How Social Security's overpayment mistakes can become your responsibility

This is an updated version of a story first published on Nov. 5, 2023. The original video can be viewed here.
Each month, about 74 million Americans - retirees, disabled workers, and others – receive payments from Social Security. But each year many people get something else in the mail – a bill. They're told they owe the government money, sometimes tens of thousands of dollars, because the Social Security Administration miscalculated their benefits and paid them too much. When we first reported this story in 2023, the agency said about a million people a year are affected by this problem, but it now acknowledges that when you consider all the agency's programs, it's two million people per year. It can happen to anyone. And it can take years, even decades, for these unexpected debts to suddenly come to light. It often doesn't matter if it's not the recipient's fault – they still have to pay. Few people realize it, but Social Security's mistakes are your responsibility.
In 2022, at Steven and Becky Sword's home in Chicago, a letter arrived from the Social Security Administration. When Becky Sword read it, she was stunned to discover that she and her husband owed Social Security "$51,887," and were expected to repay it "within 30 days."
Anderson Cooper: That letter changed your life.
Becky Sword: Oh, yeah.
Anderson Cooper: Are you scared?
Becky Sword: He's thinking we're gonna lose our house. You know, what are we gonna do? I mean, we were very scared.
When we spoke with Steven and Becky Sword in 2023, Steven was making $16 an hour as a security guard on the overnight shift at a condominium complex. Becky was working days as an occupational therapy assistant in a nursing home. They were 62-years-old and had worked full-time most of their lives.
But for several years, Steven had been dealing with the effects of a pancreatic disease that nearly killed him in 2016.
Anderson Cooper: How long were you in the hospital for?
Steven Sword: About 105 days. It was hard 'cause when I left the hospital, it took me about two months to learn to eat and walk again.
Steven started receiving Social Security disability checks in 2017 as he recovered and returned to work. The agency's rules are complicated, but Becky faxed Steven's pay stubs to Social Security so the agency could monitor his earnings and eligibility. She kept the fax receipts…
Anderson Cooper and Becky Sword
60 Minutes
Becky Sword: So I knew they were getting it, you know.
In return, Social Security sent the Swords letters like this one, saying it had increased Steven's benefits "to give him credit for his 2019 earnings."
Anderson Cooper: Is the impression you got from that, that they're examining the pay stubs--
Becky Sword: Uh-huh. Definitely.
Anderson Cooper: And they're pay attention--
Steven Sword: Uh-huh
Becky Sword: Yeah.
Anderson Cooper: And adjusting accordingly?
Becky Sword: Because they're increasing it.
Becky Sword and Steven Sword: Yeah.
But the letter the Swords got in 2022 from Social Security said Steven shouldn't have gotten any money at the time the agency gave him that increase. Steven and Becky owed more than $50,000, the agency said, "because we did not stop his checks" about three years sooner.
Anderson Cooper: Has anyone at Social Security ever, sort of, apologized?
Steven Sword: No.
Steven Sword: They-- they take no blame at all.
Becky Sword: They say it's our fault
Anderson Cooper: They're saying you should have known that--
Steven Sword: That I'm making too much money.
Anderson Cooper: That-- that Social Security--
Steven Sword: But--
Anderson Cooper: Was giving you too much money?
Steven Sword: Yeah.
Anderson Cooper: Even though Social Security didn't know that they were giving you too much money?
Steven Sword: Yeah. Which is strange because you're sending in all your pay stubs. Someone has to file that. And to me–
Becky Sword: And when we asked 'em, they said, "Well, they're not looking at that every month." And then she even said, "Well, they're not even looking at it every year." I would think yearly, at least, they would review it. I could see makin' a mistake after a few months, but not three years of a mistake. And then they blamed it on COVID. They blamed it on being understaffed. And so to me, right there it's saying it's their fault.
The Social Security Administration told us its privacy rules prevent it from commenting on individual cases like the Swords, and no one from the agency would give us an on camera interview.
Terry Savage: Nobody knows this is happening to so many people.
Anderson Cooper: This is not a story Social Security wants to publicize.
Terry Savage: Ohhh no—
Laurence Kotlikoff: No.
Terry Savage and Laurence Kotlikoff
60 Minutes
Terry Savage writes a nationally syndicated column on personal finance. Laurence Kotlikoff, an economics professor at Boston University, created software to help people maximize their Social Security benefits. Together, they've been trying to draw attention to what they call, "Social Security horror stories," caused largely, they say, by the Social Security Administration's own mistakes.
Laurence Kotlikoff: Their mantra, their rule, is "Our mistake is your mistake." And you can appeal it or ask for a waiver. The only reason they will waive this-- clawback is if you are indigent: really, really poor.
Terry Savage: The worst part of it is they have all the power. Because they say, "If you don't pay us back, we're just gonna cut your benefit check." Imagine: People live on those checks. And all of a sudden you get no check? Or a small amount?
Anderson Cooper: If someone's been paid too much in Social Security benefits, why shouldn't they have to pay it back?
Laurence Kotlikoff: Because you relied on it. So you may have decided to-- retire early, or to spend the money on your child's tuition.
Overpayments have existed for decades and caused people a lot of financial pain. But fixing the problem has never been a high priority on Capitol Hill. In 2015, Congress did approve a measure to reduce overpayments by giving Social Security more timely access to payroll data. But eight years later, the agency still hasn't put the new system in place.
Aging technology and staff shortages have taken a toll on Social Security. In 2022, the agency's workforce hit a 25-year low as the number of people claiming benefits kept going up. When we took a close look at Social Security's annual reports to congress, we discovered something else has been going up as well: the amount of money the agency has been clawing back from the checks of people with overpayments.
Jean Rodriguez, then 73-years-old, told us her retirement checks had been withheld for the past two years. A former school cafeteria worker, she started receiving benefits in 2014. But four years later, she and her husband Glenn were asked to come to the local Social Security office in Virginia Beach, Virginia to speak with a representative.
Glenn and Jean Rodriguez
60 Minutes
Jean Rodriguez: And he says, "We have a small problem."
Anderson Cooper: How much did he say they had overpaid you?
Jean Rodriguez: $72,000.
Anderson Cooper: That doesn't sound like a small problem.
Jean Rodriguez: No. It wasn't. We were both devastated.
Anderson Cooper: What did they tell you happened?
Jean Rodriguez: Somewhere along the line they made a combination of four other people in addition to my numbers.
Anderson Cooper: So they were giving you benefits based not just on your salary, but on four other people's salary--
Anderson Cooper: All combined?
Jean Rodriguez: Right.
Anderson Cooper: How does that happen?
Jean Rodriguez: Good question. (laugh) Don't know how they did it.
Anderson Cooper: Did Social Security admit to you that this was their fault?
Jean Rodriguez: Yes, they did.
But the agency said the Rodriguezes had to pay the money back anyway, because they could afford to do so. Jean and Glenn own their home and Glenn gets a pension from the Navy.
Jean Rodriguez: If it was something I knew I did totally wrong they have the right to come after me. But I didn't know how they calculated it. And then they waited four years to figure it out.
In a statement, the Social Security Administration told us "our payment accuracy rates are high," yet "even small error rates add up to substantial improper payment amounts." The agency said it's "required by law" to recover this money…and added that overpayments are not necessarily the agency's fault. They can happen "when a beneficiary does not timely report work" or other financial information.
There's no statute of limitations on how long Social Security can wait to collect an overpayment. Nearly four years ago, Roy Farmer of Livonia, Michigan got a letter from Social Security asking whether he'd forgotten to pay a debt he didn't know he had.
Roy Farmer
60 Minutes
Anderson Cooper: This is an alleged overpayment from 20 years ago.
Roy Farmer: Yes, sir.
Anderson Cooper: When you were 11 or 12 years old.
Roy Farmer: Correct.
Roy Farmer grew up in rural Cadillac, Michigan, in a family of six that struggled to make ends meet.
Roy Farmer: We ended up near homelessness a couple of times-- at one point, even living, you know, six of us in-- in a camper trailer.
He was born with cerebral palsy.
Roy Farmer: I had leg braces. I had to walk with a child-sized version of, like, an old-person walker.
Anderson Cooper: And you had surgeries. You had doctor's visits. You had it treated.
Roy Farmer: Yeah. And so thankfully they were able to get me to a point where I can live a more or less normal life-- with some limitations.
He's 34-years-old now and works full-time. But when he was a child, his mother received benefits on his behalf. Social Security told him that when he was 11-years-old, the agency determined he was no longer medically eligible for benefits and his mother received $4,902 too much. His mother died a few years ago, and the agency is insisting he pay back the money because it believes he can afford to do so.
Anderson Cooper: Could you afford $4,902?
Roy Farmer: No, sir. That much is about a sixth of my annual take-home pay.
Like most of the people we spoke to, Roy Farmer couldn't find a lawyer to help him. There's little financial incentive for attorneys to take on these cases. It took Farmer nine months to get the documents in his Social Security file. He was looking for the agency's evidence that he was no longer medically eligible for benefits when he was 11-years-old. But, he says, there was none.
Roy Farmer: And they told me "We probably had it at some point. But we don't have it now."
Anderson Cooper: And they admit there's no evidence you're at fault, but they're still coming after you for it.
Roy Farmer: Yes, sir.
Anderson Cooper: People at Social Security have told us-- "Look this is a law. This has to be changed through Congress. Our ti-- our hands are tied."
Laurence Kotlikoff: It's not, Anderson because the law says that-- "If equity and good conscience demands" that-- the clawback be waived, it should be waived.
Laurence Kotlikoff, the economist who's written about overpayments, is talking about a specific part of the Social Security Act that says the agency should not recover an overpayment if doing so would be "against equity and good conscience." The problem, he says, is that Social Security interprets that phrase in a very narrow way.
Anderson Cooper: So the agency itself-- Social Security Administration, has a lot of discretion.
Laurence Kotlikoff: Absolutely, yes.
Terry Savage: Oh, sure they do. But…
Laurence Kotlikoff: But financially the long-term picture's not good. And they've trained the staff, "Look, your job is to collect every penny you can, no matter what."
The Social Security trust fund for retirement and disability benefits is expected to be depleted around 2035 because the benefits being paid out are greater than the payroll taxes coming in. But Kotlikoff and Savage argue that clawing back money from the elderly and disabled isn't going to make much of a dent in that problem. They say there are some simple things Congress and the Social Security Administration could do to alleviate the stress and financial difficulty caused by overpayments. For example:
Terry Savage: Shouldn't there be a statute of limitations so that, after 18 months, it's their mistake, and they have to deal with it? And not the person who mistakenly received and lived on that benefit check?
Anderson Cooper: If it's more than a year or two
Laurence Kotlikoff: Just waive it. Say, "Our mistake. You're fine."
Roy Farmer in Michigan had been waiting four months to appeal his case before an administrative law judge who works for social security.
Jean and Glenn Rodriguez told us they'd been waiting four years.
As for the Swords in Chicago, Steven and Becky told us they were tired of fighting the government and had decided not to appeal the matter any further.
Becky and Steven Sword
60 Minutes
Becky Sword: I just figure we were gonna have to give up our retirement funds.
Anderson Cooper: That's the only way you can--
Steven Sword: Yeah.
Becky Sword: That's the only way.
Becky Sword and Steven Sword: Yeah.
Becky Sword: Because they said we'd have to pay it back in three years' time and we-- we'd have to come up with $1,400 a month to pay back and we don't have that. We don't have that, you know, kind of money.
When Steven Sword was not working the night shift, and Becky Sword was not working the day shift, they were preparing to hand over most of the $60,000 they'd saved for their retirement to the government agency charged with supporting Americans in their old age.
After we asked the Social Security Administration about their cases back in 2023, all of the people in our story received phone calls from the agency, saying they would not have to pay the money back after all. Last year, Social Security announced it would claw back no more than 10% of a person's monthly check to recover an overpayment. But that policy changed this year under the Trump administration. Social Security now withholds 50% of monthly checks for most new overpayments it finds.
Produced by Andy Court. Associate producer, Annabelle Hanflig. Broadcast associate, Grace Conley. Edited by Stephanie Palewski Brumbach.

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

CBS News

28 minutes ago

• CBS News

Pandemic-era puppies, kittens now filling San Francisco shelters beyond capacity

The COVID-19 pandemic is still having a deadly effect on the pet population. The number of unwanted animals is straining San Francisco's shelter capacity to the breaking point, sometimes with tragic results. Just about every animal shelter in the state is jammed these days and it all points back to the pandemic when shelters were empty and it was hard to find any animal to adopt, as people tried to cope with COVID isolation. But also at that time, spaying and neutering were suspended or drastically reduced. And now those generations of puppies and kittens are filling the shelters. "So, not just in San Francisco, but in California and nationwide, we are like two million spay/neuters behind. So, that just leads to more and more accidental breeding," said Virginia Donohue, Executive Director of San Francisco's Animal Care and Control. "Pre-pandemic, we were full a couple times a year. Now we're full a couple times a month. It is a constant problem. It's no longer an occasional problem." And it can have heartbreaking consequences. SF Animal Care and Control works to find unwanted pets a home, but when none is available, they must turn to euthanasia to make room. "We try very hard to euthanize just for medical and behavior issues," said Donohue. "But there are points when an animal is here too long and nobody is coming for it, we don't have a place for it to go and its behavior is deteriorating. Then we're going to euthanasia." One of the reasons the city's public animal shelter is so full is because its major adoption partner, the San Francisco SPCA, is taking a lot fewer dogs and cats than it used to. The SF SPCA, which is a private entity, has joined forces with the Stockton SPCA and is now rescuing a lot more unwanted pets from the Central Valley. "Historically, they've taken as many as 600 dogs," said SF's Donohue. "Currently, it's under 200. So, obviously, that's a pain point." It's also a reason why Animal Care and Control is having to turn to euthanasia. Another is that the shelter has a "custody" program that holds dogs up to two weeks for people who go to jail or the hospital or who die. That all takes space from those pets looking to be adopted. On Saturday, a dog owner named Ethan said he sometimes wonders where they're all coming from. "To see the amount of people out there that have dogs that aren't taking care of them, like, I don't really understand how they got these dogs in the first place," he said. The dogs are out there, many in desperate need of a caring home. But there is only so much space in the shelters and reducing the population is now more than just a humane thing to do. It's becoming a matter of life and death. "I mean, don't get a dog if you weren't intending to get a dog," Donohue said. "But if you want a dog, just look at your local shelter first. Even if you don't find the dog of your dreams there, just look and see what's available."

Yahoo

an hour ago

• Yahoo

WNP Launches All-in-One Hyaluronic Acid Skincare Set, Pioneering a "3-Step Scientific Skincare Method"

Culver City, California--(Newsfile Corp. - June 22, 2025) - Skincare brand WNP officially launched the "All-in-One Hyaluronic Acid Skincare Set" on its website, introducing its original "Three-Step Scientific Skincare Method." The set integrates five key skincare steps - cleansing, hydration, repair, brightening, and early-stage anti-aging - into a comprehensive skincare system based on four core innovations: nano-delivery, HTAC thermal water dynamics, 4D hyaluronic acid, and microencapsulation technology. This set offers a streamlined solution for everyday skincare needs. From cleanse to anti-aging - the complete, science-backed routine for hydrated, balanced, glowing skin. To view an enhanced version of this graphic, please visit: Four Key Innovations Nano-Liposome Delivery WNP utilizes nano-liposome technology to reduce Ceramide NP particle size to below 100 nm, enabling targeted delivery to the basal layer of the stratum corneum. Lab tests show it helps fill intercellular lipid gaps and reduce transepidermal water loss, offering industry-leading repair benefits for sensitive and barrier-damaged skin. HTAC Thermal Decomposition Water Dynamics WNP's toner features Italian patented HTAC technology, which protects red algae and recombinant collagen activity. Tests show it boosts natural hyaluronic acid production by 124% and cellular mitochondrial activity by 229%. 4D Hyaluronic Acid Multi-Layer Hydration Based on Bloomage Biotech's 4D hyaluronic acid formulation, four molecular weights of hyaluronic acid penetrate from the epidermis to the dermis. Combined with a water-in-oil lamellar emulsion structure, this provides deep, lasting hydration. Microencapsulated Time-Release Salicylic Acid Salicylic acid is microencapsulated for sustained release of active ingredients, delivering gentle exfoliation while minimizing irritation. Ideal for daily use on sensitive or combination-oily skin. Five Steps, One Streamlined Routine Gentle Cleansing: A non-soap amino acid cleanser with pH 5.5-6, refined through 45℃ natural crystallization to remove excess emulsifiers. Fine foam gently purifies without residue. Soothing & Hydration: A serum-texture toner that forms a water film on contact. Functions as both mist and toner for instant moisture. Targeted Hydration: 3% Hyaluronic Acid Capsules, a TikTok bestseller, delivers precise hydration without pilling. Brighten & Even: A matrix of niacinamide, SymWhite®377, and vitamin C derivatives to block melanin transfer and fade oxidized spots. Early Anti-Aging: Patented recombinant collagen, triple peptides, and multiple ceramides to rebuild elasticity and visibly firm skin within 28 days. Brand Vision "With this launch, WNP merges cutting-edge nano-delivery with a multi-dimensional hyaluronic hydration system to redefine what 'minimalist skincare' can mean," said WNP's Chief Product Spokesperson-Dr. Emily. "We believe skincare is shifting from ingredient stacking to true tech-enabled performance-and this launch is the clearest expression of that evolution." About WNP WNP (Wake Nature Perfection) is a science-driven skincare brand based in Asia, rooted in the philosophy of precision skincare. It integrates top-tier dermatological research with global innovations in active ingredients. As an industry innovator, WNP has introduced multiple "first-of-its-kind" technologies in both domestic and international markets, committed to delivering safe, effective, and targeted skincare solutions. For more information, please visit Source: WNPContact: MattDepartment: Brand TeamEmail: matt@ To view the source version of this press release, please visit

Yahoo

an hour ago

• Yahoo

Walmart Pulls Three Items After Deadly Food Poisoning Outbreak

Federal health officials revealed that three chicken fettuccine alfredo products sold at Walmart and Kroger are the cause of a deadly food poisoning outbreak. The listeria food poisoning outbreak, which began last August and has now claimed the lives of three people and led to one pregnancy loss, comes from pre-packaged chicken fettucine alfredo products from producer FreshRealm, according to the USDA. In total, at least 17 people in 13 states have been infected. FreshRealm is recalling the products that were made before June 17. The recalled products are as follows: —32.8-ounce trays of Marketside Grilled Chicken Alfredo with Fettucine Tender Pasta with Creamy Alfredo Sauce, White Meat Chicken and Shaved Parmesan Cheese with best-by dates of June 27 or earlier. —12.3-ounce trays of Marketside Grilled Chicken Alfredo with Fettucine Tender Pasta with Creamy Alfredo Sauce, White Meat Chicken, Broccoli and Shaved Parmesan Cheese with best-by dates of June 26 or earlier. —12.5-ounce trays of Home Chef Heat & Eat Chicken Fettucine Alfredo with Pasta, Grilled White Meat Chicken and Parmesan Cheese, with best-by dates of June 19 or earlier. Anyone with those products at home are advised to either throw them out or return them to where they were purchased. According to the Mayo Clinic, healthy people rarely get very ill from the bacteria, but listeria is especially dangerous for pregnant women and unborn babies, people over 65 and people with weakened immune systems. Foods such as soft cheeses, deli meats and dairy products that haven't been pasteurized are more likely to be tainted than other foods. Listeria bacteria is capable of surviving refrigeration and freezing. Walmart Pulls Three Items After Deadly Food Poisoning Outbreak first appeared on Men's Journal on Jun 18, 2025