny Mauricio and Francisco Alvarez, aren't adding much at the bottom of the order. And none of their stars are doing any serious heavy lifting. That includes Lindor, who is 0-for-his-last-19. 'We have to be better, especially me,' Lindor said. 'I have to be better. I am at the point where I have to do stuff to help the team win.' Little things are adding up, too, particularly on defense. Before the Phillies broke things open in the seventh inning, they took extra bases from the Mets. With the score 3-2 and none out in the seventh, Alec Bohm hit a single to right field with runners on first and second. Juan Soto fielded the ball without urgency. He lackadaisically threw to the cutoff man, Alonso, who then threw high and late to Baty at third, which allowed Kyle Schwarber to go from first to third. If all that wasn't enough, the bullpen is starting to leak, too. The Mets have shuttled players in and out lately, trying to supply the bullpen with fresher arms because of a high workload. Perhaps things are catching up to them. Friday, Reed Garrett allowed four runs without getting an out in the seventh. His ERA has gone from 0.70 at the start of June to 2.45 by the end of Friday night. Advertisement 'We're going through it right now,' Mets manager Carlos Mendoza said. 'I think it's a little bit of everything.' That's what has made it hard to get out of. 'Obviously, it kind of stinks going through it, no doubt,' Alonso said. 'I'm sure people watching, it's not necessarily fun to watch. It's not fun doing it, I can promise you that. 'But for us, we just need to be better on all sides of the ball.' (Photo of Francisco Lindor: Rob Tringali / MLB Photos via Getty Images)
