EXCLUSIVE Lawyer claims state-owned oil company may have blocked efforts to rescue divers trapped inside underwater pipe because it was 'cheaper to allow them to die'
Podcast All episodes
Play on Apple Spotify
On the latest episode of the Daily Mail's Pipeline podcast, reporter Isabelle Stanley examines the chilling theories as to why Paria blocked efforts to rescue four men trapped in an underwater oil pipe.
From compensation plots to international conspiracy, Stanley interviews legal experts and journalists to test the credibility of theories that emerged in the wake of the Caribbean Diving Disaster.
In February 2022, five divers were sucked hundreds of feet into a 30-inch pipe they were repairing off the coast of Trinidad and Tobago.
Despite one of the divers, Christopher Boodram, escaping after an unimaginable three-hour ordeal, rescue attempts for the remaining four were repeatedly blocked, leaving them to die slowly in what became a national scandal.
The pipe was managed by Paria, one arm of Trinidad's state-owned oil company.
In the aftermath of the tragedy, Trinidad's then-Energy Minister Stuart Young launched an official enquiry, led by one of the UK's top international criminal barristers, Jerome Lynch KC.
Lynch concluded that the four divers weren't rescued because of a series of mistakes, incompetence and inaction by Paria.
Despite his recommendation that the oil company be charged with corporate manslaughter, police have issued only vague statements that an investigation remains ongoing
Despite his recommendation that the oil company be charged with corporate manslaughter, police have issued only vague statements that an investigation remains ongoing.
This stalemate and lack of closure has created an information vacuum - which residents of Trinidad have filled with hundreds of theories, trying to work out why Paria abandoned the rescue effort.
Rightly or wrongly, the victims' families wonder if there is something more… another reason to explain why their loved ones were left to die - something other than pure negligence or incompetence.
Prakash Ramadhar, a lawyer representing two of the victims' families, told the podcast that he believes the oil giant may have thwarted a rescue to avoid the costs associated with caring for the injured divers if they had been pulled out alive.
He claims any survivors may have suffered life-changing injuries, creating lifelong financial liability for the company.
Mr Ramadhar said: 'I believe that Paria's initial belief was that they all had perished and if they had not perished, they would soon perish.
'As crass as it may sound, there is a belief in the legal fraternity that it may have been cheaper to allow the men to die than it was to rescue them, broken and maimed.
'Ensuring their medical wellbeing and upkeep for their rest of their lives is far more expensive than allowing them to die.'
To hear Stanley interrogate this theory and many others that emerged in the wake of the Caribbean Diving Disaster, search for Pipeline now, wherever you get your podcasts.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Kanye West's wife Bianca Censori shocks again as she pulls dangerous move behind wheel of Porsche
Kanye West 's wife Bianca Censori has pulled yet another eye-catching stunt certain to leave the public in a state of astonishment. Ever since they secretly tied the knot in 2022, Bianca has consistently shocked fans with the flesh-flashing ensembles her husband styles for her. Now, however, her conduct behind the wheel of her gleaming Porsche convertible may be the cause of further comment from observers. Bianca, 30, was spotted staring open-mouthed at her phone while she was driving the jet-black vehicle through Beverly Hills this week. She appeared to be flouting the California Wireless Communications Device Law, which prohibits using a handheld cellphone while operating a motor vehicle. Bianca's sighting comes after Kanye experienced his own bout of car trouble, as a photographer snapped images of the rapper's custom Maybach being towed away from the Château Marmont on Tuesday. New images obtained by Daily Mail show the luxury car owned by the 48-year-old Runaway rapper being put on the back of a tow truck and hauled away from the hotel. The venue – where Saturday Night Live legend John Belushi tragically overdosed in 1982 - remains a favorite haunt of Hollywood celebrities, but parking remains limited. The Bully artist was spotted with partner Bianca Censori earlier Tuesday in Los Angeles, after traveling to New York City earlier this month to attend the trial of Sean ' Diddy ' Combs, who he has professed support for publicly on multiple occasions. Daily Mail has reached out to West's rep Milo Yiannopoulos and the tow company listed on the side of the truck for further comment on the item involving the vehicle. West has remained in the crosshairs of controversy for much of the year amid a torrent of tweets propagating antisemitism, though he renounced those beliefs in a tweet last month. 'I am done with antisemitism,' he said in a May 22 tweet that garnered 167,000 likes from the influential artist's network of more than 33.2 million followers. The stance came in stark contrast to Ye's controversial one four months earlier: He posted multiple images swastikas, and plastering them on a number of clothing items he intended to sell. On February 11, the shop on West's Yeezy Website - which he advertised with an expensive ad in the Super Bowl - was taken offline by Shopify after he was selling a white shirt with a black swastika in the center. West spoke more about the controversy in a series of tweets February 20 - promising to wear the swastika shirt onstage at the 2026 Super Bowl. 'Next year I'm performing at the superbowl wearing my wittle T shirt,' he said. 'People with money bought my wittle t shirt.' He added that Shopify 'gave [him his] account back' after taking down his store after controversy erupted over the shirts, but that he was 'not going to use it.' The Anti-Defamation League said in a post on X/Twitter February 10: 'As if we needed further proof of Kanye's antisemitism, he chose to put a single item for sale on his website – a t-shirt emblazoned with a swastika. 'If that wasn't enough, the t-shirt is labeled on Kanye's website as "HH-01,"which is code for "Heil Hitler." 'Kanye was tweeting vile antisemitism nonstop since last week. There's no excuse for this kind of behavior.' The organization added, 'Even worse, Kanye advertised his website during the Super Bowl, amplifying it beyond his already massive social media audience.' Tal-Or Cohen Montemayor, the founder and executive director of CyberWell, an online anti-Semitism watchdog group, told February 11 that the organization made efforts to go over West's head and have the page removed. 'CyberWell reached out Shopify's compliance and safety teams to alert them to flagrant abuse of Shopfiy's services by in violation of the terms of use,' Cohen Montemayor said. Podcaster Van Lathan, who famously clashed with West in a heated discussion in the TMZ newsroom in May of 2018, was critical of the rapper's latest series of tweets in a post on the platform February 20, calling him 'the slow kid in the Black community's class.' 'I'm glad you're rich,' Lathan wrote. 'It seems to be the only thing you care about. Money is dope you can do a lot of stuff with it. Sincerely. We need it, as a community. 'One thing that's more valuable than money is people. I'm sure you'd agree no dollar amount can measure North's laugh, I'm sure you'd go broke to bring your mother back. I would for my dad, who I lost in '21.' Lathan told West he was 'trapped in an infant's bubble, where [he] can be reckless and careless and people excuse it because of affection. 'We realize this, and try to ignore you, until the baby picks up something sharp like Nazism, domestic abuse, etc. then we gotta child proof things until you stop crying.' Lathan, who cohosts the podcast Higher Learning with Rachel Lindsay, continued, 'You're right about one thing, I am a slave to capitalism. We all are. Gotta work. 'But No one is more of a slave than the man who puts money over dignity. No one. So I'll be a slave, and you be what you are, which is the slow kid in the Black community's class. Keep eating boogers Kanye.'
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Five men trapped in a 30-inch oil pipeline deep under the sea, air running out and left to die: Everything to know about America's No.1 podcast
On February 25 2022, five professional divers were working to repair a leaking section of oil pipeline off the coast of Trinidad and Tobago when something went terribly wrong. Unbeknownst to them, there was a pressure differential between the inside of the pipe and the underwater room in which they were working. When they removed a plug that was keeping the pipe sealed, the high-pressure air that was being pumped into the room rushed to fill the void inside the pipe with such horrifying force that it pulled the men in with it, trapping them deep beneath the Caribbean sea. They were sucked into the 30-inch-wide pipe along with a rush of sea water, down 60ft down to where the pipe turned to run along the sea floor. When they finally came to a stop along a 1,2000ft length of pipe, they managed to group together in a small air bubble. Lying on their backs in the pitch black, injured and covered in oil they strained their necks out of the liquid to breath. Over the course of three grueling hours, one man, Christopher Boodram, 39, managed to drag himself out in search of help. And he had no choice but to leave his friends behind in the air pocket. When he finally emerged from the end of the pipe, injured and exhausted, he told the crowd waiting above the waterline what had happened and begged them to rescue the others. But officials from the state-owned oil company Paria - which owns and operates the pipe - allegedly refused. They reportedly insisted that a rescue mission was too dangerous and they blocked volunteer divers from staging their own rescue attempts. The other four men who had dived with Christopher that day - Fyzal Kurban, 57, Rishi Nagassar, 48, Kazim Ali Jr, 37, and Yusuf Henry, 31 - were left to die. Yet three years on, not one person has been held accountable. Neither Christopher nor the families of those killed have received a penny in compensation. And while the world was captivated by the rescue of 15 young footballers from a Thai cave in 2018 and horrified by the Titan submersible disaster of 2023, few outside the Caribbean have heard of the 'Paria Diving Tragedy'. The Daily Mail set out to change this and to tell these men's stories with our investigative podcast, Pipeline. We found evidence of failing safety standards, lucrative contracts and secretive political relationships, and confronted some of Trinidad and Tobago's most powerful men including its then prime minister, Keith Rowley. This week, Pipeline became the top series in US Apple Podcasts when we reached number one in their American charts and number two in Australia. Today we are sharing some of the most shocking revelations that we uncovered in our bid to expose the truth of the scandalous tragedy that claimed four lives and scarred countless others. The Autopsies In the hours after Christopher escaped from the pipe, waiting volunteer divers tried to communicate with the men still trapped inside. They did so by tapping out emergency signals onto the pipe's metal sides and waiting to hear if the men tapped back. They did. In fact, the volunteers could still hear the men deep inside the pipe in the early hours of Saturday morning - almost 12 hours after they were sucked in. But despite this clear proof of life, and the agonies the men must have been experiencing in their hellish prison, Paria repeatedly blocked volunteer divers from staging a rescue. They insisted it was too dangerous. Two days later Paria announced their efforts would be focused instead on recovering the men's bodies. On Monday 28 February 2021, they started flushing them out of the pipe. The dead divers were so swollen and covered in oil that they were almost unrecognizable to the family members who went to the mortuary to identify them. But most horrifying of all, their autopsies confirmed what the tapping signals had suggested - the men had not died quickly. In fact, one of the men, Kazim Ali Jr, may have been alive for up to 39 hours in those unimaginable conditions: trapped and terrified in the dark, desperately hoping rescuers would arrive soon. Past accidents Forty years before the four men died, one of their fathers was killed while working on exactly the same stretch of pipe. In 1985, Ramjohn Kurban, Fyzal's father, was working to recommission the pipe in which his son would later die, when gases escaped from the line and caught fire. There was a huge explosion that killed 14 workers. Fast forward four decades and in December 2021, just three months before the accident, Christopher, the sole survivor of the 'Pipeline' tragedy, and Rishi Nagassar - who would perish in it - were both involved in another incident. They were working on a nearby gas line - also owned and operated by Paria - when it caught on fire, sending flames spewing across the platform. 'I was just seeing fire shooting out all over,' Christopher told the Daily Mail. 'I swam as far down to the bottom as I could and stayed as long as I could because I was expecting an explosion.' Other workers did the same, diving off the platform and swimming down into the water to escape the flames, until a boat came to pick them up. They told Paria what happened, but Christopher said the accident was 'swept under the rug' without investigation. Cruel conspiracies In the aftermath of the tragedy, the country's media descended on the small town of San Fernando, all trying to work out what went wrong, and why the four divers hadn't been saved. The story was a national sensation and Christopher became an unwilling celebrity overnight. 'Everywhere we go, everywhere he go, people recognize us,' Christopher's wife, Candy told the Daily Mail. 'People would come up and want to ask him, 'Well, how did you get out?'' But as time went on, a lack of concrete answers created an information vacuum and conspiracy theories started to fill it. People began to turn on Christopher, accusing him of lying. They said there was no way he could have survived in the pipe. They accused him of being fame hungry, or of trying to cover something up. The vitriol grew so intense that even Christopher started to think he was going crazy. When he began his escape from the pipe, he had left the other men with the promise that he would come back with help. So when he was discharged after three days in intensive care and realized that his friends hadn't been rescued, it was agony. 'I made promises that I eventually couldn't keep. And that is something that I can't let go of,' he said, 'What gives me that right to live?' As he struggled with the aftermath of this trauma and survivor's guilt he found himself the target of trolls and critics who doubted his story so publicly he began to question his own mind. 'I went mad off reading social commentary. Sometimes I was even doubting my recollection of the events,' he told the Daily Mail. Christopher was finally vindicated nine months later, at the government appointed inquiry into the tragedy. There they played footage from a GoPro one of the men had been wearing when they were sucked in - it showed them alive inside the pipe and Christopher there with them. 'After the audio played, the whole country just went, 'man this man was telling the truth',' Christopher said. 'And it's only then that it gave me some mental peace - this was real, and I didn't make this up.' To listen to the chart-topping podcast series, search for Pipeline now, wherever you get your podcasts.
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Pentagon insider reveals Trump's only option to completely obliterate Iran's deadly labs
Only a tactical nuclear warhead would be certain to destroy Iran 's key uranium enrichment base hidden inside a mountain, a military official has told the Daily Mail. It comes amid doubts that 30,000-pound 'bunker buster' bombs would be enough to destroy the secretive facility at Fordo, 60 miles south of Tehran. Your browser does not support iframes. Your browser does not support iframes.
