Dunmore councilwoman raises landfill concerns to Shapiro, criticizes DEP

A Dunmore councilwoman sent Gov. Josh Shapiro a letter Wednesday urging him to add stricter penalties to the Keystone Sanitary Landfill's remanded Phase III expansion while also raising concerns over the role of a state Department of Environmental Protection supervisor who concluded the expansion's benefits outweigh its harms.
Dunmore council President Janet Brier, who emphasized she wrote the letter as a Dunmore citizen and not as a representative of council, sent Shapiro the letter in response to the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board's decision Tuesday to send the landfill's 42.4-year Phase III expansion permit approval back to the DEP to potentially address issues with odors and leachate generation. As the culmination of a nearly 4-year-old legal battle brought by grassroots landfill opposition group Friends of Lackawanna, environmental judges ruled Tuesday that the department erred in issuing the Louis and Dominick DeNaples-owned landfill's Phase III expansion permit in June 2021, which allows the landfill in Dunmore and Throop to triple its volume of waste through the 2060s by hauling in just over 94 million tons of additional garbage, or about 188 billion pounds.
'The Environmental Hearing Board's order confirms the DEP knew that KSL could not contain the leachate that it was already producing, yet they approved the permit for 94 million more tons of garbage to be dumped on our region,' Brier said in a phone interview Thursday. 'One can only conclude that DEP is either grossly negligent or that political influence prevailed over science.'
The DEP did not respond by press time Thursday to emailed requests for comment on Brier's letter. Brier did not include her council title in her letter.
In their 74-page decision, the five judges who make up the Environmental Hearing Board said the landfill has experienced challenges controlling offsite odors and excess leachate generation at its facility for several years, and the DEP knew about those issues prior to approving the expansion.
'The Department erred in issuing a permit that does not sufficiently control or mitigate these issues,' the judges wrote. 'The Department must assess on remand whether additional measures to control odors and leachate, some of which have been required by a recent Consent Order and Agreement, warrant inclusion in the landfill's permit or changes to the landfill's operating plans.'
Harms vs. benefits
Brier took issue with the Environmental Hearing Board's findings regarding a July 2019 environmental assessment by the DEP that weighed 15 known and potential harms, with accompanying mitigation measures, of approving the landfill's Phase III expansion against eight benefits.
The harms included visual impacts, odors, litter, noise, vectors/birds, traffic, runoff, air quality and groundwater impacts. The benefits were: environmental education, continuation of recycling and cleanup programs, goods and services, continued employment for 145 full-time workers, tax revenue, participation in Pennsylvania's Adopt a Highway Program and financial benefits for Dunmore and Throop from their host agreements.
A section titled 'Excess Leachate Generation' under groundwater impacts determined that 'it is apparent KSL continues to have an issue with either excessive leachate generation and/or infiltration into the leachate conveyance system.'
'KSL continues to have current flow amounts not only higher than what was predicted for the current landfill, but also higher than what was predicted as a maximum peak flow for the proposed Phase III expansion,' according to the analysis.
In its ruling, the Environmental Hearing Board wrote that Erika Bloxham, a facility specialist in the DEP's waste management program in the Northeast region who was tasked with completing the analysis, concluded that the benefits did not outweigh the harms, primarily because, in her opinion, Keystone had not mitigated the excess leachate production to the fullest extent possible.
Her supervisor said otherwise.
'However, Ms. Bloxham's supervisor, Roger Bellas, the waste program manager for the Northeast region, disagreed and authored the conclusion of the analysis for the Department,' the judges wrote.
The analysis concluded, 'DEP has determined that KSL has demonstrated that the benefits to the public from the project clearly outweigh the known and potential harms.'
In her analysis, Bloxham pointed to the landfill resorting to hauling excess leachate offsite and adding temporary leachate storage. She said the landfill's excess leachate flows increase the potential for it to have overflows and other incidents that could impact groundwater, though on Wednesday, landfill consultant Al Magnotta said Keystone has never been close to overflowing.
Despite Bloxham's concerns, the judges said, 'The Department concluded that Keystone's current and proposed efforts to isolate and mitigate excessive leachate generation were expected to limit the number, duration, and intensity of future excessive leachate flows.'
The landfill is required to keep its leachate below 25% of its maximum 9.7-million-gallon capacity, but from May 2021 through April 2024, it exceeded that at least 20 out of 36 months, according to the ruling. The DEP cited Keystone last year for exceeding the maximum limit every month from October 2023 through June.
The landfill's leachate generation is also more than double what it predicted, averaging 282,676 gallons per day, and nearly 8.2 million gallons per month — enough leachate to fill about 12 Olympic-sized pools each month.
Brier's letter
Brier criticized Bellas' role in her letter.
'Throughout its existence, KSL has never been able to mitigate the excess leachate production for any length of time, yet the order remands the permit back to the very people who overrode the waste management facility specialist's conclusion that the benefits do not outweigh the harms,' Brier wrote. '(Roger Bellas) still holds the position of Environmental Program Manager in the Waste Management Department in the Northeast Regional Office. I think it is fair to say that his mind is made up.'
Brier contended Northeast Pennsylvania has been 'subjected to malodors, insufficient leachate containment, methane flare offs, out-of-state truck traffic and indifference to all of this by the Department of Environmental Protection.' She said conditions have worsened at the landfill since its expansion approval, and the DEP's response was inadequate.
Brier also criticized the department's odor reporting process, describing an after-hours voicemail that tells callers to 'stay on the line if it is an emergency.' She asked the DEP to remove 'emergency' from the message to avoid callers hanging up because they don't consider an odor an emergency.
'The whole process places the burden of reporting on the very people who are suffering from pervasive odors in their homes, their schools, playgrounds, churches, athletic facilities and in their children's bedrooms,' she wrote.
She contended there are minimal consequences for noncompliance. Last year, in March 2024, the DEP levied its largest fine for the landfill at $575,000. The civil penalty was the culmination of 14 odor-related violations since January 2023, close to 1,000 odor complaints in seven months and at least 70 instances of DEP staff detecting offsite landfill gas and leachate odors attributed to Keystone.
'There needs to be substantial penalties for noncompliance,' Brier wrote. 'Otherwise, the result will be the same harmful decisions.'
Brier also called for a reduced duration of the expansion, bringing it from 40 years to 10 years, calling four decades absurd.
The expansion approval was an 'egregious transgression,' Brier said, adding that the responsibility rests on past administrations.
'My only hope is that the Shapiro administration will permanently reverse DEP's prior decisions and finally put the people's health and well being before politics,' Brier said. 'The Environmental Hearing Board's remand order presents a tremendous opportunity for Gov. Shapiro to reverse the mistakes of the past.'

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Bloomberg

10 hours ago

• Bloomberg

EU Frets Over US Demands in Trade Talks It Sees as Unbalanced

The US is demanding the European Union make what the bloc's officials see as unbalanced, unilateral concessions as part of ongoing trade talks, setting up a tough decision over whether to move ahead with countermeasures if the terms of any deal don't improve. The best-case scenario remains an agreement on principles that would allow the negotiations to continue beyond an early July deadline, according to people familiar with the matter.

Axios

a day ago

• Axios

"Zero tolerance": SF leaders denounce recent acts of antisemitism

Local officials and community leaders gathered Friday at City Hall to condemn a recent string of antisemitic incidents and to assure San Franciscans that perpetrators will be punished. Why it matters: The public stand comes after Jewish-owned cafe Manny's was vandalized and a man accused of a violent attack in the Marina was charged with a hate crime. What they're saying: "As a member of the Jewish community, these incidents hit close to home," Mayor Daniel Lurie said. "I want to be clear that we have zero tolerance for acts of hatred. ... If you commit a hate crime in San Francisco, we will find you and we will arrest you." There has been "a dramatic rise in antisemitism locally and nationally, on both polar extremes left and right of our politics," Tye Gregory, executive director of the Jewish Community Relations Council, said at the press conference. "This isn't about what's going on outside of the United States in the Middle East or anywhere else," district attorney Brooke Jenkins said. "This is about what we believe and who we are." State of play: Since the Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, the Bay Area Jewish Community Federation has recorded over 40 threats — including bomb threats to local synagogues, schools and community centers — and more than 220 incidents of harassment and intimidation, senior vice president Rebecca Randall said Friday. Manny's was hit with graffiti saying "F**k Manny" and "The only good settler is a dead 1" following a night of anti-ICE protests earlier in June. Meanwhile, the attack in the Marina occurred after a Jewish woman asked a group of people to stop shouting "F**k Jews, free Palestine," she told the San Francisco Chronicle. Juan Diaz-Rivas punched the woman's friend, repeating antisemitic remarks and causing him to lose consciousness, prosecutors allege. Diaz-Rivas has pleaded not guilty. The big picture: Jewish leaders across the nation have warned that President Trump's invocation of antisemitism to justify policies like slashing college funds and deporting student protesters risks making Jewish people scapegoats.

USA Today

2 days ago

• USA Today

Trump signs executive order delaying ban on TikTok

Trump signs executive order delaying ban on TikTok - again The 90-day extension marks the third time that Trump has delayed a TikTok sell-or-ban law from going into effect after it it was passed by Congress. Show Caption Hide Caption Tiktok stays as President Donald Trump extends deadline for ban President Donald Trump signed an executive order extending the deadline to ban Tiktok. WASHINGTON − President Donald Trump has again extended the deadline for a TikTok ban to go into effect, allowing the Chinese-owned social platform to continue operating for the 90 days. Trump said earlier in the week that he planned to give TikTok a third extension and signed an executive order on June 19 making it official. It was the third time that Trump authorized a delay. TikTok and Tariffs: Trump postpones TikTok deadline as talks continue to sell social media giant The popular social media app's parent company, ByteDance, now has until Sept. 17 to secure a deal that satisfies a legal requirement. Lawmakers ordered TikTok to divest from its Chinese ownership or face a ban in the United States over national security concerns. Former President Joe Biden signed the bipartisan legislation into law. And the Supreme Court held the ban. But since returning to office, Trump has directed the Department of Justice not to enforce it. His executive orders have kept the app from going dark. White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said the administration's lawyers "strongly believe" the president has the legal authority to delay enforcement. "The political reasoning for this, of course, is because the president made a promise to keep TikTok on," she said. "He also wants to protect American's data and privacy concerns on this app, and he believes we can do both things at the same time. So he's making an extension so we can get this deal done." Trump ordered Vice President JD Vance and his then-national security adviser, Mike Waltz, to help facilitate a deal that would prevent user data from being accessed by the Chinese government. U.S. officials said they were on the verge of reaching an agreement in April but hit stumbling blocks when Trump ratcheted up tariffs on China. Is TikTok getting banned? Trump says he'll 'probably' extend deadline again Trade relations between the two nations have improved since then but a TikTok deal remains on ice. It was not clear if TikTok came up when Chinese President Xi Jinping and Trump spoke by phone for the first time on June 5. "We probably have to get China approval. I think we'll get it," Trump told reporters on June 17. "I think President Xi will ultimately approve it." TikTok has 135 million users in the United States, most of them young Americans, who Trump has said he does not believe are at risk from being spied on. "If China is going to get information about young kids, I don't know. To be honest with you, I think we have bigger problems than that," he told reporters. China denies that it interferes in the affairs of private businesses. Its embassy spokesman in Washington said in a June 19 statement that Trump has not changed its position on the United States ban. In response to a request, Liu Pengyu reiterated that the nation would "handle relevant matters in accordance with Chinese laws and regulations" and said the United States "should provide an open, fair, just, and non-discriminatory business environment." Contributing: Joey Garrison