Children denied basic rights of care and education being let down by legal system, report finds

Children most at risk of being failed in terms of their care, education, housing, disability and mental services are being denied their rights and do not have the means to challenge it, a new report has said.
Published by charity Community Law and Mediation, it found a string of issues are compounding this lack of access for children, such as gaps in professional knowledge among lawyers in how to support those whose rights are violated, and inadequate legal support for organisations working directly with children.
'Children encounter the legal system in different ways than adults do, and our approach must reflect that,' its chief executive Aoife Kelly-Desmond said.
It commissioned the report, compiled by children's law expert Róisín Webb, to determine the need for a specialised legal service for children and the role it could play.
The report said while many children's organisations campaign for reform on a range of issues, there is currently no organisation in Ireland which focuses exclusively on the reform of the law and legal systems from a children's rights perspective.
One such group previously existed, but was wound down a decade ago, and the report said learnings could be gained from that experience.
In the areas where children are currently being let down, it highlighted evidence showing a 'recurring theme' of a 'disconnect between administrative decisionmakers and those affected by those decisions'.
'The Ombudsman for Children [has expressed] concerns about provision for unaccompanied asylum-seeking children, the use of commercial hotels for children in direct provision, the need for timely vulnerability assessments for children seeking international protection, as well as the lack of robust systems to identify and support teenagers at risk of criminal and sexual exploitation,' the report said.
'Recent reports have also highlighted the fact that the focus on children and young people came too late during the covid pandemic, impacting their mental wellbeing, with the impact exacerbated for those already in vulnerable and disadvantaged situations.'
It also highlighted failings identified for children in care, children in the justice system, children with disabilities, children in poverty, LGBTQ+ children, homeless children, Traveller and Roma children and children seeking refuge in Ireland.
The report recommends the creation of a specialist children's legal service in Ireland, which should have a particular focus on outreach.
It said this had the potential to enhance access to justice for children and young people, particularly for those impacted by disadvantage and inequality or lacking family supports.
Another recommendation is around a specialist children's legal service being situated within an existing independent law centre, such as Community Law and Mediation, to avoid the previous difficulties, which led to the previous service winding down.
Ms Kelly-Desmond said: 'Informed by the findings of the report, [we aim] to scale up its existing children's law services to become a centre for excellence in relation to child friendly justice and legal advocacy for children, with a particular focus on children impacted by disadvantage and inequality.'
Read More
Back-to-school payments to be extended to children in foster care

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Learn with AIFact CheckingText to SpeechAI Summary

Related Articles

Irish Independent

2 days ago

• Irish Independent

Public meeting in Tipperary hears fiery exchanges over state of local cemetery

Size of headstones, anti-social behaviour and inaccessibility all discussed Today at 05:51 Cashel's Cormac's Cemetery has CCTV cameras which are not functioning and sensor lights that have never been connected to the power grid, heard a public meeting at Spafield Family Resource Centre on Wednesday evening. At times, the meeting heard heated exchanges between members of the audience over issues with the cemetery on the Clonmel Road which have caused alarm for families of the deceased, and deepened divisions between Cashel's settled and Traveller communities.

Irish Times

3 days ago

• Irish Times

Dublin school cancels ‘Prayer for Palestine Day' amid ‘differing opinions'

A primary school, which cancelled a planned 'Prayer for Palestine Day' this week after some parents raised concerns, has said it was obliged to accommodate 'differing opinions' on the initiative. Mount Anville Primary School, in the Kilmacud/Stillorgan area of south Dublin , sent a letter to parents on Monday outlining its plans. It was intended to educate pupils on Palestinian culture in the hope of raising awareness of the 'unprecedented hardship and starvation' facing children in Gaza. However, a cancellation letter was issued the next day by the school's board of management in order to ensure the event would not be 'misconstrued or politicised in any manner'. READ MORE In the initial letter, school principal Angela Munro, said: 'Each class will engage in activities suitable to their age and stage to raise awareness of Palestine.' Resources were prepared by the school's teachers with a focus on Palestinian culture, art, music, food, and geography. Ms Munro cited the school's Sacred Heart ethos 'of social awareness that impels us to action, reaching out in compassion and solidarity with the innocent children of Gaza who are suffering unprecedented hardship and starvation'. She said the school community would use the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child 'as our guide' when praying for the children of Palestine during an assembly. She added that they would be availing of resources provided by the Ombudsman for Children's Office in Dublin. However, on Tuesday, the board of management wrote to parents, informing them that 'the proposed Prayer for Palestine Day has raised concerns among some members of our school community'. 'In order to ensure that our intention, which was purely educational, is not misconstrued or politicised in any manner, we have decided that it will no longer go ahead.' In a statement to The Irish Times, a spokesperson for the school said: 'We have carefully listened to all views expressed on this sensitive matter. We appreciate there are differing opinions, which we are obliged to accommodate. 'We have engaged directly with the school's community. Our primary focus remains the education, wellbeing and care of all our pupils.' While the school shares the same name as nearby Mount Anville Secondary School, a private school which counts former president Mary Robinson as an alumnus, the two schools are distinct and not associated with one another.

Irish Examiner

5 days ago

• Irish Examiner

Children denied basic rights of care and education being let down by legal system, report finds

Children most at risk of being failed in terms of their care, education, housing, disability and mental services are being denied their rights and do not have the means to challenge it, a new report has said. Published by charity Community Law and Mediation, it found a string of issues are compounding this lack of access for children, such as gaps in professional knowledge among lawyers in how to support those whose rights are violated, and inadequate legal support for organisations working directly with children. 'Children encounter the legal system in different ways than adults do, and our approach must reflect that,' its chief executive Aoife Kelly-Desmond said. It commissioned the report, compiled by children's law expert Róisín Webb, to determine the need for a specialised legal service for children and the role it could play. The report said while many children's organisations campaign for reform on a range of issues, there is currently no organisation in Ireland which focuses exclusively on the reform of the law and legal systems from a children's rights perspective. One such group previously existed, but was wound down a decade ago, and the report said learnings could be gained from that experience. In the areas where children are currently being let down, it highlighted evidence showing a 'recurring theme' of a 'disconnect between administrative decisionmakers and those affected by those decisions'. 'The Ombudsman for Children [has expressed] concerns about provision for unaccompanied asylum-seeking children, the use of commercial hotels for children in direct provision, the need for timely vulnerability assessments for children seeking international protection, as well as the lack of robust systems to identify and support teenagers at risk of criminal and sexual exploitation,' the report said. 'Recent reports have also highlighted the fact that the focus on children and young people came too late during the covid pandemic, impacting their mental wellbeing, with the impact exacerbated for those already in vulnerable and disadvantaged situations.' It also highlighted failings identified for children in care, children in the justice system, children with disabilities, children in poverty, LGBTQ+ children, homeless children, Traveller and Roma children and children seeking refuge in Ireland. The report recommends the creation of a specialist children's legal service in Ireland, which should have a particular focus on outreach. It said this had the potential to enhance access to justice for children and young people, particularly for those impacted by disadvantage and inequality or lacking family supports. Another recommendation is around a specialist children's legal service being situated within an existing independent law centre, such as Community Law and Mediation, to avoid the previous difficulties, which led to the previous service winding down. Ms Kelly-Desmond said: 'Informed by the findings of the report, [we aim] to scale up its existing children's law services to become a centre for excellence in relation to child friendly justice and legal advocacy for children, with a particular focus on children impacted by disadvantage and inequality.' Read More Back-to-school payments to be extended to children in foster care